I love everything about this place! Extremely comfortable feeling, decor is super fun, Victoria is the best. My eyelashes are beautiful and mascara free. Denise Rimmer. read more

I've been a few times; I like the product (lash extensions and the look of them), but twice now I was up-charged without any communication this was going to happen. And 3/4 appointments took longer than was scheduled, also no communication that this was happening during the appointment. I wouldn't be so bothered if the tech (Victoria) informed me that this was happening, but there was no communication. Seeing the extra cost, alongside the fact that I'm getting up from the table realizing I'm 15-30 minutes later than I anticipated because the appointments took so long, left me feeling too frazzled to say something in the moment. This was my first lash experience and I appreciate her demeanor and like the lashes, but not the experience. read more

My first time trying a new lash place in forever so I was nervous but Victoria was so welcoming! I felt at ease the entire time & was absolutely in love with the results. Thank you!! read more

can't say enough AMAZING things about eye candy! Victoria is absolutely amazing and so welcoming! she makes you feel so comfortable during your tan and during lashes! they always say why have a therapist when you have your lash person! it's so true! absolutely love this place! read more

Best time ever with Victoria! She made it fun and very cozy . The out come of my eyelashes are perfect. Absolutely love them . The shop is so cute and I will keep going back to them for sure . read more

Great lash extensions from Taylor! Super accommodating to adjustments in planned look and overall a great experience. Plus they look great! read more

Victoria did a fabulous lash lift and tint for me. She was very friendly and explains every step so you know what to expect!

I couldn't find enough reviews about the microblading brow service I was going in with but there's been nothing but positive feedback on customer service and lashes and we dove right in. Victoria was fantastic and not only answered all questions but actively accepted my input on how I wanted the results - it's only been a day out but she was detail oriented. Flexible when I needed a change within respect to their expectations. Friendly. I am excited to see the results as the healing process is completed. read more

Beautiful, comfortable lashes! Exactly what I was looking for. Cute space, professional and clean.

I wish I read these reviews. I would give a zero if i could. Do NOT go here. I saw nicky. She was nice enough and the lashes looked nice upon completion hit this isnt about bedside manner. So what's the problem? She asked me if I wanted lashes that are grouped together to look fuller instead of the one on one lash. I said absolutely not. I want single lashes. The clusters really bother my eye lids for some reason. They downright hurt and feel like they are poking my lids. Despite the fact that I told her those hurt me- she put them on anyway and mixed some single lashes in there. So for the next couple of weeks I dealt with swollen and goopy eyes. Not only that but they fanned out in every direction ...up down left and right. I asked for a natural look and I looked like a fool instead. Worse, they HURT. I've never been to a place that has glued them above and below and in the middle of my lashes. This absolutely destroyed my nature lash. Something else worth noting is when the lashes were being applied my eyes burned from what smelled like acetone on her fingers. I will never be back and I warn anyone to reconsider stepping foot here. read more

Eye candy was able to get me booked for a spray tan right away - I had a big event and my regular spray tan artist was out of town, they were professional and the store was really cute! I am giving three stars because the spray tan just didnt look good. It was heavy looking in some areas the next day and blotchy. I get regular spray tans so I know how to do the after care. I think they might just need a new formula or maybe i got the bottom of the barrel. read more

I absolutely LOVE my new lashes and Victoria! I felt welcome as soon as I walked in. Victoria is very easy to talk to and I enjoyed meeting her. The lashes are beautiful and so natural. I would recommend Eye Candy Beauty & Boutique to anyone and everyone!! read more

first of all the website is very misleading about the prices, second of all I payed $235 for a full set of volume lashes, I've never paid that much for any volume set before. I would understand if the lashes looked great and I got great service but there was nothing special about them to have them be that much. I would have had NO problem paying the $235 if it is what i had ASKED FOR. I asked for full volume , The lashes were not full volume Or long at all, they were all the same length all across , very Short and straight across. she asked me did I want the lashes as long as possible& i said YES, and when I open my eyes I was very disappointed to see that it looks like a classic set. also not to mention the fact that the whole set fell out in less than a week, and I get my lashes done so I know how to take care of them and I've never had a full set of lashes fall out in one week before. Moral of the story, ASK for pictures of there work and set names. Don't go here looking for volume , only expect simple Classic sets here. yes they're very friendly& Nice but very misleading and feel like I got completely Robbed . Do not know what they're doing. read more

Been going to eye candy lashes for the last two months. Awful experience. Didn't take me until actually going to a CERTIFIED eyelash extension esthetician to know that Eye Candy lashes was destroying my natural lashes. Was attaching eye lashes with a tooth pick, and on to split bases which is what gives you corneal abrasions. Please, if you know what's good for yourself you will pay for quality lashes and service from a certified lash esthetician. read more

I am so pleased with my experience here! First of all, the hours are so incredibly accommodating if you work a 9-5 job. I had come in with extensions on already from somewhere else that were giving me a lot of problems. Mindy did an amazing job transforming them. I love the results and cannot wait to return! read more

