Cancel

Open app

Search

Frank Siena's Auto Mall

3.5 (17 reviews)
Closed 9:00 am - 7:00 pm

Frank Siena's Auto Mall Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Frank Siena's Auto Mall

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

2018 Hyundai Tucson
Arelyse E.

I'd been in the market for a new vehicle for over a year, when I finally found the best deal here at Siena's Auto Mall. My brother had just purchased a truck from José Sierra Sr. (after enduring a horrific experience at another NY dealership previously) and recommended Siena's highly to me. I went in the very next day and fell in love with a silver 2018 Hyundai Tucson! 18,000 miles for 18k! It was a STEAL. I say steal, because I almost purchased a 2017 Hyundai Tucson with 47k from CarMax at the same price point! I'm thankful my brother (and my mother) steered me toward Siena's for the better deal. They even took in my rust-bucket Ford Focus to sell at auction, knocking $500 off the price tag. From start to finish, they made the purchase as smooth as could be. The salesman, I worked with, Erick, was fantastic, courteous and extremely professional during this hectic COVID-19 time-- even their head of financing was a pleasure to work with. I never once felt pressured into buying the vehicle, which is saying something because car salesman are notoriously aggressive. It's only week two with my new baby but I'm looking forward to many roadworthy years with her. Thank you again to the Siena's Automall Team! I will send everyone and anyone I know that's on the hunt for a new car your way! And I'll be back when it's time to shop again.

Don't buy a car from here they screw you they give only A3 month warranty on a $20,000 car.THIS PLACE SUCKS!!

See all

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Gary M.
55
31
56

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Bob C.
5
30
0

10 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Frank Siena's Auto Mall

Review Highlights - Frank Siena's Auto Mall

I worked with them to find my perfect car and left with a beautiful 2018 Jeep Compass!

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Car Dealers 307 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Johnstons Subaru - I want this cute little fire truck!

Johnstons Subaru

(66 reviews)

Robbie was our sales person and karen was our financial. Both of them were great to work with and…read morewe love our new forester

O-M-G! Absolutely fantastic experience at this dealer! Showed up in early April looking at options…read more Having already been to Toyota and Honda I was upfront that I was only looking and not ready to purchase anything yet. Both Toyota & Honda reps weren't as pleasant as they once were when I said I wasn't going to buy anything YET, though I had every intention of buying sometime over the next few months. When I stopped in this dealership I told the sales guy up front, I'm only looking and I am in no way ready to buy anything. Not only did he respect that decision he gave me A LOT of his time showing me the car I was interested in and all its features & functionality. I expected him to just be like, "There is the car, look and get out of here stop wasting my time!" But nope, the sales guy, Don, was super patient, kind and never pressured me to buy. He gave me pricing options, gave me ideas of what I'd be spending based on what I wanted but never ever pressured me in any way. I thanked him and said I'd be in touch in several months to buy. That was the end of that, Don never ever harassed me or pressured me to buy anything. Well sooner than expected I stopped in true to my word that I'd be back to buy from my sales guy. I went ahead and purchased the car I was looking at and the entire transaction was absolutely pleasant. My sales guy Don was amazing and his finance team was just as spectacular, but I guess finance always goes well when you have great credit; LOL! I know dealers get pooped on for service but the sales team at this location is superb. I can only hope and pray my service experiences are just as pleasant. All I expect from service is a smile and competent mechanical techs that can take care of my new wheels and keep her running smooth for years to come.

Friendly Acura Of Middletown

Friendly Acura Of Middletown

(23 reviews)

I have owned an Acura for five years now, and I truly love my vehicle. When I first purchased my…read morecar, my sales representative, Gary, was wonderful -- genuinely one of the kindest people I've ever worked with. I have nothing but positive things to say about the sales team. Unfortunately, my experience with the service department has been extremely disappointing. For the past five years, I have consistently brought my Acura RDX in for service -- typically on Saturdays -- and have never had any issues with my vehicle or with prior service visits. This past Saturday, I picked up my vehicle with no indication that anything was wrong. I drove home as usual. The next day, while heading to a family event, my husband noticed a strange noise coming from the passenger side of the vehicle. At first, we assumed it might just be moisture on the brakes. However, as we continued driving, the noise became louder and more persistent -- specifically when braking. I immediately called Acura to arrange bringing the vehicle back in Monday morning. At that visit, I was informed that my brake pads were completely worn down. I was shocked to learn that either the inside brake pads had not been inspected, or only the outer pads were checked during my Saturday service. At no point was this mentioned to me, nor was it documented on any of the paperwork provided at pickup. To make matters worse, I was then quoted an additional $600 to replace the brake pads -- an issue that should have been identified and communicated just days earlier. I was extremely upset knowing I had been driving my daughter around all Sunday and Monday in a vehicle with brake pads worn "down to nothing," without any warning from the service team. I trusted Acura's service department to properly inspect and maintain my vehicle. This experience has completely shaken that trust and has been a major disappointment. Unfortunately, I will not be returning to this Acura service department in the future!!!!

I regret my decision to work with this dealership. I was charged over $500 for motor vehicle fees,…read morebut it has now been 9 weeks and they have yet to process the necessary paperwork. Despite multiple attempts to follow up, the dealership has been unresponsive, and when I do hear back, I'm often lied to or gaslighted. I also recently received notice from my lender that they still have not received the necessary documentation to list them as the lien holder on the vehicle. This is a serious oversight and a clear sign of the dealership's lack of professionalism and attention to detail. The lack of accountability and transparency is unacceptable. If you are looking for reliable service and timely paperwork processing, I would strongly advise against doing business with this dealership. I'm still waiting on a resolution, and at this point, I'm unsure when (or if) it will be resolved.

