They do not skimp on the ingredients. Love the meat lovers pizza. Nice mix of all the ingredients.

Like this place because it's on my way home. Pizza is good. It is a little pricy and they never have special's or any coupons. People are always nice. read more

While the pizza was pedestrian at best, I thought it lacked toppings. The order was to go so, the ambience at my house was good. The service at pickup was a bit spotty. They couldn't find my order at first however did find it. read more

Found hair in just about every piece of pizza. I thought maybe it's just the first piece it's fine which is already too forgiving but there was 3 hairs on one piece and one several on other pieces. Seemed unreal like it had to be a prank. Threw away the whole pizza. read more

This South side Indianapolis pizza place has been here as long as I can remember. Much better than your cookie cutter chain stores. Anytime I have a pizza there it's pretty darn good. They can use a little bit too much cheese at times though. The breadsticks are pretty good. I really enjoy their wings. Here they're not too crispy like other places are. read more

One of my favorite south side pizza restaurants! The Sink pizza is my family's favorite. The employees are always so nice when we come in.

Just got another kitchen sink Pizza it's a takeout place but wow their pizza is awesome. Highly recommended if you haven't tried it you need to. read more

It's been awhile since I had their pizza and it was great... almost 30$ for a large deluxe and veggie but I guess that's what we have to pay for pizza nowadays but it was good!! I'll be back read more

Very good pizza and the staff is very helpful and pleasant to deal with which is a nice change of pace from the usual change of character you usually get out in the world these days! So good so go get stuffed! You won't leave hungry that's a fact if you do there's something wrong with you. Lol you might need to see a doctor about it because this place is the best and they give you so much great food it's ridiculous!!! So stop reading this and get you some food from them NOW!!!! read more

This is a place on the Greenwood/Indy line. I called my pickup order in and it was ready by the time I got there. It is a carry out or delivery place. They do not have a dining area. they just have a bench that you can wait for your food. I got a pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was pretty good. It has a blanket of cheese, so much so that I had to cut it again to get it not to come off as one sheet. Spoiler alert, the toppings are under the cheese. The breadsticks are also pretty good too. They are reasonably priced and great value for what you get. The pizza is cut in squares and not you typical pie slice. The breadsticks come with marinara sauce and cheese. I enjoyed my pizza. It is a great option for those on the Southside of Indy. The menu is simple, but food is good. read more

After ordering there 7 more times... it's a perfect pizza every time. They put so much care into their craft and are so friendly. They give back to community organizations. The family grew up in the Southside of Indianapolis. SUPPORT THIS LOCAL BUSINESS read more

Ordered through DoorDash, pizza arrived timely and hot. The pizza was not thin but not too thin! Had the perfect amount of toppings, sausage and pepperoni. The regular breadsticks were ok, nothing to write about. I would have liked to order more cheese sauce though but didn't see an option. The stuffed breadsticks I could make a meal of! Think bosco sticks but better! You can tell they're handmade, had the perfect amount of cheese inside, and the topping literally tops it off! Again maybe more cheese sauce because one little container just isn't enough! I would definitely recommend and order again! read more

See all

I ordered a large pizza with sausage, mushroom, and olive. They are true to their word when they say they're generous with toppings, the sausage was ground and completely covered the entire crust. Even though there was a lot, it had little flavor and it absorbed most of the sauce. I love the bake and style of this pizza, but it was very disappointing because it had no flavor and it was dry. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Often eat here, but tonight the pizza is amazing. Crust cooked perfectly crispy! Very very good!

The kitchen sink pizza was great. Definitely worth the hype. Perfect place for good local carry out/delivery pizza.

Love this place haven't found anything I don't like always good and on time very friendly staff

The best pizza that I tried so far ! Not too salty , not too greasy , healthier than most other edge burned pizza! read more

Excellent pizza and service. They h as ve great options for pizzas and there other items are great.

We've lived in southern dunes for 3 years and tonight was the first time we've tried Gallagher's. When we were house hunting I remember seeing comments around about how amazing the pizza was. We ordered a bbq chicken traditional crust pizza with half bacon and half tomato. The crust was a nice thickness (not much thicker than thin), the bbq was really good (not too sweet), and it had a ton of cheese which was great. The crust had a really nice flavor as well around the edges. We ordered 5 breadsticks and glad we did as they were large and cut in half so you got quite a bit and they automatically come with a small cup of nacho cheese and a marinara. We weren't very impressed by the breadsticks unfortunately and the cheese wasn't spicy like we like our nacho cheese. We also got a house salad with French which comes in a large styrofoam meal container topped with a ton of cheese, red onion slice, tomato slice, and cucumber. Very large salad which was also nice. We had it delivered. The delivery guy was very nice. He forgot the salad and rushed back to get it and bring it to us. We would order again the pizza and salad for sure. Definitely worth a try if you live in the area and don't want a chain pizza joint for pizza night! read more

4.5 I'd give it five stars but I wish the nacho cheese was a bit spicier and not thicker. Otherwise, this is wonderful. It was delivered promptly and hot. A little pricey, but if you want to splurge on a local pizza joint, this is the place to do it. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Delux Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Best pizza I've ever ate. Get the "SINK" pizza, you won't be disappointed. The staff is great too.

Great pizza and friendly staff. Decently priced drinks. Looking forward to returning.

