We stopped at Tony's prior to our excursion with the Cape May Whale Watching trip. Don't expect much choice for kids unless they want pizza. Our 5 year old daughter wanted pasta (the pasta was going to take 25 minutes). They don't have many kids drinks like chocolate milk, or apple juice. The server was helpful, but not very friendly. Also be aware that the traffic over the bridge is typically backed up and he might need some more time to get to this place (not that I am recommending going out of your way to come here). The food wasgood . I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich and it was made just like I asked. The lettuce and onion were fresh. The french fries were a little overcooked but crisp. My wife ordered pizza and the slices were huge! Very cheesy and well cooked. Tony's is ok if you're looking for something quick and basic. read more

See all

We stopped in a Tony's Pizza for lunch today. We had a cheese steak with pepperoni, an order of fries and a slice of cheese pizza. The cheese steak we very good and exactly as ordered, The pizza slice was a good size and had lots of cheese, the fries were hot and crispy. The total cost was very reasonable for a seashore location. read more

I had a very large order . This they did deliver for a very short distance. However because my order was so large did ask if they had a special or discount for a large order. There reply was we get large orders all the time. We don't give anyone a discount. So the way they stated things I felt was a like my business was not that important. Flavor of our order was disappointing. The pizzas definitely lack flavor. Very disappointing. The subs lacked flavor and value. ( steak subs) now for delivery it was hot and on time. For value and flavor I do not recommend this place at all. I'm going to try my luck at a different place. May I get better taste and more professional answers. I still have large orders coming in the future. read more

Empty restaurant should have been our first clue. Server said she wouldn't bring iced tea out until she took our meal order. Pizza, (New Jersey Pizza!) was the worst I've ever eaten, couldn't finish one slice. Rubbery cheese, crust looked like it was pre-made frozen.. Such a disappointment. They cut too many corners here and it shows. read more

Great pizza. We found ourselves away for the weekend in late January. Most places are shut down for the season so we took a riddle looking for something to do. We drove into Cape May and stopped at the antique market on the right side as you enter the town. After 15 minutes of antique browsing I was thoroughly bored so I decided to step out for a walk while my wife continued shopping. Note that this review is for the pizza only. I noticed Tony's pizza next door and from the outside really couldn't tell if it was open so I took a peek in through the window and saw a counter person and one patron eating at a table. I decided to enter, not expecting much. The place was old school and had a giant dining room. I can imagine during the season this place May get busy but today it was empty. There was one pie sitting on the counter and it looked decent too so I ordered a slice. I must admit I was shocked when I took the first bite. This slice was fantastic. Perfectly seasoned sauce, stretchy cheese and a thin and super crispy crust. A slice of NYC pizza right in Cape May in the middle of January. I immediately texted a picture to my wife and she came right over and we ordered 2 more. Great pizza! However, the place is very run down and tired and not very clean. My wife said the restroom was filthy. Anyway, I'll be back but probably grab a pie to take out. read more

See all

Family run business that has been around for thirty plus years. Friendly staff and yummy big slices of pizza for $3.25 each! I only had the pizza so can't vouch for the other food but so far it's been the best slice pizza I've had in Cape May. read more

We had a family of 9, all adults, and came in around 2:30/3:00. There were zero patrons in the establishment. The woman who "helped" us gave our party an attitude immediately! We asked if we could eat out on the deck. She told us that "she didn't have time to wait on us". We asked what she meant. She stated that she had to answer the phone. We were able to convince her to take out order and to eat outside. Her response, "well since you all have already taken up the entire deck, might as well". We ordered 3 large pizzas and drinks. I went in there to wait for the food and she told me to wait outside. As I was leaving, she complained that I was letting the air conditioning out because she felt that I took too much time leaving. The pizzas were good. Nothing extraordinary. I would order from them again, if they hadn't been so rude. Will never receive my money again. read more

See all

Claims they're open until 10pm but they're closed at 9pm so my door dasher was unable to pickup my order which caused my order to be canceled which caused me to lose $50 for the next 5-7 business and have no food in return. read more

