We had not been to Decent in several years, and went last night for a family outing. My daughter's slice was about 30% bigger than this one. My kids' minds were blown, and they loved getting to customize their slices. My only regret is how much we ordered. We got way too much food, having forgotten how very much they give you. They have improved their sauces and now have a very good spicy ranch as well as a garlic dip, which I do not recall getting or seeing previously. Our kids enjoyed the arcade game and pop selection. Everyone who was working was very nice. read more

Decent Pizza - Just ridiculously good, enormous pieces of Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I placed an online order on Memorial Day for two pizzas and thereafter received a text confirmation that my order was being prepared and an ETA on order completion. When I arrived at Decent Pizza it was closed. While I'm parked in front of the business using my phone to search for alternatives, because I had guests at my house and this was the planned meal, I receive a text informing me my order is ready for pickup. It's pretty unbelievable that they would allow such a thing to happen. Their website shows that they're open 7 days a week. The door of the business indicates closed Mondays. I called first to ensure they were open and got the "we're probably too busy to answer the phone" message, which instructed to order online. I thought ordering online was a safe option because surely there is no way the online ordering system would accept an order while the business was closed. I used their online contact form to report this issue on the day this happened (5/25). It's now June 21st and I have never received a response. A new owner assumed the business in 2023 and apparently has no concern for customer service. I'm done with this place. read more

It wasn't bad...it wasn't great...it was decent. My friend and I were looking for a quick bite and decided to go to Decent Pizza. Similar to MoMoS, it is a slice as big as your head. It was pretty darn big. Neither one of us could finish it. The day we went, they had no ice, so we got Jarrito sodas - which weren't ice cold either - coming from a refrigerator. The service was very friendly and before the team member there started our order he did tell us about the ice machine being broken. The pizza is made to order - even the slices. However, the temperature of the pizza was not that hot - you know the first bite of out of the oven pizza should be gooey and stretchy and burn the top of your roof of your mouth hot. It was not ... it was decent. The mushrooms were fresh (yay! Hate canned mushrooms). Loved the artwork on the walls. All in all, the pizza is decent (like the name), service was great and friendly. We'd probably go back if we're in the area. read more

See all

It's nothing to look at outside. It's nothing to look at inside. The menu or at least the pizza choices were limited, especially for someone used to great NY pizzas. But I have to say Decent Pizza makes a decent pizza. Just be aware it takes a long time as they made my single slice barbecue chicken pizza fresh. So my plan to grab a bite and be on the road in 15 minutes became more than an hour total. But the staff is friendly. The pizza was really nice and crunchy as I like my thin crust. I have the Apple AirPods Pro charging case in the photo for scale context. read more

Decent Pizza - BBQ chicken pizza slice and AirPods Pro for size context. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Decided to pick up pizza from this place for our usual "Christmas Eve" eats of junk food. :o) Was warmly greeted upon entering. We ordered large specialty pizzas - meat head and veggie head; also ordered garlic knots. The pizza was made up of very generous sizes and the garlic knots were sizable as well. Everything was tasty; will certainly return! read more

See all

Despite the modestly in their name, Decent Pizza is the place to go for a really Great Pizza. Whether you want an entire pizza or just a MASSIVE slice, the quality is always consistent, and always top-tier! Always friendly service, good value, and incredibly good - way more than "Decent" pizza!! read more

Decent Pizza - A beautiful slice (hand pic for scale ) - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Decent Pizza is just a block from my new job, so today I stopped in for the first time and ordered a single slice of pepperoni and sausage to go. The total was $9. When they called my order, I was confused--why such a large pizza box for one slice? Then they opened it. OMG. The slice was massive--unbelievable in both size and appearance. When I got back to work to eat it in the break room, I had to show my coworkers. I could only finish about a third of it, so now I have two more lunches out of that one slice. $9 + a $2 tip = $11 for three lunches. No brainer. And on top of that, it's one of the best-tasting slices I've ever had. Customer for life. read more

Called to order pizzas when arriving to town, everything was delivered as ordered, delicious and fresh. Extra large pizzas served us for several meals, everyone was happy with the flavors and toppings. Would recommend for delivery service. I do not know about in-store Dining, but do know that the food is delicious! Check it out! read more

