I came here right before closing and grabbed the last couple of slices of pizza and garlic knots. Solid pizza and great garlic knots! It satisfied my carb craving at night! The owner Sal has been here for 51 years and hasn't changed his recipe and there's no need to! The bread in the garlic knots and the pizza crust are the perfect combination of crispy outside and chewy inside. Great local spot- will definitely be coming back here again! read more

Joe's Pizza - Garlic Knots - Sandwiches Near Me - Martinsville, New Jersey

GREAT PIZZA & GREAT SERVICE!!! Always friendly and helpful. Been going there for over 30 years. Won't go anywhere else!! Owner Sal is the BEST! read more

Tasty, thin and crispy pizza. We walked in looking for a few slices to eat there and he had a fresh plain pizza right on the counter. He warmed up a few slices for us and we took a seat. The pizza tasted great and had a great crisp to it. Not too cheesy and not too bready. I'd check out Joe's for takeout in the future for sure. read more

Joe's Pizza - 4 plain slices reheated - Sandwiches Near Me - Martinsville, New Jersey

See all

It was our first time at Joe's Pizza and Joe made us a fantastic, salad pizza. I would call it award-winning. I never had crispy dough before, but wow, it was good!! Some pizzerias burn the bottom of your pizza -- not here!! Joe shows great attention to detail. We haven't tried his regular pizzas, but we'll be back. read more

We decided to try another pizza spot in our area to get a taste! Ordered via Slice which is always a plus. Buffalo chicken pie was pretty regular. Not a ton of chicken and not a ton of Buffalo. It was ok. Regular pie was also nothing to be making a big deal out of. Ordered mozz sticks, no sauce with it. Kind of a bummer. If you're in the area and need a pizza, why not? But not a place to go out of the way for. read more

Ordered delivery from here tonight via slice. The pizza came, it was hot and tasty! We got a large pepperoni pizza and a large pizza rustica, a white pie with ricotta and ham. Overall, the pepperoni was pretty good, the sauce had a nice tang to it and the pepperoni was good. It was a thin crust that was a little "floppy" if we're using Dave Portnoy terms but the crust was crunchy. The white pie (pizza rustica) was okay, not too much flavor on it and I felt as though there was not enough ricotta on it. Overall this was a great experience and I will definitely keep Joe's in the front of my mind for future pizza orders, this is easily top 3 In my area. read more

Joe's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Martinsville, New Jersey

See all

I get we are in NJ and not NY. Didn't expect the pizza to be just ok. Cheese is great, liked the garlic on the grandma pizza, sauce is good, but the crust really fell flat. Very underwhelming. Wouldn't order again. read more

Joe's Pizza - two pizzas in a box - Sandwiches Near Me - Martinsville, New Jersey

Stopped in for a quick bite and I was not disappointed! The staff was very friendly and the service was quick. The plain slice had a nice, crispy base, awesome sauce, and great, salty cheese. The slices are very foldable and have a good structure. Overall, Joe's puts out a really solid standard slice. Job well done! -@BoroPizzaHunter on Instagram. read more

quick service even when there is a line. grabbed slices to eat there & a house salad. the white pizza with bbq chicken was delicious ! the margarita slices looked delicious and my friend enjoyed them. read more

The place was very clean and the owner and wife were very nice people but the food was average at it best . Just a standard nj pizza joint in the local area . We originally asked for a sausage and peppers dinner. Got plain sausage and peppers in the meal no sauce or spices . We had a large plain with half of a topping lacking sauce and chesse . Nothing more then a standard pizza read more

