Our family of five was visiting relatives up there. We were staying up by Abayance Bay and ordered 5 large pizzas over the phone. Pick up time was reasonable, order was correct. We chose from their specialty pizzas and every one tasted amazing !!! read more

Nice atmosphere. Food was excellent and the service was amazing. Only one waitress on a busy breakfast morning but she was so attentive. Quick, and very nice. We're here on vacation and like Fire and Slice over a breakfast downtown read more

Terribly slow. Waiter took 25 minutes to give some more coffee and we had to ask. No one ask us how food was , hash browns were not very warm, didn't want to send back, as who knew How long it would take to return, sure it would have just been microwaved .Waited 56 minutes for breakfast and they were not that busy. read more

When ordering out/ for pick up, check your bags before you leave, i've gotten home a couple times and i've had some items that i paid for missing & was disappointed with it read more

Tried 2x now.... first time we waited in lobby area 10 minutes and no one even acknowledge us then when they did they said it would be a hour or more to get food. It was bull thing weekend. so we tried the following weekend again No help. Waited 15 minutes to get a menu and water. Waitress took orders of tables that arrived after us. Only 7 tables occupied. 1 hr ..still no food. A Total disappoint read more

Not the same Fire and Slice! I have been a customer at all 3 locations in Eureka, but I must say the quality now 08/29/24 is more miss than hit these days. The Hit: The mango habanero bone-in wings are great, just enough heat and sweetness to win over the most staunch wing connoisseur. The house salad with fresh veggies and wonderfully pickled beets were a treat for the eyes and pallette. The mozzarella sticks well are mozzarella sticks. They were perfectly cooked, crunchy and unbroken with the ooze of the cheese. The Miss: The cheese pizza with red sauce is usually a solid hit for the traditional pizza lovers. Usually the pizzas are cooked a bit light, but that is something for a dicernable connoisseur to fret over and easily fixed at home with 10 extra minutes in the oven. However I degress, it was requested to cook this pizza a bit extra, but it arrived and appeared near undone. The cheese texture is HORRIBLE, no matter how long it was reheated, the cheese never seemed to melt, and had a very bitter/sour taste. The cheese bread cheese was overall better but the over-saturation of garlic and garlic salt rendered the cheese bread bitter, horribly salty and unappealing. The red dipping sauce usually offsets the saltiness and bitterness however, the sauce appears to have been downgraded as well. The red dipping sauce tasted as if it were just poured out of a can and served. The tomato and bitterness shown through the red sauce as well. One last minor miss which hurt the otherwise spectacular wings was the ranch dipping sauce or lack there of! This may seem like a minor quip for many, but the offset texture of ranch against spicy, sweet crunchy wings is a thing of beauty, but to run out after 4 wings is a bit much. It is not an over indulgence on my part over a half serving of ranch in the cup, literally half, which woefully denies the complexity of tastes too their full virtue. So 2 stars, this order feels as though Fire and Slices standards have fallen a bit to far for today's competition and price points. Attached is a picture of the pizza after it was cooked a bit longer, even extra and you can see the cheese problem I spoke about in the review. UPDATE: The manager has informed us of a temporary distribution issue they are currently experiencing. Today's pizza was made with a substitute cheese from the distribution center due to the center running out if their regular cheese. We have been credited with a pizza gift card which will replace the cheese knockoff. The manager was very pleasent and we will try the pizza again in 2 weeks. Updated from 2 star to 3 stars for making transaction change. read more

Fire and Slice Pizza - Slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, Montana

