Portions are humongous! My party of three got breakfast here and we ate leftovers for breakfast the next day and couldn't even finish that! Eggs and buckwheat pancakes are great, hash browns are on the spicy side. I got the Olaf, which was a bit too much, good but too rich for me. I think my mom's buckwheat pancakes were the tastiest item ordered. read more

Great food and great service. Buckwheat pancakes were excellent! Also loved the atmosphere. The rooster painting was super fun!

The atomoshere was Welcoming, the food was well portioned and very good! Very nice place to go for a delicious breakfast, lunch or dessert for sure. read more

Everything was delicious! We had excellent service. The place was very clean and the decor was cheerful and bright. Highly recommend!!

You will struggle to find a better breakfast spot on the planet. I was here yesterday with my best friend Justin. I have been to Diana's before but I haven't been since a little before Covid as I live in NJ...This establishment makes you feel like home. When you get a coffee it comes In a mug that you would have in your house. In NJ you go to a diner and you get a small branded mug etc here it's more like a mug from there personal collection of random mugs. The owners/staff are SUPER friendly and welcoming. Before I even got to PA I told my buddy Justin that I have to go to Diana's. They are master of the griddle here! Food is fresh and delicious. I got the 2 egg plate with home fries (ask for the onions and peppers added in) and over medium eggs and sausage. The sausage is so so good. Hand formed patty crisp on the outside and juicy inside. I also got a homemade cinnamon bun and ordered a bunch to go. As the menu suggest ask them to butter and griddle the buns. This will change your life. Hospitality at its finest and country breakfast at its finest. This is a gem of the Honesdale/Tyler Hill area. I have a special place in my heart for this place! read more

See all

Fantastic find!! Super friendly host/server. Food was delicious. Especially liked the sausage and pancakes. Quiet and cozy. Very reasonably priced. Cash only. Gorgeous fresh flower arrangements throughout - on the tables and the counters. Our server was so sweet and nice enough to come outside and offer to take our picture. Great for brunch! read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - a vase of flowers - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

See all

Back again! Just to say it's as delicious as ever, and the perfect remedy for a late night on Memorial Day weekend. read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - Two Eggs, Sausage, white toast, home fries, sautéed onions - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

Note that they take CASH only. But not a lot of it... An unexpected find in a pretty remote portion of the Catskills, in Tyler Hill, PA, near the New York border. Almost all locals. The placemat is mostly local construction companies. And the food is: fabulous. Smallish place in a building shared with a real estate office and a massage place. A row of tables (all of which seat six) adjacent to the windows, a long counter on the other side, in a typical diner layout but with tables rather than booths. Comfortable and attractive with lots of homey and amusing signs. The buckwheat pancakes are the must-have (and I am not really a pancake kind of person). Thick, fluffy, and light yet hearty, with the full-on grain flavor of buckwheat. Most pancakes are served on a plate. This is one pancake and it is served on a plate but nard to know, since it is as big as the plate. Tender and brown, with terrific crispy edges, served with rapidly melting butter. Order the real maple syrup ($3). Essential, in my book. The McDutton sandwich is fun. An egg, fried hard, on a muffin (yes, a riff on the Egg McMuffin), served as a sandwich with the meat of your choice. I chose the Taylor ham and it was perfect. Very salty on its own, but works in the muffin, the ham was smoky and athletically porky. Next time, I would ask for this with the egg over easy, as the muffin wants to be soaked in yolk. But the Taylor ham -- did I say it was perfect? It was perfect. The home fries are perfectly cooked with crispy bits (which can be overly salty), big cubes of potato. They pepper them with a heavy hand (in a good way) and the portion is generous. The corn muffin is OMG. Sweet, northern style cornbread in a giant muffin. They cut it in half and crisp it on the griddle. They are not shy with this: it's like a fried corn cake. You want this. Last, but not least, is a favorite, the Olaf. Two eggs over peppers, onions, and a comically huge pile of home fries with a side of breakfast meat. This is big food. We're 20 minutes away and used to go into Monticello or Liberty to find a decent diner but now we know we can go deeper into the remote Catskill jungle and find a great value and a belly-filling masterpiece. read more

