Alright here it is, I am very picky about Pizza. This place was phenomenal. We tried the 9 lives meat lovers, a create your own chicken Alfredo Pizza and Cheese garlic bread. The 9 lives crust was like a soft fresh bread. Their Pizza sauce is my favorite yet! Different than anything Ive tried and yet the best in my opinion. The staff were friendly and made sure we had everything. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

We appeared bedraggled in the middle of a terrible rain, asking for coffee. It was raining so hard we couldn't even see. The first place we stopped said simply, "No coffee" and we decided to eat elsewhere. The waitress, Courtney, found instant and won our undying affection. We proceeded to order Caesar salad, a Greek pizza, fettuccine Alfredo, and wine to go with it all. The place was comfy, but the caring people made it. We have dined in many places much more finely appointed and been far less pleased. Whenever we cross Missouri on I-44, we'll be back. Thank you. read more

Fat Cat Pizza - A half-eaten Caesar salad. Tom couldn't wait. Very nice dressing and size--very gone. - Pizza Near Me - Strafford, Missouri

See all

Pizza here is amazing. Lots of toppings. If you haven't tried it give it a go. The service was very good.

5/16/25 5:00 PM I ordered a Fat Cat Supreme which is supposed to come with both sauce and double cheese. My pizza had no sauce and very little cheese. I called and the person that answered said they saw sauce and cheese put on my pizza. I do not like to call anybody a liar, but look at the pictures and you tell me. read more

See all

Service was great. Food was literally the most average plain Jane stuff ever. Garlic bread loaf tasted like it had more seasoning than my pizza did. read more

I ate here on a road trip with family, and I heard they had a vegan pizza option. Unfortunately they said they didn't have dairy-free cheese anymore, it woulda been nice, but I did get the Greek pizza without the cheese and thought it was solid -- it came with a lot of good toppings and I've never had garlic olive oil on a pizza. Our server Courtney did incredible -- she was very pleasant. She let me have some extra olive oil, we got offered to-go drinks, and I loved the music selection she was playing overhead. Very very kind person. The dining room and bathroom were well lit and clean. Food was solid, the service sold it even more! Thank you, Fat Cat Pizza. read more

Fat Cat Pizza you are one of my favorites! We ordered to go that evening. The pizza was very fresh, cheesy and the crust was outstanding. I ordered the Greek pizza with cauliflower crust and let me tell you if I hadn't chosen my pizza crust I would have never imagined it was cauliflower. It was like a thin crust with flavor, so delicious. I added pickled jalapeños to my Greek pizza, such a delight. We ordered an Izzy which is a Hawaiian and we got a pepperoni. They were delicious as well, the crust was fluffy and just right. There was absolutely nothing bad to say about Fat Cat Pizza. Their customer service over the phone and in person was great. read more

See all

Walked from the truck stop. Well worth it. Had the 12" pizza hand rolled. Pork sausage and bacon. It's good. A must try if you're in the neighborhood. I'll eat here again. Friendly staff. Good service read more

What can I say about Fat Cat? Fat Cat is a nice, surprising experience. The value is great and the quality is reflected in the ingredients they use. The dough/crust is a delightfully flakey and crunchy texture. The value is fair for the servings. The dining area is a little small, so seating can be cramped. Also there only seems to be one restroom. The establishment is fairly clean and the staff is friendly but wasn't exactly too attentive. Maybe it's because they were busy. They do serve light alcohol, and the cheesy bread was amazing. Overall I would recommend Fat Cat Pizza Co. especially if you're in the Strafford area. No better place to get a Za. I will also return to give the service another opportunity. read more

Fat Cat Pizza - Small dining area. - Pizza Near Me - Strafford, Missouri

Food was ok but they have a waitress that is like a young goddess. If I lived here I would go back

We decided to go it seemed easy off highway lunch and it was sign could have been more pronounced from the road, staff was helpful and very helpful with menu suggestions. Nice selection of beer and wine soft drinks and tea. Didn't wait long for the place to get busy either with person eating or to go orders but still staff was quick with food drink refills and ticket. I did notice they needed more room for storage items not in use but it was out of the way of dining area. Food was great pizza crust was homemade and little sweet taste but the marinade counter that and made for a good pizza, meatball sub needs more sauce for my liking but homemade meatballs were good, bread stick seem to be store bought not as good as pizza,. Overall good we would eat more time if lived in the area. My husband and I shared a just the right amount for us. Didn't give a 5 star just for the fact is was clutter right as you walk in. read more

