Ordered here a Sunday night. Got the meat monster I believe it is called in the 12 cuts square pan…read morestyle and 2 sides of ranch. I had never had pizza joes prior to this. The pizza was a quick fix while repairing a car and I needed to feed a few hungry people. That said the size was very large for 17 dollars and some change. My only issue is the pizza was much more greasy than I am used to. It also had a bit of a weird texture noticed by another person eating it too. But I was able to feed 5 people with this one pizza and overall was a hit. They do not deliver which is something I am having to adjust to here but the staff was so friendly when I called in the order.

My husband walked in and ordered 2 pizzas, one white and one 10 inch Spinach Italiano (with Black…read moreOlives instead of Hot Yellow Peppers.) He waited for them, brought them home and discovered the Spinach Italian had yellow peppers to instead of the ordered Black olives. Please make sure your employees start listening to people when they place an order. I never see people check their order when they leave, shouldn't have to, if they listened.

Northeast Ohio Classic made by the Italian Family that has owned it for decades…read more Sweet sauce makes the pie

Pizza was so so, 5/10 Lady working the counter is rude,…read moreunfriendly. Needs some better customer service skills.

Stopped in on a Sunday evening to try a few different pies. As I'm getting older, perhaps my tastes…read moreand preferences are changing, so I'll share my experience and anyone reading this can take it for what it is. I did not order ahead, I placed my order in store to get the hottest possible pizza, and I ended up ordering 3 small pies to try some different slices. I ordered two small cheese pizzas, one with mozzarella cheese and the other with Romano cheese, and the third pizza was a deluxe. To begin, I really enjoyed the Romano cheese pizza. The Romano cheese has a sharp flavor, but it doesn't over power the sauce in anyway. The sauce was sweet, tangy, and really shined with the Romano. Most important, it wasn't greasy. The mozzarella cheese pizza was good, but the thicker cheese reduced the sauce flavor a bit, still good, and with all of the pies, the crust is a very light and airy crust which is pleasant to eat. Lastly, for the deluxe, I could have done without that. It was greasy, heavy, but my biggest issue, you can tell some of the toppings came right from a can. Overall, 3.5/5 for me at this pizzeria. I'd come back again, however, I'd stick with the cheese Romano pizza.

Been loving the pizza for years a must have if you ever in the area please try them .read more

I have been in the Cortland Ohio area since 2020. I have not found a good pizza place until…read moretonight! This was delicious! The crust was not so thin to be cardboard or thick to be cake. The sauce was so old world flavorful. I'm hooked!!!!!

Salad was skimpy on fries and pizza wasn't hot no taste. Used to buy from them not no more and…read morewings were dry tasted like they just heated up in microwave

On Tuesday, I ordered a pizza for pickup on Wednesday. Arrived at the specified time. Door was…read morelocked. Called 20 minutes later, no answer, left a message. They called back and said they had my pizza. I called back a little later to verify that they had my pizza ready. They said they did. I went and pizza wasn't ready, It was still in the oven & I had to wait for it. No discount offered, no apology, nothing. Last pizza from Boardman Cornersburg. From now on, I will go to Cornersburg location only.

this place is constantly locked-up, even when there is a guy working inside…read more I talked to someone that knows the situation. She said they have trouble finding counter help and they have trouble buying food stock items!!!??? They close and turn out the lights on their whim. WEIRDO-RAMA situation. This place used to be the best.

austintown, First time ordering here. The sauce is garbage and worse of all the pizza was burnt…read morewhen I got home. Waste of my time and gas to bring it back.....Should have just went to wedgewood pizza across the street, instead of trying something new.... The empty parking lot should have beed the first clue.....

