Eddie's Sweet Shop
Eddie's Sweet Shop Photos
Business Info
Eddie's Sweet Shop Popular Desserts
You might also consider
More like Eddie's Sweet Shop
Recommended Reviews - Eddie's Sweet Shop
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
We came for my husband's birthday. It was good to see it crowded. We waited for a few minutes as they cleared a table for us. The place hasn't changed at all. The seats at the counter looks the same. There are a few tables and booths. We got a banana royal with their peach, blueberry, and maple walnut ice cream. The bananas were sliced at the bottom of the dish. They were generous with the butterscotch syrup and homemade whip cream. We asked them to not add the chocolate sprinkles since neither of us like sprinkles. The peach and blueberry are seasonal flavors and were so good. The maple walnut had big chunks of walnut in it. My daughter had a scoop of mint chip on a cone. It was very minty and delicious. Eddie's still as good as it used to be
This place is cash only. Of course, I don't carry cash because its totally unnecessary these days. And I'm not paying a high surcharge to use their silly ATM machine. Those machines are just another source of revenue for them, but it's also a penalty on us for not bringing cash. It even has a sign that says "No Receipt". The menu is good, the ice cream is delicious, and I love these kind of places. But there are plenty of other ice cream places nearby that take modern forms of payment.
Eddie's is a Queens landmark. Everything from the plaster ornate ceiling tile to the wood panel walls screams authenticity. From the decor to the serving cups you are getting no frills but great quality. Its a traditional ice cream parlor. And im not mad at it. They have counter seating for small groups to tables in the back. We had a group of 6 and was seated quickly. I had the ice cream float with root beer syrup. The vanilla ice cream sat delicately on top of the soda. The soda wasn't overly sweet and fizzy. I had time to enjoy the ice cream and the soda separately. My daughter had vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. There was not a sprinkle in sight when she was done. This isn't our first time. Nor will this be our last. All the ice cream flavor are of great quality. The fudge to the sundae is classic. Ideal for after dinner or date night after a movie. Dont forget to bring cash.
Eddie's Sweet Shop is a legendary institution in Forest Hills, and honestly, in all of New York. It has stood in the same spot on Metropolitan Avenue since 1925. The interior reflects its age and history. Everything is original, from the wooden parlor to the style of cups and spoons. In Eddie's 100th year of existence, a single scoop will set you back $7. The ice cream is very good, though--delicate, creamy, and never too sweet. But more than that, you're paying for the experience: sitting in the same parlor New Yorkers have enjoyed for a century, eating from the same kind of silver cup and spoon as in 1925.
Good ice cream, amazing nostalgia! Worth a visit to see the decor and experience the ambiance. It's truly like stepping into a time warp back to the 1950's! The prices are fair and the service is good, too. Although you can find fancier ice cream and more options at other stores, Eddie's is a time capsule and I love it
Hubby wanted to try the chocolate milkshake at Eddie's and paid $11 for a try. He wasn't impressed by it but wants to bring our grandchild to have ice cream. I can't eat ice cream so I don't know how it compares to other places. I do like the atmosphere of old time I e cream parlor and enjoying see what they have I the store.
Eddie's shop is incredibly cozy and full of character, with a truly old-school charm that makes it feel special the moment you walk in. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, like a classic neighborhood spot that's been loved for years. The waitstaff are friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind, which adds so much to the overall experience. And of course, the ice cream is fantastic--rich, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Whether you're on a date, visiting with your kids, or just stopping by because you're craving great ice cream, Eddie's shop is the kind of place that makes every visit feel special and keeps you coming back.
I took a lengthy trip from Midtown to give Eddies a try. This place is unchanged since day one. I didn't go to stare at the place so Ice Cream is my focus. I ordered Pistacchio and Banana with Hot fudge. The Ice Cream was good, but no better than what Carvel serves. Fourteen dollars for two scoops, and they accept cash only. Is everybody in Forest Hills rich?
Came here with my walking group right at 3pm when it opened. The staff was super accommodating of our large group and gave us a long table to sit at. The mint chip ice cream sundae was good, and I appreciated that everything including sodas are made in-house (though a couple people said the drinks tasted sweeter and not as fizzy as store-bought sodas). I think the real draw of this place is the nostalgia aspect and that it's a long-standing Forest Hills landmark that still looks very old-timey. Definitely worth a visit if you haven't been before.
