I have been here twice. Service was absolutely HORRIBLE the first time. I watched my server smile and talk to every other table except for ours, so there was no way this woman was just having a bad day. She wouldn't even make eye contact with me, and ignored me anytime I said anything, even thank you. She legitimately never even said one full sentence the entire time we were there. People often treat people who look young differently when they dine-out, but this was literally the worst and most obvious experience I have ever had. And as a restaurant employee I never make my dining a complication on the staff. I am only giving 2 Stars because the Alfredo sauce was good. read more

Came to this place after reading the positive yelps. We were in town for the State Fair and were looking for some good thin crust pizza. Gabatoni's came through and served us up some solid thin crust. The crust is tasty, light and cracker-like in texture. We had three toppings and it held up quite nicely. The pepperoni and sausage toppings were good quality and were provided in more than ample supply. The only drawback with the 'za was the sauce which was a tad bit too sweet for our tastes. We also ordered the onion rings which were quite good. They are batter dipped (the batter has some nice spice and is quite garlicky) and just a good piece of deep fried goodness. Now for the bad part my fellow yelpers. The only drawback with the place is the service/atmosphere. While the hostess who seated us was quite nice, the waitress was not friendly at all and seemed disinterested until she presented us with the check. This place is a bit off the beaten path and is clearly a joint frequented by the locals - which in my view is a good thing as we tend to look for alternatives to the national chains when travelling. I think the regulars were on to us "tourists" as we heard a loud conversation about how much they hate the state fair because of all the traffic and visitors that descend upon their hamlet and muck things up. Really too bad as they shouldbe happy that people are pouring some dollars into the local economy. Despite the less than stellar ambiance of this place, you should check it out if you're looking for some good thin crust pizza while you're in town...just don't let the regulars get under your skin for invading their club. read more

Favorite pizza in Springfield! We dined here on a Saturday evening and it was packed! I recommend calling ahead of time because pizzas may take up to 40 minutes. The building has been here for years, it's very retro, so don't expect anything fancy. Try their homemade toasted raviolis and get an extra large pizza because you will want leftovers! read more

Being in Springfield we were not sure where to get a good pizza at. We heard of a few different places around the downtown area but we decided on this place as it got some good marks on the internet.We got there and it seemed small and more of a local townie type of place.We ordered the garlic bread with cheese and this was very good with lots of cheese on it. We then got our pizza that we ordered and it hit the spot. This is the place I'd recommend as it was a thin crust pizza and the sausage was very tasty and hit the spot.This seemed more of a local hangout and they had a bar in a a separate room.If your looking for a great pizza or even Italian dishes in a informal setting this would be the place. read more

We regularly travel for one hour just to eat at Gabatoni's. This place is a step back in time and feels like I'm going to one of the old supper clubs with my grandparents but with better food. Everything we've tried has been good but the fried mushrooms are fantastic. Try them, you'll love them. read more

Best mofo pizza in town! Thin crust style. Word.

Have been a customer for over a decade, and today I am done giving this place a chance. Today we ordered two pizzas, an hour and twenty minutes later we received our well done pizzas nice and cold. Considering the restaurant is under ten miles away this is completely unacceptable. We used to order 2-5 pizzas a week, not any more. Never again. read more

I've been coming to Gabitoni's for 20+years for a reason. The pizza is always perfect. Their thin crispy crust is nostalgic. I suggest to get the chicken Alfredo pizza an I always ask for my pizza a little well done for the extra crispyness. Only downside is that it's really tight quarters in there. They definitely pack you in like sardines but it's well worth it. read more

Thin crust pizza was great tasting. Meatballs very flavorful and moist. Staff was very attentive.

Good thin crust pizza. There was a line and the place was packed but only waited 10min. Friendly wait staff though the tables are very close so not the place for a quiet 'quaint' dinner. read more

Not the "best pizza I've ever had" but certainly a better pizza than I expected. Delicious, hot and the ingredients were fresh. It's worth the stop. More importantly, the fried ravioli were amazing. Get the beef with Alfredo, you won't be disappointed. read more

By far the best pizza I have ever had, I always take my friends and family there when they visit lol I just wish there were two Gabatoni's in Spfld!!! read more

Grew up in Springfield and moved away years ago but this is still my favorite pizza!! A must if you love crunchy thin crust. Try the "EBA" (everything but anchovies). read more

Awesome pizza! I grew up in Spfld but moved to St. Louis (where everyone takes pride in St. Louis style pizza) 22 years ago. I've never had a pizza in St. Louis that's nearly as good as a Gabatoni's pizza! Keep doing what you're doing. read more

This was our first time here. We got the mushrooms and a med pizza. If you are getting the mushrooms appetizer it is a 4 person not for two unless you want to be stuff because you will not stop eating them because are so good we got them with the meat sauce Will be back soon read more

Very friendly pizza joint. Super crowded on a Friday night (so call ahead!), but they found a place to squeeze us in. Lovely staff. Seating is really close, so if you like space between tables (or even at the entry door), this isn't the place for you. We we're passing through town, so didn't mind being so close to the locals to not feel like outsiders. We had pizza and garlic bread. Garlic bread and marinara was A+! I give the pizza a B. Had to put parmesan and pepper flakes to add flavor. I'm from Chicago, so I need a lot of seasoning on my pie. But, the pizza was still good. Would definitely recommend and go again. read more

The food is great. We prefer to sit at the bar & have met some really fun people. The staff give WONDERFUL service. A++++++

This was a restaurant that clearly hasn't updated anything since the early 1980's. The food was ok. They charged for every little extra. And extra dressing cost 60 cents. Two of our dishes were stuck together by gum. I have had better. read more

My family's favorite place for pizza. They made a thin crust convert out of me. The EBA - everything but anchovies- is the best. The also have excellent fried mushroom and chicken livers. There is usually a wait on weekend nights so make reservations or even use carry out. read more

Best thin crust pizza in town! I love the EBA. I just wish the place was updated and bigger.