Tasty, albeit not a crust I'm the biggest fan of - more bready than doughy. The sauce and cheese (we had 2 slices each) were really good. We didn't have time to order from the menu and the only slices available were plain ones. With COVID, no indoor seating. I needed to use the bathroom though. I wish I hadn't! DISGUSTING (literal crap was left festering in the one stalled women's bathroom). I used the men's room instead - equally disgusting, just minus the crap) !!! If I saw this prior , I may have passed. They seemed to be doing a decent take-out business, so I guess their other menu items are good too but ... I wouldn't return. read more

I tried a veggie pizza this evening. The veggies were fair but the pizza was very dry and seriously skimping on the cheese. Would never consider ordering again. read more

Stopped in on 10/18 before taking the Cape May whale watching tour for a quick bit. My wife and I both enjoyed the pizza and because it was earlier the place wasn't crowded but the phone orders were coming in left and right. The one waitress was attentive and busted her butt! Would highly recommend for a good slice! read more

Dang. The Works pizza was beautiful and delish and I ordered the Seafood Combo. Shrimp, Scallops, Flounder and mussels in white sauce. The pasta was cooked nicely. The scallops were missing! So, one of Shrimps still had legs without a tail and as I removed the legs I found a very long blonde hair wrapped...... I repeat...WRAPPED around my shrimp. The flounder (If that's what it was) was crumpled little pieces of rubber tasting something in the pasta. There was no "white Sauce". The sauce was more of a broth. Dang it! I was sooo disappointed because I was really hungry and it looked so good! My husband did say the pizza was good. Two stars for the pizza. We will be traveling by boat again Through this town at least 3 more times this year..... and this establishment will only be on the list for pizza. C'mon y'all! Gettit together! read more

Place is awesome!!! in the area working on the Dredge project and it's nice to have a good pizza place close by, I've had it here several times and I've never been disappointed read more

Ordered a mushroom and pepperoni pizza. The center of the pie was raw. The first slice I picked up sagged and dropped all the toppings. Cheese wasn't cooked or browned. Huge disappointment. I would not recommend this place. read more

Excellent meat lovers pizza.. it's just a simple review, where I have to tell a story of how good this pizza is when all you have to say is "excellent pizza" but yelp wants 85 characters + in order to write a review read more

my family stopped in on our way out of cape may headed back to our campground. We placed an order for meat lovers pie chicken parm hero and garlic knots order to go. We sit down to eat to find we didn't receive the correct orderwe got 2 chicken parm dinners and a personal pie. We called and they said we are sorry your order is here. we are 15 minutes away weren't driving back!! read more

We wanted to grab a slice of pizza before heading back home from cape may area. We saw this place on our way to beach, the place looked pretty nice and had outside seating which is what you need on sunny day. Unfortunately, this place only gets 3 star since the staff was very nice and the prices were reasonable. They can definitely improve on pizza sauce and taste of cheese. The pizza was fresh but kind of tasted bitter. I would only come back again if they improve their taste of pizza quality. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

We first had the stromboli (family-sized calzone with pepperoni, sauce and lots of cheese) to take on a the Cape May Whale Watcher boat tour. Tony's was nearby and we liked that it was freshly made. So when we were in the area again, we went back again for the stromboli plus chicken wings and calamari. Everything was good. Good prices. Place is clean and very nice customer service on both times. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Stromboli, calamari, wings after we already started on them - Pizza Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Tonys is definitely the go-to for my family. Incredibly fresh food every time. We've been going to Tonys for decades. Never disappointed! Thank you for you're dedication. Its much appreciated. read more

Came for a visit from Orlando, FL and was directed here from the visitor center. Considering I was traveling with my family from south Jersey, we were looking for a good cheesesteak. Great recommendation! Great service and cheesesteak was respectable. Pizza was delicious, especially considering that was a kids meal! My cousin ordered chicken franscese and it was pretty good. Could have been a little more flavorful and sauce was a little watery but the chicken was delicious. Lunch special prices were good too. I would probably come back during season to see if the food gets even better. Restaurant was empty so they may not have their best cooks here. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

