A Queens staple! Been going here for over 30 years. The pizza and the service is always great . My youngest kid was in love from the first slice .... Calls it the "Sweet Pizza " top 10 in the 5 Boros. Always clean inside with historical pictures of local stars on the wall . read more

The place is clean & always crowded. This has been my 3/4 time here and it's great pizza. Last visit I ordered a buffalo chicken salad. It was good but nothing special. I will continue to visit Gaby's when I crave pizza. The servers are always very nice. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Buffalo chicken salad - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

Gabys has been the queens go to for many many years even before I got into pizza lol. I am usually a regular I've had so many different menu items. Just a covid update they are not selling slices only pies so you would have to order a small/ personal pie for $7.75 that is 4 slices makes about 2 slices The next pie is medium for $17 I think a large is now $23-25 now very sure. The pizza quality is still there they just have to create a better system not answering the phone and making people wait in front to order is a waste of people's time. You can not call for a small pie u have to walk up and wait in front for 5-10 min depending on what's going on. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

My husband grew up in queens village and always bragged about how good the pizza is at Gaby's. Today, he realizes that all good things must come to an end. He was so embarrassed by this pizza and swore that's not the pizza he grew up eating. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Well done regular large pie - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

As a native and life long New Yorker, I've had many pizzas. Gaby's sauce, dough and cheese are on point. Excellent slice of pizza! read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Been coming here since I was a kid and it's still top 3 in NYC. Sauce is just right and more important- the crust, doughy and just the right amount of sauce. Fast service. Ambiance is average, but love the old school pictures. read more

OMG, this is my go to spot when that pasta craving hits!!! My preference is the Carbanora mmm mmm but I know that the pizza is great also...so go there n get you a slice while waiting for that pasta... Note: the baked ziti, chicken fettuccine mmm mmm read more

Came here for a buffalo chicken slice and carbonara. The carbonara was amazing 10/10. I also have to say that they accidentally charged me twice for something I ordered and the staff came to me and said she recognized the mistake and gave my money back without me even asking. I didn't even notice it! I really appreciate their honesty and that made me really want to give them more business. Regular slice is $3.50 but they aren't cheap with the crust so I appreciate that. read more

See all

Best slice in Queens ! I have been a customer of Gabys for over 25+ years it was good then and it's good now

Decent pizza slice, very clean fast service good ambiance and very attentive. A good stop for pizza amor Italian dishes

Cheap pizza for the portion you get! I loved the pepperoni sausage slice I got. Workers were friendly and fast. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage regular slices - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

This place is now one of the worst places. I always use my credit card to pay for my 2 slices and soda without any problem.. However here there was a $15 minimum... I used to love coming here and was really in the mood for some of their pizza, but never again. read more

Delicious menu, great quality and great service. The bread on the sandwich is soft, fluffy like if it was baked on site. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Chicken, fresh mozzarella with vodka sauce sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

I need this in my life! Lol! I am not going to start a debate about the best pizza, but from the places that I have been to, Gaby's is hands down the best I have had. The sauce and the crust is what do it for me. There is a tanginess to the sauce which is absolutely delicious and it is not overly salty. Perfect ratio of cheese to pepperoni. Just melt in your mouth, delicious! I will definitely be back one more time before I head back home. There are plenty of people working so the service is fast and efficient. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Decent pizza. Has the classic neighborhood NYC pizzeria vibe. Orders are constantly coming in, fast service. Not the best pizza I have ever had but good enough for a local pizzeria. read more

Gaby's Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

This was our go-to pizza place as a kid. My cousins and I would go here almost every weekend and just enjoy a slice of cheese or pepperoni pizza. After many years not living in New York anymore, I found myself back here when my family and I decided to visit. It was so nostalgic and heartwarming to see that it hasn't really changed and that the pizza is still as delicious as I remembered it. The casual vibes and the staff are what makes this place worth the visit. I'll always find myself coming here whenever we're in town. Such a staple with so many memories. read more

Four experiences four positive ones. Good history. Good pizza. Friendly service, replaced a dropped fountain soda. Right now the TV is running relaxing "white noise." read more

