I absolutely love this place its a beautiful little restaurant with extremely good pizza. Its a little pricey but it's absolutely worth it for the quality of food you're receiving. Forever one of my most favorite date night spots Pizza of choice- cheese with cheery tomatoes and basil leaves read more

Things finally aligned to get a chance to try this Italian restaurant that we have been wanting to try. First visit will not be the last. They are in a brand new building on the way into Woodville. There is a good bit of parking. The dining area is one big space with tables and booths. There's a little bit of bar seating facing the wood fired oven. There's table service and pleasant folks to wait on you. I ordered the Spaghetti Bolognese and the wife got the Lunch Special pizza. The Bolognese didn't have enough meat to suit me and it hadn't been cooked long enough to develop that rich depth of flavor that my all time favorite Bolognese at Mimmo's in Destin has. More like a marinara sauce than a rich and thick bolognese. The pizza, on the other hand, was stellar. Tasty thin and crispy crust with a nice sauce, delicious cupped pepperoni and plenty of cheese where extra cheese might be overkill. Would have loved more fennel bite in the sliced Italian sausage but the overall taste of the pizza was so good I wouldn't quibble. We have a local pizza favorite close to home but I would drive right by them, all the way through town and down to Woodville for this pizza. It tasted that good. read more

See all

This is the best pizza in the area. High quality ingredients, attention to detail with how they prep food, and friendly family vibe. Terry sat and talked with us about the imported Italian oven for the pizzas, cheese bread, and cheesecake. The oven and ingredients make all the difference in the world! Server and nice young lady who baked our pizza were very nice. We will return any time we want pizza. read more

See all

This was our first visit and we were not sure what to expect. We were pleasantly surprised by the food and the large oven behind the bar. We will be back to try the house made desserts. Lots to choose from and what we saw has us planning the next trip. read more

See all

Honestly this place was great when they first opened. Quality has gone down. Cheese taste less quality and much more salty, sauce is lacking flavor, crust is meh. Employees aren't trained. Not sanitary. You don't handle money then touch all over someone's food. Pizza is super salty $35 for a large cheese pizza. Every time I go their prices have gone up. One time my husband called in an order and I went to pick it up and they take the pizza out and a guy asked if I wanted basil I was confused and was like "uh no it's ok?.." and it turns out my husband ordered it with basil so why are you asking me if it's on the ticket- learn how to read. Dined in before and service is bad- like no training at all. Wouldn't recommend. Last time I order a salad Togo they forgot the chicken. Just a waste of time and money honestly. read more

Bagigio's is a tiny gem in south Leon County. Located in Woodville, this pizza spot offers wood fired pizzas, fresh salads, a few pasta options, and their own Gelato. They also have house made limoncello! The waitstaff is friendly & attentive. You can grab a table or sit at on a stool with a view of the pizza making action. Great for take out or dining in. I highly recommend the calzone and the peanut butter Gelato. read more

Bagigio’s - The Bagigio special pie. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Place is clean, quick service and the pizza was delicious! Server was helpful. Affogatos were interesting as it seems they were made with hazelnut coffee not espresso. Didn't hate it. I'd go back! read more

Bagigio’s - Table area waiting on the Zaa! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Would love to follow up and give my best to Terry and Sarek that made good on my Pizza. I have been trying something new on the menu each visit. Last one was just a fumble. Thanks again. read more

Whats going on with our favorite pizza place? We've been regulars for a couple of years, loved the pizza and the service, server Chelsea was a gem. Went this week and everything was different. Chelsea appears to be gone, as was the regular pizza maker, our server while nice enough seemed clueless, couldn't remember our order, lost the order of the table behind us and they had to re-order it, had to ask for cutlery and plates after food came. No lemonade, seems they've changed the signature root-beer as well. The pizza was the worse, both Pizzas ordered came out over-cooked, and one was just plain charred black all over, we overheard the pizza maker tell the server he thought they were overdone, but for him to even think it was edible and present it to us was baffling. He offered to remake the one but we had already waited enough. The one we kept we could only eat half, it had an odd square shape to it, smaller than the medium we always get, tasted like it lacked salt and tomato sauce, which was always excellent in their pizzas, and even all the toppings couldn't make up for it. Seems they are going through some changes, but all new staff and changing recipes is a bad combination. We will wait a couple of months to try it again and see if they get it together, or search for a new pizza place. read more

