After waiting an hour at Buffalo wild wings and not being served, we ordered a large 2 topping pizza and it was ready in 15 minutes!!! Amazing cheese, pepperoni was crispy and the crust was perfect! Best Pizza I've had in a long time..we are just passing thru and cannot wait to eat here again! read more

Super fast & high quality food for a reasonable price. I don't know how long I can go on for a food review

Pizza is good but the garlic bread is awesome, the best. Very fast service. Good customer service as well

Type 2 Diabetic-3 slices of cheese pizza. They make the dough fresh every day and with lower amounts of sugar. 3 freaking slices! read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

This is the real reason for quarantine weight! Their food is delicious, delivery is fast, and the customer service is great. They also have good deals. During quarantine, I always had them leave the pizza at my front door. I won't even describe the food. I'll let the pictures speak for themselves. read more

See all

I've ordered from here twice. The first time, I called in a pick up order. The second time, I ordered delivery through their website. When I picked up my order, the food was ready quickly and staff were friendly. It's a pretty cramped interior, so not a place you would would want to dine in even if they had tables which they did not. When I ordered delivery (at 7pm on a Friday), my pizza showed up in about 20 minutes. I was impressed. My online ordering experience was less impressive. The website was glitchy, and I had to start over several times. It probably took longer to place the order than to receive it. What about the food, you ask? It's good. I can't complain. But I probably won't return. For me it ranks somewhere between Little Caesars and Pizza Hut. I've had a pizza, the garlic knots and the pepperoni rolls. They were all good but nothing to write home about. Pizza is one of those things where everybody's tastes are different. They're not for me, but if you haven't been here I recommend giving this place a shot. read more

Five Star Pizza - Large 2 topping - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Good pizza, great garlic knots! I mostly get deliveries and the guy is always pleasant.

Placed order over the phone, gentleman told me 5-10 minutes. Pizza was ready when I arrived. Pizza was extremely hot and freshly prepared. Pizza was full of toppings, sauce didn't really have any flavor to it. Other than that pizza wasn't bad. I would visit again and try their wings. read more

Five Star Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Five Star pizza is aptly named. We had a supreme pizza delivered to our hotel via door dash, and it was the best pizza I've had in a very long time. I loved the seasonings/flavor and the toppings were all fresh and high quality. If there were one near my home, it would be my new, go-to pizza. read more

Everything was fine until I went to check out and pay. My total was $32.98. 1 pizza 16'' & 10 wings and 1 ,2 Liter coke Then came the fees 5.49 Service fee 3.69 delivery fee 7.68 Tip fee 5.69 Tax fee My total cost jump to over $48.00. I can understand the Tax fee and the Tip fee But the other 2 fees ? Delivery fee , when you first get on their website, it says free delivery The service fee? You can tap on this and it just say if you order from this place, they charge a service fee. Just because they want to. What a rip off read more

Ordered an extra large deluxe pizza for delivery, and it was great! Soft crust with generous tasty toppings and a good sauce. Very pleased. Delivery was fast too. read more

Im a big fan of pizza so I had to try this place. I got an XL pizza with pepperoni and sausage. The pizza was very good and a better quality than most other pizza spots in the city. The pizzas are very big here and they even have a 4XL size pizza. I also had the pepperoni rolls which were also tasty. read more

Five Star Pizza - XL pizza with pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

My favorite take out pizza place in Tallahassee, one of our favorite pizza places in town in general. Easy to order online and over the phone. Saw it recommended online and was skeptical based on the name but it's great. Folks working there were friendly and helpful. read more

Utterly flavorless garbage. Had never heard of this place, wish it had stayed that way. If you want pizza in Tallahassee, Isabella's is the clear choice, then Gaines St/Decent/Momos. Service was fast and pie was hot, but the pizza was excruciatingly disappointing. It's a step above a Dominos and a step below a Papa Johns, neither of which I would willingly eat. read more

My 'Go To' pizza place! The only incident I have had with them involved them giving me the wrong order for a delivery. No problem! They simply let me keep it and brought me the correct order about 30 minutes later. I had pizza for days! Their dough is made just right and not too sweet...the way I like it! The sauce is flavorful and not too salty (looking at you Marco's). The cheese strings properly and is not crumbly and empty tasting (Domino's) All around, a good and reliable choice. read more

I tried 5 star for the first time a friend loves it and sings its praises, but it fell flat for me. The crust felt undercooked and doughy, the toppings were meagre, and the sauce was toxic. This is one of the worst pizzas I've had in years I think I will just throw away the leftovers which is sad for a 25$ pizza. Avoid this and looks for something else, even frozen would be better. read more

I ordered from five star pizza a few days ago and everything about it from presentation, the box and label and the taste reminded me of Papa Johns pizza. Like someone who used to work there opened a pizza shop and selling the same product. It was just ok. Nothing to order again. The delivery was pretty quick but the food was lukewarm. read more

We enjoy this pizza very much , I ask for the well done pizza and five star services the well done version every time . To me the little extra attention is priceless. Thank you Five star . read more

Five star pizza is great! 99 cent delivery and being open until 3 am gives them an edge over the other pizza places in town. They also do an everything pizza where they throw every topping they have onto it- for a reasonable price! We tried them after they opened with a Facebook coupon and I really enjoyed it. We also ordered a side of garlic butter and it's literally the most amazing garlic butter I have ever had in my life. It's extra special and 100% worth the $1 (or whatever it is). The staff is super friendly and they turn out pizzas really fast. It also seems like they are always running specials and that's the way of life. We will surely be back! read more

Ordered over the phone to save $10 worth of fees. Friendly customer service. Received our delivery at the hotel very quickly. Pizza and wings were very good. It was hot and fresh. read more

One of the best pizza places I've tried in Florida, definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone who is in Tallahassee!!