A first on National Ice Cream day. They opened at 3 PM and we joined the queue about 2:45 PM. A classic spot. We opted to sit at a table. We were ready to order but it took a minute for our order to be taken. We ordered a banana split with two scoops chocolate ice cream, hot fudge (extra $1), chocolate sprinkles, whipped cream and only one cherry. I feel there should be a cherry for each scoop. read more
This place rocks! I wanted to go somewhere where they made good old sundaes. What a history this place has! The decor of this place brings back memories of many years ago. I ordered a 2 scoop vanilla sundae with chocolate sprinkles and strawberry syrup. It was the bomb! The sundae was so delectable! Best sundae I have had in along time. The service was impeccable. The servers were all positive and happy to serve you. I can't wait to come back here and have the triple scoop sundae. They have so many different combinations of ice cream. Lots of other great items on the menu too! read more
We got the banana royal! It was such a good Sunday that is stacked with so much ice cream. There is a very comforting feeling about the ambience and the ice cream. They are crowded and seating will take a while. They also take a while to get the ice cream and more. But that is because they are so busy and you can just enjoy your time read more
14 days ago
Based on to go order. Make sure to bring cash. What a cute nostalgic place. Ice cream was good but pricey. A single and a double was $17. Wowza. Cherry vanilla was good though! read more
We came for my husband's birthday. It was good to see it crowded. We waited for a few minutes as they cleared a table for us. The place hasn't changed at all. The seats at the counter looks the same. There are a few tables and booths. We got a banana royal with their peach, blueberry, and maple walnut ice cream. The bananas were sliced at the bottom of the dish. They were generous with the butterscotch syrup and homemade whip cream. We asked them to not add the chocolate sprinkles since neither of us like sprinkles. The peach and blueberry are seasonal flavors and were so good. The maple walnut had big chunks of walnut in it. My daughter had a scoop of mint chip on a cone. It was very minty and delicious. Eddie's still as good as it used to be read more
This place is cash only. Of course, I don't carry cash because its totally unnecessary these days. And I'm not paying a high surcharge to use their silly ATM machine. Those machines are just another source of revenue for them, but it's also a penalty on us for not bringing cash. It even has a sign that says "No Receipt". The menu is good, the ice cream is delicious, and I love these kind of places. But there are plenty of other ice cream places nearby that take modern forms of payment. read more
4 months ago
Eddie's is a Queens landmark. Everything from the plaster ornate ceiling tile to the wood panel walls screams authenticity. From the decor to the serving cups you are getting no frills but great quality. Its a traditional ice cream parlor. And im not mad at it. They have counter seating for small groups to tables in the back. We had a group of 6 and was seated quickly. I had the ice cream float with root beer syrup. The vanilla ice cream sat delicately on top of the soda. The soda wasn't overly sweet and fizzy. I had time to enjoy the ice cream and the soda separately. My daughter had vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. There was not a sprinkle in sight when she was done. This isn't our first time. Nor will this be our last. All the ice cream flavor are of great quality. The fudge to the sundae is classic. Ideal for after dinner or date night after a movie. Dont forget to bring cash. read more
13 days ago
Delicious fresh homemade ice cream sundae. Fresh handmade whipped cream and syrup. My mom is 91 years old and she's been coming here since she was a young child. Great memories. Love this place! read more
11 months ago
Eddie's Sweet Shop is a legendary institution in Forest Hills, and honestly, in all of New York. It has stood in the same spot on Metropolitan Avenue since 1925. The interior reflects its age and history. Everything is original, from the wooden parlor to the style of cups and spoons. In Eddie's 100th year of existence, a single scoop will set you back $7. The ice cream is very good, though--delicate, creamy, and never too sweet. But more than that, you're paying for the experience: sitting in the same parlor New Yorkers have enjoyed for a century, eating from the same kind of silver cup and spoon as in 1925. read more
11 months ago
Good ice cream, amazing nostalgia! Worth a visit to see the decor and experience the ambiance. It's truly like stepping into a time warp back to the 1950's! The prices are fair and the service is good, too. Although you can find fancier ice cream and more options at other stores, Eddie's is a time capsule and I love it read more
