If you're looking for legit, Fat Zach's Pizza absolutely delivers. The crust is that perfect balance crispy on the outside but still soft and chewy inside--no flop, no dryness. The sauce actually has flavor and they don't skimp on toppings. Everything tastes fresh, hot, and made right. You can tell they care about what they're putting out. It's one of those spots where you take a bite and immediately know you'll be back. Hands down some of the best pizza around. read more

My wife and I brought our 3 children in for a quick dinned And waited an hour for 5 pizzas all while the people that came in after us were served before us. Don't get me wrong the pizza is execelent we just need to work on service in this location. read more

Fat Zach's - Date and time - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all

Skyler helped us today on our first visit. Food was great, we ordered the bam bam bbq pizza, it was light and still filling. We also ordered lemon pepper and wings and honey siracha wings. They were so good. The siracha wings came out a little cold so we asked to have them cooked more. Skyler cooked and packaged a new order and gave us a free cheesy bread! Thank you. Great service (: read more

I have been to the south hill and downtown Puyallup locations and both are great! I love their cheesy garlic bread more then I love my child! (Only kind of kidding - and she knows that) The service is always friendly and we prefer to leave the fair, have lunch at fat zachs and then go back. It's so much more chill and you aren't paying so much! read more

First time to Fat Zach's. Atmosphere was cute, loved the wood burning pizza oven, employees very nice and helpful. Ordered the special 2 pizza's for $23 or something along those lines. They had combo's on menu but I custom ordered how I wanted. The pizza came, on a wooden pizza paddle, not sure what it's called. Looked good, was missing a topping I had asked for. Pizza very hot, toppings kind of slid right off and crust was very wet and very thin. It wasn't how I was expecting, it tasted ok, again very wet pizza and crust was too thin and didn't support the toppings. Might try again maybe an off day. read more

See all

We just ordered a gluten free, build your own pizza. We missed the part where you choose which sause you want. The pizza was delivered with no sause. I called and verified that it was our mistake. When I went back to the restaurant to get some sause, they had a new pizza waiting, and seemed genuinely happy to have done this! Well done, and thank you! read more

Stopped here before hitting the movies. Placed an order for the poly pig and first responder, also got an order of all flat lemon pepper wings. Our order taker said it would take about 15 mins. Or did. Our pizzas were good. I would have liked the bottom of the crust to be a little Crisper but she did tell me they were ru. I f out of wood and was having trouble maintaining the temperature. The wings were better than I expected. She shared they weren't fried but they were very crispy, I was able to get all flats, I could taste the lemon pepper and it was not overbearing. Overall we will surely visit again!! read more

See all

Pickle pizza? Yes, try it! We had 5 different pizzas which were all good but the pickle was the most surprising! Yes, we will be back! read more

Fat Zach's - a pizza with pickles and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Ambiance is cool, fast casual! I got my pizza to go, customer service was high energy even if they were near closing! Love that! Ordered the NBD for the first time and I must say, in love!!!!!!! Pickle enthusiast it's a must try and soooo addicting! Try it! read more

See all

I haven't been to Fat Zach's in so long (like since their grand opening in South Hill) and I heard about a dill pickle pizza here and just had to come back in to try it and give my review. I'm someone who appreciates a well made plain cheese and margarita pizza as well as the more unconventional flavors (yes I am one of those people who LOVES pineapple on a pizza- and no I'm not talking about the popular Hawaiian pizza cause I'm not a ham kind of girl but cheese and pineapple only or Pineapple with Jalapeños for the sweet and spicy kick HELL YESSS I'm in !! ) and I've had various takes on cheeseburger pizzas which of course included pickles as that's normally something you'd find on a cheeseburger and while it may sound odd, I really enjoyed the flavor. The #NBD (no big dill) pizza you can find at Fat Zachs has pickles combined with cheese, dill weed and ranch and those ingredients went fabulously together! If you like pickles, you'll likely find this pizza, dare I say, dill-icious ? I recommend getting the combo as it's only about $5 more (depending on which side you get) to get a side and drink. I went with the caprese salad which has always been one of my favorite salads and Minute Maid lemonade. Next time I come in I think I'll try their chicken wings as they seem to have a good variety of flavors! The food is good, ambiance is nice and laid back, workers are friendly.. all in all I'd say this place is kind of a big dill ! read more

See all

My pizza was served to me cold. My husband's pizza was incorrectly made. They remade it and let us keep the incorrect one.

We ordered the two pizza deal. The pickle pizza was surprisingly good. I wouldn't like run out to get it but it was definitely worth trying.

Great place for fresh pizza. try the NBD! You won't be disappointed. They have wings too.