We are new to Boardman but Uptown Pizza has quickly grown to the top of my list as our new…read morefavorite pizza place. We ordered two pizza's both large, one with cheese and one with cheese & pepperoni. The Pizza's were amazing. The people are very friendly & it seems to be a very popular place with the locals. I have to give a shoutout to their staff for their handling & caring of a older lady who came into Uptown Pizza lost & upset. She could have been anyone's Grandma. It was dark out & I felt so bad for her & wanted to help her but I don't know the area well enough to give her any type of direction. The staff at Uptown Pizza sprung into action to help her. Since it was so late & dark they opted to call the Boardman Police to escort her to her destination. That is what you do to foster a good community by being the reason the community is good. Kudos to you Uptown Pizza!!! God bless you guys!!! The Harper's will be ordering our Pizza's from you from now on. Happy Easter!!!

Great service and decent food. You know what you're getting from Papa Johns. Hits the spot.read more

The pizza was outstanding, one of the best I've ever had. The service was immaculate and patient…read more Overall just a great experience!!!!!! Thank you papa John

Yes yes YES! This is…read morequite literally the best pizza I have had in my entire life. Who knew it would take this long to finally find that. So cool that they are opening up TWO new locations in Boardman & Kinsman to spread the pizza goodness!! The Detroit Hot Honey Roni is my favorite. This was my first time having Detroit style pizza and it makes me feel like I don't have to travel to truly experience it. The baked cheesy goodness of a crust is phenomenal. Flavors? Out of this world. Cupping pepperoni is simply the best, their sauce doesn't give me heartburn and considering I try to stay away from red sauce that says a lot! OHHHH but their basil is always so fresh and flavorful. I think I could eat a bowl of it! The Detroit Chicken Bacon Ranch is also delicious. Best CBR pizza and I've had a lot of em. No words! The Detroit 8 Mile, same thing. Raving about it! I was thoroughly pleased that you literally get slices of garlic clove on top. The hot peppers ain't too hot & it's just GOOD! Period. Penna Alla Vodka with a fresh baked roll... my Lord! This was on a separate visit, but figured I would include it in this review. (I have been there 3 times within a month, oops) Pasta came out piping hot, flavors were immaculate; sausage, sauce, cheese, basil, OH MY! Just try it. I cannot wait to continually support this business and try new things with each visit!

I saw we are getting a Red Plum in Boardman , curiosity got the better of Me. I decided to go to…read morethe Warren location rather then wait til our location opens Nov 1st. Restaurant is Beautiful, staff very friendly and tons of parking. One of my dearest friends went with me. They have a great stocked bar and nice outdoor seating for those that prefer that. We started with the Oven Baked Meatballs, plentiful with a nice amount of fresh ricotta, it also came with a huge roll with fresh garlic and spices on it. The Meatballs were delicious. We tried the Plum Salad...the flavors were amazing the Feta was soft and creamy and the dressing was unlike any I have ever had. Best Salad. Small size enough to share. We tried a few Pizzas...took 90% home. First up New York White ...I added Ricotta to it. It was cooked to perfection and full of flavor. Second up was Detroit style The Butcher...My friend said it was really yummy, with a great amount of Sausage Meatballs and Bacon. This is the Ultimate choice when those ingredients are your Joy. We got smaller size with 4 huge square pieces. The under carriage of this pizza was pure perfection. Third up was New York Style Pesto, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce with the perfect blend of Mozzarella, We chose to have them not add the pepperoni. This pizza delivers every flavor imaginable. I'm going to ask them if they can recreate on Detroit crust which is my new favorite. This pizza was tied for my favorite.... Fourth and final the tie for first place pizza.. Detroit Style Greektown ... Between the fresh spinach and the creamy Feta add olives hot peppers and light Mozzarella this pizza was Epic. The under carriage was perfect. The pizza delivered crunch after crunch bite after bite. It doesn't really get better than this. Our waitress was wonderful. We had her bring each pizza out in its box as we really only shared one square of each pizza. I am New York Born and live in Ohio. Truly here There are very few pizza establishments that truly bring it. Red Plum 100% delivers. Quality, Taste and price. Excited they will be in My neighborhood when the new location opens. This is a truly hidden gem. I plan on going back very soon. Hands Down Best of the Best!!!!!