Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fantasy Cupcake

    4.4 (84 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Fantasy Cupcake Photos

    FANTASY CUPCAKE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fantasy Cupcake

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos - Fantasy Cupcake

    Chocolate on Chocolate!!!
    Brit B.

    My favorite cupcake place in the world! This place has the best cupcakes I've ever tasted and they are FRESH!! I'm talking baked every morning fresh and what they don't sale they give away to the church . Sprinkles in San Diego, CA has nothing on Fantasy ! I wish I could eat them everyday but they're only open 3 days a weeks so I have to control my habit.

    Lemon Poppyseed and Wedding Cake Cupcakes
    Sarah Y.

    I have used Fantasy Cupcake for many custom orders for events. Always easy to work with and friendly. Just place your orders far enough in advance. The lemon poppyseed cupcake is THE GOAT. They have lots of gluten free options and they are all wonderful. I am pretty sure I have tried every GF cupcake and coffee cake options they have. I do love the cinnamon coffee cake as well. Be prepared to pay top dollar for gluten free custom orders. It ain't cheap but it's worth the money. You get what you pay for. This is a great local establishment.

    Cupcake offerings! (5/11/2019)
    Gwen W.

    My first review was closer to their initial opening, I can say with certain that they've developed into a great local sweets shop/catering business! Their name is out and about, especially around the Canal/Pickerington area. I've been to several events on the southeast side of Columbus that are sporting Fantasy's cupcakes. Yes, their cake batter is moist and flavorful. The icing used is made from scratch, light and they don't douse the cupcakes with icing - a personal pet peeve. A wonderful treat! Their new location, three doors down from their old, much-to-small, space is great: tall ceiling, white and brick walls, a nice serving counter that incorporates several display cases; several tables and chairs line the opposite wall. Their gluten free offerings are in a separate area, which keeps stuff apart so no cross-contamination. The only thing holding me back from giving 5 stars? Their cupcakes are small for the price. Yes, the icing is quality and tastes great, but the physical cake part does not justify over $3.

    Storefront
    Nelson B.

    This place is on the main historical strip and has easy parking. The coffee is really good, the cupcakes are tasty and the staff is friendly. I would recommend this place if you're looking for a local coffee spot.

    Nijole T.

    Cute store, I was so happy to discover there is a cupcake place in Columbus I hadn't tried yet. Their hours are generous, until 8pm so perfect for and after work drive to Canal Winchester. I got there at about 5 pm and they still had all flavors left, about 10 in all plus 3 different kinds of cake pops. The cupcakes are $3 each and pretty big, the cake pops $1.50. They look beautiful and it was again a tough choice but I managed to cover all the bases with only getting half a dozen. The highlights were buckeye and blueberry lemon. Buckeye is always a winner in my book and had the best frosting out of all of them. Lemon Blueberry a yummy lemon candy on top and good blueberry filling. All of the cakes could have been more sweet, it tasted like they forgotthe sugar in the cake batter completly and put it in the frosting instead. Maybe if I wouldn't have treid the bottoms first and then had the tops with only half the cake it would have been better. The frosting was way too sweet ( thats saying alot since nothing is ususally too sweet for me), so sweet in fact it had crucnchy sugar cristals in it, not so good. I had banana split, salted caramel, birthday cake and snickerdoodle, all sound and looked fantastic, the only flavor I got though was the too much sugar and nothing much else. I hope they work on the cupcakes, because the looks and cute shop are they just the taste not on par with alot of other options In Columbus.

    Cupcakes, cakepops, cookies! What more could a sweet tooth want!
    Hannah M.

    My favorite cupcakes of all time. Fresh! Flavorful! Friendly! The cutest little shop with best cupcakes & cake pops around. Favorites: Cookie Monster, Buckeye, Salted Caramel 2 different seasonal flavors every month too. Worth the drive from Worthington every time!

    Gary F.

    Disclaimer: I went in about 20 minutes to closing. I bought 6 cupcakes which made them $2.75 each. Bought 6 different flavors. All were very good. Icing was great. The selection was a little less than normal (again close to closing time) and the cake was a tad dry. Not enough to keep me from going again when I have a sweets craving but to pay full price that close to closing will definitely make me go earlier in the day. I'm sure when fresher, they are amazing.