I currently am obsessed with the Bam Bam BBQ pizza. Although pineapple on pizza is such a divided topic there is only one correct answer... and it is yes it does belong! The Bam Bam executes it perfectly with BBQ sauce, chicken, onions, pineapple and red peppers. I crave this pizza pretty much constantly. Big fan! read more

This is a fast casual restaurant with a very relaxed vibe. The restaurant was staffed by lots of teenagers and it was a little bit disorganized. As it was our first time going in, we were very confused with the entire process. We ordered the family meal as there were five of us eating dinner together. Our pizza came out, but our salad still wasn't up. When we asked, they started shouting around about the order. The desert also came out with the pizzas, and some were being held in boxes while they finished the rest of the meal, so some things were hot, others were warm. By the time we got to the dessert, it was cold. The food was okay and not bad for lunch, but I wouldn't order this for dinner. I did appreciate the fact they served beer in their restaurant. read more

This was my first time eating here and I can hands down recommend this restaurant!!! The server, Gavin Parsons (I asked) was so respectful, courteous and upbeat that it made the whole experience worthwhile! From the food to the atmosphere to the genuine care and hospitality, this will definitely be a go-to for our pizza outings from this time forward!!! read more

Fat Zach's - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

We have been coming to Fat Zach's since beginning down on sidewalk by puyallup post office! Thrilled for their success during tough time in industry. Everyone has a favorite, thankfully personal size. We brought out of town family there once now a must when they are in town read more

We tried this after hearing positive things. We ordered the family fare which is pricy for what it is. The pizzas were sparsely topped and slightly burnt. We asked for extra pineapple, but there isn't even a piece per a slice. One of the pizzas was the wrong pizza. They didn't even check what they gave us for accuracy. It took a long time to get the order. We showed up when it should be ready, but when we got there it took 20 more minutes. There were a lot of little items with our order and when we asked for a bag they said they don't have them... then how come other people had a bag? It was overpriced and the experience wasn't positive. The staff needs more training. Overall I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone I actually like. For this type of pizza and size I'd recommend Mod. They are cheaper, not stingy on the toppings and the customer service is better. read more

Decided to try this place even though the price seemed a little high. Ordered the Family Fare for $60, called in the order and was told an hour which was fine. Husband got back with the order and they forgot to give the Caesar salad, so husband went back to get it! Comes back and it is basically just lettuce and Caesar dressing ( with bad pieces of lettuce in it). The garlic cheese bread seemed to be on the small side. Don't think we will be going back to this place again! read more

Fat Zach's - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all

Amazing food and the customer service is awesome! The boys who work there are all super nice!! Went there at the right time today around 5pm and they were watching a cool game show and the whole crew/dinging room played while they were making everyone pizza read more

overall rating: 11/10 cleanliness: 10/10 flavor: 11/10 service: 10/10 best pizza in puyallup! adding good music would be a vibe! read more

See all

Maybe it's called Fat Zach because they take all of your money and buy themselves better food their one-size pizzas are definitely considered personal size at most places. We ordered for pick up for the first time and it was definitely our last time. read more

Fat Zach's is always amazing!! The CBR is the best pizza on the menu!! And the bam bam bbq is also a fav definitely a regular spot!! Much love fatty Z's read more

Wanted a pizza. Went to Fat Zach's on South Hill. I asked the guy behind which was the best selling pie. He asked if I liked pickles, I love pickles but can't imagine that they would taste good on a pizza pie. The guy told me I would like the pizza. The #NBD was one of the pizzas I've ever had. I can't wait to go back and have another one and bring some people with me to share my next experience at Fat Zach's. read more

It's a Good Pizza at a good price. Friendly but slow service. It's nice to have a local pizza place in an area overwhelmed with boring chain restaurants. The Margarita Pizza tastes fresh and nice, the 18 wheeler was just ok. The wings were good but the bbq sauce was so so. The ranch dressing for the wings were the best part. The salad showed up at the end and didn't get eaten. The desserts look amazing I'll try next time. The young workers were friendly and dressed professionally. It's nice to go to a restaurant these days and not have a server with 18 facial piercings and rainbow hair! I'll go back again! read more

See all

Expensive and not worth the money. Beer was flat and the pizza less than good. Crust came out burnt. After spending $60 for dinner between 2 of us, we left hungry. Never going back and will let my family and friends know to find a different place for pizza. read more

Great pizza! We did the 3 pizzas, salad, cheesy bread, and drinks PLUS some delicious little "sugar babies" for dessert. Great value for great pizza. Would have cost at least twice as much at other local wood fired pizza places. We all loved it! read more

Great food and friendly staff! Ingredients are always fresh!! Atmosphere is very modern and always clean!

It recently opened in the new location across from Puppy land and they have great service and delicious foods and desserts their they'll eventually will offer outdoor seating but not right now but the food is terrific. read more

The two times I have ordered when I arrive to pick up they haven't even started my order. So it has been at least another 20-30 minute wait. Tried to give a second chance as it's the closest to my home. Will not return and wouldn't recommend. read more

Ordered the Family Deal on 9/18. Order said ready at 1:15 and we showed up promptly at that time. They told us another 20-30 minutes. I guess they were waiting on the sugar babies because the pizzas are cold. They forgot our 2-liter and dipping sauce. read more

Great pizza! Thin crust, great toppings. We're trying to work our way through the menu!

Thank you for responding, we will agree to disagree, I have lived throughout the us plus Europe I have never had a just plain sauces , it's a true art to make the perfect dough and sauces, for pizza. The bottom of the pizza should not be doughy and gooey, I would suggest use old world pepperoni, the small round s one they have a much better tastes and do better in a coal or wood fire pizza just my Advice a s a expert in pizza and wood fire cooking just trying to make it better for you read more

Look for Jackie- she gets your order down no matter the collective when you walk in! She is more than willing and able to make sure you leave with your pizza the way you want it! Ask for her, Jackie if you want immaculate perfectionism. She is human so give her grace if her order isn't want you wanted- be vocal in what your expectations are- Jackie will fulfill them. I will be back, looking for her welcoming, warm welcome. Thank you Jackie!!! Love Chelsea read more