First, the positive. They are very nice ladies and it's easy to make an appointment. The lashes look amazing for the first two days. Having said that... Don't go to this salon. Don't buy the groupon. Pay the $$$ for the salon down the street. I hate to write a bad review, but I've unsubscribed to their newsletter several times and it just keeps coming. Today it said this, "Do lash extensions cause damage to my natural lashes?Here's our answer: Properly applied extensions will NOT cause damage to your natural lashes." This is true. This is not the service you will receive here. Both my friend and I went before a girls weekend. The lashes looked great on Friday and Saturday. On Sunday and subsequent days the lashes hurt. They pulled and itched. Why? Because they used an EXCESSIVE amount of glue. They don't glue 1 extension to 1 lash. They chunk them all together. Then, when your natural lashes start to grow in they get pulled out by the root. I texted the technician and she recommended removing the lashes with baby oil. This doesn't work. I tried baby oil, olive oil, coconut oil. Steaming my lashes first. Eventually I had to make an appointment to have them removed which was very painful and I was charged an additional $45. Here's the thing, even the technician couldn't get all the lashes off. She had to cut the remaining lengths and told me they would eventually fall off when I lost the lash. My lashes were sparse, straggly and trimmed except for the few bold extensions that remained. The entire experience left me traumatized. I would not recommend this salon to anyone. I've used a different lash salon in Monona before. They did a terrific job of the 1 lash to 1 extension, and they were easy to remove. I was seduced by the groupon and assumed I would receive a similar service. Spend the money for a more experienced technician. read more

Love this place! I have tried two other lash salons in Madison and was unhappy with both and I finally found Eye Candy and they are amazing! My lashes look phenomenal and they have great prices. The girls who do the lashes are personable and friendly as well as knowledgable. The salon is clean and very cute! Extremely happy with my experience here and I will definitely keep coming back! read more

This was my first time getting lash extensions so I was a little nervous. Mindy was great! She explained everything that she was doing and made sure that I was very comfortable. My lashes look great! I feel so pretty and I'm not even wearing make-up! read more

Amazing customer service, quality and price! I've been wanting eyelash extensions forever and after only one visit I'm hooked! Keep up the good work ladies! read more

I got a full set of lashes put on in February 2016 before an extended vacation. I was very surprised that after a full month of not having a fill, my lashes still looked great! The only reason I have not returned is because they keep raising the prices. When I had them placed, I only paid $75 (which is average in the area)....but a full set is now $120 (according to their site). I would be happy to return if they did not keep jacking up the price. read more

Staff is welcoming, the salon is clean and relaxing, and I've gotten so many compliments on my lashes! One of my best friends couldn't even tell they were artificial. She just kept staring at my "gorgeous thick lashes!" Mindy is great, and I can't wait to go back. Oh, and the boutique has the cutest clothes! read more

I have had my eyelash extensions for the last 6 months and decided to take them out, because I felt like they getting shorter. Sure enough my regular eyelashes which were longer than average to start with were merely millimeters long now. So I'm very annoyed I wasted tons of money for someone to ruin my eyelashes. I'm just hoping they grow back and the damage isn't permanent. Even though they were very nice to talk to they obviously don't know how to correctly do them or they wouldn't be so damaging to your eyelashes. Both the person who referred me and I both had severe damage our eyelashes! read more

I had my lashes done today with Victoria! I love them and she did a great job. Friendly, professional, great value, nice atmosphere, very sanitary and lastly I look like a million bucks! ;-) read more

Wonderful lashes and very satisfied! Mindy did a great job adding them to my lashes and fully explaining the care and maintenance of them.

I bought a Groupon first then after reading the other reviews on Yelp I was at first afraid to go. Their Groupon reviews were great however. So I did research online about what reasonable expectations are and the person who provided services to me at Eye Candy answered all of my questions to my satisfaction. In Wisconsin, providers are only required to have a cosmetology license. The person who applied my extensions had that plus additional training and certification in eyelash extension application. I received numerous compliments on my lashes from friends as well as from estheticians I see for other treatments and even from some strangers I met while shopping and I heartily recommend Eye Candy lashes. Their Groupon deal is amazing and their regular prices are average or slightly below average for this area. When I had my refills done there, I looked at my natural lashes after the loose extensions were removed and before the new ones put on, and my natural lashes looked like they had before. But I think to expect that there be no temporary loss of length or strength after having extensions applied to head hair, lashes or fingernails for an extended period of time is unreasonable and magical thinking. There are those in the area who charge double for lash extensions( 200 dollars for the initial application) nearby and maybe one time i will try them out to see if there really is a big difference but I suspect that other than using a more expensive raw material there is little difference in the technique of application and removal. read more

Although these ladies are very kind and fun, I had the worst experience ever from the lashes they put on. I got my original lash set from eye candy and the two fills they offer with the groupon they always run, in which they stacked my lashes so badly I spent 6 hours and $400 on a table with someone experienced in lashes for 10+ years, who had to literally chunk my lashes off because they were one solid band of glue globbed together. I have pictures.. It was super painful and anxiety provoking, and alllll of my real lashes were DEAD! There were maybe 4 or five left per eye and they were all different lengths. My eyes were red and swollen for days after. I had to buy a lash serum to start growing them again. Lashes are meant to be 1 extension per natural lash. There were gads of lashes coming off 1 natural lash The crazy part was, they looked good, but they were a freaking nightmare. The lady (w/10 years experience) who I went to for a simple fill, looked at me and said "what do you want me to do with these. I've never in all my years doing this have seen anything like this". Since it was my first set, I had no idea... Thank god she was able to get them off when she did. Please be carefull and selective about who you go to for lashes because getting them off after a bad lash job is not fun. It hurts, and it can be pretty pricy. These girls are very nice, they need to do some more training... read more