Service was good and friendly but food needs Jesus to save it. The place was a cool lil spot for what it is but maybe skip the chicken options. read more

Dairy Isle - Chicken sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

Terrible service and terrible ice cream. The prices here are crazy and the ice cream and toppings are low quality cheap. I would not go here in the future. read more

Dairy Isle - Burgers Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

well well well. the bathroom was a little stinky. however the ambiance was amazing because they played sweet caroline. Go SKYLINE. chili dog needs help read more

Great chocolate dipped soft serve cone!! Coney dog... had a snap to it! Very good We were looking for an evening snack And it's walking distance from most everything read more

Horribly overpriced for an ice cream cone. $6??!? Overall mediocre presentation and taste. Would not recommend purchasing from this location. read more

A good place for ice cream. Dairy Isle is about the only place to get ice cream on South Bass Island. Luckily it's located right by the ferry docks. It has ice cream but also food. The quality varies. Ice cream is the main thing here. It's one if the few places on the island to get it. The best thing about this place is that they have Dole Whip. It's about $2 for a medium. Me and my lady friend had the pineapple. This was a generous portion. It also has regular food. It's mostly not as good as the ice cream. They now have the Beyond Burger so that's a big improvement. read more

Dairy Isle - the interior of a dairy isle restaurant - Burgers Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Due to Covid-19 mask are required inside. Dairy Isle might have a "Starbucks" coffee ice cream float and have good soft serve ice cream, but not even that will ensure repeat customers with the Rudeness of the employees who ruined the island ice cream experience. It's a shame! Stopped by on Friday for a late afternoon pre Dinner Ice Cream cone and coffee. FYI - No sign on the door, register or anywhere telling about this credit card policy ---- all orders under $12.99 you'll have to "buy a mask" to make up the difference or order more food/Drinks (FYI - I didn't see them give one person this mask they bought) - seeing this happening to the paying customers in front of us, we combined our order. The girls working could not have been ruder when taking orders and handing out orders. We asked for a small Cherry Dipped cone and she asked very loudly what dip? We said Cherry and met with an "Oh Cherry" response. Up next was our Coffee Ice Cream Floats. Again the cashier rudely said "Ok" with an eye roll; After that, we moved and let the other ppl in our party order their own items. They too said that the girls were Rude but didn't wanna say anything and have a "Karen moment" LOL - the guest before us said they thought it was them for a min, but after seeing how rude these girls were with us, it must be the employees. the order was pushed to the end of the counter. No spoons, no napkins, and no straws. When asked for these items again were met with eye rolls from the young employees. To the owner or manager- I ask that you hire people who truly want to work and believe in customer service because this type of service no ones coming back for 2nds. To Starbucks Corp., they definitely are not doing your coffee brand justice. From some of the other Yelp reviews, someone might want to correct a few issues. read more

Yes, I am aware that this place is on an island, and it is peak season, but if you are charging $6.50 for a soft serve cone, you should at least say THANK YOU. Ice cream is fine. read more

A great ice cream parlor to cool off at.. Right in the thick of all activity in Putin Bay. The joint was bustling with activity as expected on a warm summer afternoon. This place not only does ice creams but also burgers, floats, milkshakes. I found the fact that they serve burgers a little confusing given that is not what you would be expecting while walking into a place named "Dairy Isle". Neither did I see anyone else during that time try one of their burgers e I got the Diet Coke float and vanilla ice cream. The ice cream was a little bland without any ice cream like flavor. I appreciated the fact that it wasn't overtly but this was a little too flavorless for me. They do several toppings and dips( chocolate dips) etc. The price is fairly reasonable as well. The staff is efficient and have the place running like clockwork. Two of the three stars are for their great work. The ice-cream per se is alright and nothing to brag home about. read more

Dairy Isle - Interior - Burgers Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

If your not consuming dairy do not come here. They have no idea what they are talking about.

