Every time we come here for takeout we always have a great meal. My boyfriend who is Italian says that they have the best eggplant parmigiana. He will make it a point to order some when we go to my parents' house being that they only live 5 min. away. I love their rigatoni boscaiola. It is sooo good, the cream sauce is to die for. It is always our takeout place when we are having a family get together. read more

Always consistent and fantastic. They use real ingredients and do not cut corners. Penne vodka is the best.

I'm don't like to post reviews on a restaurant we ordered food before and it's been good the past few times, but this time for my luck the cheesesteak was very dry looked like it was from two days ago, bread hurt my mouth. Terrible!! the pizza was ok nothing great . read more

Enrico's Pizza & Pasta - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

See all

This is not a place to get pizza. The toppings are sparse and there is little sauce on pizza. I ordered the supreme and it was not supreme at all. I am not sure if they are trying to cut costs but a $30 pizza was more like a $15 pizza. However, if you want a sub they make great ones. read more

I've been eating here for years, pretty much since they opened. Italian food here is a hit or miss every time I order for pick up. One of the cooks there is better than the other because I've gotten shrimp scampi that tastes really good with great flavor and another time it's bland and just has chunks of barely cooked garlic with tons of butter. The same goes for other Italian dishes I've ordered. I know they lost a cook couple years ago that had been there since opening and what a big mistake! Although the pizza is pretty decent and the wings have always been my favorite. read more

The drunken grandma pizza is to die for!!! 10/10 comes out fast, service is good and ambiance is good as well,

Love everyone at Enrico's Pizza and Pasta. It's a great family owned Italian restaurant with the most positive and upbeat attitude. My favorite is the Grandma's pizza (like a Sicilian pie) which is so garlicy and crunchy. Delicious!!! It's so huge you'll have leftovers and it's as fantastic the next day and making even more cheesy, garlicy and crunchy goodness. ENJOY!!! read more

This was my favorite pizza place, now all they seem to do is burn everything. Tonight they even had burned pizza on the counter for walk-ins. Won't be ordering from here anymore. read more

Enrico's Pizza & Pasta - This place had great pizza at one point. If you like burnt pizza then I highly recommend. picture dose no justice. - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

The food was terrible. We ordered tuna sandwich meatball parm salad and pizza. The tuna was out in a roll with Mayo smeared on it. Wtf! The salad was wilted and veggies were like rubber and the meatball tasted burnt. Maybe they better stick with making pizza! They don't wear masks either. read more

Coming from an Italian family, experience working in a pizzeria for 14 years, and owning one this place gets our vote. We love walking down for a slice, picking up a special pie, or ordering dinner. My kids are addicted to the sauce too! The staff is always polite, and the place is always clean! Thanks for dinner tonight guys! read more

Been coming here for years primarily because it's the easiest to get to. I tried other places in the area and I keep coming back here because I like how their red sauce tastes vs the competition. This is particularly true for the chicken parm dinner. I think their pizza is "very good" but sometimes for unexplained reasons it flat out sucks (I.e. Too chewy or too cooked). This has happened more than once but every time I'm about to drop them as a pizza option, they redeem themselves with a good pie. The staff has changed over the years but there are some faces that I remember from years back. Always very friendly to me and my family. That's important to me. It's funny but I kinda miss "angry girl" from about 4-5 years ago. Dark hair, Italian looking, and had a "what the hell am I doing here" pout face while actually doing a nice job. Lol. read more

Went here all the time growing up and loved the pizza. While visiting family in the area we picked up a plain pizza and a white pie with mushrooms on it. Two of my favorites from growing up. But they weren't what they used to be. The white pizza had no flavor. The plain pie was lacking some cheese and the sauce was barely even there. Disappointing to have had an experience like that. Hope we just caught them on a rough day read more

Awesome family run pizzeria in Raritan area! Pizza is a must and chicken foccacia with mozzarella n peppers is awesome. Coming back for more read more

Great pizza! Whenever I'm in bdubs, i always stop in. Not only do they have slices available (usually a choice between 3 different (pre-made) pies with different toppings), but they will make you a fresh personal pizza in under 15 mins! Price and service are equally fine. Great for carry out or pick-up/carry-out with a phone call 15 mins before hand! (if its a small order) read more

Enrico's Pizza & Pasta - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, New Jersey

This is our go to for what I'd call standard jersey pie. Not too thick, not so thin that you think your earring a cracker. I'll echo another review/tip saying that the sausage is good. I'm a fan of the supreme. With all the toppings, it's still never soggy, and the proportions are spot on. Also, you'll find that it's one of the more reasonable supreme/works pies in the area. We also will get pasta dinners from here. They're always very good. The menu is a touch heavy on rich creamy sauces, but everything I've had has been good. All dinners come with a hunk of bread and a side salad with their own garlicky dressing which I do enjoy. We've never had any ordering issues and service has always been efficient and courteous. read more

Best pizza in raritan and the best prices. They give you two whole subs for the price of one. Example if you order a cheese steak they give you two whole cheese steaks for the price of one. And they always got the games on tv so if you want to eat in you get to watch the game. And it's free of people loitering for example no 15 year olds hanging out infront of the place smoking the devils lettuce like all the other pizza spots in town. read more

Food blows. Frozen meat balls frozen chicken . Use microwave to melt cheese on dinners. Mexicans ripping you off on a slice of pizza.