We shouldn't have pulled in the lot ‍ There was one car there at 7pm on a busy holiday week, while there was an hour wait next door. But, we were already beyond hungry and couldn't wait an hour, so we pushed through the dirty glass doors & took a seat in a dated booth. Pizza seemed to not be too risky, so we ordered that along with mozzarella sticks, stuffed shells and a salad. My kid asked to use the bathroom, which was HORRID, and probably ruined my appetite (although I tried to keep a straight face when I returned so as not to alarm my hangry husband). But I guess we're spoiled because a salad arrived & he didn't like the looks of it for whatever reason. The kids liked the mozzarella sticks and the pizza was okay, but the rest really didn't get touched. Somehow, all 5 of us lost our appetite. I recommend not going in there. And if you must, don't go down the scary hallway past the flickering ceiling lights. read more

Tasty pizza, good service, & prices. The pineapple pizza is delicious. The mozzarella sticks were good & the calamari was fresh & not frozen. read more

We ordered the 16" Sicilian thick crust, and the 16" meat lovers with cheese fries and fried mozzarella sticks. The mozzarella sticks, cheese fries, and meat lovers pizza were all excellent. However the thick Sicilian was not a Sicilian pie. It was incredibly doughy not enough sauce or cheese. If you get pizza I'd strongly recommend skipping the square Sicilian and just getting the round pie. The app didn't register the unit number so I ended up calling Grub Hub. However they never addressed the issue so the driver still had to call me. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

The pizza itself was pretty tasty, but the service wasn't the best. I think because it was extremely busy - because it was raining, and since you can't sit inside anywhere in New Jersey to eat - it was one of the only places people were going because they could order a pizza for take out. It had stopped raining when we arrived, so we thought we would sit on the porch. When we arrived we were told it would be about 45 minutes to get a pizza. Then another person told us 1 hour and 40 minutes. We asked another person who said that it would take about an hour because of all the call in orders. We decided we would wait because there was no place else to go. We asked the young man if he would dry off the table and chairs at one of the tables on the porch. He said he would. We waited on the porch...and waited, and waited....he just stood inside. We finally practically emptied one of the napkin dispensers and dried everything off ourselves. The pizza only took about 20 minutes after all, but the two people working could have been a bit more helpful. read more

I was traveling up the coast moving a boat up north during a time when many places were closing due to covid 19. We ordered Tony's pizza from the dock for delivery. They were very nice when I called, and the food came quickly. We ordered half "the works" and half pepperoni pizza. It was very nice of them to do that for us as most places won't "half" their specialties. We also got a Greek salad and chicken wings. The wings were the perfect mixture of meat and breading, not all breading like wings usually come! The salad was great too! Order from here!! read more

Tony's is a no-frills, basic joint that does one thing very well: they serve great tasting food. Don't come here expecting a fancy interior or spectacular service; this place is all about the food. The pizzas, cheesesteaks, and hoagies are some of the best around, hands down. If you're hungry and want some great food, check out Tony's. read more

I've driven by this place hundreds of times, and never stopped. Stopped this weekend, and I've made hundreds of mistakes by not stopping here. Good "old fashioned" pizza. Not greasy, and perfectly crisp. Being from NNJ I take my pizza quite seriously - and I don't like most places here. Tony's wins hands down. It's amazing, they still put just a dash of oregano on the pizza, like the old days. And you're not tasting it all night either. Which means, the sauce isn't old. Friendly service, take out. I'll be back here more often. It's a winner. Update: 7-17-17 We stopped in here for dinner, always had takeout pizza in the past. I was pleasantly surprised how really good it was. Cheesesteaks sandwiches people next to us had looked tremendous, but we opted for the steamers (fantastic choice) chicken marsala, and chicken parm dinners. Portions on both were very good, and extremely tasty. Pleasantly surprised by the server bringing really good garlic bread while we were waiting. If you're looking for "that" place to try, give it a shot. I'm happy we did. Our server was a very nice young lady and was very attentive. We'll definitely be going back here. read more

We ordered four pizzas and spent a fortune. They forgot the topping on one them. Expensive for basic uninspiring pizza. The BBQ chicken pizza had nothing except BBQ sauce, chicken and cheese all congregated in the middle of the pie. But delivery was on time and pizza was hot. read more

