Elizabeth&#x27;s Pizza #1

This is the absolute BEST Italian Restaurant in Thomasville. The owners are from Napoli. The food…read moretastes like something straight out of Europe. The pizza is really good...they even have Sicilian Style if one likes that. The subs are superb. The bread tastes like homemade. The Steak and Cheese Sub and the Sausage Parmigana are really good. I would recommend everyone who likes good Italian food to eat here.

Always fresh and delicious food! Great, friendly service! Decor makes you feel like you've…read moretransported to Italy!

Cheese pull!

See all

Dogs

Capri's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant

3.5(31 reviews)

1.5 mi

This was the best food I think I have ever put in my mouth the service is top tier it was so clean…read morefood was so fresh waitress was so nice/polite very affordable

Another school day, another Grubhub order…read more I was overwhelmed with the choices available on the knee but ended up going the chicken Caesar wrap. Wow! Such a huge wrap and delish too. I added onions and tomatoes - a great addition. I also ordered a side salad with creamy Italian dressing. LOVED the cream Italian!!!! I may order a full sized salad next time just for the dressing lol. My coworkers ordered a burger and it was just okay. The bread was dry and the patty was thin. However they did add ranch as asked and added cheese to the side of fries. Very accommodating.

Amazing!!

Pizza (with everything)

See all

Kids spaghetti

Mamma Mias

4.4(64 reviews)

10.7 mi

Longtime fan and newly disappointed customer…read more Hate to give a negative shout out. Our order was missing items but thankfully we checked and they made it right. Always check the bag and boxes. Ordered fried ravioli and they lost the filling in the fryer - every one was mostly empty. Not worth the cost. Limoncello cake was a whim add on. Wish we had skipped. The cooler is always stocked with desserts and looks good but now we know. The box was dated 19 days ago. If this was the prep date, it's 12 days past its good by date - especially given the cheese in the topping/filling. It tasted pungent. No go. Another waste of $. Final straw tonight was biting into a staple in my salad. I'm giving the benefit of the doubt that it fell in from opening the bag (they staple receipts to the bag and to close). But still the risk not worth it here, folks. Mama Mia would be smart to invest in a roll of stickers. I'm less than impressed tonight by one of our go to fast casual Italian spots. It's with mixed feelings that I share....

Enjoyed my recently visit to Mamma Mias Italian restaurant in Walburg, NC. My wife and I both…read moreordered the lasagna. We should have shared a plate the portion was easily shareable. We both took about half our meal home. The food was very high quality, the restaurant was clean, and the waitress was very friendly.

Interior seating

See all

SIDE SALAD

Giannos Of High Point

4.0(303 reviews)

9.0 mi

There is a reason this spot is busy. Great service and great choices. Hard to believe if you go to…read morean Italian place that meat and potato options are readily available. That tells me they know their crowd. The menu is huge! We stuck w/traditional choices. The pasta was perfect. What was even better: Our Servers. Plural because one was in training. It was a delight to see the care the trainer was providing to the new server. And the joyful enthusiasm was a treat. Nicely done!!!

Ok. I've now become a fan of Giannos…read more We were deciding where to eat tonight and all I had to say was cheese bread. The car knew where we were going. Haley took excellent care of us from the word Go! The Cheese Bread did not disappoint. We enjoyed it and followed up with the salad. The salad was fresh and crisp. Haley offered Garlic bread but after you have had the cheese bread, it would just be a disappointment. (Their garlic bread is delicious) Dinner arrived.... I got the Chicken Florentine Manicotti. Jen got the lasagna. Togo box for the lasagna for sure. We were stuffed. Nice place. I had several bad experiences at the start but they have won me over. This place just feels like someone who cares runs it. Good Job! No photos this time. My fork was on point more than my camera

Create your own

See all

Bar

Rosa Mae's Cafe

3.5(22 reviews)

1.5 mi

The service was great just not thrilled with the hamburger that I ordered but I will try something…read moreelse. I'm not disappointed

Amazing prices - delicious food dine in or pick up. So convenient and clean highly recommend this…read morerestaurant.

