Food was AMAZING, the server was so incredibly sweet - we had a great area to kick back & could hear each other chatting. Their beer menu was great & a lot of drinks I had never tried, so getting to try new flavors was truly fun. We had the wings for a starter & it was some of the best wings I have ever had. We mixed half & half Buffalo & BBQ & what a treat! I got the chicken bowl & devoured it. I would highly recommend trying this place! read more

See all

Group of friends and I got sat down fairly quickly for dinner. The food was awesome and our server was very tentative but we were only checked on once during our meal for any refills or additional orders. We were planning on staying longer but we're brought our bill and our plates kept getting taken away while there was food still on it. Usually servers will at least ask if we are done eating, would like to order anything else or would like some boxes. Felt like we ending up being rushed out or weren't welcome anymore ..which was a bummer for such a good night with fantastic food and drinks. read more

See all

3.5/5 Went for a lunch. Not very busy. One waiter managed 3-4 tables well. Wednesday Wings day. Bone-in sticky Asian flavor -- good portion and good flavor. Jambalaya -- little heavy on the sauce. Chicken sandwich-- could add little more garlic sauce. Fries are fresh. read more

See all

We had a great server tonight. The atmosphere was nice and chill, with people out on the patio since it was warm. My salad was perfection as always. Love the interaction between our server and some other customers. Great dinner as always. read more

Solid experience, but not exceptional. Arrived having made a reservation following the St. Olaf Holiday Festival. Seated promptly. Space is nice, typical sort of sports bar layout. Service was friendly, but underwhelming. Long periods of time between being seated and ordering drinks, drinks arriving, ordering food, and food arriving. We were in no rush, so no big deal. Food was typical sports bar food. I had the black and bluey burger, and it was as expected. Good, not great. Wife had the pickle burger, and liked it, but said she would not rave about it. Prices were reasonable. I'd consider returning, but not in any rush to. read more

Awesome burger, Jesse was a great and the rest of the staff was aware of our needs. Great job!

Have eaten here a couple of times. Mediocre. The ambiance is nice. A few decent beers on tap. Looks like a decent amount of wines. Full bar. The service was good and attentive. The food wasn't really that great. I had the Strawberry Hill burger which has peanut butter and jelly on it. I was exited about it when I ordered it, but when I got it, there was little flavor. I know, crazy. The burger itself didn't have much flavor, although it was cooked to a nice medium rare. As a side, I ordered the Fielder's Tots which were similar, lacked flavor, perhaps even overcooked. I also had a bowl of chicken and wild rice soup. While the flavor was ok, the consistency was very thin. Plenty of parking. Outdoor seating. read more

I was on one mission when visiting Fielders Choice in Northfield and that mission was the Ultimate Bloody Mary! This thing DID NOT DISAPPOINT! The 25oz drink uses a delicious house made mix and comes garnished with 2 cheeseburger sliders, a hotdog, soft pretzel stick, 3 loaded tater tots that were life changing, your standard meat and cheese skewer and a celery stick. As if that wasn't enough, a full sized beer back of YOUR choosing came along with it. I sat at the bar for the Bloody Mary visit and the bartender was absolutely excellent. Prompt and friendly. I will absolutely be back to tackle the menu. Based on the goodies on the Bloody the food is going to be great! Update review to follow. read more

See all

Great service with immediate seating on a Saturday evening. I enjoyed the BBQ Bowl and it was a fantastic combination of ingredients. The atmosphere is family friendly with several large TVs positioned around the seating area. Full service bar with multiple craft beer and cider options. Thank you for the great service and will look forward to returning again soon! read more

See all

Returned to Northfield to celebrate my sister's birthday! Love coming to Fielder's Choice! This is one of my favorite burgers, can't go wrong with an easy on a burger! The fries were good, but would have prefered more seasoning on them! The waitress was very attentive and helpful with our order and allergy considerations! Enjoy the wide menu they have and the atmosphere inside! Definitely a must-check out for those visiting Northfield! read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Over Easy Bacon Cheesey - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

9/25/21 Lots of beers on tap. The waitress was great. There was about 17 of us. And we came 5-10 minutes apart. She asked if there was more coming. Whereas I would have been like why didn't you make a reservation. She had the whole back idea. And let us do bills by couple. Of all of the meals and drinks I think they was only one beer incorrect. The changed the tv channel to the badger game when we asked. Later changed it to the Gophers game ha read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Chicken Bahn Mi - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

going to need to work out kinks. definitely not Italian in my opinion. pasta was wildly overcooked, chicken Marsala was not a Marsala but rather some sort of salty gravy with canned mushrooms. caesar salad was made with iceberg. when we asked for side plates for our appetizers that was delivered by a manager, he lifted his finger at us to hold on , totally dismissing us and never brought plates. eating with our fingers over a plate was messy. our server was great though. we will try it again but not for any of the Italian dishes they offer read more

