I'm not sure I have the story right, but it seems like Fenwick Ice Cream moved across the street from it's old location. I'm guessing from some limited information that the at least some of the owners are the same, but I don't really know. In any event, the new space is bigger inside. Meaning you can actually walk inside now. There is still significant outside seating. They also seem to serve some limited non-dessert food. Like the day I was there, they had lobster rolls and hot dogs. There isn't any reason why I would change my prior review score. Service was friendly. They have 33ish flavors of hard ice cream. I had a hard time picking a flavor because I was looking for something different, but the flavors seemed fairly standard. I ultimately ordered a sugar cone with a scoop of key lime pie ice cream. They asked if I wanted any toppings, and I asked for a single Blue Raspberry Sour Patch Kid on top because I thought it would look cool. The ice cream flavor was good. It had like a pie crust swirl which added some contrasting flavor and texture. read more

See all

First time at Fenwicks on Rt 1 right in the heart of Old Saybrook and I was satisfied. The ice cream was great, I tried their famous Toasted Almond. The kid working there had his hands full with a long line, working solo but didn't skip a beat. The thing this place gets right where most ice cream shops get wrong, is the bright digital menu signs mounted up high. You can actually stand in line and see what they have. Other shops you don't know what they have until you get up to the register, thus causing delays and indecisiveness. I dislike the ice cream sample tasting though. This should be banned. It's only ice cream, take a chance. When there are 15 people in line, the rest of us don't have the patience for you to sample a flavor and think about it before committing to buying a 1-scoop cup. Ok my rant is done, but Fenwick's is a great place with great ice cream. read more

Love that Fenwick offers a couple of vegan ice cream options. I ordered a black raspberry chocolate chip vegan ice cream and a pup cup. The black raspberry was not the best I've had but it was cold. The ice cream was a bit "dry and thick" with little flavor. My dog liked her pup cup though! They offer ice cream pies that looked good and unique. They have seating inside and outside available. read more

I was told they have a new location but the same good ice cream ! Congrats! No worries, I will return! :) read more

See all

We couldn't resist getting some ice cream from Fenwick after having lunch at Johnny Ad's! They have a bunch of flavors to choose from, and all of the ice cream is handmade by them. We indulged in a banana split, and it came with all of the classic toppings, and our friends enjoyed the mint chip and toasted almond. It was a cute, casual spot, and the girls at the window were friendly. This was our second time getting ice cream here and we will definitely be back for more! read more

See all

The best coconut ice cream I have had!!!! It has the perfect amount of sweetness and the coconut shavings were amazing! I would drive to Old Saybrook just for the coconut ice cream, a 1.5 hour drive from my home! read more

Nothing special. Got their promotion "flurry"... vanilla soft serve... with stale snickers or maybe it was frozen. I count eat half of it... My kids all got regular soft serve and a twist, it was fine. Nothing special about the ice cream... but probably not the worse ice cream you'll end up with. Rather have DQ. lol read more

Fenwick Ice Cream - Flurry with snickers. Frozen snickers. Break your teeth frozen. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

Amazing ice cream. As someone who worked in food service for 10 years I wish they used gloves and stuff but amazing ice cream

Ice cream made in house. Perfect place to go on a warm spring or summer afternoon for ice cream. Great flavors and a friendly staff. outdoor picnic benches included. I had the toasted almond and coconut with whipped cream and salty crushed peanuts. I'm told these two flavors are the most popular and I can't disagree. This place was a home run. read more

Delicious ice cream, especially the toasted almond and homemade whipped cream! Great customer service too.

Not a lot of flavors but the Chocolate Peanut Butter was good.great sitting area underneath the trees in the shade. read more

Fenwick Ice Cream - a young boy eating a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

Located alongside Johnny Ad's, this was a great idea--good location and lots of outdoor seating, which few ice cream places can boast. I got my go-to Blizzard/Flurry with Heath Bar, and was totally happy. read more

This was right next door to Johnny Ads where we ate dinner. The staff was so friendly and suggested the toasted almond ice cream and the vanilla black cherry chunk. Both flavors were delicious. This is a must stop place if you are looking for a sweet treat of ice cream. read more

Delicious ice cream and homemade waffle cones. Lots of flavors to choose from, perfect for a day after the beach!

