Service is terrible. Hour and a half wait to be served after ordering. No apology until I was…read morepaying the bill, only rude "we're busy." Food was so-so, nothing fancy. Definitely not worth the wait or the lack of hospitality. Ordered shots at the bar and they were in a plastic container the size you would put Arby's sauce in. These were very difficult to drink out of. When I questioned, the bartender said she wasn't "going to be washing shot glasses all night."

Get those wings, the exterior looks sketchy but the wings oh the wings. My wife liked their pizza…read morecrust, not quite thin enough for me but still good and cooked so it wasn't doughy.

Food was fast and delicious and the service was very attentive. You could tell that some…read moreimprovements had recently been made.

Stopped in to look at the beautiful hotel and saw the desserts! Took home a piece of Kentucky…read moreBourbon pie! Amazing. Can wait to go back and have a full meal.

Always a great time and always on the list when I'm in Herkimer! Food is always delicious and the…read moreservice is friendly and attentive! Love the outdoor space and the indoors is adorable too! Thanks for kicking up the social scene in the Mohawk Valley!

Went to Stone Soup finally for the first time with a couple of friends. We loved the decor and I…read moreespecially loved the music; lots of Beatles! Our server was very nice and attentive. I got the pulled pork platter and especially liked the mac and cheese on the side! The coleslaw was also a good choice. My friends got a burger and the rigatoni al forno, with a margherita flatbread which was a special. I thought the prices were very reasonable as well! Looking forward to going back during the warmer months to eat in their outdoor area!

First I'd like to say a lot of the reviews here are very old. I think I read somewhere that the…read moreownership is fairly new - like 2025, so many of these reviews may not apply. I ate here with a friend a few weeks ago for lunch. The food and service were very good, I loved the decor - everything looks fresh and clean-just like the pictures displayed on the Yelp page. There were a couple of fun pictures of chickens. There is an outside eating area and drive thru. The prices seemed more than fair. My friend had a large beef club and I had a tuna melt. Instead of fries I had the macaroni salad. It was very tasty - definitely homemade. Also, there are cheesecakes for dessert. The outside picture doesn't do this place justice.

Growing up in the area 5s diner was always a good place to go, however the new staff at this…read morefacility is the only reason I won't be back. They definitely need a few lessons on how to deal with customers/customer service. Sighing loudly and being short when someone takes longer than a millisecond to tell them what they want, isn't the way to keep customers. I'll take my business to Maine St.

You will quickly find that St. Johnsville is very small and that there are not many restaurants on…read morethe Main Street in downtown. This place is more like a small town bar where all the locals come to have a beer or play pool. Being a tourist and having no other option to eat you come in here and are very pleasantly surprised about the food. The menu is a bar type of food menu. But everything we had was delicious. Some of the best wings ever: crunchy yet juicy and not greasy! The most popular flavor is their own creation: the cowboy flavor. Really good: tangy and not sweet. The bartender, a lady that looks like Kirsten Dunst, is super sweet!

They are so nice!! Chris was so welcoming and made the best burger in town. When we drove by and…read moremade hard eye contact with Chris through the door, we knew we found the perfect place to sit down for a good meal and cold drink. Beer, wings, and fries. What more do you need. Bartender was so sweet - could pass as Kirsten Dunst's long lost twin. Pool table was great. Unique music. Made us feel right at home - even invited us back for drinks!

Worst place in town. Went in as a customer and left feeling like family. Walked in and there was…read moreonly three people including the bartender. Makes the customers get their own drinks from the fridge?? Now Dan waves at me every time I drive by and I can no longer pretend I don't know my neighbors. Zero stars.

My FAV place for a drink and a good time with old friends.. the vibes are high, chairs are squishy,…read moregreat merch

Very good service.. clean and friendly atmosphere...food was fantastic and well done... absolutely…read morewonderful....been going here my entire life... keep up the good work

Folks, KC's closed the restaurant a few years ago. The hotel is still open and my brother and I…read morestay here every year for the opening weekend of deer season. Great people that we love supporting when we can. Miss the breakfasts.

The burger was charred and there was absolutely no seasoning or passion in there food…read more i see why this is a hot spot among the seniors also the cheese fries are not cheese fries

I ordered a hot turkey sandwich. Two thick slices of bread with canned gravy and dried chunks of…read moreturkey. Very, very salty. Ate about a third and tossed the rest. Such an easy, inexpensive dish to make properly with homemade gravy and thinly sliced turkey. Ice cream is good though.

Everything about this was excellent...til it wasn't. Overall, our experience was positive. Food was…read more(for the most part) good and it was a nice atmosphere. First disappointment was that entrees come with a choice of soup or salad. It was Caesar salad or tomato soup- both of which contained dairy so I couldn't have either and was not offered another option. The salmon was excellent but 2 bites in I realized the rice was partly crunchy. Told the server and was not offered a new portion or another option. Then coffee comes and upon pouring the cream in, it immediately separated. Was at least brought another cup. Then the bill comes and NOTHING was comped. Now, any one of these experiences would have perhaps been a minor inconvenience but you add up all three and I would have minimally appreciated an $8 dessert comped on an almost $200 bill. Would probably not be back.

First time there....no idea why we never went there before. It was awesome!!!…read moreWent on a Monday night...who would have thought they would be open. The food was awesome, bartender and waitress were incredible. Atmosphere was top notch beautiful place. Go there.