Super friendly and accommodating owners. Very large menu; lots of choices. The pizza display case is quite artistic and colorful. Most importantly the food ; pizza, salad, pasta were delicious. Almost as important is that Carlo is a big time Yankee fan. read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

I walked in expecting a simple meal, but the experience was humiliating. The young woman was kind, but I took a little time because I'm feeling under the weather, and the men working there kept giving me hostile looks--as if they didn't want me there. Their attitude was so rude that I only ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a soda, even though I had planned to order a whole pizza. After one bite, I threw the slice away, took my soda, and ate at the restaurant next door instead. No customer should be made to feel unwelcome or discriminated against. The community should not ignore this kind of treatment. There are award-winning pizza places in Somerville and Raritan where customers are treated with respect and appreciation. I will never return to this place. read more

We were staying in NJ and needed to get some dinner. We ordered a salad and a pizza. A friend got one of the Philly steak sandwiches. The pizza was quite good. Salad was a typical salad for a pizza joint. All pretty decent food. read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Hawaiian Pizza (Pineapple, Ham, and Bacon) - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

The grilled buffalo chicken salad is delicious and fresh, my go to for lunch. Good portions, delicious flavor and great chicken. The woman at the counter is so friendly and always makes me feel welcome which makes all the difference when you walk into a restaurant! read more

Good slice at a good price. Generous sized slice for under $3, which is a very good price in this day and age. Decent crisp on the crust and good overall taste. Solid slice if you are in the area. read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Very good sized slice for under $3. - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

The pizza is solid, good even, but two times I called in and asked for LIGHT CHEESE, EASY ON THE CHEESE and got an edge to edge cheese bomb. This is more cheese than the picture on the website, whyyyyyyyyyy! I should have looked in the box when I picked it up. Also this pizza was $27? read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Grandma with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

This place has some incredible pizza (grandma pies are awesome) and some really great pastas and sandwiches. Dana is always so friendly with my kids and they were amazing with a big delivery order for my daughter's birthday party!! read more

My favorite penne vodka around Very tasty. Kind service. Any time I'm craving penne vodka, I will continue coming here. They also decorate for holidays which is epic! read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Penne vodka with crispy chicken - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

The food is great and the people there are so friendly. It's my go-to place for pizza.

Amazing pizza!! Staff is super friendly, overall great service. Definitely going to be our regular pizza spot! read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Half and half grandma pie - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

Old school Italian pizzeria known for their grandma vodka slice. All these were singular slices and we had the guy behind the counter split each into 2! Grandma vodka took the top spot with the vodka variation coming in second (the vodka sauce is unbeatable and with thin crust makes it feel nice and light). I'd say it's a tie for the white and square (worth mentioning that the crust for the square was like focaccia, super airy and doughy ). Great spot for a quick bite, feeling the NY Yankees love in the joint. Will be back! read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Grandma vodka slice, vodka hot honey pepperoni slice, white slice, and square slice - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

I have decided that this is my favorite pizza in the area. It's consistent and scrumptious. Top quality ingredients, I love the grandma pie soo much as margherita, pepperoni and vodka with penne. It's a crispy and fluffy grandma pie ...just perfect. They carry my Joes tea and the cannolis are so delicious!!! They are proud of their cooking and it shows. I love to come here. A straight forward ambience where you can spark up a conversation or just mind your business. Absolutely reccomend their pizza 10/10!!! read more

The best service!! Carlo served us right before close and accommodated us! Everything was amazing - from the vodka penne to the pizza to the arancini! We will be back and send all our friends and family! read more

Believe what you read...both the server and chef (I guess the owners) absolutely wonderful people. I'm at the Marriott down the road a bit and there is a Maggianos restaurant across the street...SO GLAD I decided to eat local...everything was delicious 4 stars because when you order veal Parmesan you should get silverware... But certainly not a deal breaker... Wish I lived closer it would be a once a week visit! read more

World-class homemade arancinis and penne vodka. Flew in from Scottsdale for a wedding and Carlo and his wife treated us just like family. Wish we had this type of Italian food out in Arizona! read more

This is one the best family owed Italian restaurants/take out places I've ever been to. We are here from out of town and decided to take a chance. The 1/2 grandmas 1/2 vodka was absolutely amazing! Loved every bite. The pasta dishes were great. We had the vodka sauce and chicken parm. Even the side salad was great and balsamic dressing tasted homemade. Totally try this place worth the wait! read more

