Fantastic food, service and unique atmosphere ! I will go back. If you're in the area of Dunnellon, this must go to spot.

Great flounder stuffed with crabmeat. Staff is friendly and atmosphere is nice. Lots of choices on menu.

Food and service excellent. Lobster reuben is unique. Can't saw much for the ambience. Clean rest rooms.

An amazing underground pub. Intimate setting with great food and drink. Ask for Michelle at the bar. She's the best.

Always great food and good service. The crowd is a mix of everyone in the area who knows how good the burgers are in particular.

Pub food, popcorn in the bar. Always a good meal and fun staff. Downstairs is a bar feel with food, upstairs is quieter dining room, also great for groups & parties! read more

food,service. Rathskeller atmosphere is so cool. Never had a negative experience here. Friendly atmosphere ,nice crowd

Most recently thoroughly enjoyed the bacon wrapped kielbasa widow makers as well as the Kobe burger. Although this place never disappoints and the lobster Reuben is a must try for first timers, the deviation from the norm was rewarded! read more

Dunellen Hotel Restaurant & Rathskeller - Bacon wrapped kielbasa widow makers - New American Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

See all

I met a group of my girlfriend's for dinner at the Rathskeller which is in the lower level of the Dunellen Hotel. It was just how I remembered it.. Upstairs, they have a fancier dining room. I was seated immediately by a friendly waitress name Vicky. She was very attentive and helpful when ordering. Vicky gave my group wonderful service and suggestions for dinner and drinks. The Dunellen hotel has a special on Monday's, Buy One Burger, and get One Free. ( In House Special Only.) The Rathskeller is very casual, that's what appeals to all their patrons. The food is nothing fancy, more like American Comfort Food. It's consistently delicious and there are many choices to choose from including specials for the day. For appetizers they have wings, nacho platter, , blackened filet bites, ahi tuna, mozzarella sticks,potato skins, chicken tenders, steamers, and fried calamari. They have delicious burgers which are big and look juicy.For sandwiches they offer the prime rib sandwich with a horseradish sabi sauce. Flat iron steak sandwich, grilled vegetable sandwich, grilled chicken sandwich , hot pastrami sandwich , cuban sandwich, lobster ruben sandwich, Canuck sandwich, chicken balsamic focaccia, chicken Caesar wrap, and cheeseburger BLT wrap.and more. You get the picture. For entrees they have meatloaf platter, hotel pot roast dinner, herb crusted Salmon, NY Strip Steak, Chicken Parm., penne vodka, blackened chicken alfredo pasta. If your more in the mood for salads they have a nice assortment to choose from. They serve several soups along with triple onion soup, and some fish and seafood, five personal styles of pizza. There really is something for everyone. The Rathskeller is kid friendly, their Half Pints- Mac n cheese, chicken fingers, grilled cheese, hamburger, or cheeseburger are perfect for kids. I chose to have their Prime Rib Sabi Sandwich. It came with a choice of fries or vegetable. I subbed sweet potato fries for regular fries for an extra charge. The sandwich was grilled sliced Prime Rib topped with sautéed onions and swiss cheese on a toasted garlic Italian roll with a side of Horseradish Sabi Sauce. My sandwich was tender and delicious, the horseradish sauce made it. The birthday girl chose the Lobster Ruben. She enjoyed it. Me personally, I thought the sandwich was a little small. It should've been served on larger sliced rye bread or even a brioche roll,and it could've been a little thicker. Another friend chose the Grilled Chicken Sandwich -Grilled Chicken breast served on a kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato and onion. Also available lemon peppered, barbecued or blackened. You can ask your server about additional toppings. Another friend chose a special for the day. Grilled chicken taco salad bowl. She too enjoyed her meal. Last but not least my other friend ordered their wedge salad and she added grilled chicken for an extra charge. She really liked her salad. The rathskeller was kind enough to let us bring in a small little birthday cake so we could surprise our friend. We all had a wonderful evening and I will definitely be back to try their burger which looked so good. read more

See all

Ordered calamari appetizer. Smallest serving that I have ever seen. For the price it should be at least 50% more food. The spicy marinara sauce is good though read more

Dunellen Hotel Restaurant & Rathskeller - Calamari appetizer - New American Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

