This was kind of an odd-ish experience in an odd-ish kind of place. Monticello seems like it has…read moreseen better days, and definitely has a very unique combination of inhabitants. We ended up here for a post-dinner treat, and it was quite busy. There is little to no room inside the place, so you're constantly trying to squeeze and shuffle around as the whole ordering process is a complete human free-for-all. We ended up with a gentleman who greeted us by saying "this is my first time working in three years!" Well OK then! He managed to get one of us a malted and vanilla twist soft serve on a cone, but the malted didn't really taste like anything other than an unpronounced chocolate flavor. The other one of us got a Snickers sundae that was so massive and just completely overtopped with Snickers pieces and fudge. Like, we're not complaining--all too happy to consume these thousands of calories!--but it was a bit of a wild mess. Kind of a surreal experience, but we're not necessarily mad about it and would probably even come back if we were ever in the area again. Be prepared to wait and to have a furrowed brow if you go.

Recently visited on our vacation and this place was cute and had so many options. The staff which…read morewas two young ladies were very nice and had great customer service. If we were visiting again I would definitely stop by a get another sweet treat.

This is not only my family's favorite ice cream shop of all time... their soups and stews in the…read morewinter are scrumptious! The owner is the sweetest man and we smile when we're on the way over, anticipating an enjoyable visit. Yummy and excellent quality from the food to the people. Love Sticky Fingers forever! So glad we have it close by.

We stopped in on a Monday night after finding this place on yelp and reading the reviews. The…read morecommon review is the price compared to the amount of ice cream you get or don't get, which we found to be true. Overall, the ice cream was good but nothing that blew our socks off. Also, the kid behind the counter just looked like he hated his job.

We came here twice on our trip to the area. Both times service was great and the ice cream was…read moredelicious! I got pistachio nut and Oregon blackberry cheesecake my first time - both good choices. Then I got butter pecan and cheesecake again my second time. It's hard to choose which combo I liked better - they were both so good! My husband got strawberry and chocolate both times which he loved. When we went, there was only one girl working at a time. They wore masks and were friendly, just make sure to speak loudly as there is a really loud machine inside that makes it hard for hearing. Don't forget to bring cash!

Great ice cream! I loved my chocolate and vanilla soft serve twist with rainbow sprinkles, and my…read moreboyfriend liked the mint chocolate chip that they got. Prices are super reasonable and they also have a full food menu - would definitely return for lunch or a casual dinner.

I had a great experience at Myers Century Farm. This is exactly the kind of place that gives you…read morethat authentic, old-world farm feel the moment you arrive. It's a true family-friendly spot where you can take your time, shop at your own pace, and enjoy the simplicity of a self-serve setup. The self-pay and self-shopping concept is really unique and works perfectly here,it adds to the charm and trust-based atmosphere. You can browse freely without feeling rushed, which makes the whole experience even more enjoyable. They even offer the option to pay with Venmo if you don't have cash, which is super convenient. The products are excellent across the board. Everything feels fresh, high quality, and true to what you'd expect from a working farm. Whether you're stopping in for ice cream or picking up dairy products, you can tell there's pride in what they offer. Overall, this place is more than just a stop.it's an experience. Great for families, relaxing, and a nice break from the typical store environment. Definitely worth visiting if you appreciate quality products and that classic farm charm.

Holiday, family traditions, and delicious desserts from Myers farm…read more The self serve farm stand is open 27/7 and you'll find tubs of ice cream, ice cream sandwiches, milk, chocolate milk, eggs and some other farm fresh items. My family and I make a few visits while we are up here every year for Christmas, and it's always such a joy coming here. Knowing not only are we getting fresh quality ingredients, but everything is local to the family farm. The ice cream sandwiches are one of our favorites along with the jugs of chocolate milk, smooth, fresh and ohh so delicious. Along the way, you might run into one or two farm friends who went straying into the roadways.

I admit, I stop here anytime I'm going up 17. The diner next door is great, and you can see that…read morereview. But the Twin Cone wins for the best ice cream place I've had roadside like this. Quality ice cream and even the small is massive. Excellent service and very nice folks. I've waited in line maybe 5 minutes but it's so nice outside I do not mind. Now, they took maple walnut off the menu. I always get that when I see it, since it's harder to find. Well now it's harder. Guess I need to go to Stewart's for it (iykyk). But I like Twin Cone so much, I can't even hold that against them. I'll get coffee Oreo instead. Goddess help me. Delicious.