This is a very casual, neighborhood pizza place with very good pizza, subs, and entrees all at a very reasonable price. The pizza is good, but not up to the level of truly great pizza. The subs have plenty of meat on them, unlike the sub chain eateries where they really skimp on the meat. . The entrees are quite good as well, especially the chicken ones. If you have a choice, take out is a better choice than eating in, as the eating area is small and gets quite hot in the summer months since the cooking area is just a few feet away from the dining tables. The owner, Enrico, is a wonderful guy who obviously takes great pride in his restaurant and is always eager to please his customers. Highly recommended as a great place to get good food and big portions at very reasonable prices. You can save even more by utilizing the coupons that are included in the local coupon magazines that are mailed out locally. read more

Been in Bridgewater for a few weeks now since COVID started and we've ordered pizza from here several times. Fresh pies every time and a great plain pie. Highly recommend if you want good pizza. Their chicken parm is the best around, too. read more

I've been going here on and off for the past 10+ years. It's the sort of relationship where I try it after boycotting for a year, almost certainly get burned, and then swear it off for another year. Here's a few reasons: 1. Orders are never ready on-time. And I'm not picky - if I order on the phone and they say '20 mins,' and then I go there 25 mins later, and have to wait another 20+ minute, that's just not acceptable. 2. I've been overcharged several times. Sometimes by a few dollars, sometimes by up to 5 dollars. Completely unacceptable. 3. I'm not sure if this is #2, or just cheapness, but whenever I order an extra cheese pie, there is usually the same or less cheese than a regular pie - but I still get charged. I'm not an idiot - don't insult my intelligence by ripping me off. That being said, the pizza isn't too bad. I'd give it a 7/10...even so, and although the restaurant is literally 1500 feet from my house, I've only been here a few times in the past 10 years. If you want a good pie, for a good price, and awesome service, your best bet is Dominick's up by the circle. It's a pain in the butt for me to get there, and parking is a pain, but it's well worth it for me! Just by $.02. read more

Two things could go a long way to improving this place - 1. Clean the tables. I went in at lunch time, there wasn't a single clean table. 2. Fix the soda machine so it doesn't dispense flat soda. It's not entirely flat, but it's definitely not the right level of carbonation. I had a plain slice, which was good. Nice, chewy crust. The sicilian crust was a little different from usual, kind of a cross between a typical sicilian crust and a Pizza Hut pan pizza crust (it was pretty good). It looked from the cheese like it had been sitting there a little too long, and the cheese slid off too easily. They have some garlic knot-ish things that are REALLY good, I'd eat here for the garlic knots alone. read more

my husband and I like this restaurant for their chicken parmigiana hoagie. i find that the amount of chicken is not enough for the size of the bread, so i move the meat to one half and throw away that bread. add sauce and the sandwich is very tasty. my husband eats the hoagie as prepared. the taste is very good and the sauce s tasty. read more

Tables are never clean. Pepperoni pizza is extremely greasy, pepperoni has zero taste. This is my last choice even though it's closest to my house. read more

My friend and I went to Enrico's the other day for dinner. The bread was nice and warm and the dinners were pretty good. I got calamari fra diavolo and it was good and spicy. The calamari was nice and tender and the linguini not overcooked. The sauce was very light with big chunks of stewed tomato and there was a lot of sliced garlic in the dish. That was fine for me but might be too much for people who don't like garlic as much as I do. My friend got a chicken and pasta dish with artichoke and asparagus, I think, and ate the whole thing, even though the portion was pretty hefty. Except for the fact that it was so windy that the door kept blowing and staying open the whole time we were there, letting in the cold air, we enjoyed our visit to Enrico's. read more

I've been here a couple of times for lunch with coworkers. It is a carb-loving paradise. There is an expansive menu of pasta dishes, pizzas, hot and cold sandwiches, & salads. I've had sandwiches on both occasions I've been here and both times they were quite good. The bread on the sandwich is great, nice and crusty on the outside & nice and soft on the inside. As noted in other reviews, they are not skimpy with the meat. The sandwiches are a gut-bomb full meal. I don't think I've been able to finish an entire sandwich, and I can usually put some food away. I've tried other's pasta dishes and salads and they were also quite good and more than plenty of food. You get free bread and butter, just in case your insulin levels haven't quite peaked with your meal's carb loading. The interior is pretty unassuming but does get really warm. They have a large refrigerator selection of sodas, some of which appear locally produced. The people who work here are friendly and helpful. I've only been to one other pizza place in the area, and this one is far superior to that one. I would come here again. read more

The pizza is just ok. Not terrible, not great. Garlic knots are decent. Other items, like hot subs, are very mediocre. The worst thing about this place is that every single time I've ever phoned in an order for something, and they tell me "20 minutes" or "30 minutes", or whatever, when I go at that time, it's nowhere close to ready and I need to stand around for 10-15 more minutes. Very annoying. And the staff working there doesn't seem like they give one damn about the customers. I have only gone here due to location - but I have since decided that traveling a little further gets much better pizza and experience. read more

I've tried many of their dishes, and almost everything is very good. Problem is, the owner overcharges by a dollar or more almost every time, and gets very defensive and condescending if you question it. It's happened often enough that I have to assume it's intentional - the other clerks charge correctly. It's shady and turns me off to patronizing this establishment. Especially when you consider what OTHER things he may be doing to make money / cut costs. read more