Hubby wanted to try the chocolate milkshake at Eddie's and paid $11 for a try. He wasn't impressed by it but wants to bring our grandchild to have ice cream. I can't eat ice cream so I don't know how it compares to other places. I do like the atmosphere of old time I e cream parlor and enjoying see what they have I the store. read more
3 months ago
7 months ago
Eddie's shop is incredibly cozy and full of character, with a truly old-school charm that makes it feel special the moment you walk in. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, like a classic neighborhood spot that's been loved for years. The waitstaff are friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind, which adds so much to the overall experience. And of course, the ice cream is fantastic--rich, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Whether you're on a date, visiting with your kids, or just stopping by because you're craving great ice cream, Eddie's shop is the kind of place that makes every visit feel special and keeps you coming back. read more
4 months ago
I took a lengthy trip from Midtown to give Eddies a try. This place is unchanged since day one. I didn't go to stare at the place so Ice Cream is my focus. I ordered Pistacchio and Banana with Hot fudge. The Ice Cream was good, but no better than what Carvel serves. Fourteen dollars for two scoops, and they accept cash only. Is everybody in Forest Hills rich? read more
7 months ago
Came here with my walking group right at 3pm when it opened. The staff was super accommodating of our large group and gave us a long table to sit at. The mint chip ice cream sundae was good, and I appreciated that everything including sodas are made in-house (though a couple people said the drinks tasted sweeter and not as fizzy as store-bought sodas). I think the real draw of this place is the nostalgia aspect and that it's a long-standing Forest Hills landmark that still looks very old-timey. Definitely worth a visit if you haven't been before. read more
DELICIOUS DESSERTS!! There's a line, but they seat people quickly. Since it's just dessert, the turnover is quick. It's a large place with a bathroom. The servers are generally friendly and the dessert is DELICIOUS. Got a sundae with vanilla fudge, coffee chip, and mint chip. Highly recommend the coffee chip and vanilla fudge!! Whipped cream is good, and the chocolate sprinkles are delicious!! read more
2 months ago
Did not disappoint!!! Tried their Banana Split Royale for $20. Went traditional with Vanilla, Chocolate and Strawberry. Defintely a treat for sharing!!! read more
2 years ago
I have been trying to go to Eddie's for so long. It's been a staple in Forest Hills for years. I finally went a few weeks ago and I wasn't disappointed. We sat on the stools and chatted with the staff they were sooo cool. I'm so bad with names but we were chatting with the husband and wife and the one that seems like the manager or owner. All cool and lots of laughs. Let's get into the delicious ice cream tho. I had rum raisin and coconut with marshmallow caramel whip cream sprinkles and a cherry on top. It was so yummy. Authentic ice cream in a vintage ice cream shop. This was so dope. Everyone I was with enjoyed as well. read more
Because this place is popular on a weekend evening, expect a few minutes of wait while they prepare orders. The wait isn't too unreasonable, especially when you sit at the bar and realize how busy they are. It's nearly packed with people standing in line to order, but we managed to grab seats for two. There's some families, but you'll see people of all ages here ready to enjoy sweets. The spoons, ice cream dishes, candies displayed, and bar stools all bring you back in time and give the illusion that the place looks like how it looked when it first opened. I got a dish of banana ice cream, and it was unlike anything I've ever tried. I'm not sure if it was because of the unique flavor or because of the quality of the ice cream or both, but I'm planning to find out when I visit next time. The prices are on the higher end for ice cream, but I hope to return and order something different to settle if the ice cream is worth the price here! read more
This place is a neighborhood staple. They have been here for a very long time and you definitely get a sense of nostalgia as soon as you come in. Everything is cash and everything is fresh so there's a wait and there are signs up telling you so! There's a counter you can order or sit down at and there are tables in the back. I got a float to go so I'm not sure if it's table service or not. It can get busy here, especially in the summer. The staff here are very nice and their ice cream is delicious. They also have tons of candy as well. Worth the visit whether you live in the area or not. read more
2 months ago
10 months ago
Been craving Eddies for quite awhile and was able to go today. Line always long when they first open but was early enough to still get a table to enjoy with the family. Staff was quick and super attentive. read more