3 words: Worst Pizza EVER! We ordered a SICILIAN 16" SQUARE THICK CRUST and a CALZONE. The calzone was greasy with too much chunky garlic, but it was slightly edible. The pizza, however, was the worst pizza we've ever had in our 30-something years on this planet. I can only describe it as frozen cardboard with tasteless Italian sausage and cheese toppings. This is the first time that I have ever had to throw away an entire pizza. I took two bites and knew there was no way I could stomach the rest. I would have been better off going down to the local grocery store and picking up a frozen pizza - at least they have taste. Before you decide to order the pizza, decide first if you would be willing to take $15 out of your wallet and put it right in the trash can. If so, go for it. If not, you are wise. read more

They guys at this shop are a pleasure to do business with. This pizza place is down the street from my parent's boat and whenever we need pies they drive them over, no matter how many. They are responsive and kind and their pizzas are consistently good. A nice balance of cheese to sauce ratio. They also make a respectable cheesesteak (and I've lived in Philadelphia for 8 years since growing up in CM and I still think theirs are pretty great). Their eggplant parm and other italian meals options are all of good quality at low prices. It might not be a fancy place to eat, but it is a great place for families or for carry out. The guys who work here are honest, nice guys, just trying to provide good pizza. read more

Great, inexpensive and fresh! Family friendly as well. Serves Breyers ice cream for dessert which is hard to find! They use the old Italian trick and put sugar in their sauce! We will be back! read more

Best Greek salad still and good pizza. They are struggling with staffing issues so best to go in, Order and take home. You will be rewarded with a great meal. read more

I can only speak for the quality of the pizza here, seeing as I have yet to try anything else, but it is definitely worth reviewing. It is a thin pie. Average, but not great, consistent, but not leave an impression good. My family and I order a Tony's cheese pizza at least once while we are vacationing in Cape May, and we have truly never been let down. It is your typical greasy Jersey pizza, but not necessarily your run-of-the-mill vaca slice. It fits better in a central- north Jersey setting. It is surely worth giving a shot if you're trying to get away from the fluff of Cape May for a night. read more

Sorry to see a place we have frequented so many times fall so far. Delivery prior to this evening was phenomenal. However, after tonight we will never order from there again. After the driver did not deliver to my location , i saw my phone had a call from Tonys. I called them, they did not answer, then they called me.back, i asked about my food to be told the delivery man had tried to deliver, but when i told her that i had been outside waiting and saw noone. the delivery man got on the phone and was ruder to me than anyone i have ever encountered. He blamed me for the non delivery and told me he did not have the time for me...the young lady tried to apologize for him and said our food was on the way. Upon delivery it was expectantly cold and my husband found a large piece of plastic in his cheese steak stromboli. Never again. read more

Great pizzas. Sounds crazy but I love ordering a big pie for a boat trip. Unconventional but always a big hit! This is always a great place to pick up from if you have a ton of guests over. They are fast and the pizza is to die for! read more

My mom and I split the margarita pizza and it was amazing!! We stumbled upon this place and it's safe to say if we ever are back in the area, we would stop again! The staff was prompt and friendly as well! read more

After driving all day the pizza was great! Good service too! We got sausage and pineapple. Good salad too for you buck. read more

Very friendly people and really good pizza. The crust is too thin, so I docked 'em one star for that, but the topping is tasty. A little expensive--we're not used to paying $17 for a pizza. I would order from them again. read more

Good pizza - we have had pizza places in the area and we were not impressed. Tony's was good and great for the family take out night. Easy to get to and nice staff. read more

I was craving pizza all day and this place came highly recommended. I can see why! We ordered a garden salad and it was HUGE. The wings were crispy and delicious, and the pizza was exactly what I was craving.. a thin pizza, triangle slice (not a square piece like some places cut it) and it was so good! Super cheesy but not too saucy.. i thought it was perfect. All that food for only $27.. delicious and a great deal! Our waitress was also very friendly and attentive, we got there at 8:15pm and they close at 9 but she welcomed us in regardless of their soon impending closing time. I am very picky when it comes to pizza but this place definitely did not disappoint! read more