The pizza was excellent. Most of all the customer service offered by Facundo, a young man serving and working the register. The owner should commend this young man who treated us so well read more

Craving pizza one night we wanted to give this mom and pop shop a try! Needless to say we will definitely be eating here again! The pizza was delicious, it was hot and fresh. The garlic knots we ordered smelled so good on the way home we almost ate them in the car! They were also delicious! If you're in the area give them a try you won't be disappointed! read more

Live nearby and notice this Pizza place tucked in a corner with some good reviews. I decided to stop by after work to check it out. Was greeted by (Facundo - cashier), he helped me navigate the menu and I placed an order for a Supreme pizza. Waited about 15 min and took it to go. Got home and devour the pizza, it was delicious and the crust nice and chewy but not too chewy. I loved it and this might be might new go to spot since my other mom and pops pizza shop closed down. read more

Staff is very courteous and worked diligently to get my order out quicker to be able to take to my son's school.

Food was excellent, delivery was quick, overall great experience. Highly recommended!

We just had the pizza, but it was really really good. The service is friendly. The ambience is OK. I'm sure you will be delighted with the food. read more

I was in the neighborhood on a Sunday working and I found this tiny joint. The pizza is a lil too much on the doughy side for me lots of flop and super oily. It tasted like it was made outta a bakery it wasn't bad. 6.7 read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

Loved their garlic rolls! Ordered a large 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 cheese pizza and it was delicious! My two year old couldn't get enough. The service was great. He came to our table to check on us, cleared the table, made conversation. Cute little pizzeria! We will definitely be back!! read more

Loved this small cozy place. The rolls were perfect! Our pizza was delicious. Will definitely be back to try other dishes.

What a little gem. Went for lunch after being at the park with the kids. We ordered a large pizza and let me tell you we all loved and devoured it!! It was so good. The inside is small but very clean and comfortable. They had a TV with sports which the boys loved. The cashier was friendly and very helpful cutting the pizza in smaller portions for the kids. read more

We tried their pizza and a meatball Parm sub for the first time and everything was delicious. My wife and our three boys all devoured everything. We ordered takeout and brought the food home and everything was ready on time when they said it would be. Definitely recommend Gaetano's Pizzaria! read more

The place is small, it feels like a family joint where you'll get great authentic taste. The pizza and garlic bread was good. It's New York style. Not pricey for what you get. Would recommend. read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Garlic Rolls - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

See all

I can't believe I had never had this pizza until today. It instantly became one of my favorites. The sauce was delicious and the crust was perfect. This will definitely be my new go to pizza place! read more

Good ole fashioned New York pizza place, hits all the necessary marks to make it pizza confort food.

This is place reminds me of home. NYC! The pizza is spot on old school pizza and you can get slices but only until a certain time. This place is one of my faves when I want a NY style slice!!!! read more

I've been coming here for years and still to date my favorite pizza place! This mom and pop is has some of the best NY style food I have ever had. 10/10 pizza and 10/10 family. read more

I've been meaning to try this restaurant for a long time. I'm glad I finally went last night. The restaurant is small. And there was a lot of foot traffic, which is a great sign. The owner, Elena, was there taking orders and helping to serve all of the customers. She was so friendly and humble. We ordered a large cheese pizza, garlic rolls, and eggplant Parm. The garlic rolls had an unexpected slight sweetness to the dough. Which I loved. I could've eaten a dozen by myself. They were outstanding! The pizza was by far the best tasting pizza (to my liking) that I have had here in Miami. The pizza dough had the same slight sweetness to it and the sauce as well. The eggplant Parm was good. Decent portion. The banana chocolate cake was really good. Elena checked on us a couple times to make sure we were doing well along with the rest of the customers. That was appreciated. You can tell she really takes pride in this business. Gaetanos will now be my number 1 for pizza and garlic rolls. And there is a lot of good competition in Miami (considering big cheese, pizza johnys, all star, vesuvio, mamma mia, two brothers, amicis, etc) Gaetanos wins for me, hands down! read more

See all

We went on a Saturday night. Had 1 slice of cheese, it was good and quick. The pizza had a nice flavor and good thin crunch.

Love this place. Best local pizzeria in Pinecrest. The pepperoni is excellent. Great NY-style pie. read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

Very nice hole in the wall style restaurant. Great pizza and great service, we also had some garlic knots that were very fresh and flavorful. Would highly recommend if you're in the area and are craving pizza. read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

Unfortunately we found out with this visit that my "Pisano" Gaetano Gambino passed away in December. My wife and I have fond memories of his smiling face and warm greetings whenever we visited his little shop off the beaten track. I knew Gaetano since 1969 from Kings Hwy in Brooklyn and my wife since Cozzoli's in Dadeland. He exemplified a true old world pizza maker with a great product. His wife now runs the shop and is still putting out a great product. RIP our dear friend. read more

Good local spot. Very small, only 3-4 tables. Served piping hot, good mix of toppings available, more sauce than your typical pie. Crust has a good crunch. Will go back to try again. That said, Local Pie is better. read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

The best pizza in Miami. Every time I eat there the pizza is the best. As close to New York pizza I can find in Mia

Love this local spot. Good daily specials. All the food is fresh and tasty. Staff is accommodating and engaging.