See all

Rebecca, Juan, their kiddos and the entire crew at The Fat Cat are WONDERFUL folks! We are never disappointed when we swing in or order delivery! The food is delicious, the service excellent... if you're stopping through Strafford or a permanent resident you should absolutely be supporting this incredible business! A couple of our favorite items on the menu: The Jalapeño Popper dip is the perfect way to start your meal. We also love the fried ravioli on their appetizer list. We're big fans of just about every pizza on the menu, the standouts are the Bill Murray, the Foldover (order it with thin crust and fold it over, I dream of this pizza weekly!) and the Build-Your-Own made as Buffalo Chicken on thin crust! The chicken wings are consistently crispy and every sauce we've had so far has been delicious! They carry a great selection of beer and wine that changes seasonally. Ask Rebecca for her recommendations! Do I need to give you any more reason to eat here? read more

Great food and good service. A little pricey but it's so much better than Pizza Hut across the street.

Great food, excellent service, nice cozy atmosphere. It smells amazing as soon as you walk in. We love this place. Very accommodating to allergies also. read more

I got food poisoning from their pasta. Never going back again. Service also took quite awhile. If I could put zero stars I would.

Passing through and found this local pizzeria. Nice clean place with a family atmosphere. Great service and a yummy pizza! Pizza crust flavor was yeasty and sauce wasn't sweet just tomatoey . I'm stopping again when we pass through. read more

It was great except for the camel. The belching waitress is friendly. The food is great!

Was just out for a drive on a Saturday night. Stumbled on this place. And so glad we did. We only tried a couple of there pizzas but we absolutely loved the Greek. Can't wait to get back out there to try the rest. Highly recommend the pizza. Great food. read more

See all

We were just passing through. Very nice place the food was great, very good service we will stop again! read more

We waited far too long to visit this wonderful pizza place. But in no way disappointed the food was amazing the owners in the establishment are so well run and welcoming. Looking forward to next time!!! read more

Very cool place with great people who have a nice background story. It's a place definitely worth checking out

We love their cauliflower crust Greek pizza and salad! Crave it. It's a friendly, small town restaurant and we are so glad they are in Strafford, MO. read more

The pizza was pretty good. I really like the crust. The mozz sticks definitely taste like store bought. Servers were very friendly but nobody was wearing masks. Our server was right in my face when taking my order. She also tried to serve me a slice and also tried to box up our leftovers for us. I politely declined both offers. With COVID and NOT wearing a mask, I wish she had been a little less hands on and stood a bit further away from my face! She was new so perhaps she was just eager to do well... I'd get pizza here again though! read more

The owner is super friendly, and he truly cares about the experience his patrons have in his establishment. The Big Al pizza with pepperoni is our favorite and we love the large selection of beer on tap. read more

Great local place that delivers in Strafford, yay! It's become our go-to. So much better than the standard chain pizza. The staff is always friendly and delivery is always super fast. They have a lot of unique offerings. We love the Greek pizza (fresh, flavorful, and semi-healthy with lots of yummy veg - *artichokes*), and the Bill Murray (meatballs and basil!). Highly recommended! read more

This place was amazing!! They have the absolute best calazones I've ever had!! Outstanding service, great atmosphere great price in a convenient location just off of Interstate 44 in Strafford!! read more

Under the new ownership Fat Cat is creating food that is crave-worthy! Their sauce and crust are to die for and their expertise doesn't stop at their bomb pizza! The tiramisu is FANTASTIC! We get it every time we go! It is worth the short drive to Strafford. Trust me. read more

Clean little diner. I had caprese salad and hubs had the Goodfella. Both were scrumptious! We'll be back!

I've been looking for a new favorite pizza haunt since moving to the area and this place definitely fits the bill. Great crust, great toppings and some creative combinations. Loved the white sauce pizza, can't wait to try the other specialty pies next time. read more

It's not closed, I went there to the re grand opening in Sep. The new owners are a nice young couple who really know how to cook some delicious food and the pizza was amazing I will definitely be back when I come to visit Missouri again. read more

Really good pizza, awesome staff, overpriced in my opinion. But, supporting local is important so we will keep going back.

OMG! Just finished the Greek thin crust pizza and a house salad - fantastic! One of the best veggie pizzas I've had. And here's the deal - the customer service was even better! We are staying at a hotel very close and I called in our order for pickup. I knew right away this place was awesome....I'm assuming it was the owner that answered and she was so friendly. I also asked if they had bottles of wine for sale! Boom - yes, another plus. And very inexpensive. When my husband picked up the order they had asked him if I had a wine opener and offered a bottle with a screw top - which I needed as I did not have my corkscrew with me as it was confiscated after my last flight through TSA. They prepped us with paper plates, cups for my wine and silverware. We are traveling cross country with 2 large dogs and have been driving for 2 days. We needed kind people and good food and that's just what we got! Thank you Fat Cat Pizza for making our day! read more