Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars

    4.3 (4 reviews)
    ModerateOlive Oil
    Closed 10:00 am - 6:00 pm

    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars Photos

    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - shelves of various types and sizes - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan
    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - a row of bottles on a table - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan
    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - a row of metal jugs - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan
    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - the outside of a building - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan
    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - a group of people sitting around a table - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan
    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - Welcome! - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan
    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - http://www.fustinis.com - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan
    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - Our New Location (just across the street from the old one!) - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

    See all

    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - a man cooking in a kitchen - Olive Oil Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Fustini's Oil & Vinegars

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Liz C.
    179
    373
    19

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    16 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Fustini's Oil & Vinegars

    Fustini's Oils & Vinegars

    Fustini's Oils & Vinegars

    4.7(30 reviews)
    53.3 mi
    $$

    I had an amazing time tasting all the different vinegars and oils. Inside, they have these cylinder…read morecontainers where you can pour and taste everything. It's set up like a whole room where you can walk around slowly, look, and try different combos at your own pace. The staff was so nice--super helpful and even helped me come up with different pairings. One mix that made my mind almost explode was the watermelon basil balsamic with the ginger olive oil. It was so good, I couldn't stop myself. I went around the whole place trying different combinations like a madwoman. I ended up buying a four-piece set--two balsamic vinegars and two olive oils. One of the oils I bought was a jalapeño olive oil, and being a chef, my mind went to all these different places. My brain started to itch thinking about what I could make--different pieces, different marinades, different sauces, different salads. I got so excited and giddy, like a grown man in a LEGO store or a kid in Toys "R" Us. It was that kind of joy.

    The staff in this store were extremely friendly and helpful. The products were superior! I loved…read morethe lemon white balsamic and the cherry balsamic was out of this world good! Lots of samples available and we purchased several things. The staff made pairing suggestions and there were recipe cards as well. The owner happened to be there and was very personable. He chatted with is for several minutes.

    Photos
    Fustini's Oils & Vinegars
    Fustini's Oils & Vinegars
    Fustini's Oils & Vinegars

    See all

    Duffy's Garage & Grille - The heap meat pizza full of all flavors. Amazing.

    Duffy's Garage & Grille

    3.4(160 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$

    Great food, the service was excellent! The vibes are super…read morecool, very cool decor. The porch area is very scenic and lovely. Highly recommend!

    The more I dine out the higher my standards come for reviews and Duffy's STILL gets a 5…read more There was a mistake made when we were seated on the patio as the hostess didn't leave silverware and menus when she sat us so it took a few minutes to be greeted. We had to flag someone down who thought we sat ourselves and said we needed to see the hostess. Understandable if that had been the case, but since it wasn't I couldn't help but be curious....what was his plan, then? To just ignore us all night rather than let us know? From there a different server came out, apologized profusely (even though she had never walked by and ignored us like the other server) and our service was top notch. I wish I had her name bc she was fantastic! Hate to have to describe this way...but blonde waitress who worked on the patio this past Fri night...kudos! The NA options are phenomenal and I had a spicy something or other. Sooo good! Pizza was awesome! SO. MUCH. CHEESE! Cooked to perfection, right amount of crust. I was tempted to go back again on Saturday. Patio is fantastic, cozy and relaxing without being too chill. Only feedback then is to either put more signage up about seeing a hostess or remind servers to be kinder in reminding people bc ironically we saw multiple people that either did seat themselves or were confused on where the host stand was, and both servers and bartenders weren't particularly kind with their messaging. I can only assume they are tired of it bc it happens a lot, but saw a group that almost walked out due to feeling unwelcome when they asked the wrong person about a table. Not our server. She was the best. :)

    Photos
    Duffy's Garage & Grille - Bar area

    Bar area

    Duffy's Garage & Grille - Build your own pepperoni pizza

    Build your own pepperoni pizza

    Duffy's Garage & Grille - SPICY NA drink on the patio

    See all

    SPICY NA drink on the patio

    Crooked Tree Breadworks - Crooked Tree Breadworks in Petoskey, Michigan

    Crooked Tree Breadworks

    4.6(44 reviews)
    3.2 mi
    $$

    Stopped in while in town for the weekend. Wife and I wanted to make sandwiches and needed fresh…read morebread. Grabbed a loaf of sourdough and we were not disappointed. Great taste and texture overall, everything you'd want from a sourdough. Staff was friendly and shop seemed really clean.

    I heard about Crooked Tree Breadworks on a recent trip to Petoskey and dropped by on my last day in…read morethe area. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to visit until near the end of the day and at that point they had sold out of most of their items, including the famous pepper parmesan rolls. They still had a few items left and we decided to pick up two of them. Kouign Amann ($4.95) - The caramelization of the sugar on this pastry is on point. The bottom has a layer of sugar that has melted into a glaze with extreme caramelization, almost on the verge of being burnt. If it had been left in the oven for a few moments more, it would probably have started to develop an acrid taste. Luckily, it was pulled out at just the right time. Even the sides of this pastry have been graced with sweetness and a top layer of thicker sugar crystals/grains adds an amazing crunch. While the kouign amann may not have as many thin laminated layers as a croissant, there is still an excellent buttery interior which helps balance the outside sweetness. The interior is fluffy and layered well into an even honey comb pattern. This kouign amann exceeded my expectations. (5/5) 3:00 O'clock Baguette ($5.90) - Yikes, this is by far the most expensive baguette I've ever bought. I was kind of dreading it when I first felt the baguette through the bag - it seemed a bit soft and limpy. When I tore into it soon afterwards, I found my concerns to be somewhat unfounded. By somewhat I mean that yes, there is hardly a crust on the baguette, but the interior still exhibits a nice chew and the flavor is very well developed. It's a decent baguette, but nothing outstanding. Perhaps the crust would be better earlier in the day when fresh baked? (4/5) I was definitely surprised by the quality of the baked goods at Crooked Tree Breadworks. I'll have to revisit earlier in the day on my next visit to the area so I can try more of their breads and pastries.

    Photos
    Crooked Tree Breadworks - Pre-Made Sandwiches

    Pre-Made Sandwiches

    Crooked Tree Breadworks - All butter Croissants are made from scratch at Breadworks.

    All butter Croissants are made from scratch at Breadworks.

    Crooked Tree Breadworks - Hard workers and excellent customer service

    See all

    Hard workers and excellent customer service

    Fustini's Oil & Vinegars - oliveoil - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...