Today we stopped at playa Vallarta. We ordered their new soft serve margaritas. They had…read morepomegranate and mango but they were able to swirl the two. They were phenomenal. Our food was also so good. They were definitely a little bit pricy but really good! Our server Jonathan was very friendly and attentive to servicing us! Everyone in the restaurant was very welcoming. 10/10 recommend!

Overall, a good experience dining here. It's a little off the beaten path, it's in a golf course…read more Service was friendly, and I came on BOGO margarita night which was convenient. I had the mixed fajitas, which came out quickly and were good though not great. Prices were reasonable. Would come again.

Tried the weekend lunch buffet and what a delight!…read more Delicious options of standard breakfast food and a lovely assortment of Mexican dishes--pork, chicken, beef, vegetarian, fresh fruits, fried plaintains (these were my favorite today!), and so much more. Includes drink options such as orange juice, coffee, etc. Really a lovely assortment for a small town restaurant! Will definitely be back! Also--bright, happy decor and great, friendly service from our waiter!

Very authentic Mexican food. This is the where we go for a good Mexican meal and margaritas.read more

Delicious meal, great service, at a good price for my large family. We recommend and will be back.read more

Had huevos ranchos today and wife had chimichangas. Both were very good. They brought chips and red…read moresauce on the mild side and i ask for green sauce on the spicy side., i enjoy it allot. We shall return.

Worth every penny. Although they put a branch of cilantro in my burrito it still was fire. Service…read morewas good.

Very poor service every time I went to the lake mills location. Even when it was completely empty…read morebeing 1 of 2 tables in the restaurant all the servers stayed at the bar ignoring my table regardless of attempts of flagging them down for assistance. In general just incredibly rude for absolutely no reason. Heard many other locals recall the same treatment/behavior. Also been told the one in Watertown is nothing like this. Same Great food but the standard service one expects, like giving you your drinks, treating you with kindness versus annoyance etc...

My husband remembered eating a phenomenal burrito at Snapper Vick's 20 years ago. We were…read moretraveling back from northern Wisconsin and decided to stop for dinner in our way home to Oconomowoc. Our server was "on point" at every aspect of providing excellent service. She suggested that we taste the pulled pork which had been roasted all day. My, my, my....tender, delicious and full of flavor! My husband had his burrito with the pork and I the pork taco salad. The $5.50 Margarita was wonderful! The Mexican restaurants in Oconomowoc have been falling short of our expectations and we have been looking for a better place. We have found it and will be back!

New owners new menu. They didn't even have the Strawberry Margarita. They need to change the name…read moreit's not "Snapper Vicks" Lousy experience.

I was excited to try this place after reading endless reviews on local social media stating how…read moreamazing the food was. 4 of us went on a Saturday night at 5:00. The place was packed and despite having 3 open table the hostess sat us a booth right by the door. Every time the door opened we froze not to mention we were literally blocked in by the waiting patrons for the 2 hours we were there. In place of this booth should be a waiting area. We sat down and waited 15 minutes before having to go up to the front to get any recognition from the wait staff. Finally, someone came over and took our order. This would be the one and only time we would see our server. He never returned again, despite our empty drinks. Other staff members brought out our food and a different staff member yet asked if everything was okay. At the end if the meal, wouldn't you know it, I had to go to the front to get our check! Please El Jimador do not sit people were you cannot even see that there are people to be served! The food was good, but the service completely ruined El Jimador for me. Unfortunately, even the good food could not make up for the most frustrating $115.00 meal I have ever had.

My family stopped in here for Mother's Day and it was our first time here. Most of us loved the…read moredishes we ordered. My Dad said his enchilada was cold and didn't have meat. He did like his taco and burrito though. They served red sauce on his dish when he ordered green sauce. It could have been rushed out and the reason why it was cold. The guac was disappointing. More sloppy than chunky as described. My Pollo Norteno meal was everyone's favorite. The chicken was tender and flavorful. Veggies and pineapple were grilled to perfection and all topped off with some queso drizzle. My sister and brother in law loved their Molcajete and usually get that at Mexican restaurants. They were impressed with the flavor and the amount of shrimp you get. They ordered a margarita and agreed they use too much sweet and sour mix. Not a traditional margarita. My Mom loved her steak quesadillas and said the meat was also tender and flavorful. The cheese they used was delicious. Overlooking the disappointing guac, cold enchiladas, and over sweetened margarita, the rest of the food was absolutely delicious. We will be back here. My Pollo Norteno meal was a huge portion and I had leftovers for the next day. The service was very attentive and apologetic about the mix up with my Dad's meal. *editing review to mention the chicken tortilla soup. This is some of the best soup I've had. There is a lot of chicken in this soup. This could be its own meal.

Great service. Fast and food is amazing. Very good flavor. Had fajita quesadillas and was very…read moregood and fresh ingredients. Highly recommended this place in the greater Sun Prairie area.

Fresh food! Guac is very good. Queso has a little kick. So perfect. Exactly what I was craving!!read more

Try the Hartford Cheesesteak burrito! Amazing!! Everything is fresh, and everything is awesome!read more

Chimichangas were very good. Large margaritas were excellent. Good salsa. We'll definitely be…read morecoming back, hopefully with a designated driver.