Lunch on the big, comfy porch of swell country house loaded…read morewith history and character. Overlooks quaint, old-timey golf course with great views down lake and hills towards Cooperstown. Really tasty, different, super-fresh salads, sandwiches and deserts. Friendly, efficient staff.

From the owner: Simple fresh sandwiches using seasonal and locally inspired produce. Our goal is to serve great…read morefood in a low key and relaxed atmosphere.

So, we found this place off a reddit thread when re-calibrating our itinerary-- plans had shifted…read moredue to being whelmed by Red Shed Brewing (our fault, they were likely out of a lot due to their Fall Fest which we hadnt known was happening), and another mildly annoying mix-up--after dinner plans got scuppered on Saturday and we decided to check them out. Summary: a lovely night out with good food and lovely ambiance and service, but my socks weren't blown off like other reviewers' were. The review: We were able to call the day before and get a reservation for 2 people at 7:30, and when we showed up, we loved the quaint, cozy renovated old home vibe. It's a modestly upscale restaurant in Cherry Valley, NY, another of the cute small towns in Upstate NY. We did get a couple of the daily specials, so I don't know how truly indicative of the vibes and regular food this review will be. Drinks: I really liked my Manhattan. However, my wife's cocktail, a daily special that we can't remember the name of, was almost cloyingly sweet and had an artificial caramel taste that overpowered the drink for her. We loved our spicy (they had to call it as such for liability purposes, the only spicy thing on the plate was the "medium" spicy salsa accompaniment) Beef Empanadas and Crab cake main. Entrees: to be honest, my seared duck breast special needed a little more grits, definitely a few more brussels, a smidge less sauce (it was balsamic-y an kind of over-powering) and a pass with pepper or something just give it a little bite. The duck was wonderfully tender and the grits were great. My wife also found her Ahi Tuna main nice and fresh but also a bit whelming. When we next find ourselves in Cooperstown, we might pop back up the Cherry Valley and come here. But, simultaneously who knows if our schedules will allow that.

The fish is fantastic. The staff are very friendly and helpful in helping you decide your meal…read more Nothing like eating A meal in a room that could be your grandmother's parlor or living room.

Food was fast and delicious and the service was very attentive. You could tell that some…read moreimprovements had recently been made.

Stopped in to look at the beautiful hotel and saw the desserts! Took home a piece of Kentucky…read moreBourbon pie! Amazing. Can wait to go back and have a full meal.

We eat out often. We came to Fancy Farmer tonight and had an excellent meal - the prime rib was…read moreamazing! The service was good, and my cocktai was very good. We highly recommend this place and we will be back!

Hello Fancy Farmer! Long time listener, first time caller…read more Heard about this place many of times. Finally got to experience this buffet. I'm mixed about this review. Arrived about 6pm. Food was very tasty and well prepared. It was not hot. I didn't really mind so much because it was good. And I was hungry. Salad bar potion of the buffet was mostly empty. Little disappointed in that. Service to our table and bar tender were very friendly and on point. The restaurant itself was very nice and had a great atmosphere. I will be back and hopefully have a five star experience and review to follow.

Always a great time and always on the list when I'm in Herkimer! Food is always delicious and the…read moreservice is friendly and attentive! Love the outdoor space and the indoors is adorable too! Thanks for kicking up the social scene in the Mohawk Valley!

I would put six stars if I could. The service was very quick, and the staff were super nice. The…read morescallops were the best we've ever had. The Brussel sprouts - delish. We were not expecting such good food from such a little town. This rivals some of the best restaurants we've tried in New York City and we will be coming back to try the other dishes on the menu!

We have never had a bad meal. We typically do a Sunday breakfast run before taking our bikes on a…read moreride (or heading back home in the winter). The service id fast and efficient. It doesn't matter if we call our order in, or sit in the back room overlooking the amazing view, we always have a pleasant experience. We recommed any of their Benedicts (although I'm a sucker for corned beef). Coffee is delicious and the muffins are moist!

The experience at the Diner was Fantastic the food & staff was so good i will be back with friends…read moreand family thank you. John Walcesky