Placed an order for pick up waiting 20 mins before getting it they told us flat out they forgot to make our wings then when I got home they messed up my pizza was supposed to be half banana peppers bacon and pep they put full banana peppers and no bacon on it and it's honestly not cooked very well will be calling tomorrow seemed like the person there tn didn't care about anything at all read more

First time ordering from there was tonight and it will be our last. Someone clearly turned my pizza on its side as all the toppings were balled on the edge of the one side of the pizza and stuck to that side of the box. It had to have been done right after being put in the box. It had been that way long enough that the cardboard box had become one with the toppings. I understand accidents happen however the appropriate thing to have done would have been to notify us and say it happened and there will be a slight delay on our order as you are remaking the pizza. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

See all

Our Sink Pizza was ruined because it had HOT jalapenos added, which I did not order. $30 for a pizza my wife and son could not eat. Try picking out cheese covered jalapeno pieces, Then when I called the store one of the teenaged 'chefs' had nothing to say and NOTHING to offer. I'm 15 minutes away so was hoping for some sort of comp , but NOTHING ! 1st and LAST visit and I will make sure I mention Gallaghers poor customer service anyone who will listen NOT RECOMMENDED . read more

Gallagher's pizza is always good! Love the crust and the amount of cheese they place on each pizza. Their salads are spot on as well. Would give them 5 stars but their breadsticks are just OK. Always hot, ready to pick up and decently priced! read more

Gallagher's Pizza - order of breadsticks, 14" 1/2 pepperoni-1/2 green pepper, banana pepper, black olives. 12" Cheese, Club salad with Italian dressing. - Pizza Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Very good pizza! Best pizza of my life? No. Will I be back? Absolutely! Order was ready quick and On time and done correctly. Definitely one of the best options in the area, especially if you're looking to avoid the typical chain pizza places! read more

See all

Literally the best pizza I have ever had. Reminds me of a small pizza joint from when I was a kid. And it's not just the pizza, the wings and subs are great too. If your thinking about it just get it. read more

Hands down best pizza in southport/greenwood area. Thin or hand tossed crust are both f*****g amazing!! Been there 100 times and never been disappointed. Delivery is always on point as well. read more

So delicious and friendly delivery drivers. On point every time!! I always get extra sauce bc I like it saucy!! This is a heavy pizza I mean they load it up. Thanks for being my number one pizza place for take out!!! read more

Super yummy pizza! No skimping on toppings here and a very large cheese layer on top. Crust has a sweet flavor to it, my dog loves getting this pizza crust treat. Holds up well for delivery and rehearing. I have yet to be disappointed in a pizza from this place. read more

Really good!...I will be going back! First time I ever tried Gallagher pizza,...I liked it and so did everyone at the party I took it too!

I can't rave enough about this pizza joint. For years growing up in my hometown we had a pizza place that had pizza unlike any other. Crispy outside soft fluffy inside medium depth crust with cheese over all the toppings. You might feel robbed until you grab a slice and see just how many toppings cascade out from under the blankets of mozzarella. This practice causes the toppings to remain moist and tender. No more charred and dried out pepperonis for me. The closest you will find like this in Indy that I have seen are The Willard in Franklin and this gem, Gallagher's. Well worth the cost, the pizza is delicious. I go with sausage, onion and mushroom and it's delectable. Their sandwiches are pretty good too. The Stromboli was tasty and filling. The customer service felt personal and they answered my questions concisely. Delivery seems pretty quick too compared to other places with hour wait times. All in all, this is my new go to pizza joint. Update: I timed my delivery this evening (a Friday and I ordered exactly at 5 pm). From the time I got off the phone, it was 38 minutes until my doorbell rang with tasty pizza. It's an 8 minute drive to my house. read more

Great pizza at a great cost! Large with 5 toppings for $22, not bad! The crust is also really good, not too hard and not too doughy. Happy to support small/local businesses! read more

This is a great place for pizza in the Center Grove/Perry Township area. While the pizza price may be higher than others, you will see that this is a heavy pizza that is loaded with toppings. Pickup was quick and delivery is also offered. read more

Good pizza that even my picky family likes. This is a pizza place that does the pepperoni under the cheese and it is different but not worth giving a bad review over. The crumbled sausage is good, breadsticks are great too. As always, you've got to try the kitchen sink pizza - very good! read more

This pizza is one of the better hidden treasures on the south side. Might be the one of the best pizzas I've ever had. They used to have multiple locations but they all closed...except one. Get this pizza...it is not joking around! read more

Called them for delivery 10 minutes before closing. They delivered a great pie with a smile. The pizza is consistently good!

I love this place, I order once a week because the thin crust pizza ( I order the works with the chunk sausage) is Fantastic! Gregg the manager on night shift is awesome! I ordered a pizza with a salad and ask for extra and additional toppings ( additional is only .50 and it comes stacked. Great food and great customer service I am so happy I found this place, I won't order from anywhere else because they take care of me! Thank you read more

Really good pizza and breadsticks. A little too much topping for me, but a lot of people would enjoy that. The breadsticks are so good. Reasonably priced for what was ordered- 10 breadsticks, 4 sauces, and a large 3 topping pizza for $27. Not bad! Give them a try. Sad that they moved locations from Southport! read more