I used to love this place. I used to take people visiting from out of town here proudly. If I pulled my credit card statement from last year, I would probably not be shocked to see that I spent in the neighborhood of $3,000 - $3,500 here last year, easily. Because it used to be pretty good. But... as a local, I've given up, and it takes A LOT for me to say that. I LOVE and appreciate our local businesses. But I will never go here again. The last 5 times I have eaten here in person, or ordered out, they have gotten my order wrong. Like, REALIY WRONG. The most recent: Ordered Salad with extra dressing - received - salad with zero dressing, much less extra dressing (but still paid for it, of course) Ordered boneless wings with ranch dressing - received zero dressing (but paid for it) Ordered a pizza with mushrooms and olives - received zero mushrooms or olives (but still paid for them) Ordered an extra side of Ranch - received no side of ranch (but still paid for it) Again, this is one order, but pretty much representative of the last 5 orders, except for the previous in-house time we ate, in which the order screw-up was even worse. We are done. For as much as I used to spend, I can get a pretty awesome pizza oven and not put up with their "new" cornmeal-coated cardboard flavored pizza crust, which barely rivals the worst frozen selections in Watson's. read more

Waited 45 minutes for a side of eggs(over medium) and a side of sausage. When it finally came out, the eggs were undercooked, still slimy. Paid for my coffee and left. The waitress was fine, it was the kitchen. There were 8 tables with between 2-4 people at 11 a.m. waitress insisted the kitchen was "super busy". As a local to the area, the new ownership is very disappointing. Used to go once a week for breakfast, its been 6 months since I was in due to the decline. Don't think I'll ever go back as its only getting worse. read more

Service good,server attentive with coffee and such,food was very good,nice portions.However 1 hour for food,not that busy,one cook,not a multitasker,HIRE more chefs... read more

Love the food but service almost isn't worth going in anymore. The waitress Tia ignored me and ran off into a corner to avoid grabbing my pizza that was done and sitting in the warmer, got to the point I turned the pos system around and found my order and paid for it then had to walk into the casino in order to have someone grab my food. read more

This place has awesome pizza. The wings are super tasty and the beer, well it's beer. Love the atmosphere and service! Great job team! read more

We ordered a cheese pizza from them. Keep in mind...20 dollars for a pizza now and you would think they would make it worth it. The cheese was clumpy and not melted at all. We put it on a pan to warm it up in the oven. Overall very disappointed. read more

Fire and Slice Pizza - We ordered a regular cheese pizza from them and this is what we got. - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, Montana

Came here to meet a friend for lunch and by I love me some pizza. We ordered a veggie pizza that was amazing. Probably the best pizza in Eureka. It was quick, hot and very tasty with plenty to take home for leftovers. I'm so glad there's a good pizza joint in Eureka. I heard their wings are fantastic too but we stuck to pizza. Place was clean, sanitized and Covid protocols looks to be in place. Definitely will be back for pizza. read more

Gave them a try several times ... every single time the pizza was cold and BURNED BLACK!! Absolute terrible pizza ..

The food was great portion's were large!! Our server was new so learning but still friendly. Every table was full but no servers to be found and drinks were empty while manager stood around. Also as tables emptied tables were not bussed for new customers to sit at and took forever to pay since no one was to be found. Made the experience mediocre read more

Great "4-corners" location with outdoor seating that was nicely decorated. Friendly, helpful, and engaging staff made my visit worthwhile. The menu had a diverse selection of fairly typical items. I chose the Summer Salad of figs, blue cheese, candied pecans, & vinaigrette served over over baby lettuces. It was the right choice of ingredients but the ratio was off (for me) and it ended up being more of a very large dessert than a light meal. That said, because they put the dressing on the side, I was able to portion the salad to my liking and I really appreciate this option! I chose the (fried) chicken wings to accompany the salad. The crisp wings were nicely coated (not overly sauced) with the golden bbq sauce - delicious! Not oily at all and very nice. I particularly appreciated the crisp celery and carrots - very fresh! I had enough for leftovers and the next day the wings were just as tasty eaten cold with the remaining veggies. read more

