Absolutely love their pizza!! Toppings are inside the cheese, and I would definitely recommend the pepperoni. Also try their take home pizza kit, only $10 for cheese, you can ask for toppings, and my son loves to make it with us!! Has the same great taste as in the store!! read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

I had excellent service, the woman who took my order was so nice. After I was done I asked for a box to take the rest home and she came over and boxed it for me. I didn't have to wait too long for it to come out. Plenty of seating inside. Delicious pizza!!! I just love the cheese. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Very nice place! It gets busy and the seating area is a little small. Food was excellent. You look up to order but your food is served at your table. Service was good and wait staff was friendly. I wish I could eat more carbs as I would be there a lot! read more

Best pizza in Pittsburgh, hands down. This has become our Friday night go-to and every time it's consistently delicious.

The product is excellent as always. I am willing to accept a more than 13% increase in the price of the pizza since my last visit, but a $6.00 charge for meatball topping on a 16 inch pizza is ridiculous. I know of no pizza shop that charges such an exorbitant amount for any topping. That left a sour taste in my mouth. read more

I've said this before in my reviews and I'll say it again, I'm a pizza snob. I've done the NYC pizza tours, traveled to Chicago to eat at the Original Uno and Lou Malnatti's. I've been to Detroit for their infamous Detroit style. Best of all I've attended the largest pizza convention in the world in fabulous Las Vegas and tasted incredible pizzas during the competitions. With that being said, Pittsburgh has a diverse and unique pizza scene. Every type of pizza is offered in this city and the surrounding areas. Everyone loves their local joints and their favorite city spots. For me, when it comes to a thin pizza Fiori's is my city favorite. Crust has a nice pull, great mouth feel which is appreciated. It screams made in house unlike the franchise pizza joints. Sauce is not to sweet and compliments the pepperoni. Their cheese taste like a blend of quality mozzarella and provolone mix. To me everything comes together to make one hell of a pie. While I didn't get their pasta this time I really do enjoy their sauce and meatballs. It's easy to tell why Fiori's has such a great fan base. They have great quality ingredients and pay attention to detail. All these years and not one time have I needed to complain or had an order wrong. read more

As a lifetime pgh resident, Fiori's usually doesn't disappoint. However, we ordered take out from the McMurray libation last evening and the pizza was not anywhere as good as it usually is. There was barely any cheese, the dough was super thick and doughy, and it was chewy. The sauce was still sweet and yummy... but overall a real disappointment. Fiori's, what's up? It used to be the BOMB. read more

I just got a small pie with sausage and pepperoni. They changed the type of sausage, the sauce is not the same, and I think the pepperoni also is different and I don't like it one bit. This is the one in McMurray read more

Seems like a popular place. Onion rings were very good! Sandwiches were very good. Pizza was good. Service was also good.

I had a change of scenery for my usual Friday night pizza run when I found myself commuting through the Far South Hills. Luckily, I wasn't far from the new(ish) Fiori's location! I called ahead and placed my order and was told it would be 25 minutes. I got there about 10 minutes after calling so I went in to pay and wait for my order. The dining area is large and has plenty of tables for those that choose to dine in. I could tell some people were at their first Fiori's rodeo because there were a couple groups just gawking at the menu trying to decide what sounded good (pro tip: ALL OF IT!). I will point out that if the line gets a little long and people are standing around waiting for their pickup orders, it can be hard to figure out where to go when you get in here. I made my way through the line and paid for my food (and of course the cup of cold cheese. Try it. You're welcome.). I ended up waiting about 15 minutes past my scheduled pickup time and after being asked twice to remind them what my order was. I've never had this happen at the Capital Ave. location, but considering how slammed this location was for 5:30 on a Friday night I was understanding of the situation. The pizza was great, although a bit skimpier on the pepperoni than my identical pie from the original location. Overall it was still a damn good pizza and exactly what I've come to expect from the Fiori's name. read more

Ordered pizza and a side salad. The pizza was just ok. The salad portion was very generous with lots of pepperoni and the dressing was good. Would probably try their hoagie next. read more

My god. The wing sauce is delectable. Wings cooked to perfection. Can't go wrong here!