See all

Best breakfast in town, in many towns, actually. Come hungry! Famous for the pancakes and cinnamon buns, which are incredible, as are the pies. Tracy and her staff will set you up, but come early, this place can fill up deep! My fav is the epic breakfast sandwich. read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - The epic breakfast sandwich - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

I have been coming here since I was a kid. A very friendly, home like feel with great food! I highly recommend the buckwheat pancake. read more

See all

My boyfriend's family has a cabin nearby so we decided to stop here for brunch on a Sunday. The food was hearty and delicious. I ordered a cowboy omelette with taylor ham and the portions were HUGE. I managed to only eat half of my plate and saved the other half for breakfast the next day. Tasted just as amazing when reheated. Also HIGHLY recommend their blueberry pies. Cash only! read more

This is an amazing place for breakfast!!!Food is delicious! Prepared by one person who multi tasks extremely well!! Service is outstanding, and the entire experience is just so great!! HOMEMADE !!! read more

The food here is the best I've ever had, large portions and great taste. Tracy the owner is a sweet heart and will customize your meal to satisfy your needs. Go early on weekends due to the big crowds on Sundays in picticular read more

Stopped in for breakfast, waitress was great! Best pancakes I've had, good coffee too! Chef "maybe owner" checked in to see if everything was ok. It was awesome! Thanks chef! read more

CASH ONLY. Delicious breakfast with huge portions, homefries have crispy bits, plenty of seasoning. Toast was generously buttered. Pancakes are large enough to feed 4. We will be back! read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - $8- two eggs any style with toast, + 1meat +homefries. Everything was great and they did not skimp on the bacon or fries. A+ - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

See all

Wow, bring your appetite! I had the Cowboy omelette which was off the hook good. I did think I was on an episode of Man vs. Food , the portion was enormous. My girlfriend had the Oloff which was 2 eggs any style over peppers, onions and roasted has browns with a side of bacon and she too could not finish and said it was delicious. My friend had 1 pancake, it looked like a pizza it was so big, you only need 1. read more

See all

I cannot comment on the food because we left before being seated. We walked in to a "please wait to be seated sign" which was no problem at all until we sat there for 10 min and not one staff member even came over to greet us after I made eye contact multiple times with more than one employee. There were plenty of seats available at the high counter which was where we wanted to sit but we respected the sign and waited patiently. Two customers came in and walked right past us, sat at the bar area and received a coffee within seconds. The food is only as good as the service imo and to not even greet customers shortly after they walk in, even if it's just to say "I'll be right with you," is plain rude. read more

Excellent country style breakfasts! We came up to Cochecton for a wedding weekend and discovered this amazing diner less than 8 minutes away from our Airbnb. Portions were generous and everything including the coffee tasted amazing! Wait staff were friendly, and food came out quickly from the open-concept kitchen. Keep in mind that they're cash only! read more

See all

Very homey atmosphere, pleasant servers and delicious breakfast First recommended by VR Doc Holiday. Been here several times Never disappointed read more

Finally was in the area and decided to have breakfast here. I was not disappointed! The portions are large but more importantly everything was fresh and delicious. Highly recommend them and I will be back. read more

Heaven in the middle of nowhere! After a 4 day camping trip we were ready for some homeade grub. This place was perfect- fresh baked pies, pancakes of all sorts and breakfast dishes of eggs, meat and veggies that were original, huge, and yummy! The coffee was great, and the service was on point. We ordered one slice of every pie: blueberry won it! Wish we had one close to home read more

This diner serves the best breakfast I've ever had. Their Olaf is incredible, pancakes are HUGE, but honestly the star of the show is their cornbread muffin. I don't know how or why it's so good, but try it. read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

See all

Homemade with love! We visit Damascus regularly and this is the BEST spot in the area. We never miss a good breakfast when we're visiting!

Great place to get breakfast! Visit with the local folks, and solve the world's problems.