Was in the mood for a burger, and was not Satisfied. The Good: Got a seat at the bar right away on a Friday night. Good atmosphere, lots of people having fun, Ranger game was on the TV, friendly service. The Bad: The spinach salad we always get was less than half the normal size. We were both surprised when it came out. I thought maybe we order the wrong thing, but no. My burger was very disappointing. It was way over cooked, the cheese wasn't even melted on it, and the bread was stale. The bartender asked how it was, and I told him it was over cooked. He said, "well you ate it." Which was kind of a snide remark. Like, why ask me, if you don't want to know? So, finally he pours me another beer, which I didn't ask for nor want, because I was driving and had only planned to have one. I assumed it was complimentary, due to my criticism,... But no,... he charged me. read more

Consistent, quality, elevated bar food. Solid drink selection. Incredible service. Lots of value for your dollar. I grew up in Dunellen and this is the best eats in town. This will be my first stop every time I return. A truly local spot. They really give back to the community. Get the open-faced pastrami Reuben, the Canuck sandwich, the three-onion soup or the chicken caesar wrap. read more

We've committed to supporting local businesses during this time, so we've frequented Dunellen Hotel a few times and will definitely be back! The rib eye sandwich is incredible. Soft garlic bread, tender steak, creamy melted cheese... what else could you ask for? The grilled vegetable sandwich is on foccia bread and has an outstanding balsamic glaze that holds everything together. We've also tried the lobster reuben, but compared to the other two sandwiches mentioned this one doesn't hold up. Don't get me wrong, it's okay, but man... the rib eye and the grill sandwiches are outstanding! We will be back to try something off the dinner menu very soon! read more

See all

This is a hole in the wall American bar with the best French onion soup I've had. The decor is not the greatest but service is very friendly with the same couple of waitresses always serving us every time we go. Even the other patrons are often pretty friendly, which isn't always the case in a bar-restaurant setting (I'm from Staten Island). My wife and I are often struggling to bring the baby's stroller down the staircase into the basement bar and a couple of times now, someone has asked us if we need help. Very down to earth atmosphere eating here surrounded by salt of the earth type folks. Mondays they have burger night where you buy one and get one free (just the bun and burger are free on the 2nd - you still have to pay for toppings). It is one of the best deals around. The burgers are top notch too - big and tasty, though the chips they come with are a bit stale. Sweet potato fries are good though. They have a pretty good selection of beers including domestic, microbrews and imports - just off the top of my head - Stella and Guiness on tap, bottles include Blue moon, Victory Hop Devil, Molson. A margarita we ordered once was pretty weak. I have yet to try the rib eye steak but it seems like a good deal. 20 bucks for a huge steak of a good cut. My wife and I went for taco night once before. That was just ok. Mis Amigos down the street definitely has better Mexican. Overall, its a great place to eat with great value and friendly service. read more

The go-to gem. The food is always good. If you are into beer, plenty of selections. Recommend the lobster ruben.

We've ordered delivery from here using DoorDash and its been pretty decent. Things they do well: buffalo chicken wings, nachos and crab dip! Yum! Last nights delivery was beyond TRASH! The packaging was horrible and the portions were very small. The caesar salad had like 4 leaves lettuce, calamari portion was small. They were both $10 and we received $5 portions. read more

Dunellen Hotel Restaurant & Rathskeller - Chicken caesar salad with blacked chicken - New American Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

See all

I always enjoy the food at Dunellen Hotel . I really enjoy the triple onion soup the lobster Ruben and the pastrami sandwich just a few of my favorites. I also had the meatloaf and many other things off the menu that was great. read more

Excellent waitresses, solid value on quality food, unpretentious, friendly atmosphere...a hidden gem for those in the know. I only give three stars because the crab appetizer was purely imitation crab meat. Not even one ounce of real crab...for the price of genuine crab. Yuck! I should have sent it back but I didn't want to bother our waitress. read more

Ordered the pretzel crab meltaway. FAKE Crab meat on old pretzel. Entrees: meatloaf. (Reg menu item) and swordfish (special menu item). Food wayyy too hot. Seems microwaved. No real flavor. Ambience was very casual. Rating is really based on food Not planning on coming back. read more

Dive-y local spot but the food is pretty decent, albeit slightly above a more appropriate price point.

