Enrico's has a sign on the front of their storefront saying it's NY style pizza, and as that's my favorite type of pizza, I had high hopes. Their pizza is thin crust like NY style, but that's where the similarities end. I found the crust a bit flavorless and the sauce lacking in spices as well. The pepperoni and meatball pizzas were well topped, but the spinach garlic pizza we ordered had barely anything on it. For a large pizza, I'd say each slice had 2-3 small spinach leaves, tops. It was extremely sparse considering you pay around $3 for extra toppings. It's edible for sure but if you want a solid slice of NY pizza, I'd skip this spot. read more

I visited Enrico's five years ago and had such a great experience. The food was great, as well as service. I always wanted to visit again and finally did. I could say this has been the worst dining experience I've had in a long time. Not only was the service horrible, but they hardly had any of the items on the menu. I remember the meatballs, pizza and rolls being amazing so we ordered that. The meatballs had potential but they must have been frozen and were warm on the outside but the middle was cold. There was no way of getting the waiter to tell him since we waited about 25 minutes to get our order in. Mind you we were the only ones in the restaurant. The rolls were not edible. The pizza was ok, but the crust had no salt whatsoever so you couldn't eat it. I was going to try the dessert but opted not to since it would have taken half hour more. It's such a shame because they were so good. Never again. I usually do not leave bad reviews, but this was just total neglect of a once good establishment. read more

See all

Last night my coworker picked up a pizza from Enrico's and to say we were very happy is an understatement! They have different options for entrees such as seafood and pasta items for those that aren't feeling pizza but this is what you really want! The crust tastes homemade and thin so you don't feel too overwhelmingly full. We opted for spinach, mushroom, and pepperoni on this sucker. The cheese was extremely rich and juicy. The prices aren't breaking the bank like other pizza spots in the area either. It was ready within 15 minutes which was also a lovely surprise! Krust, Upper Crust, and the other pizza joints need take note to how this place operates for sure! Highly recommend! read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Build your own 16" Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

The pizza & garlic rolls were AMAZING!!!!!! not to mention a little slice of heaven with the chocolate cake we had! It was a pretty busy and rainy night and the staff was so attentive! can't wait to be back! read more

See all

Went to this place for a pizza, a long time ago it was good, tonight it was not cut right, and all the cheese falling off, and also very Burt. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - This is the 40 dollar pizzy. - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Absolutely worst experience ordering online Apparently they don't deliver lol I ordered around 7:30pm My order never arrived, tried calling at 9:10 pm but they closed at 9 No one would answer the phone The next day I called.....got the run around....a woman called me back and would not refund my money, she said they do not deliver!! I was supposed to pick it up.....I have ordered delivery in the past BUT.....she said there was nothing she could do....and she wasn't going to refund my order....so they made my order of which I had to go pick up...when I arrived their delivery car was parked outside and they didn't put the arugula on my pizza!!! What a crock & she was very rude. Honestly I could not believe it. The chicken parm looked like a 2 yr old made it and who knows what else they did to it. Very disappointing!!! I will never order from them again and will be telling all my neighbors.... read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Order confirmation - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

A-M-A-Z-I-N-G Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich. Thin sliced throughly cooked breaded just right with enough crunch to stoke up against the zesty homemade sauce and the crunchy soft hoagie roll. In heaven..... now I don't have to fly three hours north to the big Apple to fill a craving. It's just 90 minutes from Miami and bada bing bada boom. Absolutely yumminess and $11 a sandwich is quite reasonable. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich (Hot) - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

We intended to go to another pizza joint while vacationing in Islamorada but it was closed, I'm glad it was! We went to Enrico's for some good NY style pies and it was worth it. The staff is friendly, big smiles and the food was outstanding. I had a delicious anchovy calzone and the family bragged about their personal pizzas. We high recommend the mozzarella appetizer, one of the best I've had, sauced and seasoned to perfection. read more

Very disappointed with the anti-pasta salad , dressing, garlic rolls and pizza. The dressing that came with the salad had absolutely no flavor and was just oil. We requested creamy, Italian or a vinaigrette. Garlic rolls were dry and did not look anything like the pictures posted previously on the yelp reviews. The cubed spam mystery meat and cheese on the salad was gross. I would've sent it back right away if I had dined in but my husband ordered the food to go and brought it home. Needless to say I was very disappointed and had to use my own dressing to give the salad an ounce of flavor . The salad was just gross and the pizza was really average. Over priced & waste of money won't go back. read more

See all

Ordered food online to go. I provided my contact information as well as my phone number when checking out. Waited the 30 minutes to go pick it up. We get there and they say they didn't have lasagna and couldn't contact us. I told them and showed them my phone number on my online portal. "It's the keys." read more

Good pizza in a pinch. I can never say great since it's not NY/NJ but it was better than most. Plus it was good price and service was friendly. read more

2 quick pepperoni slices, nice portioned slice. Great and quick service. Would definitely stop in again.