The Glimmerglass at the Otesaga Hotel in Resort in Cooperstown is a throwback to the old style…read moreelite hotel dining. Unfortunately, it is no longer appreciated for it's greatness as times have changed. As a Resort Guest, I had the breakfast option which was a great choice to enjoy such elite dining on premises. Convenient and top notch. In the times I visited (July 2021) it was trailing to the end of the COVID nightmare (but before Delta) and the buffet was open and full quality was there. About all a guest could notice was the diligent wearing of masks by staff. The buffet was as good as you can get. Full fruit and Continental options, or hot eggs, meats, potatoes, biscuits, and gravy. And eggs/omelets made to order. The only drawback was that I didn't want to over eat to start the day. needed a second stomach. Upon sitting the wait staff gets any drink you need (coffee/juices) as part of my breakfast included price. I was only brought a check at the end for a gratuity. Some uneven service getting to drinks quickly but it wasn't hard to get their attention if needed. There is a fancy dining room (I dropped a couple of photos) and a nice outdoor patio facing the lake. The outdoor seemed to fill up first albeit the weather was near perfect so can't blame. A point of confusion was logistics and dress code. Upon check in, the desk clerk let me know where it was and strongly advised a reservation and let me know it was fine dining and dress code was appreciated. Not knowing what time I wanted to eat I called late and no answer. I called restaurant services when I woke up and was forwarded to the casual dinner restaurant. I called the desk and had them transfer me, same as just calling, forwarded to casual not answered. No worry, I arrived and they had the guests on a list and it wasn't crowded enough to be an issue. Other thing was dress code. Some things I'd read in the literature was no sports gear, no hats, etc. Since most of the patrons were at the hotel for recreation (kids baseball tournaments, Hall of Fame, etc.) I didn't think wearing a T-shirt and tennis shoes would be an issue. It wasn't. Just don't wear swimwear. At the time I went it was breakfast only. If and when it opens for dinner do not listen to this advice and discuss with the management. Really nothing wrong here, can't withhold even a star. If you stay here, eat here. If the cost is too much, then find a place in your range but you won't beat the quality. This buffet was as good as it gets.

Timeless elegance of a bygone era paired with impeccably charming and attentive service and…read moreexceptional cuisine. Real silverware. And the VIEWS! Every angle provides a feast for the eyes. I absolutely adore this place.

Absolutely fabulous! We popped into Double Day Cafe for lunch on Saturday after a LONG morning at…read morethe baseball fields, and we were so happy to get seated right away. We just ordered burgers and fries, but they were fantastic. Great food, great atmosphere, and exactly what we needed after a morning of baseball. And Karen was absolutely wonderful! She was the exact opposite of the definition of a "Karen." She was smiling, welcoming, genuinely excited to have us there, and just an absolute joy. Then there was the Long Island Iced Tea. After spending the entire morning at the baseball field and heading into the afternoon, YES, I needed one! Stephan made it, and I have to say, it was probably one of the best Long Island Iced Teas I've ever had. Phenomenal! So, if you're looking for a place in Cooperstown to grab a great meal, have a good drink, and get a little much-needed mental health time after baseball, this is your place! Thank you, Double Day Cafe, for knocking it out of the park! Great food, great drinks, and even better people. We'll definitely be back! If you want a good meal and good drinks in Cooperstown, come here!

Update on my review...returned for dinner. OMG BBQ Saturday so good. Soups are all made in-house…read moreby the owner. NE clam chowder was awesome, French onion sooo good. We ordered 4 briskets and 2 steaks, all knocked it out of the park. Service was outstanding! Def come for dinner!! Had about a 20 minute wait for a table, not bad at all. Cute restaurant decent service went for breakfast, food was very good. I will say that their coffee is terrible, sorry just terrible cup of coffee. Corn beef cash was delicious ,really good cinnamon bun, nice bloody Mary and mimosa and very good omelette. If they got better coffee, it would be a home run.

Love their beet burgers!! My go to selection also their…read morestaff is friendly and professional. Great choice for some eating pleasure

We were seated quickly, and our server started off strong--she was friendly, attentive while taking…read moreour order, and offered great suggestions. She offered to bring out a couple dipping sauces for our fries, and I asked for the bourbon jelly, which she was willing to do. That initial interaction set a great tone. The food itself was very good--both burgers were delicious. Unfortunately, after we placed our order, the service dropped off completely. We waited about an hour for our food, with no check-ins, no water refills, and no acknowledgment of the delay, even though our server walked past our table multiple times. At one point, I had to get up and find someone to talk to. I asked a man near the front for a manager, explained we had been waiting an hour, and pointed out our table. No one ever came over afterward to follow up. We were later told there was a large party, which is understandable--but that's not something customers or servers can control. A simple check-in or acknowledgment would have made a big difference. Instead, we were told we "should have said something," despite no one coming to the table. At the end, we waited again for the check, and when my daughter calmly tried to explain our frustration, the server spoke over her and said, "I'm almost 50--I've been doing this since I was 17," which came across as rude and unprofessional. The food was good, but the lack of communication, attentiveness, and management involvement made this a disappointing experience.

Sweet sweet spot to spend a night, or more. Clean. Very comfy. Quiet. Scenic route, worth the trip…read more Great water pressure, & very good water for drinking too!

The Meadowlark Inn is a surprising gem in upstate New York. The rooms are spacious, clean and…read morecomfortable. The giant backyard is fun for kids to play in or to gather. But the real gem is the proprietor, Austin. He made us feel so at home and went above and beyond to ensure our stay was memorable. He made waffles for all the guests and even went out and bought gluten free waffles for me. This really is more of a charming Bed and Breakfast instead of a roadside motel. I would recommend the Meadowlark to anyone looking to stay in the area.