I don't want to start this out by saying this is the worse place i'v ever eaten, because i'v never been to a soup kitchen. first of all the place looks authentic with the white cloth square tablets, which makes you think you're about to try some real local mom 'n' pop style italian food, with all this in mind i decided to try a pasta dish, the mariner with mushrooms which comes with a salad, as expected the salad came first which you could tell has been sitting around as it had a yellowish colour to it, they also give you half a pound of salad, after 15 minutes of eating i was only 25% done, so i pushed that to the side when the entree came, first thing i noticed was the bright red pasta sauce, the kind you get from a jar in aldi, and the mushrooms well they where just thrown under the sauce not cooked in like i was expecting, nether the less i tried it and it was even worse than aldi, gabatonis have managed to make a worse tasting sauce than most can's, charge you $8.45 for the privilege. so if you're looking for an authenic italian experience go anywhere else. read more

My wife and daughter agree that this is the best pizza we have ever had. 140 years between us, and we have had a variety of pizza across several states. (Full disclosure: no NYC.) If you like cracker thin pizza crust and scrumptious toppings, this is the top of the line. I loved it 35 years ago, and revisited 5 years ago in 2009 and it was just the same! And we had 4-5 pies while we were in town, because we knew it would be awhile before we got back. Bravo and thanks Gabatoni's!! And please keep the restaurant as it is; it feels like home. read more

The service is beyond awful. First we waited 2 1/2 hours for our large pizza to be delivered after being promised the delivery in 45 min. Then when it finally arrived they brought us the wrong order. They charged us 30 dollars for a small one topping pizza. When we called to ask what happened they did not offer to fix the bill, but said we could have a free pizza next time we ordered. We decided to give Gabatoni's a second chance and ordered the free pizza. We waited 3 hours and it never arrived. Do not order from this restaurant unless you enjoy being ripped off. read more

We ate here while we were in town for a little sightseeing. While I agree with some of the other reviews that the decor is dated the staff and food make up for it. Our server was very accommodating (We were a large party with 6 kids)-super friendly and helpful. The food was good-the pizza was delish (although the crust was a bit too thin for my liking) and the meat sauce was awesome. The kiddos gobbled it right up which says a lot. I found it to be reasonably priced, I paid $40 for 6 people to eat and we left stuffed. read more

I love the pizza, best around. Victor, our server, was excellent. We came with a couple of kids and he made the experience seamless.

I purchased a veggie pizza here for lunch it was thee worst pizza I've ever eaten. It barely had sauce or cheese on it it was so bland very dissatisfied. read more

I went to have dinner after the game last night with my family. The service was good but the kitchen has problems. They brought out the pizza which was good but my daughter's chicken fingers never were brought out along with my brother in laws pork tenderloin sandwich. The manager did not once apologize. The waitress did comp the pizza. The kitchen needs to get it together. Bernie and Betty's here we come! read more

Very good pizza. Not the best part of town, or the best atmosphere. Hadn't had it in probably 8 years, but it was as good as I remembered.

Best Pizza around. Flavors fresh and very tasty. Great thin, crisp crust. Also recommend the Italian Beef sandwich. Tasty beef on a super crusty bun. Consistently good. read more

After moving away from Springfield, whenever I'm back in town this place is a must! So good I couldn't stop eating it! Excellent thin crispy crust pizza. To die for! read more

Great food. Small local Italian restaurant. We absolutely loved it! Our server Victor was funny, welcoming and attentive.

Best pizza in Springfield, hands down. A little pricey for the ambiance and what you get but it is delicious pizza! Dine-in or carry out (drive thru), this is my go to spot for pizza. read more

Great food a Springfield landmark and staff Is great treat you like family . Thanks Rose Mary .

Great pizza and such a helpful, friendly staff! We brought in a group of forty on a busy Friday night and the waiter (Victor) and waitress (Jessica) handle it ease! They were smiling the whole time, bringing out drink refills, appetizers, and their delicious pizza! Would highly recommend to anyone! read more

My family and I love Gabitoni's!! Whenever we visit my grandmother, we always go to Gabitoni's for the great food. The potato skins are heaven and the pizza is to die for. Whether you're dine-in or carry-out, Gabitoni's has the best pizza! read more

I can't say enough good things about Gabatoni's. I have eaten there many times over the years and the food and service are both outstanding. I personally can't vouch for the entire menu but I've yet to hear anyone say they didn't like something they ordered. The pizza, toasted beef ravioli and garlic bread are all delicious, as I'm sure is everything else on the menu. While all of their servers do a good job, Victor goes above and beyond. They accept reservations and if you want to get in on the weekends during the evening, make sure to call in advance or you'll be waiting at the door. They're also open late and have a separate bar area that serves various wines. read more

I lived in Springfield in 1963 - almost 50 years ago - and my the group of young singles from my office use to hit Gabatoni's every Thursday night. I has elated to find on a recent visit that they not only are still, but they are serving the same fine pizza's (Well, not actually the same ones but rather freshly baked ones) as they did 50 years ago. read more

What is there not to love? The food is awesome; the beer always cold cold cold; the help very friendly and really treat you like family and not in a bad creepy way. Love the ambience and the fact everyone knows one another or so will. Do yourself a favor and get there early as they do get busy. read more

Been here three times now and somehow I'm always the one they've forgotten to put in my order for. Service is always bad, food is ok. Just like any other Italian place in town. read more

wonderful thin crust pizzia,, is a place out of the 60's decor is old wrought iron with rickety wooden chairs, they have been there for ages!! as have the employees, and the folks in read more