Never received my pizza. Waited two hours for a failed delivery, and no reimbursement. I called multiple times and received no response. read more

Decent Pizza - Excessive wait time. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

This is a great place if you're a college student who doesn't care what they're drinking, but wants some decent pizza. The food is... decent! The canned beer selection is too. My wife and I drove all over south Tallahassee trying to find a pizza place that wasn't a complete front for college kids getting hammered on cheap vodka, and this is the best we found. read more

Dinner tonight is the 20" Margherita Pizza - an olive oil base, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh garlic, and fresh basil. Great flavor and fast service. Ordered for pick-up and was advised that the pie would be ready in 30 minutes. A half-hour later, and the pizza was on time. William E. Lewis, Jr. Vero Beach, Florida read more

Decent Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Everything was perfect. I'll trade a fancy restaurant for damn good pizza any day. The staff was super nice, the restaurant was clean and the Meathead pizza was AWESOME covered in good quality ingredients. We were advised to ask to try the spicy honey sauce and they gave us a sample. Highly recommend but be warned the spice is real. Thanks guys! read more

Decent Pizza - Pure Yumminess!!! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

We were looking forward to enjoying a pizza lunch and had found memories of eating here 20 years ago. What a disappointment! Not only was the pizza marginal at best and over priced compared to other pizza places in town, but we also later discovered that we were over charged. When we returned with the receipt to point out the error, they could not even understand their own billing system and refused to correct the error. read more

Has Gluten Free crust but cooks in same oven with no protection for cross contanimation. Decent Pizza is one of my favorite resturants before i becaome a celiac. Tried them once afterwards..... got sick for days. Called the resturant to confirm how they ensure gluten free and was told they do nothing but the oven is hot enough to burn off the gluten.... sad day. read more

I hate to write this review because I like the pizza here and have patronized Decent for a decade at this point. At this point we've had three bad experiences in a row and I don't think I'll be back. Yesterday we waited over an hour for a small cheese pizza and two slices. There were 5 employees behind the counter - close to the same number of customers in the place. They were moving slow, hanging out and chit chatting most of the time. When the food finally came out (with no apology for the wait), one of the slices was wrong. This is the third visit in a row that either this has happened or they have completely forgotten part of the order. At least the last time they offered the incorrectly made slice. This time I'm sure that slice went in the trash while I sat waiting and watching everyone else eat for another 20 mins. Some advice: If you screw up an order, offer the screwed up order to the customer (they did this last time). And also make damn sure the next thing getting fired is the replacement. Instead I watched pizza after after pizza come out and get boxed and stacked on top of the oven - for door dash or whatever - instead of my slice. Another table was waiting for their togo pizza for a long time and it turned out it was sitting on top of the oven in a box. In the end, the only redeeming action on their part is that they acted a bit ashamed - as they should have been - when I called them out about my order. I suppose they could have been dicks about it. Either way, we're at three strikes. :( I hope the owner can get a better crew in place and take care of their customers, but maybe it's just a bad turn because of a change of ownership. In any case, there are way too many pizza places in Tallahassee to have clowns behind the counter driving loyal customers away. read more

So we saw this place while driving and decided that anyone gutsy enough to call their place 'Decent . . . ' must have a great product, so we decided to give it a shot. We had four different types of pizza. First, the staff was very friendly and engaging. The pizzas were ready pretty much when they said they would be, which is also a positive. Overall the pizzas were . . . decent. I can't say they were the best I've had but they were also far from the worst. There was just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The pepperoni was generous; the black olives and jalapeños were sparse. The crust was done nicely - and it was chewy but not overly, so that was good. The bottom crust was a bit thin and a bit greasy but not too bad. The really odd thing was that the Italian Sausage was paper thin slices - we've never before in our lives seen it like that - it's usually always crumbly, which we prefer. So, in the end if I was hungry for pizza and in the area I would have no qualms about going back for pizza; I probably wouldn't specifically drive far for the pizza - it was decent, not bad. read more