We celebrated my friends birthday at Fiori's McMurray tonight. That was her choice despite living 30+ miles away. The food is consistently good and I have to say that the service was top notch. They could not have been nicer and more hospitable. Since the pandemic and staff shortages and cutbacks, customer service is often lacking. This was not the case at Fiori's and we so appreciated them making our evening so special. Kudos to Amy, Mike, and the whole staff. read more

Decent place for pizza although I think it is overrated. The sauce is too sweet for my liking. However it is nice to have a place where you can grab a couple slices. They give you so much pepperoni on a slice! The staff is friendly. I've only ever ordered to go so I'm not sure how the service is. Overall a decent pizza joint. Definitely not the best tasting in the area unless you like sweet pizza. read more

Just waited an hour for a pizza that was undercooked. Too doughy. So disappointing. Somehow they had given out two of the same number. Waited a long time for our salad also. Lots of staff but not great service or food read more

Ended up getting Spaghetti with meatballs and a pepperoni and sausage pizza. Everything I would expect from Fiori's. Service was attentive and super friendly! Will definitely be back soon. read more

We moved here from California and have been trying as many new places to eat in our area. Needless to say, my family and I have found our new pizza place! We typically do take out since we live up the street, but If you dine in know it's super clean and the wait staff are all great. Note, this can be a popular place especially on the weekends so it can get crowded so there may be a wait. All in all, I highly recommend this place! read more

every time i come here i realize.....i don't come here enough!!! love this pizza....great staff, outstanding quality. read more

Well wanted some chow after work so I thought I'd try a local place. I ordered a half Italian an sub and slice of pizza. The staff was very friendly and willing to hide me through the ordering process. Here you order, pay, take a number and head for a table. The best I can say is "yawn". The Italian is ok, I like a vinegar and oil based dressing and this hoagie was very lightly dressed. It contained typical deli meats, light on the lettuce, onion and tomato. The pizza crust was a bit soggy and as others have remarked, I found the sauce to be too sweet for my palate. In short...I may not come back. The food just isn't good enough to warrant a return trip. read more

Nice place but the food is sub-par. Italian salad had way too much cheese, and I forgot, here in da burg, everyone loves iceberg lettuce. Most of ours was the white. Onion rings too breaded. Wings-- forget it. The bbq sauce didn't even taste like bbq sauce. I can't even describe the taste. Sent them back for regular Buffalo. That was just as bad because it was just res hit. Hey, chef, Buffalo sauce is suppose to have butter and red hot mixed- duh. Now the pizza. I will say, the topping were good and fresh. The crust was good too.. but the sauce! It was so sweet I thought we had ordered a dessert pizza. Yuck! Won't be back. read more

You know when a pizza place lives up to the reputation This is now a go, all good. I've grown up on the Brookline-Capital 1990's 2000's Saw. You will not find that ever again. Seeing dough tossed in the window morning to night is not happening again. But this is good! Get extra sauce sauce, still sweet and you will thank me... read more

I have had the pizza, pep and sausage , meatball hoagie and Italian hoagie and all were excellent!!! This place gets really busy on the weekends and in the winter , but it's worth it. read more

That pizza was good I had to tell the lady at the hotel thank you for that Recommendation love the pizza done just right

I am so glad I finally found a sitdown place to enjoy excellent pizza. I absolutely refuse to go to a place that serves pizza shells or uses conveyor belts to cook the pizza. Pizza here is cooked in the traditional pizza oven and does not come out with burnt or singed edges. We enjoyed a nice thin crust pizza that was crisp and not chewy as well as a cheese calzone. Beware that the small calzone is huge lots of ricotta cheese. read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

Fiori's has been one of my favorite pizza places in Pittsburgh, having eaten at the hole-in-the-wall South Hills location for several years. I was excited to see this new, dressed up restaurant in Peters Township, and suggested to a group of friends we eat there for lunch since we were already in the area for an event. The four of us ordered two small pies to share, but I was completely mortified I made the suggestion as soon as I saw our friends' pizza. They ordered a plain cheese, and there was literally a puddle of grease sitting on top of it. I understand pizza is greasy, but this was excessive. I could've tipped this pizza over a sink and had a small grease waterfall going. It took at least a dozen napkins for them to sop up what they were served, but still ended up eating a soggy mess. Perhaps my friends were trying to be polite in eating it, but if it were my pizza I would've sent it back to the kitchen, something I rarely do. I didn't understand how the wait staff could carry that pizza to our table with a straight face. We mentioned it as he served it, but didn't seem to think much of it. I still love Fiori's, but I don't think I'll come back to this location. The pizza here barely resembled the Fiori's I know and love. read more

I had been told by a few people to try Fioris if I want good pizza. It wasn't worth the hype, to me. The prices were fair, the service was great, but the actual pizza flavor wasn't that great. The crust was crispy. The cheese was stringy, but thats about it. I had to add Parmesan cheese, garlic and salt. Personal preference but the sauce is really sweet and I prefer my sauce to have a little more zest to it. I'd be willing to try something else from there but I'll keep going to my usual pizza place for now for my pizza fix. read more

We picked up pizza for dinner one night. It was very good. Fresh toppings and piping hott. My wife loved it, if you like a sweeter sause then you must have the pizza. I really like the cheese on the pizza. Overall it was a really good pizza for pickup read more