See all

What makes a great restaurant experience?..... The food? The ambiance? The value? The owners?.......yes, yes, yes, and yes! But there also other things for me that make me want to come back.....Passion and experience. Up until a week ago, Joes Pizza in Martinsville, NJ was just another NJ pizzeria that I drove past whenever I drove thru Martinsville. At the recommendation of a long time friend, who first told me that the owner is Salvatore Pasalaqua, a name I was familiar with from a pizzeria that my family and I frequented in the 1970's and '80's in my home town. Then he told me "his pizza is GOOOOOOD! I knew I had to go! His pizza is a crispy thin crust, not a cracker thin crust but some of the thinnest hand thrown crust I've ever had. His sauce and toppings are perfect and appropriately distributed and that crisp bottom is just perfect! Tonight we tried some entrees; she had the eggplant Parmesan and I went old school and had Spaghetti and Meatballs. I'll often have this as a gauge when I visit a new to me Italian restaurant. If the meatballs aren't homemade, I won't go back. Joes meatballs are tender and mostly meat. They're seasoned well and I thoroughly enjoyed them. It was so refreshing to not have to ask for my pasta cooked al dente. In fact, I usually do but this time I forgot and how refreshing it was to be handed a plate of pasta that was indeed perfectly al dente! The Eggplant Parmesan was damn near perfect! Nice and soft, not bitter, and an ample amount of mozzarella. How happy I am to have a goto place for red sauce Italian food being served in a pizzeria atmosphere as opposed to a sit down, white tablecloth place. My girlfriend referred to the place as a step higher than most pizzeria's and Joe and his wife couldn't be more friendly and grateful that we chose their place to spend our dining dollars. We will be back and be back often! Joe's Pizza 1938 Washington Valley Rd Martinsville, NJ 08836 732-469-3356 read more

See all

I love their margarita pie!! Toasty under carriage. Not floppy at all. The pizza slinger in the back I believe is the owner, he is always nice to me so I always go back. read more

Best pizza along the Washington Valley Strip in Martinsville! Thin crispy crust and least expensive per slice. Salad is consistently fresh and well dressed. read more

Did take out. They were fast and reasonably priced. Friends did a vegetarian pie and they were happy with the amount of toppings. I had a gluten free pizza. I was surprised they had one to offer and I was doubly surprised that I was satisfied with the crust. Well done all around for a neighborhood pizzeria. read more

Very delicious Pizza, honestly one of the best in the area. Sal the owner is a great guy, he will do anything to satisfy the customers. read more

My family has been eating here since the original Joe owned it. Even with new owners, the food is amazing, if not better. The lasagna is swimming in sauce, which is personally what I like, but keep that in mind if it's not your preference. The cavatelli broccoli is usually in need of a little salt, but other than that is another favorite. The rice balls are always perfect and crispy. The pizza itself is really amazing, great sauce, great crust, great everything. I really wish I saw this place get more business because the owners are very nice and work very hard. Every occasion with friends or family sees a pizza from Joe's, and maybe a few garlic knots. Best pizza in Martinsville, hands down, no question. read more

Our favorite pizza in the area!! Highly recommend the zucchini Marinera pie or the sausage.

Love Joe's. Simple menu, outstanding traditional Italian food, reasonable cost, and good people who own. Great thin crust Italian pizza. Dough is chewy and crisp at the same time with nice tomato sauce and right balance of cheese. I actually enjoyed the eggplant parm the most. If you like eggplant, go on Wednesday's when it comes in fresh! Also enjoyed a nice, simple salad with oil, vinegar and oregano complimented by freshly baked Italian bread. read more

Joe's Pizza - Eat at Joe's! Order from the menu on the wall or table side. - Sandwiches Near Me - Martinsville, New Jersey

I was in the area and I wanted a slice of pizza. The pizza looked gross and it was only one pie ready. I would definitely never eat pizza from this place. I walked right out and went to another location for Pizza. I have no idea how it gets 4.9 stars. read more

After reading the reviews I placed an order and got the eggplant with ricotta cheese pie. They make really delicious pizza! The crust is perfect - to my liking - chewy and crispy in all the right places. The pie was small for a large and the topping was on the stingy side. I would order there again. read more

Great pizza, very friendly service and Sal is terrific!! Clean and nice atmosphere!!!

