I've always got my Fioris from the well hidden Brookline location but I'll admit it's been years. I remember the grease runoff from the pepperoni. This new fancy joint with lots of seating in Posh Peter's has just what the family ordered. We started with a small salad and there's enough in one for both of us. If you don't like chopped onion and green peppers then make sure you request them off. The salads are loaded with greens and pepperoni and cheese plus some other salad usuals. Great salad. We then dug into a large pizza and took most of it home because the salads were so big. After a couple drinks our bill was $32. A bit pricey but worth it as it was a great casual on the fly meal. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

In my opinion this is the best local pizza. They don't deliver but it's worth the drive or just eat it there. Other options as well.

Great pizza, enjoyed a salad with it. Good service at the table, quick with the refills. Clean and new, would definitely recommend and will definitely go back read more

Our go to pizza shop. Love the onion rings too. Nice staff and clean tables. Convenient and easy on Rt 19s.

I was in Washington PA and returning back to Pittsburgh when I stopped to dine here. I was told by numerous people about the quality of Fiori's. I ordered 1/2 mushroom cheese steak (L,T,O) and a large white pizza. The bread was over toasted on the sandwich in which no amount of mayonaise could soften. The waitress asked me how my sandwich was : I replied there was no cheese nor onions and the bread over toasted. She said she would correct. My white pizza arrived and asked why there was no tomatoes on the pie. The waiter said you didn't order them (never had a white pizza w/o tomatoes?) but promptly brought me numerous slices of tomato to dress the pie. This was one of the better pizza's I had in quire some time. The waitress came over and comp me with a 1/2 s teak hoagie to go. This is what you call customer service, wasn't entirely necessary, and definitely will be a repeat customer. Good Job! read more

Best Pizza! We love the crust but also the sauce is so good. you can eat in, or take out. Staff is always nice. Try it, you won't be disappointed. read more

This is my go to pizza joint! Hands down worth the 20min drive while I have 6 pizza places within 5 minutes of the house. Has a slightly sweeter sauce. read more

Best pizza in Pittsburgh Friendly staff and the food is just amazing. It always has been and probably always will be. The Brookline location is the one we normally go to and have never had an issue. Try it, you'll absolutely love it!! read more

my brothers and I tried Fiori's in Canonsburg, PA -- Dave Portnoy style!!! Fiori's is always a fan favorite in our house with the sweet sauce balanced out by the salty pepperoni and a heavy layer of cheese. We loveeee Fiori's Pizza!!! read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Large Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in Pittsburgh. Best pizza in state of PA and OH! Crust is sweet, sauce is flavorful and plenty. Cheese is very good. Add pepperoni to it for a intense meat flavor. Price is fair about $20 for large pie. read more

I always make sure to stop by Fiori's and get an Italian Hoagie. I'm from the west coast and they don't know what a hoagie is. Fiori's has the best Italian hoagie I have ever had!!! read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - 1/2 Italian Hoagie. My "go-to" when visiting the Burg! - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Popped in for a slice. Ended up eating two. Pizza crust is a little crunchy. A bit past chewy. Staff is friendly. Tables are blocked off for COVID spacing. Sauce is a tad too sweet for me but obviously everyone loves it. Pepperoni is fantastic! read more

Pizza here is great but it is competing with what seems like a dozen competitors with great pizza. The decor is cafeteria type seating. The service can be slow. All that said, Fiori's is probably the busiest business in the area. There are occasional traffic jams of customers trying to get their Fiori's pizza fix. read more

Salad was good, but the sauce on the pizza is way too sugary sweet. Not a fan at all.

