Tucked in at the far corner of a busy strip mall, this place is often overlooked. Prices are great -- Sicilian slice, pepperoni slice and a bottle of Pepsi for 8 bucks. Folks behind the counter are efficient, but not very friendly, and the pizza slice options are generally good. Pizza is middle of the road, not too thin, not too thick, but the sauce is tasty. They also have dinners and sandwiches to eat in or take out. read more

I was a customer this past Friday. I brought my pizza home and half of it was wrong. I called and asked to pick up the correct pie. Long story short, the owner's nephew, Sal, wrote "dickhead" in Italian on my pizza box. When I saw and I called back to ask about it, he was incredibly rude. I will never be spending my money at this classless establishment. read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - Rude message on pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

Everyone at Dominick's is friendly. They are fast and the pizza is great! I always pick up my order and it's always ready in like 20 minutes. read more

The food is excellent. Sal is a great guy and the pizza is even better. I love the testa pie! Extra cheese and pepperoni

Dominick's pizza is always solid. Recently discovered they have the best Gluten Free pizza in the area! read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - Gluten free cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

Bought several slices: artichoke/mixed veggies, pepperoni, spinach, plain... the ingredients are so fresh! The flavor is from the quality of the products used. The crust was even flavorful. Customer service was very kind. Absolutely will come back! read more

The best pizza on the planet-has not changed since they opened!! Come in from out of state, and go straight there! read more

Pizza was thrown on the ground, made like shit and looks like shit. Oh wait, it also taste the same way. Just stop and quit your job if you are going to serve shit. read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - Did you get in an accident on your way here? What a joke no one cares anymore. Pizza looks and tastes like garbage - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

If the pizza was bad enough for me to leave a review... that's how you know it's horrible. charging 28.50$ for a specialty pie that bad should be a crime. the buffalo chicken tasted like boiled shredded chicken with franks red hot and made the pizza soggy. the tomato sauce tasted like it came directly out of a jar. you're better off going to get a frozen pizza and making it yourself over this. read more

Their Sicilian and sauce are incredible! They are always quick and friendly. Highly recommend!

I work in the area and truly love the pizza, but the service I receive is worst than horrible! They make me feel like they don't like BLACK people and in shows in there service . I went there today with a coworker her order was taken while I was ignored. The worker threw her pizza in and went back to what he was doing never asking did I want to order anything. I waited 2 minutes still nothing until finally I said excuse me can I place an order ? Another worker came over rolled his eyes like I was bothering him and threw my pizza in the oven. In the meantime a WHITE couple come in and his whole posture changed " HI WHAT CAN I GET YOU?" I WILL NEVER AGAIN GO THERE ON TOP OF GETTING MY SLICE NOT HOT AT ALL I WILL LET EVRYONE KNOW HOW BLACK PEOPLE ARE TREATED IN DOMINICKS PIZZA! read more

Delicious pizza with a variety of toppings and other food for take out or eat in . Friendly staff. Never been disappointed in the quality of food and the reliable service . Easily one of the best pizzerias in the Bridgewater/ Somerville area. read more

Dominick's Pizza is a small spot right off of the Somerville circle. They have a great counter selection and the staff is very welcoming. The plain slice is fairly generic. The cheese is subpar and the crust tastes like burnt sesame seeds. The baked ziti slice was good. The sauce is decent but was a tad cold. Overall, Dominick's was unimpressive. Perhaps it was an unlucky time to come by. read more

TIP - there are no fountain drinks available ...hence there is no ICE available either. All drinks (soda/water) are sold in bottles/cans out of the cooler. The pizza - really good! We stopped in and were pleasantly surprised by the crispy crust, the fresh taste and the overall high quality pie. read more

Grama Pie is nothing more then a regular pie with regular cheese and plops of can tomatoes on top... not worth the 18$ read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

One of the very places in Somerville/Bridgewater that stays open in the late evenings...I mean past 9:30 pm. We just ordered a whole pie with half mushrooms and half pepperoni. The pizza was made fresh. It wasn't too bad, but there was definitely more sauce than a usual pizza which made the cheese come off very easily and runny. We also had some garlic bread. It lacked garlic flavor. Okay spot to grab a so called "late" bite to eat. read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - a plate of bread rolls with dipping sauce - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