Not great pizza. Football style, a little greasy and cheese is bland. Sauce doesn't have that tang or kick so overall was meh. Owner is great and very nice and considerate. read more

Small local place to get delicious Pizza. The cheese, sauce, and crust were perfect in my opinion. Also, we had a few of their pasta dishes (Spaghetti and meatballs, penne vodka, manicotti) and thought they were all tasty. read more

We came all the way from Berkekey Heights after hearing great things about Joe's Pizza. . .and we are so glad we did! Date nights are hard to come by so we brought the whole family (and a bottle of wine) for a casual night out. We started with the buffalo wings and garlic knots. Both appetizers were devoured in short order and despite the generous portions, we were eager to try the pizza. Our margherita and eggplant pies were obviously made fresh and the thin crust. was. on. point. I loved the leaves of fresh basil on both pies, and the ratio of cheese:sauce:crust was perfection! We were there for quite some time and saw several returning customers come into the shop who obviously agreed with our assessment. Our kids enjoyed their pizza so much we ended up ordering an extra couple slices to go! We look forward to returning to Joe's in the near future! read more

See all

This place is amazing ! Everyone is always so friendly and welcoming, Sal the owner is just such a sweetheart and will go above and beyond for all his customers. The food is always fresh and done with perfection. read more

Good stuff.... Happy with the food, pizza and wings were great.

The pizza is average in my opinion, the two others I was with sort of agreed. One said they didn't like it b/c there wasn't enough cheese on it. Ok fine, I hear you but its still average.. The other thought it was good, I didn't take what they said to heart b/c they come from down south which doesn't have nyc style pizza. I grew up in nyc and nj, so this is average for NY/NJ, it will be good if you are from out of state. The chicken parm sub- From what I remember b/c it was a while ago, the bread was over toasted which I don't like when its so hard its crumbling everywhere and you are left with a dry tongue. After you get past that part it was pretty good. I haven't been back in a while but now that I am writing this review, I think I will have to stop by there the next time I stop by. Go in for a slice! read more

Joe's is a friendly family run pizza place. After a long road trip, their hospitality and food was really great. I love that they have half sandwiches, like the half chicken parm for $5. I'm going to stop in next time I'm in town. read more

Joe's Pizza is the best pizza, best real Italian pasta, best Stromboli, best everything! This wonderful, authentic family that has taken over the new and improved Joe's Pizza know exactly what they are doing and they are doing it perfectly! Any kind of Italian food, this wonderful place should be your first call read more

Joe's Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Martinsville, New Jersey

See all

For a pizza place the food is great! Order the zucchini pie if you like garlic. Me and my friends all had pasta and the sauces were spot on. For a little dumpy pizza place this spot has great big tastes! read more

Joe's Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Martinsville, New Jersey

My family of 5 ate there a couple of weeks ago and had the best pizza and mouth watering garlic knots you could imagine. Turns out that the current owner took over for the original Joe's so can't say how this compares to the past, but Lombardi's better watch out!! read more

Very unprofessional and unfriendly staff. If you want to be treated okay don't go here.

After driving all day from Georgia, we picked this restaurant because of all the great reviews. We were extremely satisfied with the service and food. The owner even made our pizza bigger than we had ordered because he could tell we were hungry!! Amazing, authentic food. Definitely will be back if we are ever in the area!! read more

It's really difficult to find decent pizza in this area of New Jersey as most people know. Other locations are either okay or way way overpriced. Joe's Pizza on the other hand is reasonably priced and very very good. I wouldn't go out of my way to compare it to anything in NYC but it's pretty darn good pizza for the area and probably the best my fiance and I have tried locally. Really nice family owned establishment that was very appreciative of our business. We will certainly be returning. read more

Came here the other day on my lunch break. I am a pizza snob and let me tell you this was AWESOME! I will defensively be coming back here! Staff was super friendly too, really made my experience great! read more

I had the Cheesesteak which was good. Parking in back. Plenty of seating Atmosphere was OK. Staff was friendly read more

I agree the ingredients have changed, they started using lower quality ingredients. The last few times I've had a grandma pizza or margherita pizza is wasn't any good. The cheese steak is bad too. There's to many pizza places to go to one on the decline. read more

We moved into a year ago and took us about 6 months to find Joe's..and now it's become our go-to for pizza! Do yourself a favor and try the eggplant marinara pizza (fried eggplant slices on top of marinara with cheese)..very good! I can't wait to try their sandwiches! read more

Ask for Jerry - pizza is amazing & everything is delicious. I love this place it's awesome!

Joe's serves delicious pizza and it's a friendly family business. I can't wait to try their other offerings. Highly recommend! read more