Just had lunch here as recommended by The Goat in Northfield, and it did not disappoint. The food was great, my husband said it was the best jambalaya he's ever had., and our waitress Theresa was wonderful. We'll be back whenever we're in town! read more

Horrible service and food. We waited an hour and 15 minutes for our food and the burger I ordered was burnt and had mushrooms which I asked to not have on there. My friend flagged down our server after an hour to get a refill on his drink because no one checked on us. Pizza was decent. read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Burnt burger - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

I had the best Fettuccine Alfredo that I have ever tasted. Good service and great food.

My wife and I stopped by late afternoon today (Monday). 3 regular tables of customers, including ourselves. 2 different couples outside. Never got waited on the entire time we were there. No water -nothing! After our patience ran out, we walked out the door. We may try again someday, if they are still open! We ended going to Flaherty's Down the road. read more

One of our go-to spots in Northfield! Generally pretty easy to get a table, they just added outdoor seating too. Lots of menu options so there's something for everyone! read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Pickle Lucy - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

Fast service, lots of seating, great waitress. I had a short rib sandwich, coleslaw and tried the cheese curds. The curds kick a**, better than anything I've had in Wisconsin. I tried the Duck Duck Beer, $3, which was good, if undifferentiated from a regular old big tank rice-corn beer. The sandwich was fine but dry. I'd go back to try the wood-fired pizza. read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Menu as of Feb '24 - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

See all

Four of us met up here for lunch. Casual bar atmosphere, with a good menu selection. We got the pretzel appetizer (very good), BLT with avocado (also good), wings (I didn't have them, but they looked good and were big), a vegetarian bowl (healthy/good), and a burger. Nothing amazing, but solid spot that I would go back to. read more

First time trying this restaurant. A lot of time in between when needing something from our server although a kind person. We ordered the onion straws appetizer which came out in under 5 minutes which is great if they aren't already cooled off. The sauce which came with it was small so we asked for another along with ranch for the pizza. Turns out these tiny cups are a $1 a piece so $3 in sauce. Pizza was ok. We truly are simple folks and hate to leave this review but must be fair. Overall we wish this place the best but will not return. read more

Love this place, lettuce wraps were amazing. Tiramisu was fantastic. The only place you can get a giant Bloody Mary with everything on it for a fantastic price. The only downside they update the menus every so often so it might not be there the next time you go. But everything else is delicious. read more

See all

This is basically one of the only other restaurants in Northfield besides El Tri Unfo, QB Club, Carbones with decent food but a little over priced. I got kicked out of every other bar in town so have to go here. Their beer selection is insane and burgers are top notch quality. Not a big fan of the pizza although it's not bad. Mike is definitely a great chef with a good attitude and always makes sure my food was more than satisfactory. I wouldn't really recommend if you're a family on a budget but if you want to spoil yourself with good food, drinks, sports on TV with a nice atmosphere and have lots of money then come here. I'll stop in here monthly or quarterly to get my fix. read more

Service 5/5 Food 4/5 Atmosphere 5/5 We made a mad dash to Minnesota and stopped in here to eat. Our server Jesse was absolutely fantastic! Best server I've had in a veryyy long time. We started with the Swedish meatballs which were filling and had good flavor. I ordered the beer can chicken and my husband the Thai peanut pizza. Chicken was juicy and full of flavor and the sides absolutely delicious! The pizza was good but slightly bland... it did had some good crunch to it. my husband added some sriracha and hot sauce and it was great! The only two downs were the pecan bourbon pie which was very dry and grainy and there absolutely no where to wait. I'm not sure who designed the building but they missed a waiting area! Overall, a neat place that we will definitely go back to if ever in Minnesota again. read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Beer can chicken - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

See all

Had a great meal here on a trip. All our food was well prepared, and the staff was exceptionally friendly.

I ordered the fettuccini Alfredo and I was pleasantly surprised, for $12 the portion was large. The food was great, my boyfriend got a burger and said it was amazing. The service was fast and our waiter was helpful. The ambiance of the restaurant is calm, unlike most sportsbar like restaurants, the music was not too loud and it felt very intimate. read more

Great service! Food was good! Good experience! Menu has switched again but that's ok---

We came here a year ago and the food was good. They must have changed their menu because the pretzel bites tasted very cheap, the walleye tasted burned/tasteless, the pasta tasted like it was made with cheese whiz. Very very disappointed. read more

Great food as always, sad to see the price of lettuce wraps so high but they are definitely worth it!