This place is filthy.... Flys all over the place. Returned not one but two cups of water because of dirty cups with stuff floating around in them. The food is mediocre at best. Can't complain about our server, she was very nice and attentive. It's real hard to find the best in a dirty place full of flys and dirty water. I really hope they clean up, it's a great location with tons of potential. read more

9/10 pizza good Service excellent got a dirty plate but when asked the nice server to replace it boom no problem then followed up by a delicious pie read more

Sadly we have liked Enrico's for awhile. Last night got the menu, ordered to go and when we got the bill the prices were WAY different than the menu. We were told "oh sorry" "new prices". Ridiculous. Showed the menu we ordered from and how prices were different but nothing was done. When I say WAY different...IT WAS A LOT read more

This place is amazing !!! Down to the very last bit the food and everything , the service is fantastic and the music and atmosphere is perfect! I do recommend this place highly but I don't suggest to order from home after seeing the reviews , mainly a sit down place remember that ! Overall 10/10!! read more

We ordered meatballs and a meatball pizza to go. The meatballs were huge and delicious. The pizza was salty and delicious. My entire family enjoyed it. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Mamma mia! Had never been to Enrico's and now I'm sad that I've been missing out all of these years. While sitting in our car stuck in traffic in Islamorada, our hunger grew exponentially and so we decided to make a stop at Enrico's. I've seen it for years but had never actually been. We got a table outside and made a rather simple order: cheese pizza & a dozen garlic rolls. Our food arrived and just by looking at it I could tell that it was going to be delicious. And dang it was. The garlic rolls were so hot, garlicky, and the inside had soft, dense dough that complimented perfectly with the lightly crispy exterior. These were definitely some of my all-time favorite garlic rolls. The pizza was also some of the best -- perhaps the best -- I've ever had in South Florida. Lightly crispy crust, oozing delicious cheese. Phenomenal. Service was great. Food was amazing. This will be my go-to pizza place in the upper keys from now on! read more

This is a hard-working restaurant that features tasty Italian favorites. We loved the meatballs made from a family recipe. The pizza was good, but the crust has very little seasoning. Cannoli was okay, but the Key Lime pie was the best. Great service from start to finish. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Homemade meatballs. - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

If there were no stars that would be our rating. Horrible service. Young kids and they don't seem like the understand or listen. Salad was brown and old. Called to complain and young lady acted like an idiot. 6 times repeating that the salad was old and wanted a redelivery of the salad and kept saying they don't deliver under $20. Couldn't get it through her head that it is a reorder for fresh salad. Never again. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Salad from Enrico pizza totally old and gross - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Hands down some of the best pizza and mussels I've eaten while vacationing somewhere (and we always search out some good pizza!). Enrico's was so good we had to have it twice. The seating is outdoor and first come first serve with a few smaller booths/tables inside. Staff both times were super sweet, prompt, and professional. The first time there we ordered the small Boss (their supreme), Mussels Fra Diablo, and a kids pepperoni pizza. FYI the kids pizza is actually a 10in full size pizza. The second time we ordered the same just double mussels and a Caesar salad. The Boss was loaded with toppings and came out hot with a crisp bottom crust and the perfect amount of chew to the edge. Same goes for our sons pizza and he is super picky about his pizza. He begged us to go back and eat it again today before we left. The Mussels Fra Diablo were AMAZING!!! The amount of heat, basil, fennel, and garlic was perfection. I could eat them every single day! The portions were huge and one bowl is enough to share, but we didn't want to share the second time around. So we had to get our own. The Caesar salad is a large family sized portion as well and could be a whole meal or enough to share as an appetizer. Most definitely will recommend to my friends and family and will be back for more on our next vacay. Oh and the cutest family of peacocks live in the area! read more

See all

It's simple pizza nothing to write home about. Place was cute and super clean. Has seating inside and outside. Service was quick and he was polite. read more

We ordered 2 pizzas and 2 salads on a Monday at 5:15 for carry out and the order was messed up. One of our pizzas was completely wrong and although it was in a box with our name on it, I can only assume that our pizza was put into someone else's box by the pizza oven guy and we got theirs. The Caesar salads were about 25% spongey croutons (yuck) and the rest was the lettuce. The pizza was just ok and I probably would try somewhere else next time. Note: This place is very small and has very little seating so carryout and delivery are your best bets. read more

The pizza here was pretty good nothing out of the ordinary, was fairly priced and a convenient location. Also they have outdoor seating which was nice. The staff was amazing great service. They are very friendly and quick. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Menu cover - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Amazing food! Awesome service! If you're in the key largo area and are craving some good pizza, this is the place to go! Great outdoor sitting, masked up and clean, I felt safe. Garlic rolls are a must! And if you have some room left at the end, finish it with zeppoles. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - 1/2 Hawaiian 1/2 meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Best Pizza and Nicest People!!! We always stop on our way to and from Key West. Love Enrico's

Amazing food and service!!! Christina and everyone were very helpful and friendly! We tried the Ceasar salad for appetizer and a Margherita pizza and they were delicious and fresh! Margherita pizza was fabulous! For our main courses we had cheese ravioli with pink sauce ( there's an up charge, but it was totally worth it ), an amazing eggplant Parmesan, extremely recommended!!! and the primavera pasta with linguini, the best!!! For dessert, an amazing cheesecake! We were very satisfied with the food and service! We just found our best new place in Isla Morada!!! Thank you for such an amazing experience! I am sure grandpas are very proud of you !!! : ) read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

