I had this place twice while I was at a hotel for a week. The eggplant pizza was amazing and the pizza was just like the pizza in New York. I haven't had real pizza like this in a very long time. read more

I ordered through a delivery app. The delivery was fine. The pizza was not well packaged and had slopped around in the box a good bit before it was delivered to me. It could have been the drivers fault, but the restaurant should have taped the box closed, if for no other reason than the fact that anyone could have picked all my toppings off, which is maybe why the pizza looked so skimpy. It was a gluten-free pie, and the crust tasted like chewing rubber soled shoes, the $1.99 each toppings were hardly noticeable, and the cheese was in one chunk on one side of the pizza. I will not order from here again. read more

$20 will get you a grilled chicken salad that has no chicken & a mountain of melted mozzarella cheese. had to throw the thing away because it was a melted brick of cheese and 1 slice of pepperoni pizza. pizza wasn't bad at all. wish i could get my money back for the salad tho, such a waste. employee who brought out the food was nice. read more

The best pizza in the county. I have been on a mission to find a good pizza place since moving to the area. The chains and others in the area I won't name, are fine but I did not feel the need to go back for more. As soon as I picked up the box to take out, I knew it was going to be good. I had to fight the urge to open it up and devour a slice on the way home. We ordered pizza, pasta, garlic knots and salad. Everything was correctly made ( I made a couple of requests when ordering) and SO GOOD! The staff was friendly, quick to greet us upon entry and our order was ready when we arrived. You have made a new loyal customer today. Excellent job! read more

Couldn't figure out what I wanted to eat but I knew I wanted pizza. I'm not from Charlottesville so when I searched for the best pizza spots, Fabio's was 3. Based on prices compared to the other two, I went with Fabio's. Upon arriving I can tell this place was pretty popular. I ordered a medium NY style pizza with pepperoni and sausage and a steak and cheese combo. The steak and cheese is surprisingly good. It was extremely hot on the inside so be careful when you bite into it. The flavors were good, my only issue was the bread was soggy I hate soggy bread so less juices when placing the meat onto the bread. The pizza was ok. No different than any other NY style pizza place. I honestly think I could use more flavoring. My date on the other hand thought it was great. All and all, if I'm in Charlottesville, I will probably eat here again. read more

See all

Average is the only fair way to describe this pizza, and that may be being generous. The dough was tough and the sauce to cheese ratio didn't work very well. I got the veggie pizza, and I'll not go as far as to call it bad, but it was a pretty far cry from good. If you're going to try this place, probably at least order something other than that. I don't like being hard on pizza places. I've worked at a few and I know how it goes. But even so, it's my opinion that you've got to do a better job on the food than what we got if you want many repeat customers. read more

Ordered a grilled chicken salad and a 5 topping Sicilian pizza. Salad was large enough for two people. Unfortunately, it had too many brown pieces of lettuce for me to eat it. The chicken in it was tasty but the ranch dressing was gross! The pizza had fresh toppings but was very bland. It was our first time here and I'm not sure we'll return. Overall, I'm disappointed for $23 I thought it would be better. I would've appreciated fresh salad. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

My husband was craving pizza so ordered delivery from Fabio's NY Pizza! We got a large NY style with pepperoni and mushroom for ~$16 - lots of yummy gooey cheese and toppings. The dough was not consistently thin/thick (good thin crust on some of the outer parts but too thin in some middle areas where it wouldn't hold the cheese/toppings which would then slide off); however, it was nicely chewy, and the crusts were great to dip in ranch dressing. The large pizza is roughly 8 slices so we had leftovers for the next day. For dessert, we ordered the zeppole - large serving of fried dough balls lightly covered in sugar and topped with Nutella (which I'm very partial to); it was soo good that we finished the whole thing! Overall, satisfying meal - we were missing one of our sodas but totally get that it can get crazy during these times. read more

Best pizza in Charlottesville. It's definitely NY style. Fabio's is my new favorite restaurant.