Mediocre ice cream at best. Pb malt tasted like watered down shake w/ no malt. Don't order the kale smoothie... they did have good customer services, however. read more

Pros: Clean restaurant with decent island decor. Cons: Very overpriced food that tasted awful. Very slow service. It cost us more to eat here than it did to go to a local restaurant with a waitress and better food. For the money, I can safely say this is the worst burger and fries I've ever had. This restaurant was previously a Dairy Queen and it was the worst Dairy Queen in America. The new ownership has cleaned the place up a bit but that's it, bringing its rating up from an F to a D- I recommend a hard pass. I'll never be back here. read more

Stopped here after dinner to grab something sweet! There isn't a whole lot to choose from, but the soft serve is your typical soft serve. My sister got the Oreo storm (McFlurry basically) and my dad got the m&m. They both enjoyed theirs and I got the chocolate soft serve in a waffle cone. The waffle cone was nice and soft and had a vanilla wafer taste to it. The service was very prompt and fast! There are some tables outside and plenty of seats inside. They also offer burgers and hotdogs and things. Definitely a place to check out on a hot day! read more

I loved the ice cream, the food came out very very quickly. i got a perch sandwich and a strawberry dole whip. I enjoyed that there was lactose intolerant options. The girls up front were nice and helpful when I asked for the best recommendations. I would love to go back to the Dairy Isle next time I'm up at Put-In-Bay!! read more

Dairy Isle - The sunset at the docks!! - Burgers Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Disappointing! They advertise the islands best hamburgers! We went there at 8:50pm and the "kitchen was closed" could only order ice cream. The food may be good, but we didn't get to try it. I don't recommend due to their unpredictable availability of service. read more

Meh, the soft serve at McD's is better and cheaper...which isn't my favorite either, but in this case, I'd rather go to McD's. read more

Dairy Isle - Enjoying a hand dipped ice cream cone on the bay - Burgers Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Disappointed... This place is mediocre, overpriced, and if you want soft serve just go to DQ or McDs, or ANYWHERE else. We got some 10% off coupons which brought us in the door, but then we were told we could only use them on food meals, not ice cream. I thought this seemed a little deceptive for an ice cream place. I did appreciate that they put the cones in a paper cup too so we could take them to go and we wouldn't drop everywhere. read more

The Dairy Isle is a frequent when I go on summer vacation at Put-in-Bay. I order the chocolate kit kat flurries, chocolate cone dipped in cherry, or the chocolate waffle cone. Their ice cream is a typical, delicious soft serve & the service is quick & easy. read more

$15.99 for three dry, salty perch and over-salted fries? Are you kidding me? Worst place on the island. Skip it and go next door to the Keys. read more

Nice place, busy but friendly. The food is average and enjoyable, and the seating areas are welcoming and enjoyable. Now the prices are a little higher than usual, but you're on an island so that's what happens. Get used to it, and be thankful that you are on a beautiful party island! read more

Dairy Isle - This is where you order, you'll notice the Christmas decorations. That's because the whole island celebrates Christmas in July. - Burgers Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

Advertised as best burger on the island, sadly lacking in taste. Too much bread and bland tasting meat. Fries are extremely small shoestring fries. Taste was ok. Combo meal overpriced like everything on the island. Restaurant was clean and employees almost seemed interested in what they were doing. read more

OMG the vanilla ice cream is godlyyyy . it's SUPER creamy and amazing when u are super hot . i live in texas so sadly i won't eat this again for a while but LORD the vanilla ice cream is inexplainable . it was also very clean and the staff were super sweet . read more

The food was average, but overpriced. It took way too long to get our order. We wait about 30 minutes to get our food and everyone in our group was already done. We could've just gone to a regular sit down restaurant and gotten our food faster (which is what we'll do next time). When we did get our food, my daughter's chili cheese dog was cold. They fixed it, but then I had to take it back up because they didn't put any chili and cheese on the new one. The workers were apologetic and willing to fix any issues, but the food was not good enough to draw us back. read more

Awful chicken tenders. I ordered a chili cheese dog and was told at 1 pm the chili wasn't ready yet. Gross and overpriced. It's a shame they can't offer soft serve ice cream at a descent price and keep the place clean. Will not return read more

Was craving soft serve and found it. Smelled wonderful because they were making the waffle cones when we were there. They also had a water bowl outside for you for legged friends :-) read more

I loved the ice cream! It would have been even better if BBQ sauce was allowed for the ice cream, however. The employees were very nice, mostly the little girl named Ella! I was wondering the name of the green, crunchy stuff in between the burger, could you please let me know? Thank you! read more

This place was horrible I got a flurry and they fill the outer rim of the cup but left a gaping hole in the center