Seeking ice cream before the storm hits. Googled a different ice cream shoppe and tada here we are at Fenwick. Many flavors, I believe 32 is what they advertised. I was originally going to have the vanilla black cherry, then saw they had Italian ice. That was a must have. The Mate had the key lime pie. I tried some, it was flavorful and just the right amount of lime. Ice cream extra creamy, mate loved it. My Italian ice soooo refreshing. Enjoyed the lemon while we watched the storm roll in. The cool breeze along with the cold ice cream felt phenomenal. It's a definite return. No inside seating. All picnic tables. Made for a comfy picnic feel, with 1950's music playing from their outside speakers. Attached to Fenwick is Johnny Ad's, we didn't try, but will have to. It's a burger / fried seafood joint. Loved the customer service. Very friendly and helpful. Oh there's the lightening. Time to go. read more

See all

I always thought all soft serve ice cream was the same. Since going to Fenwick and having their soft serve chocolate , I will never go back to the others! It was so rich with flavor. The consistency was thick yet creamy. And I had them top it with the chocolate dip, OMG!! It tasted like home made fudge. Everyone needs to treat themselves this summer. read more

We all loved Fenwick's soft serve last year.Yesterday,it was icy.Not the same.New machine? Not good.

Visited for the first time tonight. Overall, just okay hard ice cream, but the chocolate soft serve was very disappointing, simply tasted like frozen water with chocolate syrup, perhaps the machine was running warm. Otherwise, the folks running the stand were very nice and the service was strong. Ambiance was a typical New England ice cream stand. read more

At first, I was concerned with the portions. For the price I would have liked a bit of a larger scoop. Still only a few dollars though, and when I tasted it I was sold. I had the Black Raspberry ice cream and it was unbelievably good. Some of the best ice cream I have ever tasted. read more

My SO and I enjoy staying in Niantic for some quiet R&R. We were over in Old Saybrook for some mini-golf and I needed some ice cream after a very close game in the summer sun. This place was delicious! We each got 2 scoops in a waffle cone and omg. Toasted Almond and Rocky Road = . He got Vanilla Black Cherry Chip (or something like that) and Cookie Monster, both also delicious! The ice cream was smooth, rich, creamy, and worth a Yelp review. read more

Excellent quality ice cream with great choice of flavors. Size of small scoop varied somewhat among different servers. Fun music with outdoor seating. read more

Delicious! Broad selection of flavors. Chocolate mousse was excellent! So was the pistachio. Have to return to try them all!

I've driven by here so many times but never stopped. Last night we decided to give it a try. This little ice cream shop is a hidden gem, the quality of the ice cream is top notch. The ice cream is super creamy and rich at reasonable prices. We will be back! read more

The ice cream was good! And the staff were so friendly and quick! They even have picnic tables around so there is plenty of seating! For sure will have to come back if i'm ever in the area again read more

Real cream Ice cream - you can't beat that! Delicious - quick service - awesome ice cream! We just moved to the shoreline and I'm happy to have my new go to ice cream shop! read more

Best ice cream in CT hands down, and the friendly service can't be beat either! My family looks forward to every visit!

Excellent ice cream, without a doubt my favorite ice cream shop on the CT shoreline. A must stop when visiting Old Saybrook!

We are new to the area and stopped in tonight to try the ice cream. So glad we did! Ice cream was creamy and delicious, and the staff was so helpful and friendly. Before leaving we asked about the soft serve, and they gave us a taste. Delicious! We will be back soon! read more

Always great here! The service is always good, fun, and friendly. Perfect scoops every time, ice cream is great!

Ice cream is delicious! ...but a one scoop is a VERY little one scoop for $4.00! Not worth it! Barely a full scoop! Very disappointed!!! Don't skimp so much! You will actually get more customers if you give people what they're paying for!! read more

great ice cream!!! such a cute local place. the chocolate peanut butter was amazing!!