For us older generations, this is the same owner as our beloved Pizzeria Italia. Let me tell you,…read moreat first bite, it took me back 25 years. Still exceptional taste at an exceptional price. The small crispy pepperonis are epic. So glad I got to share this place with my son who is now the same age I was when I first ate there. Keep up the good work!

Five stars, because if there 10 I would leave 10. The pizza…read moreis simply perfect. Don't eat it because I said so, do it for yourself.

We visited Nonno Carlo tonight (4/24) with a group of six, and WOW - what an absolute gem!…read more Every single thing we ordered was incredible. The two wood-fired pizzas were perfection - crispy, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. We also shared the meatball hoagie, meatballs with ricotta, antipasto salad, caprese salad, cucumber-tomato salad, Italian chicken salad sandwich, and the Italiano... and then there was the porchetta sandwich - hands down my new favorite sandwich in the universe. I'm still thinking about it. As if that wasn't enough, we finished with imported gelato (strawberry and caramel), and it was the perfect sweet ending. Beyond the amazing food, the two young ladies working the front were so kind, welcoming, and helpful - it really made the whole experience even better. Do yourself a favor and don't sleep on this amazing little market & café. We will 100% be back!

Nonno Carlo (Italian restaurant, Morgantown, WV), March, 2026. A small group of us shared…read moretake-out from this deli while visiting an in-patient relative at the WVU Ruby Memorial Hospital. The group was mostly Italian-Americans, and Italian food is their "go-to" comfort food, especially during such a stressful period. Nonno Carlo, while a bit on the pricey side, did not disappoint with its high quality, abundant, and authentic Italian food. We also appreciated that its location was only about a 5-minute drive from the hospital. Food. (4.5/5). We ordered and shared: (1) The Ellis Island ($15.25), which is described by the restaurant as an Italian American classic sub that is a "sandwich so big you got to take a boat to get there!)" It features herbed aioli, provolone cheese, hot ham, pepperoni, vinegar peppers and onions, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic, piled high on a Mancini's hoagie roll. It was served with potato chips. (2) an Italiano sub ($15.50), which features mortadella, salami, soppressata, capocollo, provolone, and Calabrian pepper spread, served on focaccia. (3) an appetizer, Meatballs and Ricotta ($8.95). This was a favorite, with three DeMedici meatballs served over house-made ricotta. It was served with homemade bread, which was perfect for dipping. (4) Caprese Salad ($3) -- cherry tomatoes, house-made mozzarella, and basil, finished with extra virgin olive oil, salt and pepper. (5) Cucumber-Tomato Salad ($2), with sliced cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, and basil, finished with extra virgin olive oil and vinegar. (6) Dessert: 2 for $7 cannoli. (You could also order a single cannoli for $4). My rating is 4-stars rather than 5-stars for two small reasons -- (1) the subs were somewhat soggy by the time they reached us, from the vinegar/spreads on them, and (2) both salads were sour given the ratio of vinegar to olive oil in the dressings. I can't speak to ambiance or service, as this was take-out and someone else picked it up. I would eat in or order from here again.

I would rename this The Beeth Oven after the fabulous Bill and Ted movie, because this was like…read morestepping back in time, but in a totally excellent way. The Most Triumphant dish? The Pizza Fries. These fried dough "egg rolls" contain pepperoni and cheese and are served with a most excellent red dipping sauce. They used to be called Pizza Fryes which was a take on the Historical Dude Founder's name. The Wedding Soup was also a favorite. It was loaded with meatballs and all the other goodness wedding soup has. I had a bowl because I knew it would be good. The pizza wasn't my favorite, but I was already kinda full from the other stuff too, so it didn't get a fair chance. I was kinda bummed they didn't use pasta as a straw. So much fun drinking that way. Love the extra carbs, but I can understand why they went with regular straws. They still serve soda pop in mason jars though. Be Excellent to Each Other! And enjoy your trip to The Italian Oven.

Delicious Italian Comfort Food…read more The food here is really good in this Family Style Italian Restaurant. I visited on a Friday night and was seated quickly. Entrees come with salad and fresh bread. I ordered the Stromboli Deluxe and my wife ordered the Chicken Marsala. Both dishes were delicious and the portions were large. This is very good Italian food and the prices are fair. The restaurant itself is a bit old, but it was clean. The restaurant's decor could really use a refresh, and the men's room needs an overhaul. This is a nice place to eat.

Pizza is my favorite food since I was a kid and Sorellas has literally the best pizza ever!! The…read morecheese especially is hands down the best around. They also have subs, fries, chicken tenders and so much more and everything I've tried has been 10/10. I've gotten sorellas since I was 12 and still is my favorite local place to eat to this day :)

Family owned and operated- terrific foods, great people! Currently up for sale, I can only hope…read morethat the owners are as caring as the founders are

Stopped in for a quick lunch and this spot didn't disappoint. The service was excellent from start…read moreto finish. We ordered the red grape and Gorgonzola pizza--unique at first bite, but it quickly grows on you in the best way. The thin crust was spot on, and the beer was served at the perfect temperature.

We have been here a few times and every time we are pleased. The staff is always friendly and…read moreattentive. The place is a regular pizza place with a full bar. The food is fantastic from the pies to the sandwiches. They are able to make almost anything gluten free. The place has a very chill vibe and is a good place to meet up with friends.

Delicious food all around! Family owned and operated! Dough is made fresh daily! Waitress are…read morealways attentive and pleasant! Dining is always fast and the portion size is huge! The dining room is huge, clean, and quiet! Perfect for family dining ! You can also host a birthday party as their dining room is huge!

First day of Pike Days and they were slammed. But as always, our food was delivered hot and fresh!…read more EVERYTHING they make is fabulous! Driver is always courteous and so nice. Best pizza by far!!!

Well, hopefully the third restaurant will be the charm for this small strip mall outside of…read more Smithfield, PA. The pizza, strombolis and calzones are good. Have yet to try the salads, hoagies and wraps. The service could use some improvement, which will in time. This reincarnation is sit and be served instead of order and sit. This habit is hard to get rid of.

Iv called literally 24 times over a 30 minute period and I can't get anyone to answer the phone. It…read moreis Saturday at 7:30 pm.

Friendly Staff, Great Service & Delicious Food! It's nice that they have daily specials and keep…read moretheir customers updated on their Facebook page.