Delicious food and amazing Guatemalan bread to go! Definitely worth trying more than just pizza and pasta. They are super polite and speak more Spanish. For us anti-socials, they give you your space to eat when you dine in. I went with The Godfather panini with french fries. It was so good and portions are enough to share. I tried their Concha bread and took a pack to go as well. *my labubu was used for size reference read more

Gabby's II Pizza & Restaurant - The Godfather panini with french fries! - Pizza Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

was never told that there are no refills on the drinks. the person working there was a bit rude as well would not recommend.

I only grabbed a white slice w broccoli, but it was quite good. I live far away, so I can't frequent this place but if I did live closer, I would probably try some of their other dishes. read more

The food needs and major upgrade, nothing taste as it should, sauces are always watered down, fries are not fried proper, meat balls taste like they are from Korea war issue. read more

Pizza was delivered cold, under cooked and looking liked it went on a roller coaster ride. I asked for a refund but the nephew said he did not know what to do and would have the owner call me. Waited over an hour for phone call back. My 3 yr old son, mother and myself were starving so we ate the pizza Owner called me and said he would refund my money unless I gave him the pizza back. I told him we were hungry waited an hour so we heated it up and ate. Owner refused to refund my money back because he didn't believe. This is the first time we ever had this issue. Very sad to see read more

Not sure how this place is in business giving customers what they gave me today. Ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and was given a soupy mess of hot sauce on top of what used to be a pizza crust. It's hard to imagine they'd give me something so disgusting read more

Gabby's II Pizza & Restaurant - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

thin crust bacon pineapple mushroom pizza is the best. good sandwiches too. delivery is quick and food is always hot

Yesterday my wife and I needed some comfort food for lunch. I ordered a meat lovers slice which when it arrived was delicious. The crust was so excellent that I had to write about it, the topping was well seasoned as well. Overall my experience was overwhelmingly positive. This place is now our go-to place for pizza in Hackettstown read more

Hi this is my second time ordering from Gabbys, and I ordered simple items, like chicken Alfredo and egg plant Parm dinner and a Chicago pan pizza. The Alfredo and the egg plant barely had any gravy. Cold The pan pizza was absolutely hard as a rock and ice cold, for my entire order I paid $46 and throw it in the garbage. So needless to say if you're in the vicinity Gabby's pizza keep driving, not a good choice thank you read more

Go here often and the food is always good I especially like the chicken bacon ranch pizza and the stuffed slices they have. The prices are fair and they are quick with their service. read more

We order it for a night out at one of the breweries. It arrived in time and hot. Delivery person was great. Some of the worst pizza I have ever had. Dough was stale, hard and tasteless. Wouldn't order from them again! read more

Nasty food!! We ordered several times and the first few times it was good to ok. However, each time the food just gets worse. We had burnt pepperoni pizza with no sauce and that was after they messed up the first pie. The zeppelins are small and over priced and often come with very little powdered sugar. The pepperoni roll was burnt and the chicken Alfredo was bland and nasty. Overall just disgusting food. We won't be ordering again. read more

Great food, great prices, awesome customer service and very large menu with lots of options to choose from. Moving here from New York I thought all the pizza places would be a disappointment but Gabby's WAS NOT. Love this place. Highly recommended! read more

Gabby's was our go to pizza and wings place but sadly the last couple of times we've ordered the wings have been soggy and the honey bbq sauce on them is overwhelming with vinegar. We even ordered them extra crispy and they were a soggy mess and inedible. Have to find a new place. read more

The menu advertised 2 pies for $17.99 and it was not honored. When questioned the man said yes you need money returnEd but the pizza man making pizza said no. The pizza man making pizza also collects the money and doesn't wash hands. read more

Decided to order a pasta dinner that clearly stated it comes with a side salad on the menu from their website. When I called to place the order I was asked what type of dressing so this confirmed that a salad was included. When I recieved my food guess what was missing.....my salad. I called the store to ask if I can get the salad and the lady told me it's not included as she just asked her manager. So why was I asked what kind kind of dressing on the original call as well as it states on the menu... so I asked about this. The manager decided to get real nasty and told me he was not going to give me my salad I paid for. Long story short. I had to go back to the store to get a new salad so I decided to get my $ back since my time was wasted and went to Frank's on Mansfield instead. Well I ended up getting my exact order for less $, larger and fresher portions and will be returning to Frank's and boycotting Gabbys from now on! read more

We order from here very often and the food is good and the people who work here are friendly. Every once in a while we dine in also. The delivery is pretty fast and when we have errors with the order they always fix it right away. Definitely give them a try! read more

Best pizza around! You know when you've been searching for that perfect slice for a long time and then you finally bite into? Thats what my experience was like here. They have the kind of pizza where the sauce is great, the cheese is fresh, and when you bite into a hot-out-of-the-oven slice you hear the heavenly crunch of the crispy bottom. Everyone searches for that crispy crust, dont deny it. I ordered a plain slice (to be fair) and an indulgent slice of chicken parm pizza. Both were fantastic. The staff was also very nice and the decor inside was classy and above average for just a pizza place. I really loved it! read more

I come here often for pizza. Always very good. Their buffalo chicken is excellent! However my pizza the other day was outstanding! Just like NYC, thin, hot, perfect amount of cheese and sauce. read more

Stated all dinners include a house salad they refused to give it to us. Lost business for arguing with me

We got take out from here and the pizza was just ok. But the chicken Marsala was disgusting. The chicken was white, looked uncook and over cooked at the same time. Sauce was terrible. It ended up in the garbage. Such a shame because this place used to be pretty good. read more