A Monte Cristo is a battered and then deep fried ham and cheese sandwich, a variation of the French croque-monsieur. Hard to find at a lot of restaurants or they are not done correctly. Fielders goes one step further and adds 2 kinds of cheese, american and swiss along with turkey and ham piled high. They serve it with a ghost pepper jelly that is sweet with a little bit of heat the perfect combination and way better than just plain old strawberry jam. read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Monte Cristo with ghost pepper jelly....the perfect combination. - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

We visited our freshman St. Olaf student and took her for dinner. At the advice of some other parents, we tried Fielder's Choice. There were only a couple of tables of guests when we arrived. Upon walking in, I stopped in the bathroom. There were 2 empty soap dispensers and an air dryer for your hands. So.... not only could I not wash my hands... I couldn't dry them and needed to turn the door nob, with my dirty hands (as many others have) on my way out. Gross. If an establishment can't take care of their bathrooms, they don't care about you as a customer. I shudder to think about the kitchen. We have 4 years down in Northfield and Fielder's Choice is off the menu. read more

The pizza crust was tough, rueben meat tasted weird, bread burnt. Fries were great and Bloody Mary was good. Service was excellent. Could not finish ruebens. read more

Bottom-tier service, mediocre food, great environment. This is the closest Northfield has to a civilized-presenting bar 'n grill, so let that inform your opinion of the other reviews. At least the portions are big. read more

It's pretty good, although it is very meat centric. I wish they had better vegetarian options. The service is always great.

*****UPDATE***** I ordered last night and took too long getting there. Once I showed up, they apologized (they didn't need to) and RECOOKED my whole order! Beef and potatoes, house salad, and Reuben...all excellent. Will definitely return Ordered takeout here for the first time last night. Two things about that: 1) I couldn't figure out how to order online and 2) when I called to order they said it would be ready in ten minutes! (Great!) I ordered the Strawberry Hill which is a PBJ burger with bacon and pepper jack with sweet potato waffle fries, fried cheese curds, chicken wild rice soup, stuffed tots, bacon Mac and cheese, pretzel breadsticks, and a house salad ($79) The strawberry hill was amazing, very unique mix of flavors! My wife didn't care for the Mac and cheese. Everything was very tasty on my end. Pros: fast service, delicious food, HUGE portions, clean restaurant Cons: appetizers tasted a little old like the fry oil was a little past its prime, prices were a little hIgh I'm looking forward to trying more of thee flavors in the future...just as long as it's close to payday. read more

close to early ... i was ready to party until 4 am..this club is lame and doesn't appreciate new people

So friendly! Loved it! The food is delicious and they gave a good selection of craft beers on tap.

We live in the Cities but get to Northfield occasionally and usually have good food here but the other night when we ate here it was very disappointing. First of all their choice of tap beers and wines was scanty. I asked to try a cabernet that was on the menu and was told they just have the little bottles so that wasn't an option. That was not promising to start with. I had the patty melt with fries while my wife had the chicken sandwich with waffle fries. She said her sandwich was find but didn't care for the waffle fries. Meanwhile my patty melt was soggy and bland to the point where I couldn't even finish it. As far as the service our water glasses were never refilled although I hesitate to blame our waitress because it looked like she was handling all the tables in the restaurant. The bottom line is that with all of the other food options available in Northfield I doubt we'll be giving Fielder's Choice another try. read more

A popular spot in NORTHFIELD. I know people really love this place; however, I have found the food to just be okay. My last burger had a disappointing cold hard bun....at this price point I expect it toasted or at least soft. The fish and chips is generally the go-to for me with generous portions. Atmosphere is a sports bar wannabe mixed with family restaurant feel...kind of a Perkins meets Champs. The wait staff is very nice. read more

Wow! I finally made it to Fielder's Choice for the first time since it opened in the fall, and I'm so glad that I did. I know exactly where I'm going every Monday and Tuesday next fall. First, the tap selections. They have an incredible amount of beers on tap at the bar, and ALL of them are local. I was very impressed. The food was fantastic. We went on a Tuesday, which means you can get a burger and a pint for just $10. But wait, there's more; it's not just a burger, it's a juicy lucy. The fries were awesome--good crunch to potato ratio. Also, Mondays are personal pizza and a pint for $10! read more

Fielders Choice Tap & Table - Juicy Lucy and a pint for $10?? Such a good price. - Burgers Near Me - Northfield, Minnesota

See all

I came to Fielder's Choice while in town for a wedding. I came to watch a football game and get some lunch and had a really great experience. The bartender was attentive and had good recommendations for food. They had ample beer choices, and the burger I had was excellent. They had a good crowd to watch with and the staff was very friendly. I would definitely come back. read more