Did pick up on a Friday night. The XL pizzas were large and the toppings were generous. However, after living in NYC for over a decade we were very confused why this is labeled "NY pizza." Decent pizza but doesn't even begin to compare to the type of thin, crispy NY style that we'd assumed it would be. Ok pizza and good value if you use the Charlottesville attractions coupon book. read more

We enjoyed the food. Great chicken Caesar salad . Pizza was good not great. We did carry out. Service was fine for pick up

Never got my pizza! Ordered Grubhub, driver delivered half of the order, said that was all he picked up at Fabio's. Called Fabio's and they claimed driver picked up the full order. It became a "he said she said" contest. Young lady at Fabio's said she'd deliver missing pizza. Never happened. Would have been better just to tell me I was S.O.L. laugh and hang up!Never again Fabio's, there's lots of other pizza joints in Charlottesville! The Lopez family read more

I typically go to gordonsville (Fabio's) for a steak and cheese sub, because I didn't know Charlottesville had one. Wednesday of last week I posted a pic on fb of the sub I ordered from the Gordonsville store. All my friends told me that I was wasting my time and gas going all the way there when all I needed to do was take a 10 min drive to east high street. Yesterday 3/09/2020 I made that trip. I'll be making another trip TODAY 3-10-2020 & again 3-11-2020 and most likely 3-12-2020 to order me that SAME FOOTLONG STEAK AND CHEESE SUB w/ fries and a drink. I'm obsessed now thanks Facebook friends. ‍‍‍‍ read more

Wings and garlic bread is good. Pizza is good but the bottom was kinda burnt, not true NY style pizza. The staff was super super nice ! Would go back if i needed a quick slice read more

They have a take out hut with people who can't seem to communicate or provide customer service. Was given buzzer that didn't work. Showed up to pick up pizza after it was supposedly ready and waited 20 mins. When we got it, pizza was cold and barely cooked. Place has been going down hill for a while. read more

I grew up in suburban NJ and have struggled to find pizza that comes close to the pizza I knew growing up. For the 5 years my husband and I lived in Maryland, we never found anything that was good and knew when we moved to Charlottesville, we would probably struggle. My husband actually spotted Fabio's the weekend we were moving in, and a couple weeks later we decided to order for delivery just to try it out. The pizza was outstanding. Is it exactly the pizza I knew growing up? No, but it's pretty damn close. We have also ordered the Sicilian which was SO good and way more reasonably priced than I had ever had anywhere else. We love Fabio's pizza and it is the only place we will ever order from! read more

Great Staff first off .Im in the biz & these guys & gi really hustle and are super friendly Bravo Pizza is great I prefer to eat in but the take out is great too. Disclaimer : don't order slices they are too busy with the drive thru & delivery side and slices don't do their pie justice :reheated Pizza Sandwiches are solid and well priced and portioned I've tried meatball sausage & cheesesteaks Wifey got eggplant parm wasn't bad bud I jazzed it up with a little extra sauce cheese from my fridge & alls well Great People & Good Food ! read more

Ordered an XL deluxe with no extra cheese. The pizza had no cheese on it at all, it was soggy, it was cold. It was disgusting. The place is ran by teenagers on the weekend. Please train your employees to count change. It's no excuse that they're new or under pressure. That's a very poor leadership and setting them up to fail. Interesting my neighbor got a pizza the same day and she said the pizza was not good. I'm not returning. read more

The Margherita pizza is the real deal!! Solid slice of NY plain pie and maybe the beast garlic knots I've ever had. I will definitely be back for more pizza and to try the cheesesteak. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Margherita medium pie - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Delicious NY style thin crust pizza. It's a simple but awesome pizza. My favorite in Charlottesville!

Best pizza I've had in Charlottesville. They're reasonably priced and there pickup is super quick and well organized.