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J R.
    0
    1
    0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Fantasy Cupcake

    You might also consider

    Porters Coffee House and Bakery - Fresh croissant with sausage, egg and cheese.  Yum

    Porters Coffee House and Bakery

    4.4(127 reviews)
    3.9 mi
    $$

    We were in the area and looking for a new coffee shop to try out. This popped up as suggested and…read morethe location was close. The building is awesome. It's an old house and the inside is super cute. The actual coffee shop is in the garage so they open the garage door cuz it was a gorgeous day outside. The pastries all looked delicious. The ham and cheese quiche was so good. I asked if they had any sugar free syrups. They had vanilla and caramel so I had them add both to an iced latte. It was really good. My husband opted for one of the house drinks, called the White House. It was delicious as well. Wanted to try the breakfast bagels but they were all out since it was later in the afternoon. Once they are gone they are gone for the day. The quiche was delicious though. We will just have to try other things next time. The cinnamon roll was awesome too! We will be back.

    Decided to give them another try and I left so disappointed. The customer service was not the best…read more They weren't super busy when I got there - just steady flow of customers coming in and out. I did have to wait to place my order but it wasn't too bad. The cashier was not warm whatsoever. I ordered two drinks and two pastries, scones to be exact. My drinks took a little over 10 minutes to be ready (which was not bad given how busy they were) but I still hadn't received my pastries. What was frustrating was that people who ordered after me HEATED pastries had already gotten their orders yet I hadn't received mines that just needed to be bagged? I kindly told the cashier I was still waiting for my scones and I could tell she had clearly forgotten about them. She shortly gave them to me with no apology for the delay or anything. When I got home, one of the scones I had ordered was the wrong flavor. They were also extremely dry. If you're in a rush, be mindful that the pour over coffee takes a little longer to make. I am completely dissatisfied with the service today. I might give their other location a try but this one is a no for me.

    Photos
    Porters Coffee House and Bakery
    Porters Coffee House and Bakery - Egg, cheese and bacon on a jalapeño cheddar bagel

    Egg, cheese and bacon on a jalapeño cheddar bagel

    Porters Coffee House and Bakery

    See all

    Scooter's Coffee

    Scooter's Coffee

    4.3(9 reviews)
    4.1 mi

    Scooters has become one of my daughter and I's favorite breakfast/sweet treat spots! We've been…read moremany times so I'll do my best to provide a brief overview on everything we have ordered! Sidenote - We are a huge fan of the blenders as they are perfectly blended and super creamy (they're comparable to a Frappuccino; however, are blended so perfectly that you are able to drink the entire cup versus leaving a half full cup of ice). - Autumn Caramel Blender - Creamy and sweet with a nice caramel flavor! - Peanut Butter Crunch Blender - Creamy and chocolatey with a not-too-strong peanut butter flavor and a satisfying crunch at the end! - Sugar Cookie Blender - Sweet, creamy, and SO good! - Candy Cane Blender - Strong coffee taste with just the right candy cane and chocolate flavors! - Sausage Maple Sandwich - The waffle was nicely flaky, the cheese melted perfectly, and the flavors came together really well! The perfect sweet and savory breakfast sandwich! - Bacon Burrito - Really good with flavorful bacon and super cheesy eggs. The bacon was tasty, but could have been crispier (it was a little too wiggly for us)! - Spicy Sausage Burrito - Hot and spicy with creamy, cheesy eggs and a Rotel sausage-queso flavor. This burrito has become a must every time we visit! Another note - Scooters is a drive-thru only location. Our favorite part is when they say "Scoot on around" when you are finished ordering - so cute! The workers are always so kind and friendly when providing your food and drinks too - amazing customer service!

    Happy to see a new coffee joint making it into the suburbs of Columbus, even if Scooters is a…read morechain. I first heard about these can-be-24 hour spots last August on my driving trip down to Phoenix and back. I did got through the drive-thru, but looking through the nice big front windows, the seating area looks completely doable. I will admit, I'm not much of a "stay and work at coffee shops" kinda gal, so feasibility and comfy seating are of a different caliber for me. Heads up, this location is not 24 hours, but I wouldn't expect that to be the cast having this location in Pickerington; it's a busy suburb, but not even close to enough industry and third-shift traffic to appease. I prefer matcha, but Scooter's only offers chai, which is my second go-to. Their's was a solid good, but nothing above and beyond. I absolutely love their cup design, however! Instead of the usual cardboard sleeve, their cups come standard with an extra layer, so there's no need for a sleeve - brilliant idea Scooter's, fluffing brilliant! Every time you put a Scooter's cup in a cup-holder, you dont have to worry about gripping the cardboard sleeve ALSO when you want a drink!

    Photos
    Scooter's Coffee
    Scooter's Coffee
    Scooter's Coffee - Brand new location!  (02/06/2025)

    See all

    Brand new location! (02/06/2025)

    Fantasy Cupcake - desserts - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...