Hands down my favorite pizza in the South Hills. Both the sauce and crust have a a slightly sweet taste to them. We prob eat here way too much! read more

Just as good as the original in Brookline. Great restaurant, great pizza, great service

Everyone in Pittsburgh raves about how great Fiori's is, and I had never been until today. We stopped here and got some carry out. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza. They told us that it would be ready in 45 minutes but it was ready in a half hour. We were really excited to get home because the pizza in the car smelled amazing. The pizza itself, the sauce and the crust, were very very sweet for pizza. I'd like to try it again when it's fresh! read more

Pizza was below my expectations based on reviews and "best of..." lists. The red sauce is runny and sweet in a way that's reminiscent of SpaghettiOs. The cheese is globbed and chewy and falls off the slice. I prefer cheese that bakes in with the crust. The serving sizes are large as stated but $6 for a "premium" topping (sausage?) is not cool. The salad and garlic bread were very good which bumps up the score. Would go back to try a hoagie. read more

Fioris is highly rated and reviewed by fellow yelpers but my first outing here wasn't what I expected . Time to serve : way too long ! It surely was quite busy on a Saturday evening but even then - it took close to 20+ mins to get the pizza . Thank god for the beer ! The Pizza itself : we ordered a half with the pepperoni and the other half with sausage. Unfortunately- the toppings were hardly visible - felt like eating just a cheese pizza . BTW - the Pepperoni tasted like it had just come out of a giant eagle freezer ! Hopefully that's not what they use . The place itself was buzzing - a lot of grandparents with their grandkids . Will give it a 2nd try- but my search for a good pizza place in Mc Murray and neighboring areas continues . read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Half pepperoni and half sausage - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

See all

I grew up eating pizza from the original location in Brookline and it's my all-time favorite pizza! Now that I live in the suburbs of the south hills, I was so happy when they opened a second location that was still close to me and it has an easy to access parking lot! I loved going to the original location, but always hated fighting for parking on the steep hills that surround it. This location is easy to get into and it's also significantly larger, so you're also not fighting for a table. I don't think the pizza here is quite the same as the original, but it's still pretty darn good with its signature sweet sauce. Whenever we're wanting pizza, Fiori's is usually our go-to because we always leave satisfied! read more

Good pizza. They sell by the slice. Can't go wrong with Fiori's. Clean and good service .

Best pizza in area, don't waste time anyplace in area, it's the best! Everything on menu is good! Nice clean place! read more

We live closer to the other location but we were on our way home from a game in Washington county and decided to finally try fioris. Sad to say the pizza was not the best pizza I've ever had but the servers were friendly and the restaurant has a nice setup. I'm glad we tried it. Maybe we will try the one closer to our house. read more

During the past month or so we have had to look for places that were open for dine in or take out after 8:30 Pm. How fortunate we were To find Fiori's open for both late evening. On Sat night I called to place an order approx 9:30 PM and they were so helpful and accommodating Again thanks for being open were everyone else closes at 8pm read more

Luv luv this pizza. I haven't ate here for over 2 months because of having surgery. The crust is light and crispy. We always get a large plain for me and large pepperoni for my husband. This way we eat in the restaurant and then take the remainder at home for left overs. The people work there are all very nice. The servers are very attentive at the tables. Will refill you drinks. Leave tip at table or in container at the register. read more

Delicious pizza and crispy wings! Don't forget to get cold pizza sauce on the side and dip your pizza in the sauce! Our "go to" for football Sunday. read more

I went to Fiori's in McMurray for the first time ( Tuesday, 22 March) after reading a couple of good reviews on-line. I decided to order a Medium Calzone which was supposed to contain "Ricotta cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, onion, and provolone cheese." My Calzone contained a ton of Ricotta cheese and nothing else. Where were the other ingredients??? A positive point to mention is that a "medium" could literally feed a family of four. Most of mine went home in a box. I will pry it open later and put in the missing ingredients and enjoy it much more. The saving grace for the day was the Counter and Wait Staff were very congenial and polite in every regard. read more

Raise the prices and get better ingredients. I've had better pizza at a public elementary school cafeteria. This pizza is so bad it's almost great. Is it a nostalgic connection to horrible bland dough and pasty flavorless sauce with cheap cheese? I don't know what a pizza would taste like if you ground up some corregated and mixed it in with the dough but I'd imagine it'd be close to this. Completely flavorless. This was my 2nd try. bye read more