An excellent Southern Chili Dog - chili is loaded with meat and flavor - $2

See all

Giovanni's Restaurant

2.7(211 reviews)

14.2 mi

Okay atmosphere is strange. Big speaker in the bar area just playing random music, pictures on the…read morewall were all crooked, had a coat hanger at the door with a belt just hanging off of it and clothes just piled in the corner. Amelia the bartender was honestly great, fast, and attentive 10/10. She recommend the 2 entrees we got. We split the Alfredo, rigatoni vodka, and a cannoli. Alfredo noodles actually tasted homemade and authentic and sauce was light and really good Vodka sauce was tasty but the serving was a tad small. Cannoli was good and tasted fresh. Bread came out fresh and the vinegar oil blend was delicious. Atmosphere 6/10 Service 9/10 Food 8/10

I didn't think I could write a one star review but yeah. This deserved it. And unfortunately my…read morelobster ravioli was delicious but the service was horrendous. I went with my friend I literally went right after work and he got a lasagna and I got the lobster ravioli. We were sitting in the bar area and it was nice and clean however you can hear the kitchen staff in the back today and they were arguing. My ravioli was great the house salad was good but my friends lasagna was lacking meat and he told the waitress/bartender this so she took his plate back. The OWNER came back out with the same plate saying that the meat is very ground up and chunky and claimed my friend ate most of it and that he refused to keep making pasta dishes and that he'd come back with something else. Which he did, he came back with some random rigatoni dish that neither one of us ordered. My friend said that he wasn't going to eat any of it and that he'd still pay to which the owner turned around and said that my friend of course still had to pay for the lasagna that he barely ate. He left after that and never came back outside Two of the waitress's came back apologizing, and a couple who was sitting nearby also expressed disappointment. The waiters added that the owner had been belittling them all day and I told her that the lobster ravioli was amazing and she said she'd tell the chef but he walked out. I would give negative stars if I could.

Interior

Spaghetti and Sausage Spaghetti and Sausage

See all

Bar area I got the Lamb Lollipops

Cristina Gray’s Restaurant & Bar

3.8(27 reviews)

7.2 mi

•$$$

Omg! This place is amazing. The food was great and the service was impeccable. The ambiance is top…read morenotch and I will be visiting again. Chef's kiss

Had a great dinner with friends last night. Tried several…read morenew menu items. The chef was super friendly, and the food was delicious! I cannot believe I've never eaten here before. I think our table tried about everything on the menu. We will be back!!

See all

Lubrano's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

3.9(56 reviews)

12.1 mi

My husband and I decided to go to Lubrano's recently and it did not disappoint! The staff and…read moreserver were so friendly and the food so flavorful! I got the eggplant parmesan and my husband the lasagna. Both were delicious! So glad we remembered this little gem hiding in plain sight and we're sorry we had forgotten about it. We will be back soon! It is a quiet little spot in a strip mall near Big Lots. Don't overlook it!

Food as allways was great …read more.. Take out went smoothly Neen coming here for at least 25 years all ways enjoy the food

Eggplant Parmigiana Pasta

See all

Dusina's Pizza

4.4(57 reviews)

9.4 mi

Highly recommend Dusina's pepperoni pizza and Garlic Fingers! This has become our local go-to pizza…read moreplace. My husband enjoyed their wings as well! We are ranch-loving people-- just an FYI that their ranch is the bomb! Side note: The cashier has actually given my husband a nickname because we order from here so often!

This place is great, and great value for the money- been eating here for many years. Would highly…read morerecommended

Things to do in Thomasville

Pepperoni Pizza

See all

Garlic Fingers, Cheesy Bread

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

B J.

0

1

0

11 years ago

I will have to say that being from out of the area that this restaurant has the WORST "business acumen" and "customer service" I have EVER seen! I have NEVER experienced such a confrontational demeanor from ANY restaurant in the 43 years I have been alive and I have dined in multiple restaurants across the United States. Additionally, "John", the rep that assisted me in the checkout process had an attitude that would make a mafia boss look like an angel. This place will not survive with the current business ethics they have in place!! I DO NOT recommend visiting this restaurant if you truly want to keep your peace of mind if there is ever an issue with their service! read more

Tee P.

Elite 24

2

31

67

3 years ago

The food here never disappoints. I mostly order to go, but have dined in on several occasions. They have recently renovated and it looks fabulous. I love the grilled chicken salad and hoagies, but the Chicken Alfredo is like that! I get the kids meal because I can not finish the regular portion let alone a salad and garlic bread! They are a very clean establishment and the lady running things now has done a great job done Aldo opened the second location. read more

Teresa T.

0

7

0

3 years ago

great food !! good value !! fresh !! the staff is amazing. I wanted to be friend ... they were all so happy and helped each other out. dinning is about average. booth and tables. but was not overly loud. this place was very clean for the amo of activity going on. the staff was Jonny on the spot with clean up and turning over tables. ty their lunch specials !! read more

Michael B.