I was here on an early Saturday afternoon. I wasn't sure if they were open or not but, fortunately for me they were. Chelsea greeted me warmly. The interior was spotless and the tables so cute. The greeting was very friendly. I ordered a Coke and later decided on one of their smaller pizzas with pineapple, ricotta, ham and pepperoni. The pizza crust rocked Even though I would prefer mine a little more crisp on the bottom. When I return, I am going to order lasagna or a calzone. And there will be a next time. read more

Bagigio’s - Yellowstone Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

First time here and the pizza was great! The restaurant was clean and not too busy, and had only one server working which seemed ok. Service overall was a 3.5/5, food was a 5/5, restaurant overall 4/5. Sadly, a couple and their child walked in at 8:45, sat down, and then were told they would not be served because they close at 9. I get it, but if the door is open it is bad business to refuse service. Just my opinion. The family seemed really upset too. read more

Was greeted warmly on arrival. You order at the counter and sit at any table you want and food is delivered to your table. The space is nicely decorated and feels open and airy. The food is fresh and made to order. We shared a salad which was good but the portion was small not really big enough to share (we ordered the large salad). They have 3 sizes for pizza: individual (which is perfect for one person, looks small but was perfect), medium which is good enough to share for 2 people and large which is huge. The dough is incredible, one of the best I have had in the USA. Tomato sauce is also excellent not acid and with tons of flavor. Prices are on the higher side but everything is great quality and I thought was worth it. Make sure to save room for dessert because the ice cream is home made and seriously good - worth every calorie. Would recommend. read more

See all

This business is tucked under some trees. Barely noticeable if you aren't looking for it. Definitely worth the stop. You walk in and place your order and choose where you'd like to sit. We walked right in at 3 and had prompt courteous service. Everyone was very attentive and we never went with an empty cup. The stuffed cheese bread was delicious as well as the Pizza Americana. They are a little heavy handed with the cornmeal on their products. We purchased a Stromboli which came out like more of a calzone. Only reason we gave the restaurant a 4 star is due to the garlic in the Stromboli. It was poorly diced and there were several whole cloves. I love garlic but an entire bite of it will take you back if you aren't ready. Over all it's an upscale pizza restaurant, with great ambiance and wonderful customer service read more

See all

This place is amazing. Service and food are always on point! They are a little pricey but in my opinion it is well worth the money :)

First visit and we were pleased. Food was good, priced reasonably. Sat at the counter and watched the cooks working non stop. Was busy but not loud noise level. Overall pretty much what you would expect. If you like Italian / Pizzeria restaurant approach you will like this one. read more

Too long to wait for our meal. It took over an hour to get a pizza in the dining room. They apologized and the food was good however

Bagigio's, what happened??? We stopped and got a large supreme to go Sunday. It was so greasy! I had heartburn all day yesterday. And the price has gone up almost $10 since last year!! It's $36 now! Would have hurt less if the pizza was as good as a few months ago. I can't in good faith recommend y'all anymore. read more

Bagigio's is located on Woodville Highway in South Tallahassee, more popularly known as Woodville. It's an Italian casual restaurant. You'd think the star item is the pizza and to many, you'll be correct. But make no mistake the hidden gem here is the homemade ice cream! The ice cream is elegantly served on a plate. No cup. No cone. The flavors include key lime, blueberry, apple pie, strawberry, Nutella, expresso and vanilla. We tried the key lime ice cream. It was served as a round 1" to 1 1/2" slice. To our surprise a scoop of vanilla was on top with a generous sprinkling of graham cracker crumbs. There are two options: small for $4 or large for $7. We opted for the small. And it was a good thing because you WANT to save room for dessert after pizza. The portion size is generous and plenty for two people. Keep dessert in mind when you order the pizza! They have three sizes, a ten inch personal pizza (size of a dinner plate), a medium pizza and a large. We ordered the medium Pizza Bagigio's, their namesake. This pizza was topped with Tomato sauce, Mozzarella cheese, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Hamburger, Mushrooms, and Red Onions. The pizza is cooked in a wood-fired one-of-a-kind suspended oven. It's behind the counter so you can see it from nearly every one of the 15 or so tables. The tables and the counter are also works of art. They're live edge tables made from 200-year-old reclaimed trees pulled straight from the Suwannee River, as their website touts. The pizza was excellent! Hot, crispy crust and plentiful toppings in every bite. Again, good thing we split the medium because we had room for dessert! The restaurant was built from the ground up. It's nicely decorated with plants in the windows, brick flooring and leather booths surround the live edge tables. The service was welcoming, friendly and personable. If you're looking for a nice reasonable drive and want to try something new, this is a great option and we will return. read more