My boyfriend and I love Fiori's so much! We always order a large so we have enough for lunch the next day. The sauce and crust have a sweeter taste, which makes this pizza unique. We have also ordered the wings, which have improved from prior visits. We will be back soon. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in Pittsburgh. 12 Buffalo wings and a small pepperoni pizza is the go to order. Can't forget the ranch. 10/10 never a bad experience here in my entire life. read more

Fabulous pizza. One of the best the city has to offer. Consistently fresh and delicious. Even the toss salad is remarkable. And, to top it off, they have the MOST courteous and kind people working there. You will measure every other pizza to this one, I promise! read more

My husband and I love Fiori's pizza! They have the cutest restaurant...not too big but not too small. They have a sweet sauce on the pizza and we can't stop eating! Our pizza had lots of toppings and was very satisfying. They have beer and wine along with soda and tea. We always recommend. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

One of the best Pies in the area. Sauce is slightly sweet but, for me, not overly so. Wings pretty good as well. Only negatives are prices are little high and wait times can be over 1 1/4 hour on busier nights. read more

We were in town and had heard good things about this place so we stopped in for dinner with our 3 kids. It was busy when we arrived but the wait staff were attentive and friendly. We started with garlic bread but didn't really notice a garlic flavor. The dipping sauce was good though and made up for the bread's lack of flavor. My oldest ordered chicken strips and fries which were your standard nondescript tenders and fries. No different than you'd get at a chain. My middle ordered the ravioli which were really good and plentiful and came with another side of garlic bread we didn't know about until it was delivered to the table. My husband, youngest and I shared a pizza. The pizza took forever which was not unexpected given how busy they were however the table next to us got their large pizza considerably before us and they were seated about 5 minutes after we were so that was a bit confusing. The crust was delicious and perfectly crisp and the pepperoni were tiny and delicious. The sauce, however, had a sweetness we were not fond of and I wish the pizza sauce had been more like the savory marinera that came with the garlic bread. Overall it was fine but if we return we will be passing on the pizza based on the sauce and trying something else. read more

Local icon lives up to the reputation. Great for takeout or enjoy the dining room with great service. After the last year,it's nice to see people enjoying themselves over good Italian food and pizza. read more

Today was the Third time eating at Fiori's and we just love this place! I can't figure out how other yelper's give this place one star, everything is delicious, the crust tastes great and is cooked perfectly and the sauce is one of the best we have tasted!! It's Definitely in the Top 10 Best Pizzas we've ever had!! We'll definitely be returning!! Keep up the great work Fiori's!! read more

See all

There are 2 Fiori's in town. One is on West Liberty Avenue and then this place which opened about a year ago on Washington Road. It is near our church so sometimes after church we go there for lunch. This location is a much nicer and brighter location. Their cheese pizza is very good. Occasionally we order toppings but I believe a good pizza doesn't NEED toppings. They also have hoagies which are very good. You order at the counter and they bring your food to you when it's ready. It's a great place to go as a family or group. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Absolutely fantastic calzones, pizzas, and salads!One of the best pizza places in town! Enjoy!

Since high school, I have always loved Fiori's Pizzaria. The amazing dough, the sweet sauce, and the flavorful cheese all combined to make Fiori's the best pizza in Pittsburgh. There was nothing like eating a piping hot fresh pie as a dine-in customer. I have since moved to St. Louis, but I am currently visiting family back here in Pittsburgh. I told my family that I definitely need to have Fiori's after having amazing pizza in St. Louis. It was then that I found out about this second location. My dad was able to pick it up on the way home from work. While it has been many years since I had eaten their pizza, I can say that it still tastes amazing. While it wasn't the same as eating in fresh in the original location, it still had the same wonderful combination of flavors that I remember. I definitely recommend this pizza to anyone in Pittsburgh or anyone visiting Pittsburgh, and I still believe that it is Pittsburgh's top pizza. Give them the takeout business! read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Cheese Pizza! Yum! - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Great pizza, pasta, salads! GREAT Atmosphere. Cold beer, and good pours! Italian Salad, Italian Hoagie