Extremely poor server ruined most of the experience. We were going to tip but the man tapped the card and turned it to himself and swiped away. One of the servers was very nice, a little Hispanic lady, I think she was. Then there was this awful I believe Guyanese lady, since no one has name tags or bothers to answer if I ask their name, I have to go with what I got. She was constantly rude and sassy, wouldn't give my 70 y/o mom another napkin, and cleared everyone's tables except ours, even the people who only got 1 slice of pizza, and rudely told us to clean it up and throw it out...when there was nothing but wrappers neatly put on the tray, as well as paper plates and two trays plus a cleaned dish. on top of all that, really burly guy with Gaby's on his shirt, bearded, kept glaring at us when we were ordering and eating. He always does that when either me or my Mom visit. Now, I have been in the neighborhood since 2004, and we come here ever so often. Never have I been treated worse by any restaurant. Genuinely awful and in my opinion, discriminatory. No matter how good the food is, not worth being treated like human garbage as a paying person who was incredibly respectful the whole time. I didn't react to their petty shit cuz I'm not like that. But I feel slighted, and here you go. :) Enjoy! Never coming here again! read more

I absolutely love coming to Gabys.... Literally freaking hot and fresh pizza made Honestly everything on the menu is really amazing for a pizzeria read more

Gaby's is certainly one of my go to spots for pizza. They consistently turn out a great slice of pizza. The pizza is always fresh and never sitting around for very long. So many different slices to chose from. The Regular, Sicilian, and Vegetable slices are my go to here. The sauce is slightly sweet with some tanginess as well. My favorite slice of pizza here is the Chicken & Tomato. Plenty of chunks of chicken, cubed slices of tomato, and plenty of garlic. This may very well be the best Chicken & Tomato slice I've ever had. Gaby's has plenty of indoor seating and it's conveniently located in a shopping center with enough parking spots. read more

See all

1/22/19- Their pizza is so tasty and full of flavor! We ordered the "Rachel Ray" and the no sauce 3 cheese pizza. I called ahead and picked up our order. It was a little busy at the time so I waited a little under 10 minutes. Customer service is satisfactory. It was a little confusing though since it wasn't clear where the line was to pay versus customers that were simply waiting. The establishment looked clean. From the register counter you can see the pizzas being made and man they all looked amazing! I'm looking forward to my next visit to NY and will be sure to stop by here and try their penne vodka pizza. read more

Gaby's Pizza - 1-22-19 medium Rachel Ray and no sauce 3 cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Gaby's is consistently good! I've been coming here for a while, their pizza is very good. The sauce is everything! Delicious! One thing that is also consistent is the fruit punch fountain drink to be watered down. All in all the name speaks for itself. Go and get some deliciousness!! read more

I read the reviews on yelp (thanks yelpers) and decided to get some NY pizza. Not often do you hear of the reputation of a pizza shop having such high community support from the neighborhood. The gossip is true; the pizza is good and they do a lot for the community. The shop has a strong history here. Nice. New York pizza has a reputation on its own--always imitated but never duplicated. I tried many "NY style pizza" from several states but NY pizza in NY is something different. I called Gaby's and was immediatly placed on hold--a good thing because the woman was talking to another customer completing the order. I ordered a large pepperoni to eat tonight and for tomorrows breakfast. I requested delivery since it is close. I was told 45 minutes to an hour; the pizza arrived in 30 minutes. A typical NY large pie. Three people took a slice--huge slice--NY size slice. Great tasting crust, nicely seasoned sauce, good amount of cheese and pepperoni. Everyone said it was good. And it was good. Familiar texture, taste, feel, and grease (fresh mozzarella). If my first experience is the norm, I see why this place is loved so much by the people in Hollis. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Large pepperoni from Gaby's. - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

This is tough because Gabby's sauce is off the charts. But so are their prices literally. The online menu prices in no way reflects the prices Gabby's charges. They also don't have the prices on the wall menu (makes it easy to rip off people). Good food but unaplogetic about ripping people off. read more

Gabys is the best in Queens. The pizza is something that you just crave and have run to get right away. The staff is super nice and makes you feel like you're at home with family. They have done some really nice updating while keeping the true Queens Gaby's vibe. read more

Great tasting pizzas. All flavors are top notch. Made with a fluffy bread and good proportion of sauce cheese. Veggie slice is loaded with veggies broccoli carrots spinach zucchini etc. Cozy ambiance. read more

This wont be as long as my usual reviews because it doesnt have to be, Gaby's is 100% top 3 Pizza Spots in Queens and I will hit it anytime Im passing through that area. Plain slice and a buffalo chicken slice absolute heat. Fire. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Slice and Plain Slice (she kind of dropped it dont mind the cheese slide it came perfect hahaha) - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Surprisingly pretty good!!! I've lived near the infamous Gaby's pizza for 25 years and heard so much about it hesitant to try because I doubted it could be as good as all the raves. Finally, I gave this place a try and it certainly didn't disappoint. For a pizzeria establishment in Queens this place definitely qualifies as best pizza and could compete with many manhattan pizza joints (and blow them out of the water). It's a neighborhood special for sure and now I understand the hype read more

Gaby's Pizza - the menu and prices - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Back in the day everyone either went to Gaby's or Margherita's Pizza depending on which side of Jamaica you lived on or school you went to. I've had my fair share of Gaby's Pizza and quite frankly it left me with a bland taste each and every time. I remember the dough being hard. The slices of pizza didn't contain enough sauce to cheese ratio. The pizza tasted like a heated up slice of cardboard. Not appealing nor appetizing. The reason for the two stars is because the food is pretty bland and unmemorable. However, the staff here are courteous and sweet. read more

Always fresh and hot, my go to is a cheese slice with extra cheese. Their chicken parm is also very good.