Great local place. Love the pizza. Love the eggplant. Better for pickup than delivery. Try eating there. read more

We've been enjoying Gaetano's since they opened so many years ago. Our kids grew up on the cheese pizza We've been customers for so long they even named a pie after her. When you come in tell Elena to make you an Elsa. You won't regret it. read more

One of the best pizzas in Miami Florida. I thought that I was in NY. It's hard to find a delicious pizza with the perfect dough, sauce and cheese! Truly it's perfection. We have never had better. read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Great Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

See all

Amazing!!! I just happened to stumble on this hole in the wall one late night craving pizza and wow was I happy. This place immediately embraces you when you walk in like a hug from a loved one. It felt like home. The owner, Elena greeted us immediately and with so much love. There's no pressure to order they let you breathe but never forget about you. Elena was the sweetest. She even shared her and her husbands story with me and how they came about and it was just so moving. Folks doing what they love, making delicious food. The pizza and the garlic rolls ! So fresh. You can tell everything is made in house and with love. It had such a beautiful flavor and the dough consistency was perfect. I couldn't stop haha. The garlic rolls were my favorite. I hate when you bite into garlic rolls and they are so crunchy. These were not that all. Perfect flavor. We also ordered a Greek salad...so fresh! Healthy and vibrant greens. If you are ever in the area or hell! If you are ever craving pizza and looking for quality taste and service then please pay Elena a visit! You will feel right at home. Can't wait to go back myself! read more

Nice but very small family operation off the main strip of Dixie highway. Our freshly made thin crust pizza was fantastic. Lots of mushrooms and very thinly sliced sausage. A few points off for a watery feel - maybe from the mushrooms? And a lack of seasoning - zilch salt, pepper, oregano on the pizza or the tables. But inexpensive and friendly service. Worth a repeat for a family but not a date place.... read more

Great pizza place nestled away behind Dadeland South train station. Limited seating so recommend it more for takeout.

Hubby has been wanting to try this place for some time now. Yesterday he ordered a pepperoni and ricotta pizza and a chicken parmesan sandwich. We loved the pizza but not the sandwich. I was happily surprised by the pizza. Everything about it was good! The crust, the sauce and the cheese were just right! Give it a try! read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and ricotta pizza - delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

Service was good, the food was good and everything went real smooth a great place to eat!!!

I came here at the request of my best friend who came down with his kids from NC and they asked for great pizza. When we got there I guess they were in the mood for something else since they saw Spaghetti was in the menu. So my friends son had the Spaghetti with marinara sauce, his daughter had the spaghetti and meatballs, and me and my best friend had the large pizza. The kids loved the spaghetti dinners and me and my friend well we thought the pizza was very good. The sauce in the pizza was delicious but a tad sweet. Great cheese and the crust and pizza dough was tender with a good enough crisp to it. It wasn't filling because it wasn't thick but good enough to satisfy my hunger. The service was very good and felt the restaurant had that great family friendly feel since a small family runs it. read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Gaetano's Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

Read reviews had me intrigued but I was not impressed looks great but for me it lacked taste and my pizza within minutes it was soggy andvtge crust was doughey, garlic rolls barely had garlic and were too doughey, the Sicilian slice was crunchy but sauce was too sweet for my taste. Friendly service, free parking is provided. There are a few ranked available. Tables and bathrooms were clean. read more

See all

I have been to Gaetano's Pizzeria many times now and every time I go, their food is always delicious and their service is top notch. One of my favorite dishes is their Lasagna. Rarely do you go to a restaurant where the food tastes like a home cooked meal. Gaetano's gives me that feel every time I go. Whether is their Lasagna or their delicious Garlic Roll served with a side of this amazing pasta sauce, which I have been told, is a home made sauce made by the owner, Rosa Elena. Lastly, for all you beer lovers, i usually order a Peroni when I go because the beer is served with a beer mug that is frozen for you to poor your beer. The best. Shout out to the Owner of Gaetano's Pizzaria, Rosa Elena, who creates a family atmosphere when you dine in. Enjoy! read more

This place was honestly a HUGE let down. My boyfriend and I were staying at a hotel near by and saw this place had good reviews. Sadly, we do not see how this is possible. The pizza I ordered was super dry and flavorless. My boyfriend ordered a Chicken Parm, with double chickien. Not only did they NOT give us the extra chicken we paid for ($4 upcharge), it was also super bland. Not sure if we caught them on a bad day, but we will NEVER be ordering from here again. $42 for tastless food and missing items. First and last time here. read more

Found this place on Yelp, and fell in love, family oriented, cozy and the pizza was delicious. I will definitely come back for more pizza here! read more

Gaetano's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza and Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

First, I want to start off with how great the environment is, beautiful people, beautiful drinks, and especially beautiful pizza. One of my favorite, if not, most favorite pizza places I've been to. Absolute 11/10. Knocks "Local Pie" out of the ballpark. On top of everything, the service of Gaetano's is one of the greatest. Wholesome atmosphere and great staff. -Ryan Taks read more

I tried this place on a whim. If driven by it a few times and wondered how the pizza was but I was always loyal to my main pizza joint for pizza. This time I figured I'd try something new and honestly, this will be my new regular pizza joint! The pizza is perfect for my taste. Sauce is a mix of sweet and spicy just the way I like it and the cheese was also great!! It reminds me of my favorite NY pizza! The garlic rolls were also delish. It had a sweetness to the garlic that I loved as well. If you haven't already, give the pizza a shot. I will definitely be going back for more! read more

See all

Best pizza I've had in Miami!!!!!!!! Love the people there too. And it feels great to support a small business! read more