Honeycone is a wonderful little ice cream shop that I stumbled upon while checking out some shops…read morein Cheshire. They offer a variety of seasonal flavors, and they've just swapped to their winter ones! I got a cup with gingerbread ice cream and chocolate orange ice cream. There were a bunch of other flavors though, like a peppermint one and eggnog! Since there's a good number of seasonal flavors, it was hard to figure out which one to try! While they unfortunately don't offer samples, they do offer an ice cream flight with 6 small scoops for $13.50. Tempting, but I unfortunately didn't need 6 scoops so I went with just the two! A cute option nonetheless. They do let you mix and match flavors of the scoops you get, so I got to try two. The flavors were phenomenal, I was so happy to get try them. What a pleasant little surprise in the middle of a cute shopping area!! I certainly recommend it here.

Delicious little ice cream shop. I had the seasonal peppermint stick and it was perfect.read more

I'm not sure I have the story right, but it seems like Fenwick Ice Cream moved across the street…read morefrom it's old location. I'm guessing from some limited information that the at least some of the owners are the same, but I don't really know. In any event, the new space is bigger inside. Meaning you can actually walk inside now. There is still significant outside seating. They also seem to serve some limited non-dessert food. Like the day I was there, they had lobster rolls and hot dogs. There isn't any reason why I would change my prior review score. Service was friendly. They have 33ish flavors of hard ice cream. I had a hard time picking a flavor because I was looking for something different, but the flavors seemed fairly standard. I ultimately ordered a sugar cone with a scoop of key lime pie ice cream. They asked if I wanted any toppings, and I asked for a single Blue Raspberry Sour Patch Kid on top because I thought it would look cool. The ice cream flavor was good. It had like a pie crust swirl which added some contrasting flavor and texture.

First time at Fenwicks on Rt 1 right in the heart of Old Saybrook and I was satisfied. The ice…read morecream was great, I tried their famous Toasted Almond. The kid working there had his hands full with a long line, working solo but didn't skip a beat. The thing this place gets right where most ice cream shops get wrong, is the bright digital menu signs mounted up high. You can actually stand in line and see what they have. Other shops you don't know what they have until you get up to the register, thus causing delays and indecisiveness. I dislike the ice cream sample tasting though. This should be banned. It's only ice cream, take a chance. When there are 15 people in line, the rest of us don't have the patience for you to sample a flavor and think about it before committing to buying a 1-scoop cup. Ok my rant is done, but Fenwick's is a great place with great ice cream.

Excellent and friendly! They treat everyone very kind and ice cream is good! Neighbor hood placeread more

Not homemade ice cream. Good outdoor seating but the ice cream was not very good. I may be an ice…read morecream snob lol but it was a little icy. It's a cute setup, nice outdoor area and parking but ice cream is just ok

Good ice cream Numerous options…read moreGood service Why does Yelp need reviews to be wordy?Just promoting padding reviews!

What a cute place! This new little treasure is walking distance from Goodspeed Opera House and it…read morewell worth a stop. The talented and enthusiastic owner bubbles over with pride in her creations. Everything is delicious and unique. You cannot go wrong in this adorable shop!

Just updating to add a photo of the custom cake, which was absolutely gorgeous, and was enjoyied…read morethoroughly by all guests.

When renovations started on this building, I did not have high hopes. But I'm so glad I was wrong!…read moreThis place is awesome. There is a deli to the left where you can order all sorts of cold or griddled sandwiches. Straight ahead is the ice cream (serving Gifford's!), and to the left is a wall of refrigerators with plenty of waters, sodas, etc. They do breakfast sandwiches in the morning and have plenty of self serve coffee to choose from. If you're headed to or home from the beach, this is the perfect spot. We were in the mood for ice cream, but didn't feel like driving to Saybrook. I'm so glad we stopped in. They had both our favorites-s'mores and maple walnut. A small cone was a good size and we walked out with two cones for under ten dollars. That is about what you'd pay at Fenwick or DQ. We'll definitely be back!!

There were 2 of us getting sandwiches and no one else in the store at 5:30. The service was sooo…read moreslow. The young woman making our sandwiches was on the phone wandering around while she made the sandwich. We are boaters and were so happy to have a place nearby to grab sandwiches to go. I guess not. She was oblivious to us. So disappointed

I love Ben & Jerrys and this was a nice one for sure. Just on vacation I prefer local homemade…read moreplaces but with nothing open in the area we took our son hee. I think even he got spoiled by the local places or we just picked the wrong flavor for him, or maybe he was tired of ice cream lol. Took him till the 2nd night to finish his ice cream from here. We wanted shakes but blender was broken so we went somewhere else.

the ice cream is good, but really over priced for what you get…read more ordered the brownie sundae and it came in a cup with 1/2 a scoop of ice cream and whip cream. for over $10 this is super disappointing. The cup is small, the scoop is small, and there is like a quarter of an empty cup.

What's great little beachy place. We spotted this place on our drive down tot he shore. Ample…read moreparking and outdoor seating. And service was fairly quick. Big portions of the ice cream for a modest price. As for the ice cream itself, it was a little hit or miss with our family. We loved most of the flavors (particularly the salted caramel) but the mint chip was a little toothpastey taste. I'd skip that the next go around. But otherwise, friendly people and a nice way to spend a summer evening

"I went down to the crossroads Tried to flag a ride…read moreNobody seemed to know me Everybody passed me by" (Eric Clapton) If you're heading from the Hartford area on a trip to the shopping outlets in Clinton, the odds are quite good that your GPS will take you south on Higganum Road or Route 81. Eventually, you'll hit a crossroads and traffic circle where 81 meets Deep River Road or Route 80. Congratulations, because that crossroads is also the location of Crossroads, a very cool ice cream shop. We made our first ever visit to Crossroads today (they've only been open for a year and a half) and were very impressed with the friendly service, great ice cream, and outdoor seating overlooking the water. My Kiddie sized sea salt caramel dish was excellent and very reasonably priced at just $3.75. Bonus points for their generous amount of chocolate sprinkles! My wife had a dish of peanut butter brownie, and of course I sampled it. If you like peanut butter ice cream, as I occasionally do, you've probably been disappointed once in a while because the peanut butter flavor was kind of timid. But not at Crossroads! Their peanut butter flavor came blasting through loud and clear. It was fantastic. Their outdoor seating area is quite nice with lots of Adirondack chairs, tables, fire pits, and a corn hole game. I enjoyed chatting with the young staff who gave me a few blank looks when I asked them if they knew Eric Clapton's song "Crossroads". *Pro Tip - Crossroads doesn't have a website, but you'll find them on FB and Insta

Absolutely amazing experience every time I stop in! The staff are always the friendliest, the froyo…read moreis cold, fresh, and delicious, and the place is spotlessly clean and inviting. If you are ever lucky enough to be in the area, do yourself a favor and stop in. You will not regret it!

Self serve allows you to create your own amazing sensation. People there are very friendly, what a…read moregreat place. Frozen yogurt Gelato and sorbet very flavorful.