See all

We loved this place but tonight was awful. From the service to the food. Had to wait 15 mins before we ordered drinks took 15 to get drinks then she said she would be right back to take our order. 20 mins later we placed our order. Waitress never came back to check on us. My husband had to get up to ask for another drink. Once we got our food my husband asked for meatballs. Didn't get the meatballs the noodles weren't undercooked. They said they are working on getting meatballs. Meanwhile my meal had hamburger in it. Our meals didn't have any flavor. Just a little bit of oregano or even some salt would help. The cheese bread was cold. Before we were done they wanted to cash us out. They had about 5 people working with only 3 tables of 3 or less people at each. Im guessing the owners, not sure, sat down to eat their dinner. I beat their noodles were fully cooked. Horrible service, food not that great anymore. Very disappointed. Instead of investing so much into the parking lot you should invest in your service and food. I'm sure people don't mind parking in a dirt lot. I mean we are in Woodville. Most of us live on a dirt road. It will be a while before we go back. read more

Picked up a large supreme Pizza for take out. The Pie was being pulled from the oven as I arrived. The time given when ordering was spot on and so was the Pizza pie. They also supplied some extra parmigiana cheese and red pepper flakes to go with. They had me check it out before leaving and it was perfect. Upon arriving home had to take a picture of its perfection before devouring. It was delicious and exactly what I was looking for in a pizza pie. I cannot eat like this daily but will hold out for this place when I do. Recommend anyone who what's a quality pizza pie to try them out. read more

Bagigio’s - Lg Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

My husband and I went here while on vacay in Tallahassee, we didn't expect such a nice quality restaurant in the middle of nowhere! It was beyond delicious and our server was very hospitable. We got a half and half. One side with margherita, one with their white pizza. It's outstanding. One of the best white pizzas we've ever had. If we ever go back to the area we'd absolutely visit them again. Highly recommend! read more

Bagigio’s - Half margherita, half white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Have been here twice. First visit had the best custom made pizza and salad. My pizza is made with Alfredo sauce instead tomato. Add basil and mushroom. Perfection! Second visit I had the sausage calzone. Again excellent and tasty. Great attention from server (group of 5). Enjoy the atmosphere. read more

Good food, excellent service but the large pizza is extremely expensive - $35-$36 if you compare it to Tallahassee. I would do a price structure studies to make more competitive to Tallahassee pizza market. read more

They are back under Ms. Terry's management and back to excellence! Chelsea is the best server ever. Highly recommend.

Pizza is excellent, service prompt & friendly. We've been there twice recently. I like that they carry soft drinks that are not either of the main 2. The restaurant itself is pretty big with lots of space, which I always appreciate. read more

Quaint little place outside of Tallahassee. Would not have come out this way but the reviews and pictures on Yelp drew me in. Glad I made the drive. This is my kind of pizza. Thin, brick over style. Cheeses and sauce are fresh and delicious. Wife ordered a calzone and couldn't stop talking about the sauce. A little too much ricotta for me, but that's just my preference. She loved it. Staff was very welcoming and service was fast. read more

Pizza was amazing! Got the medium White Pepperoni Special and more than fed 2. Clean and pretty inside.

Authentic pizza and food . A must if your headed to the coast grab a Gelato or pizza . The calzones and salads are large .