I ordered the special with the intro coupon. Got one loaded pizza, second one (free) was just cheese. It ended up making four (4) meals for me. Very delicious, and I made a salad to eat with it. They are open every night til 3am. What r u waiting for?? I will be back soon!!! read more

This is a combination review of two visits. We dropped in on December 15th to try this place out and then today. We got a cheese pizza with garlic knots the first time. It was good, but not great. It was a solid pizza, but nothing amazing. Customer service was great both times. I got a coupon in the mail for a free large pizza and I was like, hey let's try this place again. We called it in after the gym (the best time for pizza) and went it with the coupon, the guys in there were so nice and friendly. Got home and threw down on that mother. That pizza was demolished. We both ate half a pizza each and it was a lot better. Sauce and crust consistency was amazing and the pizza bones were baller and fluffy AF. I will definitely come back for a slice after this second experience. It is my favorite smaller joint for pick up now. For the taste, customer service, and price- I don't think you can't beat it. read more

See all

Super nice staff. Yummy pizza even the vegan one. My to go to pizza in tallahasee for sure. They have so many cupons too

Good quality pizza made by a friendly staff. Let's not forget about your amazing quick service and awesome sides: We had the Mild Wings and Garlic Knots. Who can beat $0.99 delivery and open til 3am. Keep it up read more

Daniel is such a quick and professional delivery driver. I hope to see him as a manager one day. He answered all my questions and really seems to know a lot about pizza. I have ordered from 5 star probably 10 times and will definitly continue as long as your employing courteous and professional individuals like daniel read more

Def not five stars, the garlic knots we got weren't all the way cooked. Pizza was decent but pretty greasy. They were quick and the price is alright. read more

Good pizza and they stay open late until 3am. I like the late hours because I work late and they aren't far from my place of work. The delivery is great when they aren't that busy. There have been times when I call for delivery and they tell me it's an hour and 45 minute wait...and it's 2 in the morning. If you close at 3am how could that be, and why don't you have more delivery drivers? The food is good, but they can do better on the delivery. read more

I went to elementary school with the owner Jim. Always a very kind and honest guy. You can be sure his operation is up to all standards The pizza is really good for the price and availability. 5 star pizza is a no brainer. read more

Maybe not a five star pizza here, but a solid choice for delivery pizza! Seriously, you can't beat $0.99 delivery! We had been wanting to try Five Star for a while, but that sealed the deal when we heard about their delivery. Plus, they offer a ton of other coupons, so we got to try their garlic cheesy bread as well. Overall, it was a solid choice that I have no complaints about! You get a lot of pizza and toppings for the price, so I'd definitely order again when I need a quick slice on the cheap. read more

I've ordered from this pizza place and both times very disappointed. The 2nd time the pizza was overcooked. Cheese was burnt. I couldn't believe they sent it out for delivery read more

We are from out of town here on a work trip and ordered dinner tonight from Five Star Pizza. We screwed up our order and the manager Jim couldn't have been more helpful and kind. The pizza, wings and garlic knots were hot and great. The delivery time was very fast. I definitely recommend trying them. read more

Just got my delivery and love that Five Star is reducing their carbon footprint by putting different items in one large box (recyclable) as opposed to multiple styrofoam containers. And of course the food is delicious and properly separated. read more

This pizza is sooooo good! And it's beautifully crafted. It looks so appetizing and for .99 delivery charge you would expect it to be a long wait or to arrive cold but it was a very quick delivery. I order it a little after 6:30 and it's not even 7 and it's already here and baked to perfection. Wow. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Good pizza with minimal grease, wings were average for a pizza place, but the garlic rolls is what got me. Best rolls I've had in a while, definitely worth it off of them alone. read more

I got to give it a 5 star. I got the XL or large and ate it all the next day. This pizza was a life saver for me that night and the next day when I needed something decent to keep going. It was very good and the service was great while I waited. read more

I am a DoorDasher who takes their dashing very seriously.I'm always respectful and calm.So I was very upset with the rude and completely unprofessional service I received from the staff and when I was certain that I did not have all of the customers items. They assured me I did and looked like a complete fool when I arrive with not one but TWO MISSING ITEMS. Which led to a disagreement with the customer. As far as I am concerned the five in five star pizza should be a one. read more

As a native Bostonian, it is hard to find really good pizza in Florida. I first tried Five Star in Gainesville, Fl a couple of months ago and was excited to see it opening here. As a still fairly new Tallahassee resident, I have not yet tried all of the pizza in Tallahassee but so far was not impressed. However, I give Five Star Pizza an 85% Boston rating. I ordered the xtra large with half pepperoni, green peppers and half Hawaiian. I added garlic, basil, oregono and banana peppers (to pepperoni side) at home. Very, very good. Good customer service on phone order and with delivery driver. I highly recommend it. read more

Good pizza. Great value. Fast delivery. The two people I dealt with, one on the phone, the other delivery guy were terrific. We will definitely be back. Thanks! read more

Tallahassee needed this. The pizza here is all chain or junk. Five star's ingredients and consistency is noticeably better than anything in the area. You won't find a better meal at 2am read more