Fresh bread makes for a good start to the sandwiches. We stopped on a Sunday and there was a steady stream of customers in the early afternoon. I got turkey, which was good, but nothing too imaginative. My wife got the Cranberry Chicken salad, and that was very good. Food came out really fast as they have limited options, and most (all?) sandwiches are served cold. Polite and friendly service. Indoor and outdoor seating. Fresh and frozen bakery items available. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Turkey Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

I just got two chicken salad sandwiches- wow for what you get it's a ridiculous price. Two sandwiches and a scone for almost 40$ Not worth it!! read more

The food is so good. Great sandwiches, great soups, amazing baked goods, and of course next level bread. Absolutely must have the cherry sour dough. The women that run the place are so great and kind. Vintage charm as well. Eat outside during the summer months for a little extra charm. Can't wait to go back again in the spring when it opens up. read more

Delicious scones and yummy soups. The staff was the most helpful with suggestions on items that were local faves!

MacReady is my favorite spot for lunch every time I visit Door County! Their fresh breads, cookies, pastries, and soups are all amazing. My favorite menu items are the Cranberry Chicken Salad, Egg Salad, Tomato Soup, and chocolate chip cookies. The cookies are baked just how I like them, thin and crispy with great flavor! The staff is always very friendly. I met Jenny at my last visit and she is personable and kind and made our visit that much better. I enjoy the outdoor seating options and sometimes in the summer I've heard live music there. No complaints and I always make sure to bring home bread and cookies to share with family members! Highly recommend stopping here while visiting the Door. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Cranberry Chicken Salad sandwich and a bowl of tomato soup. - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Says it's not open, but they are open must have just changed their hours amazing chocolate chip cookie! And super fast service read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Chocolate chip cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

We visited this cafe and bakery in Door County during our recent vacation. The staff was very friendly and helpful in navigating non-dairy options. We ended up ordering a sandwich, the lemond chicken soup (soup of the day) and a half salad (cherry chicken salad). They make fresh bread along with some fun sweet treats. It's a great spot to grab lunch for the road. Parking is easy and the space is filled with sunshine and natural light. shout out to the friendly staff- this spot is oozes moms and pops vibes in the best of ways read more

MacReady Artisan Bread is a hidden gem. This place is knocking my socks off. I ordered a French loaf and asked to get it cut but the lady said "the bread is too hot and fresh". she was so friendly and took the time to get to know us. I also ordered a hot sausage egg and cheese and let me tell you this was a top three breakfast spot I've ever had. The warm yoke oozed down my face. the bread melted in my mouth. what a treat, the overall feel of this place is a true one of a kind. god bless! read more

Cranberry Chicken salad sandwich - plenty big for hubby and I to share! $13.50 for sandwich and chips. It was really flavorful, with lots of chicken chunks and cranberries. Happy hippie cookie was wonderful. Moist with lots of flavor! Some outdoor seating and a few tables inside if needed. This might be a regular spot on our stay here! read more

Phoned in our bread order two days in advance, because we wanted to be sure we would have it. The process worked perfectly our cranberry and cherry bread was delicious and ready at pickup! read more

We stopped at McReady Bread Company while visiting Egg Harbor with our family, hoping for a quick local lunch in Door County. The sandwiches themselves were good - fresh bread, quality ingredients, and generous portions - but definitely overpriced for what you get. Unfortunately, the experience was overshadowed by how unkempt the restaurant felt. The display case was nearly empty with a few sad-looking items, and what was there didn't look fresh or inviting. The overall space felt cluttered, and the bathroom was filthy, with storage boxes piled inside, making it feel like an afterthought rather than a customer-friendly space. Door County has so many great small businesses that take pride in their appearance, and it's disappointing that McReady Bread Company isn't currently one of them. A deep clean, better organization, and a commitment to presenting food in a way that feels welcoming would help this place better represent Door County's hospitality. read more

Good lunch spot with pretty good sandwiches. Wish they had hot sandwiches too but cold was good. Served bread as well. Maybe a little pricey but all is well with service too! read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

