While their pizza is good, I don't come here for their actual pizza. I come for their subs…read more Specifically the pizza and ham & cheese subs. I really like that their salads use romaine lettuce that is actually green whereas a lot of other places use iceberg. Their service is great, always fast & friendly.

I love Cristy's pizza, and I cannot get this in Columbus, but last visit there was very sub par…read more I ordered small personal pizza with onion, sausage and tomatoes. The crust was soggy, and very doughy. The ingredients seemed to weigh the pizza down? Not tasty at all. Not sure if crust was cooked right? I have no clue, but will think twice before heading to Cristys anytime soon. The place was not busy folks, as this was in the daytime. Me thinks something was hurried, because my last time there, the pizza was super good. We need consistency. All I can say is very iffy as to your experience with this pizza.

The food quality and taste have drastically gone down hill. My most recent visit this week resulted…read morein a cold, soggy sub and a pizza that was dry. The staff used to be the best in town, but now they seem bothered and unhappy. I'm hoping for improvement, but have my doubts.

Worse pizza ever!!! Who puts American cheese slices on a pizza instead of a decent or good shredded…read morecheese?!

I wish other pizza places could figure out how to be so inexpensive and taste great all at the same…read moretime! The service is nice, but dont expect glamorous. It's just great pizza! Easy enough to take your kids, feed them, and go.

Food was fast, hot and delicious! Def recommend this place. The value and price was unbelievable…read more Very friendly staff and very clean dining room.

If I could give 0 stars I would. To start we made a…read morereservation for a 20 person party a full 24hrs in advance. (We usually tip extremely well, we will not be this time) Staff: The staff are rude, snobbish, arrogant, and absolute dunces. Our waitress took all the orders and forgot to put 3 of them in until everyone else has finished all their food which is absolutely unacceptable and ridiculous. When asked about she said "oh I forgot". We have been here over and hour and a half. Most have had their food except for 3 children who were very hungry and quite upset. We had to flag down 2 different servers to get refills for our drinks and that took 20min. Our order: We ordered 6 different pizzas, 1 set of wings, 2 salads, 3 subs, and 4 pastas. The pizzas were bland and tasteless. The cheese on the pizzas were burnt and tasted way off. The pasta was overcooked. Needless to say the food was absolutely not worth it Experience: Absolutely appalling experience! We will NEVER return here and I recommend everyone to steer clear of this location as this was the worst experience and service I've ever delt with. Rating: 0/10 Recommendation: I recommend everyone to avoid this place unless they want treated like crap and ignored.

It's a pretty well-run regional chain. The Circleville location has ample seating (outdoor, too)…read moreand a pizza bar vibe. There are party rooms, etc. It's good pizza and affordable. The sauce is great and has great use of toppings. Quick and easy service, whether counter, or sit-down.

Circleville Pumpkin Show item -…read more I have a collection that has all of my favorites and will be adding more each year I go or as people recommend them to me. Come here to get everything for $1. They always sell pumpkin pizza for $1 a slice. It's so delicious and is a must try. I've been getting this pizza for years and I look forward to it every time I come here. In the past they have sold pumpkin Buckeyes which were a little strange. The pumpkin pop was not good either.

Pumpkin pizza? I was a skeptic but it was delicious. It is a thin crust with a layer of pumpkin,…read morecheese, and cinnamon sugar sprinkled on top. Sweet and savory. The best part is that it is only a dollar a slice! One of the best deals at the pumpkin show and arguably one of the best pumpkin food items.

Really good pizza and food, and the drinks are cold. The staff have always been nice.read more

I live within 3 miles of this Sunoco station. I placed an order for CB w/ltmpo and an order of…read morefries, wait time 30 minutes. After 20 minutes, drove to the station, got 2 gallons of gas, then went in to pick up my order. The fries were tasty, but were lukewarm and only a minimal amount (4.99). The cheeseburger was one that was premade like they keep in the self serve warmer and no tomato (9.99). 20 oz bottled soda (2.59). One candy bar (2.39). UNBELIEVABLE! You can eat at a decent fine restaurant for that! Mind you this is not a 'sit down family' restaurant. Don't be deceived by the menu photos. This is not inflation. It is greed and outright price gouging I truly regret not accepting this order and will NEVER order from there again. DO NOT recommend

We have been here many times and the food and service never disappoints! We've had brunch and lunch…read moreand we've sat out in the patio a few times to enjoy being outside while eating. It's a very comfortable vibe. Oh, and they have great Bloody Mary's!

We just tried this restaurant for the first time-two adults and 2 kids. The A/C either doesn't…read moreexist or doesn't work. We heard multiple people complain about it. (It was 91 degrees at 8:00 pm). The waitress just blew off the remarks, which I don't blame her. She's young and just works there. But there was a family sitting on the patio and every time the waitress went outside, where we were seated it felt like we were blasted with a heater. When they walked in to leave, they mentioned that it felt the same temperature inside as it did outside. My children ordered a personal pizza off the kids menu, each, but the waitress only brought one and my husband ordered the street taco nachos, which were good and a salad, which he said was okay. We didn't say anything about the pizza, they just shared because we honestly just wanted to leave as soon as possible. They enjoyed it. I didn't order any food because the heat just made me nauseous. The waitress was nice, raved about the strawberry shortcake for dessert (tried it, none of us enjoyed it, which is unusual for my kids). Our bill was $60. In my opinion, it was overpriced for mediocre food and the feeling of 80+ degrees in the restaurant.

Honestly I'm SO annoyed and done with this pizza place. Every time I order here my food is wrong…read morelike, I've started to feel like when my name pops up they purposely make it wrong. I'm also DISGUSTED at how one of the managers responded to my complaint. Her attitude was foul. My order wasn't complicated at all and frankly I'm never coming here again.

Pizza was great! Kali made it perfect, just the way I ordered it. Hot and delicious :)read more

Service was way below par. It said 20 minutes for pickup. Made it there in 20 minutes and had to…read morewait another 45 minutes before the food was ready. The pizza was under cooked and the boneless wings was luke warm and dried out from sitting under the heat lamp. Was told the ranch dipping sauce was in the bag and wasn't. The cinnamon rolls was raw. Called to speak to a manager but they must of been afraid because I sat on hold for an hour and 45 minutes with no answer then hung up on. This place is a joke. I would be ashamed to be associated with location or it's staff.​

Completely on me that I was super late to my pick up order, this team called after X amount of time…read moreto confirm I'm still coming and when I arrived they remade the order with complete professionalism and empathy. They do not train this in corporate manuals - this team went beyond my expectations in every way. Well done!