One of the best, easy access, accessible parking seasonal ice cream shop. Well run shop with many…read morefriendly employees. Delicious ice cream with great servings. Multiple flavors available in hard and soft serve. Enjoyed by multi generations. Portions commensurate with price. One drawback is no indoor bathroom but they have portapotties. Great for after shopping or going out to eat as they're very close to Middletown off rt17

Delicious and generous ice cream. I had the "one scoop" and couldn't finish it. We had the…read morewalnutella, black raspberry, and butter pecan flavors. All were well-received.

Too crazy in there on a long weekend to even take a pic of the ice cream. The ice cream was good…read more Half scoops are huge. The fig flavor was interesting, glad I tried it. My son enjoyed his cookie dough. The shop is small inside and it got pretty hectic with the crowd. I would have sampled a few more flavors, but it was just too busy to really take my time. Best bet is to grab your ice cream and eat outside with the beautiful view.

Our absolute favorite ice cream!!!!!! Their coffee ice…read morecream is the best I've ever had. Soooo creamy and delish. They have a flavor called"Queen of Hearts." It's my families favorite ice cream in the world - dark chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirls. Follow them on insta for more @nif.ts it's a must stop!!!!! Right next to Roscoe diner.

The good weather on this month of October take us here during a town visit. This is a popular ice…read morecream house in Roscoe. Multiple flavors are available for the regular ice creams. Unfortunately since they just open, only vanilla flavor is available for vegan ice cream and dairy free. We were disappointed but it is what it is. There is nothing significant on this place to put us in awe moment. Taking it back . One good note though...price serving size is very affordable.

Stopped in on Saturday night of Memorial Day weekend while in town visiting my parents. We were…read moredriving by and the kids (teenagers) wanted ice cream. Sign said open, lights were on and other customers were in their cars. It was 6:50pm. Kids went up to order and the man and woman working seemed very annoyed to have customers. My daughter came back to the car and told me the man said the "F word" as he came in to help with the ice cream. My son came back to the car and reported the same thing. Watching from the car, the couple seemed to also be having words with each other. My 74 year old father came back to the car and also said they were rude and seemed as though they didn't want any business. They flicked off their lights as soon as we stepped away from the window despite another customer approaching. This was about 7:04pm. I'm not sure why they have chosen such a joyful business if they don't have any joy to spread. I'm not happy that we spent our money there.

Soft serve ice cream very friendly family owned business. Recommend the vanilla orange sherbet…read moreswirl!

I love this spot already! My first visit was for ice cream and the staff was so sweet. I received a…read morelot of ice cream with the brownie sundae and you can add any topping that you like. There is a large selection of toppings. I returned and tried there pepperoni personal pizza and fries which were delicious as well. They have a selection of sandwiches, pizza, etc. The staff is friendly and there is plenty of parking. I definitely recommend this spot to anyone!

Staff had bright green outfits that stood out to me for it being an ice cream shop. It was very…read moreneat and clean. They also serve fast food such as burgers, and the girl behind the counter said that was a popular menu item when I asked. I'm impressed with their dip flavors that included coconut, which pleased me. This seems to be a bright little gem in this otherwise simple town. I was just passing through when I saw the bright sign and the fun logo, so I pulled around. Glad I did.

My wife actually introduced me to Holy Cow when we lived nearby, and from that very first visit I…read morewas hooked. It's easily one of the best places to grab ice cream on a warm summer evening. There's something special about enjoying your favorite flavor while watching the sunset. Fast forward a few years, and now we're bringing our own kids here to make those same memories. The ice cream has always been consistently delicious, no matter how many times we've visited, and the staff has been friendly and welcoming every single time. It's one of those places that never disappoints, and we're always happy to make the trip back whenever we're in the area. Highly recommend if you're looking for great ice cream and a relaxed atmosphere with family or friends!

Holy Cow indeed! The best soft serve ice cream. Simple done right. Light and creamy…read more My go to is a chocolate dipped vanilla cone in store, and usually get a pint or two to bring home. There is no indoor seating. There are plenty of picnic benches outside, but minimal shade. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Note: This is a CASH ONLY establishment.