0

1

0

8 years ago

It took us 30 minutes of waiting before our waitress came and took our drink order. She brought us our drinks and took our food order and never came back! Plus our food was wrong and the manger did not care at all! I will never be going back. read more

Walter B.

0

5

31

3 years ago

Best Italian food around. We order almost everyday from these guys and right down the street for our tattoo shop aka Rocket Roys Tattoos. Thanks Anna and Luca and the crew for giving us the best food around read more

Caroline S.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Horrible service and horrible food! All of our food was cold and incorrect and the owners treated my family like crap. We will never eat at that location ever again and would never recommend it to anyone. read more

Andrew C.

0

12

6 years ago

This is one of our go-to spots for take-out, delivery, and dine in! The owners are wonderful and the food is always great!

Elizabeth's Pizza #1 - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Thomasville

People found Elizabeth's Pizza #1 by searching for…

People who viewed Elizabeth's Pizza #1 also viewed

Elizabeth Pizza & Restaurant

4.4

(57 reviews)

This is the absolute BEST Italian Restaurant in Thomasville. The owners are from Napoli. The food…read moretastes like something straight out of Europe. The pizza is really good...they even have Sicilian Style if one likes that. The subs are superb. The bread tastes like homemade. The Steak and Cheese Sub and the Sausage Parmigana are really good. I would recommend everyone who likes good Italian food to eat here.

Always fresh and delicious food! Great, friendly service! Decor makes you feel like you've…read moretransported to Italy!

Vinnie's Pizzeria

4.2

(148 reviews)

Sometimes we open Yelp and decide to go to some places just because we've never heard of it before…read moreand the reviews are awesome. Vinnie's Pizzeria was that for us today. When we want pizza, I'm looking for authentic New York style or some brick oven baked charred crust. Vinnie's isn't either of these but it had great reviews from fellow yelpers so of course we needed to see it for ourselves. It was pretty crowded when we arrived but we didn't have to wait long before we were seated. Dominique our Server helped us decide what to order. She was awesome and fun and we could tell she loved her job and the food there. I love that! She highly recommended the garlic knots so we started with those. My husband got Chicken Marsala on Dominique's recommendation. I ordered Chicken Cannelloni. The portions are very generous and I ended up taking some home for a nice treat later. Everything we had was delicious and now I want to go back and try the pizza.

A solid little pizzaria, we stopped in recently for some dinner and Vinnie's was a good choice…read more We were greeted walking in and seated within the same moment. A surprizingly small eatery, has a separate dining area with booths and some tables. Our server was professional and kind, we ordered our drinks and a start with their version of Bruschetta. This was an excellent start for our evening there. A beautiful presentation of five pieces, nicely toasted with paper thin prosciutto de parma, fresh mozzarella, chopped tomato, capers and balsamic reduction drizzle. Delicious, rich, crunchy, sweet, savory and full flavored. I went for the Parmigiana with chicken, served over angel hair with a rich tomato sauce. A hearty meal, the chicken cutlet was breaded nicely, and pounded thin, cooked very well. The pasta underneath cooked al dante, and it all smoothered in a rich maranara. We also tried the Mediterranean pizza, a 12" and it was huge. A well made pie, loaded with ingredients. The combination of fresh pesto with the mushrooms, olives, banana peppers, roasted red peppers and feta was a solid choice. Along with a cold draft Stella it made for an very good meal. 4 Stars a solid choice for a good meal 01242

Francesco's

3.8

(85 reviews)

I honestly had no clue this place even existed since we never really drive through this part of…read moretown, but now that it's on my radar, we'll definitely be coming back regularly. We're big fans of good pizza, and finding a deal where you get a massive slice and a salad for just $6.00 feels like a total steal. What's even better is that it wasn't just some limited lunch special; we stopped by on a weekend at dinner time and the price was the same. The crust is perfectly thin, the marinara has a great kick to it, and it's just a really satisfying meal. I went with the sliced meatball and garlic pizza paired with a Caesar salad, and it hit the spot. This was such a great find.

A good friend recommended this place and we finally tried it. What a nice surprise! For as picky as…read moreI am about pizza, I LOVED THIS PIZZA !!! it's thin, the marinera sauce is great, it's just a satisfying slice of pizza. I appreciated that it wasn't oily on top, and the price ! They have a $6 deal that comes with a huge slice of pizza, any kind you want, and a decent filling bowl of salad. You can dine in and order cold bottle of beer and they'll bring you a iced glass for the beer. Not bad. We'll be regulars.