Picked up a carry out on New Years Eve. Bacon Alfredo Chicken Pizza. Awesome stuff. Quick carry out at the bar. They do have a drive up window, which I didn't notice until after leaving. read more

Hands down best pizza in town. Staff is long term and cares. Other menu items have never disappointed either. My teenage boys always chow the meatball sandwiches without hesitation. Only advice is ask for extra sauce on your pizza. Once in a while a little thin. read more

Awesome place that is so cool and laid back. I am surprised it's not on Diners Drive-ins and Dives. The salad had homemade blue cheese and the thin crust pizza is as good as it gets. read more

The pizza is great along with the appetizers I've tried. The beer is very cold and fresh. My problem with this restaurant is the service one gets when ordering take out. The customer service standard is lacking for phone orders and drive through service. read more

Pizza is a bit greasy but damn, it's the best pizza in town! The poorboys are really good too!! I recommend carryout as teh building is old and rundown. Plus they have a drive-up window for convenience!! read more

The wife and I will make the 60 mile drive just to have a night out at Gabatoni's. The place has an aged atmosphere but it is a great place for a pitcher of beer and a delicious thin crust 4 item specialty pizza! I have had pizza's all around the country and none of them ever compared to a Gabatoni's pizza. read more

This is a local place and if you like thin crust pizza - not what places call thin crust that is really medium crust - with a crust that will be crisp with a few air bubbles, with a good special mozzarella cheese that gets just a little browned, with toppings that are fresh and diced (they are not chintzy on toppings and FYI: sausage doesn't have fennel seeds), in a place that has a bar eating area with numerous flat screen TVs, along with a restaurant area (just remodeled), great servers, full bar with cold bottled beer, then this is the place in Springfield to go. They have a full Italian menu but whenever I am in here, I get the pizza - it is all about the pizza. They have been here for over 60 years and usually crowed by 6:00. I think they do take reservations. Has a large parking lot and quite a few tables. I've never had a better pizza anywhere and I've tried many (never been to Italy). read more

love love love it! I think it is .little pricey to have.to order seperate instead of a pizza salad lunch combo.

Best pizza in town by far.. Have been there for years & always have been a successful restaurant. They are a little pricey but well worth it. Definitely a 5 star pizza!!! read more

Bar none, THE best pizza in town! If I go to Gabbs, I'm going to order pizza. They have huge salads and other things but the pizza is just so good I don't want anything else. read more

Had to have a meal in the Capital before leaving Illinois, and glad to find this great place with entertaining atmosphere and friendly people. Completely satisfied with the quick service and delicious chicken alfredo pizza. read more

Still very good pizza, great service! But....it is pricy, we got a medium 4 topping pizza + two side salads (just cheese and 1 slice of cucumber) and two ice teas and it was $36+ without tip. But it was full last night and everything ran efficiently and quickly but with tip $41. It is steep. read more

We ordered dinner from this location after discovering the other location was closed. Gabatoni's website provides their contact information and menu, but it is a basic menu. There is no pizza sizes listed, crust type or prices for any of their menu items. The website doesn't say anything about extra charges nor was I told when I placed my phone order that I was going to be charged a $3.00 base rate plus $0.40 per item for delivery. The pizza was okay, it's a soft thin crust but it was oily. Other than the oil the pizza wasn't bad, we ordered the four topping special. You could tell there was onion, green pepper, mushroom and sausage on the pizza and neither item's flavor over powered the rest. The other items we ordered, potato skins and hot wings, were good. The wings were spicy but still had flavor and the potato skins were thick and had the perfect volume of topping. We received the order hot and with disposable silverware. They delivered the order right to our hotel room as well. read more

Ate here months ago after taking daughter to college and really enjoyed the pizza & salad. So because I wrote no review or did a check in, neither my husband or I were able to find it on a whim. Since he's doing the driving, I was able to search Yelp high and low until I found the photos of the building. So I'm writing this review so we will always have a bookmark. read more

I ordered a one topping medium pizza for my two little ones and a italian sausage for myself, not remembering the exact amount, it was way over priced and I have ordered from about everyone in town. Nothing special at all. read more

The best pizza in town in my opinion. The service is always good. prices have gone up - a large pizza with 2 sodas will run $25 - but it's always fantastic. read more

Food was ok. Rather on the expensive side, but the parking and the parking lot is horrible and we probably wont return. It has pot holes and only 2 handicapped spots. Almost impossible to walk on! read more

Great Italian food, vino, and salad. This place is very local but very openly welcoming. Come enjoy everything!

Went here after getting the recommendation. Appetizers were amazing. Have to try the chicken livers. Pizza was a great thin and crispy crust. This will be on my list of regular visits. read more

This is the best pizza in Springfield, period. Sam's and Saputo's are very good. Coz's is nice. They are all thin crust.