When first looking at the shop and the pizza itself, you'll think "Okay, typical New Jersey pizza joint". Then you'll bite into a slice and BAM. Very classic flavors and very classic texture, but done SO well. I just felt like everything from the saltiness of the sauce, the amount of cheese, the time the pizza was baked was just perfectly balanced. This might be sacrilegious, but in some ways I loved Carlo's pizza better than local gem Prima Pizza (now don't fight you two, I still love you both and I promise to split business with you evenly...I'll just be buying twice as much pizza every week so we all win, especially me ) The standout for me was the "Seafood Pizza", which came with calamari, shrimp, and scallops. You gotta love seafood obviously but this was such a unique offering and fit so well with the cheese and sauce that I was sad I only ordered a half and half. Then again, the "Eggplant Parm" was very good too. Carlo's might not win any awards for being a cutting edge pizza restaurant...but who cares? It's clearly got some roots in honest pizza tradition and tastes freaking great. With reliable taste and service, Carlo's has won my allegiance read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Sicilian Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

Listen I only leave reviews for really bad or really great food and service. This is one of those ones that it is great if you want a place that will take care of you make you a delicious dinner and leave happy come to this place. The food is always phenomenal and the staff always treats their customers good if you haven't tried it do you self the favor and go read more

food 10/10 customer service: top tier ! i had a plain slice , side salad with oil & vinegar & their chicken parm & penne in vodka sauce my son had a kids spaghetti, my boyfriend & his son had a tuna sub . everyone really enjoyed their food & the way the staff was so attentive to us made us feel at home . will definitely be back to try everything else on the menu ! run don't walk to Carlo's !!!! read more

The real deal! Sauce very tasty, cheese very melty t, Crust perfectly chewy, and baked in an appropriately hot oven. Thin and just the right amount of grease. Good ingredients, good pizza. A don't miss! read more

Food at Carlo's is just great. The team pays attention to detail to make sure you are getting what you ordered. From individual slices to go or whole pizzas the crust and sauce is great. If you are looking for a real treat try their Stromboli. It's the biggest Stromboli I have ever eaten. The stuffing in the Stromboli is massive and delicious. If you are in Bridgewater definitely give Carlo a try you will not be disappointed!! read more

Ordered a buffalo chicken with ranch pie from menu. Picked it up and opened the box at home. Got buffalo chicken BUT no ranch. Does buffalo chicken without ranch yummy? I'll let audience decide. read more

I usually don't rave frequently about restaurants as many if not most are hit and misses! This place is amazing! I always order here and the quality and consistency stays the same which is something I like and highly value! Whoever the chef is please give them a raise or whatever you can to keep them because if anything slightly changes you'll loose me as a customer! I have ordered over 50 times and my order is the Penne Vodka w/chicken and it taste the same ALL the time! The chicken is tender "not hard and rubbery, like some other Italian joints around here" and the pasta is al dente! The vodka sauce is so rich and flavorful and not oily To say this place is excellent is an understatement. I can't speak for the other menu items, as my go to dish is always the penne vodka but I can't imagine the other dishes not tasting just as amazing. I always recommend this place to my clients who come from all over the world and they always give a thumbs up to this place! I should start getting some commission haha! This place certainly beats some of the other higher prices "so called" gourmet Italian restaurants I've eaten at! Hands down! read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Penne Vodka w/chicken - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

Excellent food! Pizza was amazing . We had the half grandma and half vodka pizza. We also Chicken Marsala that melted in your mouth and a large salad that was complemented with mozzarella. Staff was super Friendly . We would go back in a heartbeat read more

I have tried almost every pizza place in this area and Carlo's is just better in my opinion. We usually order a half pepperoni and half vodka sauce pie, eggplant rolatini and sometimes the white pizza with broccoli. Everything is always delicious. read more

Superb experience! Absolutely huge slices and the lunch deal is unbeatable at $5.50(plus tax) for 2 giant flavorful slices and a bottle of water/or soda. I intend to make an order for one of their specialty pies next! The menu looked incredibly unique and had a lot of neat options. The shop was clean and the staff (a man and a woman at the time I went) were both polite in their welcome. This place is hands down the best this side of town. As a bonus, my kid was real excited for the little toy machine which takes a quarter. Great overall experience start to finish. read more