Amalfi's Pizza Italian Restaurant

4.0

(156 reviews)

I got takeout from Amalfi's and was really impressed! I ordered the chicken Parmesan with a side…read moresalad, cheesy garlic bread, and cheesecake. Everything tasted fresh, was packaged really well, and made it home without becoming a mess. The chicken parm was especially tasty, and they also included some complimentary bread. I saw online that when you dine in, the bread is served with an herbed oil for dipping, so now I feel like I have to go there in person Overall, really good Italian food and a great takeout experience. I'm looking forward to going back and actually eating at the restaurant next time to get the full experience!

Amalfi's is our favorite Italian restaurant. We went today for my birthday. The food was excellent…read moreas usual and Riley's service was wonderful. She went above and beyond by presenting me with this special cannoli platter. They were delicious! The shell was light and airy. The cream was the perfect sweetness.

Elizabeth's Pizza

3.3

(84 reviews)

Elisabeths Pizza We love the food. Service was great for…read morethe most part. Atmosphere was quiet and peaceful. Plenty of seating for large parties. Food was fresh and tasty. A great spot for a quick bite.

The Elizabeth's at Quaker Village is my favorite Elizabeth's! The staff is always happy, friendly,…read moreand helpful. The food is always great. Inside there are plenty of seats and is decorated well. I got the Greek salad with salmon and it was fresh and large portioned.

Coppola's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

3.9

(138 reviews)

Small local Italian restaurant serving very good food. We enjoyed lasagna & stiffed eggplant…read moremanicotti. My wife loved the lasagna...plenty of sauce & cheese. The sauce was rich & dark red with a slightly sweet taste. Both meals came with nicely topped side salads & warm tasty Italian bread & butter. I had never heard of stuffed eggplant "manicotti." It was excellent. The pieces of eggplant were stuffed ham, beef & cheese & topped with. Their delicious sauce. The prices were very reasonable & the service was excellent! I would highly recommend.

Yesterday my family picked up a couple pizza's for dinner at the urging of my stepdad who says…read more"It's the best pizza we've found since being here!". Now, I'm a die hard Mellow Mushroom fan because in all honesty, it's the best there is out here (we've been spoiled with AMAZING pizza in CA)... with that being said... Coppola's pizza came in a STRONG 2nd! That was a damn good pie!!! It's much closer to home, and the price point was decent! We will absolutely be back ! Wish I would've snapped a couple photos before the family devoured them! They looked as phenomenal as they tasted!

Elizabeth's Pizza Express

4.4

(31 reviews)

Every time I'm at the lake I order pizza! Love love love it!…read moreGreat pizza and great service!

Staff were very nice and checked up on us while we ate. The service made our visit pleasant…read more Ordered pizza at the cashier first and then sat at one of the tables to wait for the food to be cooked. One large pizza was enough for the two of us and our toddler. We had a pizza with bell pepper and mushrooms. Pizza itself was alright, did the job of satisfying our pizza craving. We also had a meatball calzone, decent tasting. Before entrees arrived, had a chef salad that came with some kind of rosemary salad dressing. While I can appreciate the abundance of cheese and ham, it just wasn't good. Came with way too much green olives, and served over iceberg lettuce. I didn't like the salad dressing very much either.

Capri's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant

3.5

(31 reviews)

This was the best food I think I have ever put in my mouth the service is top tier it was so clean…read morefood was so fresh waitress was so nice/polite very affordable

Another school day, another Grubhub order…read more I was overwhelmed with the choices available on the knee but ended up going the chicken Caesar wrap. Wow! Such a huge wrap and delish too. I added onions and tomatoes - a great addition. I also ordered a side salad with creamy Italian dressing. LOVED the cream Italian!!!! I may order a full sized salad next time just for the dressing lol. My coworkers ordered a burger and it was just okay. The bread was dry and the patty was thin. However they did add ranch as asked and added cheese to the side of fries. Very accommodating.

Capri's Pizza

3.2

(21 reviews)

Located in the shopping center near Food Lion, this little hidden gem is amazing!…read moreEverything I have had there had been delicious. I'm normally an eggplant parm person but on my last trip, I decided to try the fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp. It was $16 and comes with a salad and garlic bread. It melts in your mouth! I can't wait to try it again. This is a typical dinner type atmosphere - some chairs with tables and some booths. Service is always friendly and food is quick. everything is fresh! Highly recommend!

Excellent Stromboli! It's freshly made, lots of toppings, and good dipping sauce. Super kind staff…read moreand fast service. While I grabbed this to go, I would eat inside for sure. We will be back to try something else on the large menu.

New York Pizza Bar & Grill

3.6

(157 reviews)