Nothing special. I had the lobster roll. I am surprised everything is a little too expensive for what you get. Sure, the people are nice but there are better restaurants around and in Dunellen read more

Great atmosphere and service. Staff is friendly. Food is great. I did not know this gem existed right in our neighborhood. Been here 3 times, each time ordered a different dish. Taco salad and pot roast is great. read more

See all

My husband and I have been going here for years and it's one of the best places to eat around central jersey. Everyone is so friendly and the food is amazing. Always have great service! read more

A phenomenal, classy, traditional establishment. Two visits and both were spot on. FRESH food that's prepared with care. So far I've had the 1) salad wedge (smoky bacon, tasty blue cheese) 2) chicken balsamic focaccia, w/ fresh mozz, melted and a full delicious red pepper, 3) the flawless house salad with grilled chicken, and 4) grilled chicken Cesar wrap, generous portion and constructed professionally. Guinness is the perfect pour (proper rest). Kevin & Tom were on the stick and were total gentlemen and can hold a conversation. A very comfortable place to drink, dine, and relax. read more

Dunellen Hotel Restaurant & Rathskeller - Flawless House Salad w/ Grilled Chicken - New American Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

picked up dinner tonight from Dunellen Hotel & Rathskeller and it was amazing! They are doing curbside pickup, just call ahead to order, you won't be disappointed! (pictured shrimp cocktail, pretzel crab meltaway, port wine cheddar burger, chicken bacon rancher) read more

Dunellen Hotel Restaurant & Rathskeller - a variety of take out containers on a kitchen counter - New American Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

The staff are rude. They don't have manners. there is one cranky old man that is stuck in the 1700s get a grip and grow up. Never would recommend and will never go again read more

This was a random place that my wife suggested. The menu looked interesting, so we figured we would give it a shot. Upon arrival (according to Google) we took a few seconds to actually locate the place (Looks like a regular house) but parking wasn't an issue. When we entered the restaurant, it was like I imagined it had looked for the past 30 years (not a bad thing, great atmosphere). It was a busy night so we took a spot at the bar, ordered a round of drinks and the Crab Pretzel appetizer. I would have to recommend this as it was soo good, but I would suggest to the chef to add a sauce on the side, maybe an aioli of some sort (its a pretzel, they can be dry sometimes). Dinner for the family were burgers, and they certainly had no complaints. For me, I tried the Lobster Reuben... To say that I am a foodie is an understatement, but I have to say the Lobster Reuben was probably one of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten. Pricing was fair, the bartender was an absolute joy to "sit with". Cant wait for our return trip. read more

Good place for drinks and a burger a historic building. The food and service was really good great place to meet up with family and friends

This is a great local eatery. The drinks are fantastic, the food is great and the staff is friendly and helpful!! I have been there three times and have had great experiences each time. read more

Dunellen Hotel Restaurant & Rathskeller - Vegetable Sui Mei. Delicious!!! - New American Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

The Aji are he tuna sushi might be the best item on their appetizer list bartenders a very friendly may be the best dirty martini made in New Jersey.the rathskeller, The bar below the hotel is a pretty cool place kind of quiet cozy great atmosphere and the fruit fly or two read more

Saw the reviews. Was in the area - over the top meatloaf ! Bar very friendly and amazing dishes coming out of the kitchen. read more

Dunellen Hotel Restaurant & Rathskeller - New American Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

Unfortunately, my last meal picked up from there was not good. The chicken was very thin and dry and the sauce was much too salty. Also, this was the 4th time I also ordered the Chicken Caesar Salad The 1st time there was very little romaine, so when ordering the 2nd and 3rd times I mentioned the lack of salad in the previous one so that one was good. This time when ordering I did not mention the amount of salad it should have and it was very light again. It seems like thinner, saltier meat and less salad is the norm for their chicken parm and Caeser. read more

This place is hidden gem , not many people know about this place probably because it's in a basement. That said the food it pretty, and you get free popcorn which is sometime not stale , depending on the you go, so good luck read more

We come here a lot. Food is always fantastic and great service. Thanks to Vicky for making today's Friendsgiving extra special!!!