We tried ordering pizza for deliver. Had one random order show up at our door after an hour. Order was incorrect but it was late so we grabbed the pizza just to feed the kids. Had the actual order show up after an hour and a half. Quality of the food was below expectation and the service/timing of delivery were ridiculous. Better options in the area for delivery read more

Congratulations on making us comfortable to dine here during the Covid-19 pandemic! We sat outside and enjoyed an 18 inch Hawaiian pizza. It had super thin crust. That's good if it your preference as it was mine....less calories. The waitress wore a mask and masks were required in order to dine inside. We took precautions and put our masks on each time anyone passed by our table. Fortunately it wasn't very busy, that could have been annoying. The temperature outside was very tolerable with a cool breeze. The waitress was very personable and efficient. There was soft music playing outside at just the right volume. The only negative point was that the restaurant was on a busy highway. Many cars passing by made noise. It was also difficult going North when exiting the restaurant. All in all, thanks for an enjoyable experience. This was the first restaurant that we ate at since restaurants opened up after Covid-19. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Eating outside during Covid-19 - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

This was my go to Pizza Place in the Keys besides Tower of Pizza in Key Largo for over a year after it opened. However, something happened here in the last year and I am warning the owner, it will be the death of his business. I have lived in the Upper Keys for a long time and this same curse has plagued this location for over a decade (which also were all pizza places btw). When you remove the owners from the daily operation and put your trust in teenagers and under 25 year old brats, you business will take a death march every time. This is exactly what happened to Boardwalk and the other pizza place that was so bad, it's name is unmemorable (almost off the bat because of this same fatal error of trusting ungrateful kids to run the business in the ground). If you want to salvage the original reputation of this business (when the older owners still came to this operation several times a week) please get them back in person before this place closes. The garlic rolls and pizza used to be my favorite in the Keys, until the kids started taking over. Once better management and customer service returns, you will get the local support back and raise profits. But if you don't heed this advice, I am certain will be seeing a new business pop up here in the near future, which is the plague that seems to burden this location. Do not solely trust young people to keep your business afloat and please keep a hand in the daily operations. Thank you! read more

Visiting Islamorada and Enrico's is a great vibe! Ordered a simple cheese pizza, Caesar salad, and a glass of wine. It was all fantastic! I walked in and was greeted by such welcoming and friendly employees. The indoor is small, but they have a lovely outdoor area with plenty of nice seating and parking is easy. Loved it so much I went back two nights later and it was consistently great. I wish they had a location in Miami because I would go weekly! read more

We ordered takeout and it came within the time frame. The pizzas however were skimpy on toppings and the crust was dry.

I am a pizza snob, made pizzas in NY from starting in the back of a pizzeria at 13 to tossing pies at 15. Enrico's is delicious Pizza, I can tell it's fresh dough, quality mozzarella, tasty sauce (gravy). Just the correct amount of each, with fresh toppings. read more

Enrico's Pizza Islamorada - Enrico's - Pizza Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Some of you might know this pizza from the big chill. It's good at the big chill but even better here. Food always great. read more

See all

Very friendly service. The pizza is amazing there's really nothing else to say. It's not greasy so they definitely use good quality cheese, the crust is thin and crunchy, they don't put that much sauce and it's also homemade, and the garlic rolls are to die for. Honestly you really can't go wrong here. read more

See all

The food was awesome! The homemade mozzarella app was amazing. Meatballs like I make my own - meaning delicious and third third third : ) chicken parm and an eggplant app also very good. The reason I did not a rate 5 stars was a really small pour on the wine, no bread served (as an Italian it's a must) and a little slow on service. None of this will keep us from returning as the food was really outstanding. I'll just ask for bread and drink something else!!! read more

See all

This pizza was so good we came twice during our week long trip to the middle keys. The first time we stopped, it was because we were stopped in bumper to bumper traffic headed south. We probably wouldn't have seen it if we'd been going the normal speed! Both times we stopped by the wait staff was friendly and prompt. It was 5-ish in the evening both days and they weren't busy at all. We shared the caprese salad, truffle fries, and a meat lovers pizza. It was more than enough for the three of us and fantastic. Our second visit, we all got our own pizzas and were stuffed. We weren't able to try the desserts, though they sounded great! Something about the crust makes this pizza the best. We even saved the leftovers for a third meal. This will definitely be a regular stop on our trips to the Keys! read more

Great food - we had pizza, an Italian sandwich and some pasta... We had food delivered by Kendra...she was very warm and personable.... Great place for some very good pizza!! read more

We had the food delivered to the hotel we were staying in. They did not include a fork or napkins which I think is a pretty basic...especially for a customer in a hotel. Mediocre pizza...at best, and not even close to NY pizza. The Cesar salad would have been much better had it not been a finger food. read more

Delicious pizza. New York style. Our favorite in the keys. This is our Friday night spot.