1 year ago
I would like to start by saying, we have been coming here for over 20 years. But what we saw transpire today needed to be mentioned and highlighted. A latino looking family with their two daughters had placed their order and the man behind (the son's owner I presume) the counter was absurdly rude and a complete jerk. When the older customer said you could be nicer to your customers, He took her ice-cream and threw it away. Even after they paid! He mouthed off some racist comment that I won't mention here, but that was the straw for us. We have seen other instances where they have been rude before and we shrugged it off, but clearly this place has got to be checked and everyone should be informed that your experience will be subject to what you look like and how much crappy service you're willing to accept for an overpriced ice-cream. Horrible horrible horrible establishment and I would stay away. Not family friendly, not a wholesome experience and most importantly, embarrassment to the community and what it stands for. read more
CASH ONLY! We came here on a Sunday afternoon after watching a movie next door and it was extremely packed and busy. It gets pretty crowded inside especially when the to-go line wraps around bar. Also they're very transparent that they have long wait times especially since everything is made fresh to order. Everything looks delicious and everyone there is really nice. We got two shakes with 3 scoops of ice cream in each. Blueberry (seasonal summer flavor) with vanilla syrup, and orange freeze. Both shakes came out to $28. The blueberry shake was incredible, we highly recommend trying it because of the fresh blueberry flavor. The orange freeze was also insanely refreshing and nostalgic. Everything was delicious so we didn't mind the wait. We cannot wait to return and I try out their sundaes and other flavors of ice cream. read more
2 years ago
We were so excited to finally find a place that sells Banana Splits !! And the ambiance, service and dessert didn't disappoint, TOTALLY recommended !! There was a line even at 9-10pm at night on a Saturday summer day so be ready to wait, there is space in the counter but still need to wait to be seater! The service is really quick which we love! We really enjoyed the ice cream, most of their ingredients are made on premises which makes the flavors genuine and delicious! Go on a date, go with your family, but go!! read more
1 year ago
One of the great ice cream places in the country. It never disappoints! Best hot fudge, best butterscotch and that incredible whip cream on everything. Get an egg cream while you are waiting for your sundae. read more
They make their own ice cream and sauces, and boy are they good. We got a banana split with rum raisin ice cream and chocolate ice cream. A delicious treat. The place looks like a truly classic ice cream joint out of the mid 20th century. All original decor. Note that they only take cash. read more
An authentic ice cream shop that even makes their own whipped cream. The icecream is creamy and delicious. They only take cash but it's so worth it. I would recommend the pistachio icecream and the vanilla with chocolate syrup. read more
3 years ago
Totally enjoyed the ice cream experience at Eddie's Sweet shop. Shame on me for not knowing Eddie's has been around since 1925 and is located right here in Queens, NYC. I'm so impressed and wowed by how the look and feel of Eddie's look like just how it was back when it was first opened. I enjoyed the original soda fountains, bright red booths, marble interiors and high ceilings. I also was amazed my the original/traditional stools by the counters. My friend and I ended up having the tradition vanilla flavor ice cream served in an authentic ice cream cup. Have to say this has been the best ice cream I have had in such a long time. And I also ended up buying candies I used to eat as a child. This experience brought back beautiful, tasty and joyful memories. They make their ice cream in the basement. And they accept cash only. Highly recommend visiting if you are in the neighborhood. read more
We were taken out to lunch by grandma, after school let out for the summer. It was about a week or two later, and we didn't look up the time it opened. It opened rather late, around 2pm or 3pm, which, for the summer, seemed a little off, but then again, you're in FOHI, QNS, not some poppin' neighborhood. Thank goodness it was the middle of the week, bc they're also not open a couple of days in the beginning of the week, which was even more surprising, bc it was July. The ambiance felt just like an old school soda fountain shop. The service was attentive. We sat at the bar. There aren't many booths or tables and chairs, so if you want to sit in one, arrive before they open, as we did, to get those types of seats, especially in warmer weather. They had some great flavors on the menu and the shake was made just right. They only accept cash. Don't leave home without it. I guess they kept to the old school feel with that idea, as well. read more