This place has gone absolutely down hill, placed an order for pickup and got there 30 mins later, didn't even make the pizzas yet, no apology or anything, not like them at all, the owners younger son or nephew is an arrogant and smug a**hole. This is Jersey, pizza is everywhere and there's better places around. read more

Ziti pizza was very good, but wasn't heated up all the way. Tasted great either way. We'll be back. Could use a facelift inside, but whatever. read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - Ziti pizza - very good. - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

When i walked into Dominicks last night to get a slice of Jersey Suburban pizza, i had a sudden flashback and i actually thought i was in Tallahasee Florida last month You might want to think about following the New Jersey Law regarding wearing of masks AND the law against eating indoors at restaurant. The ignorant Floridian rednecks thought they were cute and laughed at the experts until they found out about the lack if hospital beds throughout the state due to selfish and somewhat ignorant behavior. Im sure the last few times i was in Dominicks your staff forgot about protecting each other and thought they were on a cattle farm in central Florida. Come on now! Lets learn from others mistakes fir the sake of the community ( your customers). Ciao!! read more

Delicious assortment of pizza with thin crispy crust. Best pizza for miles around! Everything is delicious on the menu. Highly recommended!

Ordered a pie for dinner and Moy 90 year old mother bit into a push pin. I went back to show the owner and he argued with me and asked what do you want me to do with an attitude. Do you want another pie? I said NO THANKS - Toke my money and left. There are many more good pizzerias around the area. Poting a picture of what I showed the owner. read more

We had ordered takeout on 4 plain cheese pizzas and discovered the total amount charged including tax was higher than the price listed in the menu we picked up on the way out of restaurant the same day. We will verify prices and total amounts before pickup in the future. That said,It was great tasting pizza. read more

I wouldn't let my dog eat this food. Over priced, under sized. The location is generally dirty on all surfaces. Nobody speaks English. Run away read more

THE best pizza in New Jersey. Searched for 2 years for really good pizza after moving to the area. Best one was right down the road!!!

Others may enjoy this style of pizza, but I was incredibly turned off by the taste. I had to stop eating this pizza, I just couldn't stomach it. I don't think I've ever willingly put down a pizza slice before in my lifetime. The adage "Even a bad pizza is worth eating" does not apply here. The sauce was bland and uninspired. The crust OK at best. But the main negative was the taste of the cheese - waaaaay too much chedder/sharp cheese. Not only did it taste bad, it didn't appear appetizing either. Typically the cheese is spread out evenly, but the cheese on this pizza looked like globs and some slices lacked while the others were stacked. I regret winging it on a pizzeria in this area because this pizza was one of the worst I've ever had AND $15 for a SMALL pepperoni. Like, come on. I know several places that sell a LARGE for that price. Avoid. read more

Walked in to pick up 2 cheese steaks from here and no one even greeted me. Then got all the way home to find both of them were completely black. How could they ever think this was ok to serve? After frequenting this place for years, there have been issues with multiple orders here recently. We will not be coming back. read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

BIG pizza fan but not a big Dominick's Pizza fan unfortunately. The pizza is just "alright". On some days the crust is perfect, some days its too dough-y. Their pre-made pies on the counter have all your classic toppings but never anything new or creative. Guys at the counter are always friendly. They'll even deliver your slices or sandwiches to the table once they're ready, which is a nice touch. I was a regular here for some time... until I became disappointed with one of the guys at the counter who rushed the reheating process of my pizza every day at lunch. They have a solid mushroom slice and their cheesesteaks aren't bad either. I've tried their eggplant/ricotta slice which was delicious when served crispy and hot. Decent plain slice too! Sometimes the mozzarella cheese they use doesn't sit right in my stomach. Tried their chicken parm sandwich once and the cheese smelled very pungent. Ended up throwing away most of the sandwich since it tasted off. They sit at the corner of a small strip mall, making it a convenient stop for shoppers. They recently remodeled their dining area and it's much more cozy now. Dom's Pizza was my go-to pizza spot in the area for quite some time. but I've since moved on. read more