We have been coming here for a number of years and tonight was exceptional. Stuffed portabella mushrooms were delicious. Hats off to the chef for the Oktoberfest menu. Chicken Schnitzel...thin not dry at all. Great flavor. Excellent job on the Spaetzle. Just the way they should be. The bar is always good but tonight the Southern Comfort Manhattans were perfect. Great job Dunellen Hotel! read more

I have lived less than two miles from this building for all 25 years of my life and always disregarded it. I never even knew it was a restaurant. I was never curious to know what it was. It took a particularly long, boring trip to Medemerge down the street to discover it. If you've been to Medemerge, you are familiar with the eternal wait in the examination room before you even see a nurse. While perusing Foursquare in my boredom, I came across Dunellen Hotel with gleaming reviews. I took my search to Yelp - more gleaming reviews. And not only gleaming reviews - but a universal decree to try the French onion soup! I cannot resist that! So my mom and I came here for dinner one rainy night, and my goodness, my fellow Foursquarers and Yelpers did not lead me astray. It wasn't the best French onion soup I had ever had, but it was definitely a serious contender. A deep, rich broth was molten beneath the perfectly brown, bubbly mixture of cheeses. It was a teeny bit under-seasoned for my palate, but not so much to even make note of it. Definitely a must-try! The French dip sandwich (apparently, I was feeling French) was great, too. The meat was on the dry side, but the bread was extremely fresh and crusty and the jus was just as rich as the French onion soup. I had it with swiss cheese instead of provolone. The portion was enormous and the sandwich was nice and meaty - great ratio with the bread. My mom had the lobster reuben, which many people have raved about. The hype was definitely warranted...great, unique flavor profile and great textures between the super-crisp bread and the creamy lobster. Great textures, perfect balance. Wonderful suggestion. As mentioned, the portions were huge, so we didn't have room for dessert. But every item on the dessert menu had me salivating! I am now plagued with guilt that I have neglected this place for so many years. Now that I know how great it is, I have a lot of lost time to make up for! read more

I can't believe I just found out about this little gem after living in Central NJ my whole life. First of all the atmosphere is awesome, the building was built in the 1800's and the bar and downstairs restaurant are situated in the basement. Very cozy and homey without having that "tried too hard" feel. The food was excellent, and I was surprised by some of the interesting things on the menu like Port Wine burgers and an entire Oktoberfest menu, complete with seasonal brew. My husband and I brought both of our kids here, and the atmosphere (at lunch time on a Saturday) was very family friendly. We were the first customers, but eventually the place was relatively crowded. Even though our server was tending the crowded bar and serving the restaurant goers solo, he was still friendly and attentive. The food was much better than I had anticipated. The french onion soup was probably one of the best I've had, and I loved the different cheeses and the addition of shallots. The Port Wine burger was large, cooked perfectly to my specifications and delicious. I could have done without the very hard chips that were served along with it though, I would have preferred fries. My kids and husband equally enjoyed their meals. The prices were reasonable, we will definitely be frequent visitors of the Dunellen Hotel in the future. I'd like to get back there before the end of the month to try some of their Oktoberfest offerings. read more

Quaint and cozy, American food. The menu offers a little bit of everything from burgers to salads to pasta and chicken entrees. I had a spinach salad with balsamic reduction and then chicken Marsala with a side of fresh vegetables for my main course that did not disappoint. There's an upstairs and a downstairs. We sat downstairs, at a table near the bar. It had a Cheers-y type of atmosphere and the football game on in the background. On a previous visit, I had the port wine cheeseburger. . . excellent!! For the type of establishment this is, I give it 5 stars for a comfortable and casual dining experience with above average food. read more

Great food, good prices, service excellent. This is not a sports bar, there are many of those around. You can have a conversation and enjoy a great meal. read more

This place was pretty good. We didn't get to eat downstairs as some other reviewers suggested. This was because the wait was 20 minutes and we were HONGRAY ;). So word to the wise, make reservations for the pub downstairs. Anyway, our waitress was serious but efficient and the food was well priced. We both ordered the triple onion soup and it was very tasty actually, heavy. I had a Guinness which was nice and my husband had a glass of red wine. For my entree (couldn't finish it because the soup was so filling) I had the lobster Reuben which was good. My husband had the meatloaf and he didn't really enjoy it very much. Too heavy and a pate like consistency. read more