came to Wildwood on vacation and wanted pizza we called a…read morefew places and they were very rude so we went to the third place which was Mr. D's The first phone call placing the order was the nicest gentleman on the phone sooo polite & professional. the price was great! the pizza was delicious and not a long wait! even the delivery driver was so nice delivering to us. what delicious pizza and such professional & kind staff! thank you very much!

I truthfully think this pizza is closer to 4 stars, but when I ate a slice here today I was…read morestarving and it tasted delicious, so I'll give it the 5 stars this time around. Cheese is just the right amount - it doesn't slop off. Sauce is more on the savory side - not too sweet. Crust has a nice chew to it. Slice pretty much holds its shape when you pick it up. Looks like someone needs to show this place some love on the inside (I saw pictures from years ago and it looked more lively with some of the decorations back then).

I've stopped here during work and a great deal for a slice and a drink…read more Can add toppings to a regular slice. It's the perfect portion for a lunch on the go where I'm not starving all day until dinner. It's small and locally run so have a little patience if you hit it during the lunch rush. He takes phone orders to have it ready if you need. Place is a bit small so be prepared to take it to go. Great place to grab a slice or a whole pie and take it out to the beach at the end of Sunset for a little car side picnic and watch the sunset.

Great unpretentious pizza place in West Cape May on the way to Cape May point. They offer slices…read morethat are reasonably priced. Quality, tasty pizza.

Ever since the moved from Rio Grande, nothing but problems. If you have a new front of house…read moreperson, you should shadow them... guide them on how to handle less cash payments... Nope, just give me crap for being upset with an individual who is incapable of counting. I supported you for many years, not any more. Good job!

Horrible pizza. The dough is dry and under fermented. Has zero structure and completely flops…read more Cheap ingredients and greasy cheese. Will never return.

We ordered food from Brother's Pizza ll Cape May. We were there 45 minutes before closing. The guy…read morethat waited on us wouldn't let us sit inside to wait for our pizza because they were cleaning up. We said okay and we would stand inside to wait for the pizza, he made us wait outside.

Was very surprised that the pizza we ordered wasn't that great being this business is in Cape May…read more I didn't hate it, but you can tell the ingredient used are on the cheaper end of quality I feel middle of the road so the reason for 3 stars. The service was fine, but the electric wiring being exposed and being used for refrigerator case being plugged into it in the open on electric strip is dangerous. I think they could do better with the presentation of their place and with ingredients just saying.

Wow, the Penguins were cooked, almost to perfection and are well seasoned. The mozzarella fries are…read morethe perfect combination of crispy outside and soft inside and the mozzarella that they useis just delicious.

Stopped in here yesterday for a slice and it was the best white slice of pizza I've ever had. I…read moreasked for it to be well done and every bite had a crunch which I love. John behind the counter was really nice too. Highly recommend this place over Steak em up!

10/10 experience! Everyone was incredibly kind and even took the time to answer our questions about…read morestreet parking with the storm coming in. You can tell this place is run by people who genuinely care AND the pizza was fantastic. We ordered the Meat Lovers pizza slices (and honestly would've gone for a whole pizza if we were hungrier). I loved the wonderfully thin, crispy crust and how the toppings were packed with flavor. The restaurant itself is cozy, decorated with Cape May artwork, and has a charming diner-style vibe that feels both local and welcoming. Would recommend to anyone visiting!

Awesome!!!!! I expected average boardwalk pizza.... What a got was some really well made pizza;…read moregreat crispy crust, fresh ingredients on the "works" pizza (see picture) and high quality cheese. My guess is grande cheese, the best of the best .if it's not, I'd be shocked. Anyway, highly recommend!!! ‼

We stopped at Tony's prior to our excursion with the Cape May Whale Watching trip. Don't expect…read moremuch choice for kids unless they want pizza. Our 5 year old daughter wanted pasta (the pasta was going to take 25 minutes). They don't have many kids drinks like chocolate milk, or apple juice. The server was helpful, but not very friendly. Also be aware that the traffic over the bridge is typically backed up and he might need some more time to get to this place (not that I am recommending going out of your way to come here). The food wasgood . I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich and it was made just like I asked. The lettuce and onion were fresh. The french fries were a little overcooked but crisp. My wife ordered pizza and the slices were huge! Very cheesy and well cooked. Tony's is ok if you're looking for something quick and basic.

Delicious food & great service. We enjoyed a buffalo chicken wrap, meatball parm sandwich, chicken…read morecheesesteak, and a cheese pizza. Everyone enjoyed their food. We will definitely order from Tony'a again.

Just an FYI, there is no indoor seating. Shared seating with other businesses out front. Table out…read morefront was filthy so we sat on a bench along the boardwalk that was fine. Pizza was delicious over all. Great crust, good cheese and good pepperoni. Made fresh in 20 minutes. Drove down from Philadelphia to try it out. Worth the trip. Great ice cream right next door as well!

The pizza was more like three stars, there was too much cheese for how thin it was and they didn't…read moreleave the slice in long enough. However, the view is great. There are only two picnic tables out front. From the pictures and other reviews I think maybe getting a fresh pizza made would've been a lot better than this but we only wanted one slice each and they had a lunch special.