Cute diner serving awesome food! Parking is tight when they're busy, be prepared to park creatively. The staff was really friendly. If I'm going to catch COVID, however, this is the place I'll get it from. It was like pre-pandemic times, everyone was in close quarters and maskless. I still ate there, so my hunger trumped caution. Hopefully I won't regret that later. read more

This place was an amazing stop for my family and I. The hospitality and the food we're out of this world. I would highly recommend it to anyone and everyone for a great home-cooked meal with the hospitality of being at a relatives house. We will be back. read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

Absolutely fantastic breakfast! Very generous serving of delicious breakfast by friendly and welcoming staff! If you're in the area stop by, you won't regret it! read more

My favorite place to get breakfast with my stepson and fiancé in the Tyler Hill/Honesdale area. The food is fantastic and the portions are huge. Many of the breads and meats used are locally made as well. One of my favorite guilty pleasures there are the cinnamon buns, ask to have it grilled, it's amazing It is definitely a local favorite and is always busy, especially on Sunday mornings. read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - One blueberry pancake (larger than the plate), an order of bacon, and one egg. - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

Best diner breakfast I've ever had!!! Such nice atmosphere and lovely owner. Super friendly and clean, accommodating for gluten free dietary restrictions read more

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner - The Olaf - eggs over a mound of home fries + onion + bacon - New American Near Me - Tyler Hill, Pennsylvania

If you are anywhere near Duttons and want an outstanding breakfast in a quaint and friendly atmosphere, get yourself to Duttons Tyler Hill Diner. Pancakes bigger than your head cooked properly. Chocolate chip, banana, blueberry, peach or just plain buckwheat served with a big ole hunk of butter and pure maple syrup for an upcharge, go for it! Eggs made to order light and fluffy, sausage patties as big as a 1/3 pound burger, and corned beef or home fries make this the place to be for breakfast. French toast was made to perfection. Tracy on the grill was a master at slab top technique and Kelsey was a pleasant service professional with quickness of mercury. You could transfer this place to Williamsburg and charge 3 times as much and make a killing. Get there early on a weekend it fills up fast and they are only open until noon. Oh if you want one of their amazing gigantic pies call a few days in advance. read more

See all

Great breakfasts & food. All homemade. Delicious! Cheese & spinach omelet highly recommend . If you have a sweet tooth - great homemade pies & cakes. Also, great cinnamon buns. All made by hand with the best dough, crusts ( pies) & fruits. Cakes are great, chocolate to die for. A great lunch piriogi lasagna, or any specials made fresh for that day! Coffee, iced tea ( sweet or sun) also available for the kids milk, chocolate milk, juices... I have always enjoyed my meals & snacks at the Duttons! And oil paintings as well as other interesting things to view & buy! read more

See all

Wonderful little local spot. Homemade pies and delicious fried cinnamon rolls and muffins etc. cheap...scrumptious...worth the drive... Put your phone down and go eat! read more

THE BEST breakfast place ever! I am ashamed to say that it took me this long to find this place. It is a hidden gem! The place is lovely, staff warm and friendly, the food heavenly! read more

This is now Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner. Same great food, same family (my understanding) just a different name. Mom retired. This is my go to spot. A bit of a drive but well worth it .. great smiles, great food, always sunny in Tyler Hill. Wish i had hours and menu, i would post. FYI prices are very reasonable and portions generous. read more

Small charming place with the best pancakes on earth! One pancake is practically the size of a manhole cover with crispy edges and a fist sized knob of melted butter on top. Everything was delicious-- a fantastic spot for breakfast, highly recommend! read more

What a great place for breakfast . The cinnamon roll grilled and buttered was fantastic.

Amazing spot. Olaf, veggie omelette, and banana pancakes were out of this world. The owner whipped our order up in no time and you can tell it was done with love. Highly recommend! read more

Go here!!! Amazing huge breakfast cooked right in front of you. We met the owns and her best friend. Sit up at the far left end of the counter and you can watch wild turkey, deer, and other wildlife out the big window while you eat. Can't say enuf good things about this place. I just wish it wasn't so far from where we live read more

This is defiantly one of our favorite places to have breakfast ( the pancake is my favorite ) , we always go home with a doggie bag! The service is great ! read more

This was a once a year stop when visiting my mother in law at one of the summer camps and we never regret it! Wonderful homecooked food, large portions, friendly service and at a reasonable price. Pancakes the size of tires! read more