Eddie's Sweets is the oldest Ice Cream Parlor in NYC. They have some delicious handmade ice cream and I was excited to try some with my friends. I got the Cherry Vanilla ice Cream with M&M's as a topping. My friends tried Maple, Peach, and Raspberry Sorbet. My ice cream was so delicious and tasted so fresh. If you are in Queens, check this gem out! read more
1 year ago
Went there with my family. Service left alot to be desired. Rude employees. Like, if they are doing you a favor by taking your order. Third and last time I will visit this place. read more
3 years ago
Great place to take your place for a sweet Sunday family outing but I wouldn't go every single weekend. Their prices are outrageous. I know inflation is currently in effect and the price of milk and cream is high but....$10 for a small milk shake is price gouging. Calling it what it is. This place has been around for decades and the owners (who most likely own the building) have retained the same nostalgic feel of this forest hills institution (which appeals to the baby boomers and older crowd who most likely used to go their with their parents when they were young), but being price conscious to appeal to a larger audience should definitely be a concern of his/hers. Not everyone can afford to enjoy a great dairy-based for a family of 4 that comes out to $50-$75. Taste: it's ok. Nothing to write home about. Your average milkshake. It's worth $6 in all honesty. Tip: Buy a tub of natural organic vanilla bean ice cream for $4 (brewers) organic milk for $4 (horizon) and a small jar of vanilla for $10.. you can make 6 milk shakes at home for your whole family for less than $20 PS - Cash only as well which is a nuisance. They also charge to use their own ATM. PPS- a bevy of high school students and college freshman run the service station and it smelled like body odor when we went in. Not a good smell (or look) read more
Been wanting to come here for the longest time and so my guy and I trekked here in the hot summer. We sat at the bar as no more seating in the regular table area. Packed place with old school charm. We ordered a scoop of ice cream each along with a coke. Chocolate and coffee were our chosen ones. Coffee tasted alot better than chocolate in our opinion. It had a rich, deep flavor to me. The homemade coke tasted like how you would get a fountain soda but at the end of the bag when there's not enough soda lol. Very sweet. The reason I knocked off a star was because we saw a server put back a scoop of vanilla into the fridge because it was wrong order probably? We were like uhhh ok. Not sure how kosher that is but this guy ended up being the to serve us our ice cream lol. Thought that was kind of strange but nothing to waste I guess? read more
Page 1 of 28
More info about Eddie's Sweet Shop
105-29 Metropolitan Ave
Forest hills, NY 11375
Forest Hills
Directions
(718) 520-8514
Call Now
Visit Website
https://eddiessweetshop.nyc
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Eddie's Sweet Shop Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Eddie's Sweet Shop
How do ice cream cakes work?
Do they still,serve the summer flavors of peach and blueberry?
I think I saw a sign there yesterday that said "summer flavors are back" or something of the sort.
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
65 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
1 year ago
14 years ago
16 years ago
1 year ago
12 years ago
5 years ago
7 years ago
4 years ago
7 years ago
16 years ago
12 years ago
14 years ago
7 years ago
8 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
7 years ago
17 years ago
12 years ago
Eddie's Sweet Shop - desserts - Updated July 2026
Best of Forest hills
People found Eddie's Sweet Shop by searching for…
Candy Stores in Forest Hills, NY
Jobs for Teenagers in Forest Hills, NY
Frozen Yogurt in Forest Hills, NY
Kosher Bakery in Forest Hills, NY
Ice Cream Cart Rental in Forest Hills, NY
Soda Pop Shop in Forest Hills, NY
Banana Split in Forest Hills, NY
Sweet Shop in Forest Hills, NY
Coffee & Tea in Forest Hills, NY
Soft Serve Ice Cream in Forest Hills, NY
Late Night Dessert in Forest Hills, NY
Malt Milkshake in Forest Hills, NY
Root Beer Float in Forest Hills, NY
Browse Nearby
BEST of Forest hills, New York Restaurants near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Coffee near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Things to Do near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Parking near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Ice Cream near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Bakery near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Boba near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Shopping near Eddie's Sweet Shop
BEST of Forest hills, New York Cookies near Eddie's Sweet Shop