This place was recommended to me by the staff at the hotel where I was staying. I reviewed the menu online, and I was excited because of the gluten free pizza and the bone in wings are cooked in their own fryer. My biggest complaint was that everything took a really long time. I understand the place was short on staff, but I think the staff also played a part. This spot is definitely a local place, and the servers spend a lot of time helping tables where they know people. If you're out of town or not familiar with the staff, don't expect to get served. It took a long time to have water brought to my table, it took a long time to have my order taken, and then I waited over 50 minutes to have food brought out. I was by myself and was texting some friends, which is how I was able to keep tabs on how much time had passed. I understand servers are busy and have to help a lot of people, but it's really frustrating when you ask for something like water, and then the server spends 10 minutes talking to friends, and then the server completely forgets you wanted a refill. As for the food, I wasn't too impressed. It might be because of the service I received, but my impression was "I waited almost an hour for this? Why?!" The wings were kind of soggy and had feathers still on the wing. To me, that's gross. And the pizza was undercooked. I had waited so long for my food that I was afraid to have the servers take it back. So I only ate a slice, and I didn't bother to take it home as leftovers. It was such a waste. read more

The food is awesome. It's worth coming and checking out. The price was very reasonable. I can't wait to come back again. read more

See all

The outdoor seating is so much fun! My family loved the games they have to play while we waited for our food. The crust on their cheesy bread and pizza was nice and soft and had great flavor! We also tried the wings and the chicken was nice and Tender, but the breading was a bit thick. read more

Fire and Slice Pizza - Chicken Outback - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, Montana

See all

Great food Service was fast Ambiance is very nice Waitress' are very attentive and always have a smile. read more

Probably some of the best pizza we have ever had! Wait time took about 25 minutes, service was friendly even though we showed up ten minutes before closing asking to place a to go order. We ordered the cheesy bread & the fire cracker pizza, both had so much flavor & were cooked perfectly. Would 100% recommend! read more

Such a great place with delicious pizza! I was only in Eureka a few days but ate here twice! So tasty and Carmella was the sweetest gal! I would definitely recommend this place to anyone & everyone. Made my Montana trip all the better with great food :) read more

Fire and Slice Pizza - Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, Montana

My favorite place in Eureka. Best pizza in town and cheese curds are awesome. Service is typically pretty good considering how hard it is to find employees these days. read more

We have ordered out here quite a bit and 80% of the time they screw up our order in one way or another. The last time they forgot or "didn't hear" that I had ordered a salad. I called, said we didn't get our salad, "oh yeah it's sitting here". My wife shows up to get it and tried to explain to them this happens a lot. Then they cop an attitude and say it was never ordered. Piss pour customer service. We have spent hundreds here feeding our family and friends. read more

I have had breakfast and pizza here and I have to say they have a dang good pizza!!!! Breakfast is good, but I only eat pizza occasionally and this is where I go for it. Never had better anywhere. read more

Andre is the best pizza chef there is. Noelle is amazing and super courteous. Considering this is the only place in town that makes pizza I think that makes it a winner. read more

New location and still yummy. Love that you have a choice of cooking wings in fryer or baked. Dry rub on wings was yummy,skin was crisp and meat was tender. We also had the "hot" & garlic honey wet wings...great flavor. Happy hour 2-4 daily.. specials $5 wings $3 beer. We ordered meat lovers pizza and it was flavorful and crust was perfect. read more

Stopped by Fire and Slice while visiting Eureka for a wedding. I had their chicken white sauce pizza - it was SO GOOD! A complex blend of cheeses combined with the chicken and caramelized onions made it the perfect comfort food with just the right amount of zing. It was the kind of quality you would expect in a big city, not a small town. But the salad was what really blew my mind. Their Greek salad was crisp, fresh, and colorful. So refreshing! I cannot recommend this restaurant enough. When I raved to my friend about the pizza, she told me their wings are even better. I will definitely be back for Thursday wing night. read more

I've eaten ALOT of pizza (one of my nicknames is uncle pizza) and I have to say fire and and slice delivers one of if not the best pizza I have ever eaten. Their wood fired crust has a nice crisp but yet a great chew as well, combine that with a great flavorful tomato sauce and lots of great toppings for a fantastic pizza. I have tried almost all of the different pizzas and I have thoroughly enjoyed them all, but my go to is the bacon margarita ! You should of course start with some of their tasty wings. Some great flavor combinations both wet and dry I think my favorite are the garlic Parmesan. Along with great food is the great service. Shauna the manger( if she isn't a manger she should be! ) keeps thing moving along like a well oil machine. Tonight our waitress Rena was efficient, super friendly -thanks Rena We will be back every time we get close to eureka! read more