I don't know what all the fuss was about. This was very basic pizza with nothing unique or memorable about it. read more

Most pizza places in the McMurray/Peters area are garbage. Fioris is hands down the best around. Ask for your pizza well done and you can't go wrong. Also the home made provolone sticks are the bomb. Steak hoagies are great too with their special sauce. Weekends can be crazy sometimes so make sure if you want Fiori's for dinner on a Friday to call it in early. When they tell you it's going to be an hour and a half wait, they mean it. So be prepared to wait for the best pizza you've ever had. That place gets jam packed on weekends. Glad to finally have some good Italian food in Washington county. read more

This is some of the best pizza I've ever had. Since moving to Canonsburg, I was extremely worried that all I saw was Pizza Hut - then a quick Yelp search led me here! They only do pick up or eat in, as far as I know. They might deliver to houses closer than mine, but the drive is every bit worth it. I've called in multiple times. My pizza is always hot & ready as soon as I get there. Employees have always been friendly. The menu is extremely basic. Pizza and hoagies. No frills and they don't need it! Their crust isn't too thick or thin. They're generous with toppings but the best thing about their pizza is the sauce. It's a sweet sauce and by far my favorite. The only reason they lose a star is their hoagies. They left A LOT to be desired compared to the pizza. read more

On vacation from Michigan , my dad who lives in south pointe suggested fioris and let me tell you ..... by far the best pizza I have ever had ! Out of this world can't wait till I come back again to have it again !!! read more

Excellent food with large portions. Service and staff deserve an A+! Only complaint about this place is that it is freezing in the dining area! I was shivering the entire time. read more

What a excellent place highly recommend we go at least once a week pleasant staff food is ALWAYS fresh and HOT read more

See all

We've been experimenting with other pizza in our area that we've never tried before. Got a large pizza and wings. Both in their photos and on our pizza, the cheese was heavy in the middle and almost a 2 inch wide band around the outside crust with no cheese at all. Also the sauce was too sweet for me. I think they overwork their dough because the dough is "tough". The wings were average in every way, not bad but not great either. Considering the distance from our house, would probably not drive this far unless I was in the area already. I have made the drive to Buckeye Lake Ohio to buy pizza at Pizza Cottage, which is the best. read more

One of the best pizza places in Pittsburgh. This is the second of two locations. While it's cleaner and much newer, I still like the old Pittsburgh dive vibe of the other location just a little better. I would describe this locatoon as more family friendly thanks to more space and coloring books for the kiddos. Either location, it's delicious pizza. The crust is subtly sweet thanks to Sprite in the crust, and the pizza is always loaded with cheese and toppings. read more

I made the right choice by ordering that very simple dish...spaghetti and meatballs! The sauce at Fiori's is heavenly and the meatballs were some of the best I have had in a while. The portion sizes were huge and they give you plenty of garlic bread on the side. The staff is friendly and always wear a smile. I will definitely be back for more! read more

Fiori's Pizzaria - Fiori's - Pizza Near Me - McMurray, Pennsylvania

I eat out 14 times a week, all over the U.S. I think it's time to start giving honest feedback; helping others make informed dining decisions. This was a takeout for 6: +Very friendly staff +Clean atmosphere +Pizza is fantastic! +Meatballs were tasty. +Magic Hat #9 while we waited. +TV's, too. +Very casual +They take American Express! Overall Grade: 93% out of 100% I would definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

Fiori's was good. The layout is a little confusing if you have not been there before. The staff was super helpful and welcoming--they helped us understand the structure of Fiori's (pick up a menu when you walk in, order at the register, they bring you your food and drinks). I thought the Pizza was just okay. The crust and cheese were good. The sauce was blan and unmemorable. The pizza was also very pricey. I was surprise to see how busy the place was. The Staff was very friendly. Everyone kept checking on us to make sure we were enjoying our food and time at Fiori's. read more

We have eaten at Fiori's many times in the past and I seem to remember it as much better than it actually is. Our last time here served up a very lackluster large pizza with olives and banana peppers. The crust literally has no taste and the dough was not well cooked. Service is always great though and the team does an excellent job at bussing the tables. We are definitely looking for a different go-to from now on. read more

The demand for this pizza in Peters has skyrocketed, so I wasn't surprised about the hour+ wait on an early Friday night. However, on a separate occasion, I picked up a couple small pizzas I ordered and they were both placed in the box too soon, so the cheese slid entirely off the pizza. It wasn't as good as it could have been because of the messiness, BUT I'd be willing to try it again. We did call and they apologized/gave us credit for next time. It was good anyway and the sauce was just the right amount of sweet! read more