This year was our first time in Door County and this place was my absolute favorite! The first day of our stay was cold and rainy, so we all decided we a soup and sandwich sounded good and this place totally delivered on exactly what we wanted! Their bread is amazing. I got their ham and swiss but let me tell you about their chicken pot pie soup!!! It was so creamy and flavorful and I could have ate like several bowls of it. We ended up staying at Door County for a week and since this place had such a memorable affect on my family, on our way out of town we stopped by to grab lunch to go for the road and it must have been my lucky day because their soup was cream of mushroom. I simply cannot pass that up so I got a cup, which I ate in the car, and it was honestly like the best cream of mushroom soup I've even had, and I've had MANY over the years so I know what I'm talking about. Literally to die for. If you are the owner and reading this and would be so kind as to share your recipe, please contact me. I dream about your mushroom soup every week. read more

Epic fresh bread and other baked items comes it off this spot tucked back from the nose of the highway. It's a great spot to grab a quick bite as they do sandwiches with their fresh bread and other tasty options. The staff is always helpful and knowledgeable about what they're selling. While the seating inside is limited, there is also outdoor space or the food travels well either to a waterfront park or back to where you're staying. Highly recommend! read more

6 or 7 years ago, my wife and I came here mainly by accident when leaving Door County and we've been coming yearly since. It's one of our favorite DC traditions. The soup and sandwiches are absolutely amazing, especially due to the outstanding freshly baked bread. Got the carrot cake this year which was some of the best I've had! We love this place!! read more

Do yourself a favor and go here!!!!!!! Everything is so good, it is not just a sandwich. The Chicken Salad is my favorite! By far my favorite lunch spot in Door County!! read more

Their bread as well as their chicken salad sandwich, but please note they are closed on Thursdays, though here on Yelp it notes they're open. They will be opening on Wednesdays in July. read more

this place needs an award or something. seriously. they know breads and pastries like none other in the area. i recommend their famous cranberry bread and their Italian sandwich. i kept hearing from other customers how good their desserts were so we will be going again tomorrow! great great spot to pick up sandwiches for the scenic beaches in the area. we stumbled upon this while exploring the area! day 2 update visit #3 in less than 24 hrs : came back before we left door county and loaded up on sweets breads and sandwiches!!!! we cannot express how happy this place has made us and our tummies. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - YUMMERZ! - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

Excellent service and pleasant outdoor eating area. Would be nice if they offered hummus as a replacement for the creamed cheese on the veggie sandwich. A pickle on the side would be nice, too. We go there every time we are in Egg Harbor. read more

If you are looking for lighter fare, MacReady's offers great soups and sandwiches made with love and care.

The chicken salad sandwich is amazing, you must try it even if you don't like chicken salad. The tomato soup is a bit too sweet with some very large chunks of tomatoes and diced onions which gave it a strange texture. The Mushroom bisque was very good. They are very nice and if they are open I recommend on going there. read more

Best sandwiches in Door County! My husband and I stopped here for a quick lunch before biking Peninsula State Park and we were glad to find it via reviews or we may have missed it walking by. They have fresh baked bread and many options for sandwiches and baked goods. The outdoor dining was so cute with white metal chairs and tables around a small gazebo and even had live music. It was a perfect stop and an amazing sandwich. Definitely stop here if you are looking for great food, safe COVID protocols and a wonderful outdoor dining experience. read more

See all

Freshly made sandwiches on homemade bread...what could be better?!? My family and I stopped in for a quick lunch, and we all thoroughly enjoyed our sandwiches! Yum! Quick and friendly service, too. read more

I'll make this one very easy for you. MacReady's is a must if you're in fish creek. Across three different kind of meals, all were exceptional in the quality of ingredients & at a fair price. Of course, the bread is a home run. I'm still thinking about it a week after returning from vacation Good amount of seating on the lawn to catch some vitamin D & fresh air. Fast & friendly, such a well run establishment! read more

See all

I was in the mood for a really good sandwich and hearty homemade soup. So glad I came here! I ordered the 1/2 egg salad sandwich and navy ham bean soup. Super friendly owners who make your sandwich fresh on delicious bread. One of the best ham soups I have ever had. The restaurant is small and takes a little bit to get your food but so worth it. I'll be going back for sure! So yummy! read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - 1/2 egg salad and navy bean soup. Yummy! - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

Fantastic breads, sandwiches, soups, desserts!, wonderful owner! Baked Artisan Chicken Salad Sandwich Cream of Mushroom Soup read more

Nice place for a pick up and to sit outside to listen to the music. Bread is really good.