I've got many minions and they come in all shapes and sizes and ages, I am not exactly sure how I collected all of them along the way but they have clung to me over the years like barnacle glue and I haven't the slightest reason why. I eat too much, drink too much, I can be rude, crude and socially unacceptable at times, however I do not swear nor use curse words but that cant be enough, can it? Today's minion was on the plumper side, picture a calzone with legs, but we eat out together and I respect his palate and I rarely want to jab my fork into his eye. He knows all the old classic spots, some new, just not as many is he would have you believe and all I have to do is get us to and fro. So he went in, I did loop de loops in the parking lot, \ I poked my head in once just to take a quick peep but my eyes were immediately met by some 1970s beat up car of a woman with headlight eyes that glared back at me and made me instantaneously uncomfortable, so I shut the door quick. Resigned to the fact I was to dine in the car, I placed the slice in my hand and did this upward, downward lift and release indicating the robust weight of this regular slice. The tomato sauce was a brilliant red, thick but not clumpy, slowed stewed to be sure. The hand gyrations were to illustrate the weight to myself, it was almost two of that mass at my local pizza spots, all cheese and I can not imaging a pie was ever ordered with extra cheese from this place, for it would choke a horse. Then I tore the meatball hero in two and one side only got one meatball in the soft Italian bread, hard bread would have been my preference, not for the tear but for the consumption. The meatballs would not cool down, the temperature seemed to not heed a degree so I thought cool thoughts and asbestos mouthed my way through. Three stars on the meatball hero, which pairs really well with naps by the way and five for the regular slice as it was as pleasant and enjoyable as the over rated old names, storied parlors that hang on to the name which seems to be more their their actual recognition than whats been coming out of their ovens.. read more

Not the same anymore use to be good and $4 for a slice of Pizza? I guess only celebrities can afford to eat there! Haven't eaten there since they raised the price of a slice to $4.00 and what's up with the electronic menu board with no prices on it? That's so suspicious! Haven't they gotten the message that people are not going there anymore? read more

Traveling into Queens for work and this well established pizzeria is tucked into a very busy shopping plaza. Take out or some tables for dining in. Nostalgia and accolades plastered on the walls and extremely friendly serving staff Behind the counter. Enjoyed the white slice, buffalo chicken and regular cheese slice. Thoroughly enjoyed by all in attendance. read more

I like this place because it's always quick. Your in and out in a jiffy and the slices aren't too bad. I'd recommend staying away from the plain slices and also bringing cash. They have a $15 minimum for card which is always a pain. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Best pizza best service best everything! Courtesy and costumer service is the priority. Also Genuine ingredients, I love the taste. But read more

I have been coming to Gaby's for over 20 years. When I first tasted this pizza, I was hooked! This pizza place reminded me of a well-known pizza place that existed in New York City in the 80s called Pizza town. Sadly, in the last couple of years, the taste of the pizza has just gone downhill. The owners were always visible and interacting with their customers, now it is completely different. I hardly ever see them there anymore. The taste of the pizza is a hit or miss. Sometimes way too much cheese, or the dough is just too thick, the sauce doesn't even taste the same. I wish the owners would come back and go back to the way that they were doing pizza beforehand, when it was more of a family business. Now it's all new workers, and unfortunately they miss the mark when it comes to Pizza. Very disappointing. read more

My favorite NY slice since 1982. I grew up in Hollis. Gaby's was part of my childhood. I moved to Long Island 31 years ago but I still drive to Queens (although it's quite a trek) just to eat at Gaby's. My family and I love it! read more

This pizza was just okay. The flavour was mediocre. I think if it's this or no food, or you're eating it relatively fresh/right away it's worth it. If not, it's pretty disappointing. read more

My new Queens Pizza spot!!!! The pizza is delicious! I come through whenever I am on the side of town. read more

Dylan (Dillon?) was super sweet! Or maybe I'm just a sucker for good customer service lol. Oh! The sandwich was good too. I already get the California Cheese Chicken. read more