This place was packed and the waitress was kind and attentive. We enjoyed the picnic plate , with fresh baked bread, cheese, olives and pepperoni. Followed by Honey BBQ and Buffalo Gold wings. The Buffalo Gold wings are a tangy mustard sauce with a hit of smoked flavor. For the small town of Eureka this place is clean and welcoming. read more

Fire and Slice Pizza - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, Montana

See all

Great food and service! We will definitely be back here the next time we're in town. Love that they have gluten free options!

Great ambiance..Edison lightbulbs, whimsical artwork (friendships in wildlife sharing pizza), wonderful, personable staff. Warm, clean, cozy....Wood Fired pizza is EXCELLENT! Some of the best I've had anywhere and, I'm from California where it is all the craze. BEERS ON TAP, although it's a limited amount, they are hand picked, and specialty micro brew. All the beer perfectly accompanied any pizza. I really liked the Cold Smoke Brew out of the Kettle House brewery in Missoula Mo. We happened to perfectly pair it with the Bacon Margarita Pizza. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit and highly recommend! read more

Excellent pizza - we enjoyed the classic pepperoni and the signature thai. The crust was nice and chewy and the base wasn't too thin or floppy. Wait staff was friendly. read more

I was excited to visit this pizza place in Eureka, this week. One of our group went into the restaurant and after sitting for over 25 minutes, with three hungry little ones, finally had their order taken. We ordered over the phone and was told that our order would be ready in forty-five minutes. Over an hour later, the order was finally ready. When we arrived home with it, we realized they had forgotten to give us part of the order. A phone call revealed that we were correct, but no apology was forthcoming from them. "They weren't ready when you got the the order." Was the reasoning. We let them know we were coming back to get them. Upon arrival, the wings were cold, feeling like they had been in the fridge. "Well, it has been over an hour." The reply was when we questioned that. Seeing as the order had been picked up only 15 minutes previously, something was off. We took our frigid wings and went home. The pizza was tasty, but the service was so underwhelming and totally frustrating that I don't know that I would ever visit again. I love supporting local businesses, but this one needs some tweaking. A simple apology for the mistakes they made would have made it so much more enjoyable. (Update: The owner/manager did get back with us, apologizing as they had an unexpected work load and young crew. I will plan on giving them another try). read more

Great stop in for lunch with friendly employees! Pizza by the slice worked out great for our kids. We also enjoyed boneless buffalo wings! They had a large variety of flavor options which we liked! We also shared a small pizza and had a beer. Nice variety overall. read more

The BEST pizza in town!! Highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza and the Parmesan garlic wings!!! We've come her a number of times and jabe loved it every single time!!! Absolutely zero complaints and this place is definitely worth visiting read more

Fire and Slice Pizza- Monday Feb 15th 5 pm. The Pizza was great and the service was good. However, we waited an hour and half for our food, which would reduce the number of stars to about 3 for us. This is the second visit we have had this issue. I would say that I wouldn't mind visiting if I had all the time in the world, as the food was great. don't go if you are in a hurry. read more

We came here for dinner and it was amazing! Super family friendly. Service is great. Our waitress was very kind and when we sat down she said that the kids could eat free that night! Pizza was great and the crust was excellent! read more

Outstanding pizza! We live about an hour away but we will be going back for sure! Well worth it!

What a great place! We were traveling through Eureka planning to stop at another location for lunch ( they were closed), when on a recommendation from some locals, we dropped in for lunch. First, they have a very friendly staff. The wood fired pizza is off the hook. There is a good variety of specialty pizzas with house made sauces. They have a limited number of taps but offer local and regional beers. This is a place worth the time. read more