This was definitely a great choice when we wanted to grab lunch! I ordered the Italian sandwich and wow, it was so great! Of course the bread was incredible, and the ingredients were all fresh. We ate outside and there was a guitarist playing live music in the gazebo. It was a really nice atmosphere to sit and eat in. The service was friendly and the sandwiches were prepared quickly! I definitely was pleasantly surprised with how much I enjoyed our spur of the moment lunch here. Can't wait to come back and have another delicious sandwich! read more

One of our must-stops in Door County. Every time we visit, we get the best service from such kind people. And the bread? Heavenly. Flavorful. Delectable. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company was great. We forgot how nice a simple, "clean" sammich can be. By clean, I mean not a bunch of fancy toppings I can't pronounce and just good ingredients. Italian sandwich was excellent. Turkey was excellent. Cream of Mushroom soup was excellent as well, outdoor seating was nicely shaded and spaced apart. Can't complain, would love to go back again!!! Staff masked up and placed to go orders outside when ready. Good assembly line system. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Italian sammich - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

Pricey but delicious. Like most things in Door County this little shop is on the pricey side, but really good. Sandwiches range from $9-11 (extra $2 for avocado) and come with a small bag of lays (no other chips are available). They have limited canned beverages and water available for $2. They also sells whole loaves of bread, but most people seemed to be buying sandwiches. I tried the cranberry chicken salad sandwich on a recommendation from another patron and was not disappointment. The chicken salad did not have too much of a Mayo flavor and the cranberries were a nice addition. I heard multiple people ask about buying just the chicken salad and found out they do sell it in a pint or quart. We also tried the butter cookie which was as good as it sounds - super flavorful with a moist center and crispy edges. My only regret was not getting a whole cookie for myself! Great place to grab a quick sandwich! read more

Driving thru Door County we found ourselves suddenly in need of food and there in Egg Harbor was MacReady Artisan Bakery. Hand made sandwiches on in house baked breads. My wife got the cranberry chicken salad sandwich and I got the Italian. Excellent choices, aand not jsut because we hadn't eaten for 7 hours. The sandwiches were really good. We sat outside (with our dog: pet friendly) and enjoyed these tasty sandwiches, instead of trying to eat while driving. The staff was friendly and we ended up taking some loaves of bread to go. If gou are in the area, it would be worth your time to stop and enjoy some soup and a sandwich. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Italian - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

They have amazing breads and great customer service. Their location is in the quaint Door County village of Egg Harbor.

We stopped here for a quick lunch and were amazed with the bread and food here . The tomato bisque was one of the best. It paired very well with the rosemary and garlic focaccia bread that we bought . The chicken salad sandwich was delicious . Definitely a good place to visit in door county . read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Rosemary and garlic focaccia bread - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

A bit hungry on Labor Day weekend Sunday drive and happened across this stand-alone bakery. We chose Door County cherry scone and cherry streusel-topped muffin. We would post pictures, but we scarfed them up so fast, we didn't have a chance. The exceptional young man who served us was conversational and encouraging. We bought a beautiful French round to take home. Nice way to spend Sunday on the road! read more

Everything about this bakery is delicious. I could smell the bread from down the drive way and immediately walked up to order their cherry bread. I've returned everyday this last weekend, and I have yet to find something that disappoints. The staff are lovely and clearly love to work their. 10/10 read more

Good food. Lady that took our order was very short with us in a rude way. Charged us $1.72 more than what was on their menu. I'm more than willing to pay for good food but when brought up they told me that they couldn't give me a receipt and that their menu board is getting redone next week. Not sure if the heath department would agree with the open sodas and sandwiches being eaten by the staff in the same area as the sandwiches being prepped. Seeing the staff eat with their bare hands then go prep food to be served without washing theirs hands is a bit off putting. read more

I stopped in here based on Yelp reviews. I had the turkey sandwich which was just about the same as you'd get elsewhere. The price is high for what you get. Be prepared to pay far more than what it's worth because of the location and the seasonality of business in Door County. Based on reviews, I asked for a sample of the hippie bread. It was delish and as another reviewer noted, I bought bread even though I don't keep bread at home! I do appreciate culinary artists and it is evident here in the goods. Long day at Murphy Park with many hours drive home so did not have time or place to enjoy the cookies or folded pie sweet treats. All in all would stop in again to try additional items but am not convinced upon a first try that this is a top tier place. read more

Smaller than expected but quaint little spot. Like most say- the chicken salad was great!

Great food super friendly staff!!! Will definitely be back. My wife and I both had sandwiches and they were fresh and delicious. They included a wonderful carrot cake to help us celebrate our honeymoon. Just great people serving great food. read more