This pizza is all about the crust! It's perfectly crispy, even better in the toaster oven the next day. Loaded with toppings. Will definitely keep this in the delivery rotation! read more

Such good Sicilian style think crust pizza! They're right up the road from us and we'll be ordering in them again soon. Loaded with toppings but still was a crispy crust with loads of flavor! read more

Fabios on Pantops is amazing. I have a standard thing I get. I usually order through GrubHub but I had a driver steal my meal...grrrrr...but I digress... I get their grilled chicken salad. It's awesome. As an appetizer I get their fried mushrooms (yummy) and their fried mozzarella sticks. They changed their recipe recently on the breading and it's fantastic. I love their salads because they're big and generous and usually takes me two days to eat it (2 meals.) Great small business with terrific staff. Love them! read more

Best deep dish pizza in Charlottesville! Best calzone and Stromboli ever....It's hard to find a good Stromboli and calzone and Charlottesville and definitely you will never find a deep dish pizza read more

The pizza was good and the Tiramisu was outstanding. However the panini was soggy and the lasagna under par. We'll stick with pizza and Tiramisu next time. read more

If you're from up top (if you know you know) best place to get a NY slice in C'ville. Hot, fresh and foldable. Shout out to Diane the manager. She is awesome. read more

Really awesome pizza!! First pizza delivery place we used since moving here a year ago. Great surprise!! I agree with another reviewer who said this was better than most pizza in DC. read more

Best pizza and the garlic knots are delicious. I always order meat lovers and cheese pizza and some garlic knots. Pizza is delicious, but my favorite part is preheating it the next day. Taste amazing. read more

Really great pizza, nice people and local. Why would anyone go anywhere else for great pizza?

Best real pizza in town. Best cheesesteaks in town. Guys behind the counter are always friendly and move quick. Pies always come with a lot of cheese(not too much) and they have the good amoroso rolls for their subs. Never had their deep dish but it looks dope -- will update. read more

Great food and great service. Best pizza in Charlottesville. Ordered pizza extra crispy and was delicious.

Awesome pizza! Their thick crust (the square pizza) has the most flavorful dough! It also is very filling so you don't need as big of a pizza! Would highly recommend and will be ordering from here again read more

Superb Ny Style Pizza !! Best crust in Cville, hands down. My kids normally are picky about pizza especially the sauce, but they crushed this pizza in record time. And an XL 2-topping for $16 is a solid price. Oh and Great job on the contactless pickup, it was super fast and easy. Will be back for sure! read more

This is my favorite pizza place in town. If you just want a simple cheese pizza, this, IMO, has everyone else beat. Staff can be somewhat iffy sometimes but the product itself never disappoints. Garlic knots aren't bad either but stay away from the fried mushrooms. Worst I've ever had. You just gotta know what's good here. Don't trust it all but their pizzas you can rely on to be good. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Excellent food, fair prices and friendly staff. You get a lot of food for the price. Nice family environment and very Italian indoors love it. Definitely coming back here again. read more

I grew up in Jersey so I'm a pizza snob. Fabio's is about as close to NY/NJ pizza you can find in CVA. For tonight, we ordered the Hawaiian (to which I cannot speak because I grew in in NJ), a sausage pizza, and a margherita pizza. The two I had were superb. Sausage was thick with cheese and toppings, while the margherita was thinner. The people who run Fabio's have always been extremely nice. If you need takeout during quarantine or you want to support a pizza place that isn't a national chain, give them a shot. read more

Small pizza place but it was very good eating. Service was helpful as well. Has both indoor and outdoor seating which is always nice when the weather is good. read more

Excellent NY Style Pizza! Highly recommend. Great taste, great customer service. During Covid-19 they are taking all measures and have a patio. Definitely now our go-to for pickup, delivery or casual patio dining! read more

Fantastic visit! Everything was wonderful! This was our first visit and we will definitely be back! Customer service was outstanding! Pizza was the best we've ever had. We stopped at this place not knowing anything about it, and we were very pleased! read more