Pizza is definitely decent here! Ha, I am sure I am not the only one to be that clever. I personally prefer more of a pan pizza style, but I nearly devoured the entire thin crust 12" pie that I carried out on Thursday night. I ordered my pie topped with red onions (I prefer white but that was not an option), green peppers, and Bradley's spicy sausage, which was recommended to me by a colleague as a Tallahassee staple -- and it was a great suggestion that I will now pass along. :) The pizza was baked what I would consider "well", as in some of the crust was on the slightly burnt side - but I know that many pizza fans prefer that taste. It was presented to me as a perfect circle (a talent that I have yet to master when I bake my own pizzas at home). It was not the best pizza that I have ever had (being a pan crust girl makes that inevitable) but for being my nearby local pizza joint, Decent Pizza will definitely suffice for all of my unplanned pizza cravings. And my parents will dig it when they visit me since they love thin crust. read more

Decent Pizza - Create your own personal pizza with Bradley's sausage, onion and green pepper! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

This is an updated review from my previous one. We had a great experience this time around, from the food to the service. The pizza was cooked perfectly and the cheesy sticks were delicious. Decent selection of beer as well. I definitely will be back! read more

Decent Pizza - Create your own pie - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Pizza is more than decent! Just ordered large pizza pie, slices were great and more bang for your buck than Pizza Hut. Support small business! read more

Service was apathetic. However, the demeanor furthered emphasized just how decent the pizza is. As if they don't really care, because they know the pizza is decent. Classic family style pizza place, but they do seem to move quite slow. read more

Great slice of pizza Great service for cheese. Pizza is just awesome. A nice little salad. It's a great place to go for a slice. read more

vibes are wonderful. free arcade machine with old school games. pizza has a perfect balance of ingredients. my partner and i come once a week and they have never disappointed. i love this place. read more

Decent Pizza - half sugar & spice, half margarita - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Wonderful service, great atmosphere, and the best hot pies in Tallahassee! It's my new go-to for pizza!

Nothing decent about it, this Pizza was AWESOME!!! I cannot wait to order it again. We also tried a calzone which was delicious. Please treat yourself and order some Buffalo Cheesy Bread. It is the BEST appetizer you'll ever order at a pizza place. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, their ranch is FIRE 10/10!!! read more

See all

Best pizza in Tallahassee!!! The dough can be eating by it self!!! I had the half supreme and half meat lovers...Really Good Pizza!!‼ read more

Decent Pizza - Half Supreme/Half Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

I was absolutely appalled by the pizza I picked up at Decent tonight. Have not been there since change of ownership. Pizza was lacking in sauce, cheese AND toppings. It was not even a ghost of the reliably delicious pizza of old. Worse, we had relatives here from out of town and were bragging about " the best pizza" in Tallahassee! On a positive note, the Greek salad was as fresh and delicious as always. read more

I got here around 12:15 and ordered a slice of pep. pizza & some garlic knots. It came out to $11.99, which I was kinda shocked by. I waited about 20minutes to receive the garlic knots, and a minute later the pizza came out. The pizza slices here are HUUUGEE so I understand the price point now. It was pretty good! I would definitely recommend the garlic knots, they were really good! read more

Decent Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

The price to quality and size of the food was more than I could ask for. Cheaper doesn't always mean lower quality as it is was all quite savory. The cannolis were wow, so worth it. I don't know where else you'd get cannolis of this size with fresh ricotta anywhere else in tally (that I know of). You even get a pitcher of beer for $6. They have a varied and flexible menu as the variation of toppings are wonderful and include choices that you don't always see, like ricotta or pesto. I love the low key, mom and pop, local and cozy feel as well as having a touch of that old 80s style. read more

Been going to decent pizza for over 10 years. Tonight was the first time I had the pizza and it was not decent. It was thin. It was hard it was dry. Not enough cheese. The first bite of a slice of pizza the cheese stretches and it is gooey and moist and that was not my experience tonight. There was no pulling of the cheese. Very disappointed. The young lady, was very nice who took our order. As you can see from my picture it is very thin ,very hard and very dry pizza. I have no idea why they made a change. They had a good thing going. read more