Dropped by bc I was hungry and this was near where we were and convenient. Luckily, they allowed inside dining (distanced of course) so we had our food there. I don't remember what my husband had but I ordered something similar to a fat cat (those that know what that is just know lol). It was just ok? Filling to bread ratio was decent but flavor was kind of bland. The sandwich itself was solved it hunger but can't say I'd order that again. Staff were super nice and very helpful! I'd like to try out a few slices next time so stay tuned! read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

Overall: great little spot. People who complained, all seemed to have a bad experience with the pizza by the slice. I got the ham pizza, fresh, and it was great. Food: 5/5 see above. Service: 4/5 the staff was fine, but certainly not outstanding. The dining space is not large, but no one is here on a Monday night at 930p. Value: 5/5 great pizza, fair price. 13 bucks for a14" one topping. read more

See all

The pizza was very good, ordered online without problems and it was ready fast. But stay away from the calamari, it was bad. I've had a lot of calamari in my lifetime and this was by far the worst. It smelled and tasted horrible, unfortunately I had to throw all of it away. Updated review- the owner called and explained that the distributor delivered bad calamari and that it has been fixed. I appreciate getting a phone call, shows how much they care about their customers and business. read more

Got regular pie and 1/2 and 1/2 Grandma. Loved the standard grandma slice. Others were ok.

Great, delicious food and a very friendly staff. I will continue to visit and I highly recommend! Recently purchased a cheesesteak sandwich from there. Delicious however I do have 2 small suggestions for the cheesesteak sandwich, which like I said was already very good. A bit more cheese, but I do love that it was mixed in and not on the top which peels away with the foil. Also the peppers and onions were chopped up a bit too small. Larger slices are better. Cannot taste diced up pieces too well. read more

Carlo and Dana are the owners food is excellent. The owners are excellent and the prices are just right. You'll get treated like a king here.!!! one of the best cheesesteaks I've ever had in my life also and their penne vodka unbelievable !!!! read more

Inside Carlo's Pizza, you get the look of a quintessential neighborhood pizzeria. There are classic wooden booths with benches, plenty of baseball memorabilia and a super friendly waitress. I ordered a slice of plain and a grandma vodka slice. The plain had great flavors of salt, a slight tinge of garlic, and a rich red sauce. The base was perfectly crispy and the crust was yummy and fluffy. The grandma vodka slice has a nice creamy, cheesy sauce. It tastes like a cheese explosion. The pizza Carlo's offers is great and if you are thinking about trying it out, I highly recommend it. read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

Love the food vodka sauce is awesome on everything. My favorite is chicken vodka sauce sub!!!!

Mmm... Great spot to grab some pizza. Got the half hawaiian and half pepperoni & sausage. Pizza was absolutely yummy. Also got some garlic knots which was tasty as well. That marinera sauce was fantastic. read more

Carlo's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

Awesome! We ate at Carlo's on a Friday night and it was great. Food was delicious, staff was friendly, and prices were good. Tables were clean. All of the food we got from pasta fagioli to slices to chicken parm sandwich were delicious. The veal parm was probably the best I have had in a number of years. We will be back. read more

Superior pizza! I was visiting NJ over Christmas and we ordered a Carlo's Sicilian pizza, it was delicious with the garlic knots!

Came back to jersey to finally be in pizza heaven. It's decent pizza don't get me wrong. But I love when a pizzeria adds their own flavors to the sauce. I have a grandma slice, a cheese slice, and Roni slice. Nothing magical. Slices are huge, so one slice can feed a child completely. I was trying to find my pizza spot, I'm still looking. read more

First of all, we walked in an hour before closing so you could imagine how embarrassing this was, we were so hungry and I've eaten here before the Big Pete sandwich is wonderful!! The staff did not cast judgement (noticeably.) we ordered a meatball parm sandwich and a chicken roll along with a pasta fagioli soup everything was AMAZING! We can't wait to come back only this time not right before they close. Let's not fail to mention the owner Carlos is a yankee fan (hehe) read more

Love his pizza and pasta dishes! Great vodka sauce for pasta and my favorite grandma's pie. Very flavorful subs too. He is willing to customize any dish to meet your requests. Plenty of seating is available but most of his business seems to be take out. read more