We came here for the first time today and it was an outstanding experience. Their wood-fired oven gives the pizzas a delightful flavor with an amazingly light and crispy crust. Our supreme pizza, topped with olives, baby pepperoni (not greasy) onions, Italian sausage and mushrooms was supremely delicious- and not salty as most pizzas would be. The caesar salad was are a perfect complement, bursting with vibrant, fresh crispy lettuce and croutons and crunch red onions with a perfect Caesar dressing that wasn't overloaded with salt. The mango gelato was refreshing and just had the right amount of sweetness and zing. The tiramisu was light and creamy with just the right amount of coffee that made it delightfully rich! The ambiance is cozy and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a casual meal with friends or family. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience from start to finish. Definitely worth the drive from Tallahassee. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Amazing service and great pizza. Loved the atmosphere and home town vibe with a splash of Italy in this little eatery read more

Bagigio’s - Great little eatery . Amazing pizza !!! - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Folks have been talking this place up on the Tallahassee Foodies FB page. Was passing through on way back to TLH from St. Marks and stopped to get a pizza to go. As soon as I walked through the door, I was warmly welcomed. This place is family run and everyone there was very friendly. I ordered a 20" Pizza Bagigio. I have to say this is now the best pizza joint in the Tallahassee area and bests the current "big three" of pizza. The pizza was excellent and the crust is hands down the BEST pizza crust I've had around here. They have a Marana rotating pizza oven that was shipped from Italy. It's impressive. That demonstrates the owners' commitment to making the best pizza. Apparently they're working on getting beer/wine. Might be waiting on the license. Anyway, love this place and will be back! read more

Went to Baggios's in Woodville last night. Our waitress Sheila was amazing. She made sure everything was perfect and that we had our drinks refilled spot on.will definitely go again read more

10/10 would recommend! This place was so cute outside it caught our attention on our way into Tallahassee and it's really not far from the Southwood area at all. There was no wait and the pizza was the best we have had in Tallahassee area. You can tell the dough is fresh and crust isn't tough like at some other local places. We each got personal sized pizza and a salad. I wished the menu were a little more extensive with like a weekly special or something and its also kid friendly as there is no alcohol to my knowledge. The pizza had that yummy wood-fire taste and ingredients were super fresh! read more

Bagigio’s - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

My husband and I had been curious about this place and saw it was open today as we were returning to Tallahassee from the beach. My hubby got the Americana and I got the Deluxe with extra cheese. The pizzas were very good, with tasty crust and savory meats on the Americana and fresh veggies on the Deluxe. The interior is nice and interesting. The service was a little slow at first but we found out someone called out so our server came in to cover. She was very concerned that we had everything we needed. We will definitely return! read more

Pizza was okay! The crust was too thin and the sauce lacked flavor. I ordered the all meats - topping were NOT plentiful. The staff was nice! The pizza is not for me. read more

It had been a while since I've been to this lovely little restaurant. But we went back for some pizza and some beer. Everything was delicious and the pizza sauce and mozzarella just perfect. They're just perfect. read more

Am from Chi, we know our pizza, mind you, I cannot stand deep dish. I love this place. It had a family vibe to it Also there was a line to order here outside of the building. It was straight up dang delicious!!! I got a custom with double pineapple and basil (they use fresh pineapple) The cheese, I can't explain it- it was amazing!! Crust was perfect. Probably in top three pizzas I've ever had in my life. read more

We came here from Tallahassee and it was so worth it. The pizza is very authentic and of course, delicious. They have a beautiful pizza oven and you can sit at the bar to watch them being made. It is owned and operated by a lovely family! Highly recommend checking this place out! read more

Bagigio’s - Margarita Pizza and Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

The worst Pizza I've ever had in my life. I am 64 so that's been a lot of years that I've eaten pizza. This pizza was overpriced; burnt so badly all I could taste was burnt, chewy chewy cheese, pepperoni so overcooked they were bowl of oil. The sauce was dried up so nonexistent. The pizza crust was black on the bottom. Horrible!!!!!! I would not recommend this pizza to anyone.Pizza Bagigio in Woodvill read more

See all

It is delicious! We had a large house salad, a lasgna, and the girls ordered a kids pizza. The kids pizza was pretty big for a kids meal. It was sweet, thin, and crispy. The lasagna had like 6 layers and the sauce was more rustic, not sweet like the pizza. It was SPECTACULAR!! The background music was perfection. read more

Bagigio’s - Kids pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all