Johnstons Toyota

Johnstons Toyota

(121 reviews)

My wife broke down in the middle of the road in front of Johnstons today. She was disabled for…read moreabout 30 minutes before a Good Samaritan helped move the vehicle to the side of the road in front of the dealership. I showed up and parked in front as I attempted to diagnose the issue to hopefully get the car started to at least get to a parking lot. Ironically, staff from surrounding businesses came over to offer assistance. The car place, nope. I watched as employees came outside to take their breaks, walk the lot and not once did someone stop and ask if we were okay. They did look. I sent my wife off as I waited for the tow. I was able to get the car started and as I let it run, I went to ask an employee if I was able to park in the lot for safety. He ignored me and walked away, looking over his shoulder to see where I was. I sat for an hour before the tow driver arrived. He even laughed that the dealership had a great opportunity to go for the assist and sell a new car. Nope. I wasn't thrilled the last time I visited them to entertain vehicles. I definitely will not consider them moving forward. It's not up to the business to assist a disable vehicle that's not one of their lot, it's not their job. However when the vehicle is right in front of your showroom, human decency would say to check on them. Especially when you have mechanics that might be able to diagnose, assist and make a few dollars in the process.

They are using switch and bait they estimate your payment on their website and switch when your in…read morethe showroom their website said I can purchase a 2023 Camry for 23,985 267.00 per month 4.49 apr 72 months with 10,000 down the interest rate went to over 7 percent I showed the sales person the website quote so they lowered the interest rate but then messed up my trade in, on their website they offered me 1200-1800 for my trade through KBB which is what they use to aprassise vehicles but when the appraised my vehicle at the dealer they used carfax appraisal and showed me the carfax appraisal for 800 dollars my estimated payments went from 220 to mover 300 per month. please beware check you numbers shady dealer.

Compass Mazda

Compass Mazda

(21 reviews)

I bought my 2007 Mazdaspeed 3 at Compass and have been servicing it there ever since. I have to say…read morethat their customer service skills are spectacular except for one incident I had with them but I believe this was before the Wagners took over. Chris Hackett is my favorite employee there. He knows what customer service is about, same with Gordy, but he is one of the owners. UPDATE to my comments below: Gordy got back to me to apologize about the mix up with the advertisement and we are working out numbers on the car in question. Unfortunately I couldn't give a 5 on Overall Experience and Price because of a recent incident I had there when I came in to see an advertised vehicle. The vehicle was advertised for $22,676 ,and underneath the price, the "Special" stated that Compass would match 'up to' $5,500 on that specific vehicle. I came in and test drove the car expecting to put down $5,500 and have Compass match but I was told that the $5,500 was already factored in to the price. Being that the Ad said they would match "up to" $5,500 on the price listed this didn't make sense to me. I emailed Gordy and Greg about my disappointment in that and didn't get a response back. I figured Compass would at least come half way as when I was there they admitted that the Ad was presented wrong. I'm assuming this was an honest mistake, and they did change the Ad after I left.

The dealership was supposedly taken over by new management, if that's true what a freakin…read moremistake,these idiots have NO IDEA WHAT THEY ARE DOING!! Sold us a car WITH A HIDDEN PROBLEM THAT THEY KNEW ABOUT and then refused to deal with it. A car with NO BACK SEAT- they hid it under a huge box and when we got home and discovered the problem we called them ( when the phone is even answered...) they send you to voice mails that are not even set up. When you leave messages they do not return calls. DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THEM- the better business bureau was contacted this morning and now they are involved. What a circus, DO NOT PATRONIZE!!!

Prestige - Prestige PreOwned

Prestige

(2 reviews)

This is one of the most unreputable dealers I've ever experienced. I had a 2 1/2 hour drive and I…read morespoke with the sales person extensively over the phone before making the trip so I would not have any surprises. I made him aware that I was coming from a good distance away and he assured me that the vehicle would be detailed and ready for me to see. When I got there I was horrified. I was told the sales person I spoke to on the phone is only "telephone sales" and is at an offsite location. The first words out of the replacement salesman was "We price our cars low and we don't negotiate price" which is a great way to start a relationship. The vehicle I was interested in was full of leaves, had rust everywhere, was obvious that there was recent body work from a poor paint job, and had a new frame. The Prestige representative lied and did not disclose any of this over the phone when I asked him directly. To add insult to injury Mr. replacement salesman tried to put me in a different car, the classic bait and switch. When I asked to speak with the owner he was nowhere to be found. After wasting 5+ hours the best advise I can give is go buy a car anywhere else but Prestige.

Worst place iv ever bought a truck from. When I bought the truck it looked clean, then after 3…read moremonths everything started leaking and it wasn't covered under the extended warranty they sold me. Also I understand that they are aloud to check your credit but I asked if they could only check one place because I didn't want too many hard inquires on my credit but they tried 15 places. I walked in there with a 670 credit score and walked out with a 560. Almost couldn't buy the truck. I advise never go there. Rate - negative 5 stars

Frank Siena's Auto Mall - car_dealers - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...