We have been trying to find a new Italian restaurant since Capezio's closed. We think we found it…read morewith D'Augostino's. The restaurant has a formal yet cozy feel about it. We were greeted at the door and seated promptly. We decided to try the eggplant and chicken parmigiana. The gravy (sauce) was like nona's and the eggplant was perfectly done. My husband enjoyed the chicken parmigiana mentioning it was the best in the area. We will return to our new favorite Italian restaurant.

Had an octopus pasta dish last night that was GREAT!!!…read more It was a featured entree and I got the impression it was a test dish. I should have taken pictures because the presentation was top-notch and portion size was just right. We are locals and come here regularly. The food is always good and reasonably priced, but rarely sit in the restaurant section. Seems they have a broader menu and perhaps a better wine selection, so will be turning left into the restaurant more often from now on. Service was OK. I think like most places they have a hard time attracting and retaining staff. There isn't a single TV in the dining room, which made the experience and evening MUCH quieter and more pleasant!!!

We decided to have dinner here while on a mini vacay to Michigan. Both my husband and I were…read moreimpressed with the food. We had the chicken parm/ lasagna and the chicken piccata. Will definitely return when we are back in the area.

Overall is a high 2/10. Food was just bland, no seasoning, or anything impressive. My rigatoni was…read morejust burnt and poorly made. Shells were still solid. Do not recommend.

We had an incredible experience celebrating my sister's bachelorette dinner here! From the moment…read morewe arrived, the staff went above and beyond to make our group feel welcome and ensure everything ran smoothly. Having a private room made the evening feel so special, and the team was incredibly accommodating throughout the entire planning process. They were attentive to our dietary needs and worked with us to make sure everyone had delicious options and felt included. We also had some trouble connecting to the room's speaker to play our music, and the staff was so patient and determined to help. They took the time to troubleshoot the issue with us until everything was working because they genuinely wanted us to have the best night celebrating my sister. That extra level of care and hospitality meant so much and made the evening even more memorable. The food, service, and atmosphere were all outstanding, and we couldn't have asked for a better place to celebrate such a special occasion. We highly recommend this restaurant for anyone planning a private event or celebration. Thank you for helping make my sister's bachelorette dinner so special!

Disappointed....Delightful server and good food but…read more.. We arrived on time for my BIRTHDAY dinner at 6:30. At 7:37, before the check arrived, the host told is that we needed to prepare to leave because their policy is to turn tables within 75 minutes. It was the rudest experience I have had in memory at a restaurant. I couldn't believe it. I won't go back.

Dinner out with a bachelorette group. We shared the…read morefocaccia and the Arancini and they didn't disappoint. I had the Pappardelle with the Bolognese sauce and it was delicious. Someone else had the ravioli and they were delicious as well. They had a special that night of a seared Branzino fish with an Olive topping with fresh asparagus that was phenomenal. The table also shared the cheesecake and the tiramisu for dessert. Drink of the night and not to be missed was an Espresso martini!! 10/10 highly recommended

We decided to celebrate my birthday (one day after) here since we are staying at the hotel, and it…read moredid not disappoint. I made a 6:30pm reservation and noted the occasion, and the staff sweetly sat us right by the window with a stunning view of Lake Michigan. I started the night with an Aperol Spritz. While their menu doesn't explicitly label items as gluten-free, I had called ahead and knew they could accommodate me. The appetizer options were a bit limited, so we shared the Brussels to start, followed by the corn and tomato risotto for my main, which was delicious. Our server was relatively new but incredibly attentive, even making sure to double-check with the kitchen that everything was safely GF. They offer multiple gluten-free options for mains and desserts, including GF pasta. We shared the ricotta cheesecake, and our server also brought out a complimentary chocolate mousse with orange slices and a birthday candle. Don't let the unlabeled menu scare you off--the staff is wonderful, the food is great, and you can't beat the lakeside view!

Food is OK, but service and attitude from staff and management are horrible. Seems to have a…read moreclientele that is part of some kind of a clique or cult.

We tried this for the first time last night. Exceptionally friendly staff makes you feel welcome…read more And the service was perfect. Being a vegetarian, I opted for Eggplant Parmesan and my husband had manicotti. All dishes appear to be homemade and the gravy (sauce) is very tasty. I also enjoyed a cannoli for dessert. My husband had the cheesecake but it was a small slice. The restaurant interior gives a homey feel and is able to accommodate large families. Great value for the price. We will be back.

Always a hit, my favorite restaurant in New Buffalo, Mi - awesome pizza and tikka masala surprise…read moreawaits you - outdoor tables with a relaxed vibe. Good service. Will be back again and again - my staple go to place Thanks

We stopped in for lunch and had a wonderful experience. The vibe inside is lovely--they have an…read moreoutdoor patio, but we opted to sit indoors by the bar. They even have an indoor atrium with fake windows, which was a pretty cool touch! I started with their tropical unsweetened iced tea, which was incredibly refreshing and delicious. As someone who eats gluten-free, I was thrilled to see how accommodating they are. They offer GF pizza and pasta, and other GF items are clearly marked on the menu. I asked our server about their cross-contamination protocols for the pizza, and she was super reassuring: they use a fresh pan and change their gloves, even though it goes into the same oven. I built my own pie with red sauce, cheese, and hot honey, and it was absolutely fantastic. My husband ordered a regular Detroit-style pizza and said it was delicious. They even have a few GF dessert options on the menu, but we were way too full to try them this time. We will definitely be back!

While staying in Benton Harbor on business, I tried out Joey C's. The service as fast and friendly…read moreand placing an order over the phone for pickup was easy. I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza, an Italian Julienne salad, and Buffalo sauced chicken wings. The pizza was really good. Nice dough, generous toppings, and good tasting cheese. Not much to say here, other than...good pizza. The Italian Julienne salad was delicious. The capicola and salami on it were delicious and the rest of the ingredients were fresh and delicious. Now the not so great (one-star taken off). The wings were small and dry. They were sauced really well, but the wing meat itself was dry as if it was over fried. But oh well...everything else was really good. Give this place try...not the wings though.

Pizza should be cooked MUCH more as the dough doesn't seem fully cooked under the sauce. The…read morebottom of the dough is cooked but the top of the dough under the toppings absolutely needs about 10 or more minutes in the oven. Kinda mushy. Not well seasoned either. Hard fail for me. I gave a 2 because the Italian sausage was decent.