Excellent pizza. I would think that NJ would have better pizza then this but in this area of NJ pizza is tough. FINALLY i found something decent and awesome and this place is quality stuff....highly highly recommend the pizza as it is just perfect on all levels. Try it, get fat and thank me later. read more

For the most part, I like Dominick's. Prices are reasonable and the food, taste wise, is good. The problem is, if they are even slightly busy, more often than not, the food comes out burnt. Don't know whether it is that the ovens are set too hot, or they don't pay attention, or a combination of the two. read more

Dominick's Pizza Shop - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

All the people leaving One Star ratings obviously do not know what a REAL ITALEAN Pizza place is. People Complaining about employees "not wearing gloves" and "touching money before handling food". First of all, Real Italeans DO NOT wear gloves, especially not while preparing food. If the wear gloves, how can they get close to the pizza and give it the Italean flair? Second, everyone knows that any good Italean Business owner should count his wad of cash every 1-2 hours to keep track of his earnings, as well as to show off his success. If you want a true Italean Pizza experience, go to Dominick's, you wont be disappointed. - the connoisseur of Gabigool read more

We spotted this place and decided to give it a try based on a review stating that this is the best pizza in NJ. I ordered a regular cheese pizza cause you can tell a pizza place is good based on their cheese pizza. If they care about the simplest pizza, then the others must be good too. I have to say, we were all satisfied with the slices we got, and the added crunch was a bonus. Highly recommend. read more

Neat little neighborhood joint. Good clean place and consistently deliver quality product. Quintessential Italian owner and his family members run the place. Over all a decent place for one in a while good tasty Italian delights. read more

In speaking with the owner on a personal matter, he told me his shop is by where I work. I told him, I don't get pizza around here as pizza outside of Essex County as no one can make a pizza to my liking. Vito promised me that he could make a pie to my liking. Well, I ordered one today and I was more than pleasantly happy. I ordered a small and only shared one slice, with my co worker who shares my pizza issues. My coworker picked it up for me and when I got it after being in the box, I pulled a slice, and it was still crispy. I folded it and it snapped! It snapped from happy crispiness! Needless to say I am happy and I can get pizza while at work again read more

This place is gross!!! The guy took money from the customer before me then touched my pizza without washing his hands or using gloves!! It's not that hard to have just one person on register. Imagine touching a gas station handle and then touching pizza - you would never! Money has been everywhere. imagine what other things they're touching while handling you food. One star for that + very mediocre pizza. So many better spots in BW please skip this place! read more

Great place! I was super happy to see a cheese less pizza when is was there picking up a slice for my daughters. My husband is dairy free and he was so excited to eat that piece of pizza. He said it was delicious. Will be coming back for sure! read more

I ordered a pizza, they said 10-15 minutes, I send my boyfriend to pick the pizza up. Boyfriend calls and says "uhhh are you sure you placed an order here because they say they never received a call" I verified the number with him an everything. I called the number again asked them what happened to my order they said they had no such order offered to make one real quick. Seriously? No apologies or anything? You're just gonna assume I'm some crazy whacko who never called. Never again will I order from these people again. Whoever took my order must not have cared enough to write it down. read more

This generic pizza spot gets 2 stars for convenient location and convenience of take-out. I cant imagine driving out of the way to find this place with the nice brick oven pizza places in the area. The ingredients used are standard - average quality. read more

Blah. I wish I could say it was great but my chicken roll was under-cooked and cold inside, although warm and toasty on the outside. :( Pizza looked good, however. read more

What a great place! There's no shortage of pizza places in NJ, especially not in this area but Dominick's makes a great pie. Friendly staff and good pizza, what else could you want! read more

Best pizza in Somerset County. Trenton style pizza is unique and worth trying. Old school, has been around forever, and the pizza hasn't changed. It's a shame they don't deliver. read more