Decent Pizza - A slice of pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I've been searching for a reasonable facsimile of a Margherita pizza since I moved here. This is the closest i've found so far and it was pretty good, not a traditional pie a little different than most but still very tasty. I am a bit of a traditionalist I guess the ingredients are a cracker thin crispy crust, extra virgin olive oil, fresh buffalo mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes and basil leaf, NEWS FLASH - there is no red sauce on a true Margherita pizza. Pizza Margherita is basically a Neapolitan pizza, typically made with tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, garlic, fresh basil, and extra-virgin olive oil. I think of it as a sophisticated version of your basic cheese pizza and also a Caprese salad, but with a crust. The service was prompt and efficient. Have to admit I was a bit surprised at the gargantuan size of a large pizza in the adjoining price of said pizza. That's partly my fault. I should've asked when I placed the order and didn't but with tip close to $60 for a large and a medium pizza is New York City style pricing but if you like the pizza it's worth the money. It's a typical street corner, pizzeria, and exudes that type of ambience which is nice and laid-back. read more

Tried while visiting for a sports event. The pizza was pretty solid and the garlic knots were delicious.

Holy Cow! It is so yummy. We ordered a medium and got the largest medium pizza I have ever seen. FIVE STARS. I could smell the veggies before I opened the box. This is better than "Decent" pizza. EL read more

Searched for the best pizza in Tallahassee a few hours away while driving through from Miami to Mississippi and came across this place on Yelp. We ordered a small Greek salad, a beer, a medium half buffalo chicken and half margerita pizza. We watched them make other pizzas and they were HUGE! Everything tasted really good, and the owner sat next to us and struck up conversation. Would definitely return to this place! read more

Decent Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

The most 'Decent' pizza I've had in a while! Next time I get Corn Pops to go with it! Gracias! read more

Decent Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Wish I can give zero stars. Sitting here 40 minutes after paying and they are just making my pizza. Since I was in the business for 35 years I feel more than qualified to call bullshit. If it was going to be an hour to get one pizza I would have walked and never ordered. BTW it is Wednesday night and there were 2 tables already seated when I arrived. Don't care about the pizza quality now. I won't be back. Stay away unless you are literally just killing time. read more

4:36P on a Friday afternoon. "Decent Pizza, please hold". Over ten minutes later they hang up on me. Can't order online, unless using via delivery service, so I called back, was told a medium pizza would be ready in 25 mins. Picked up pizza asked for a bottled beer to take home, denied. They said they couldn't sell it to me if I was to leave with it, even if it was not open (I've had restaurants seal my bottle of wine to take home, so what's up with that?). Instead of driving across the road to buy a beer from a gas station I opted for a cherry Coke (one size choice: medium). Got home and noticed the cherry Coke was all soda, no flavor, didn't have it in me to call and sit on hold for 10 mins to let them know. I have an Airbnb apartment around the corner from this joint, and don't feel good about recommending them to guests. The pizza was great, but the service seems like they have better things to do than take orders from hungry people on a Friday afternoon. Is the beer thing really legit? read more

Decent Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I got the Margherita pizza and loved every bite of it, it had a lot of basil on it and I simple picked it off (I'm not much of a fan of basil) read more

After an entire week of wining and dining down to and back from Miami we craved pizza. After a little internet research (almost 300 miles away from Tallahassee) we choose this place. We ordered a Greek salad to start and a medium 1/2 buffalo chicken and 1/2 Margarita pie and a Greek salad. We sat at the bar and struck up a conversation with the owner of the joint. He told us how he came to own it and described ingredients etc in real time. We had a nice chat. The pizzas going out were HUGE! We only had 2 pieces left to take back for a late night snack. read more

Decent Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Decent is more than it's namesake and possibly my favorite pizza place in town. Whether it be their pizza by the slice or their calzones, I don't think I've ever had a bad meal here. I'm assuming they got their recipe for their garlic knots from the most high himself. Don't tell anyone, but I usually try to soak/dip my calzone in it. read more

Decent Pizza - Museum Family Night - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

The pizza is great, got a lot of toppings, was delivered on time.excellent pizza and service...ordered on line