We order and pick up food from the Stop 11 and Arlington location all the time and never have issues. Today I had a pizza sent from this location via DoorDash to my daughter. She had limited time as she had to leave for work. The ETA was 15-31 minutes. It took 50 minutes for the pizza to arrive and when she sent me a picture of the pizza, I couldn't believe what I spent $35 on! It was burned and inedible. I find it unbelievable that someone put this pizza in the box and said "Yep! That looks great!" So my daughter went to work without dinner because she was out of time and couldn't wait for another order to be delivered. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Burned BBQ Chicken Pizza (Deep Dish) - Pizza Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Good pizzas & cheese bread. Great place for carry out pizza. Good pizzas & cheese bread. Great place for carry out pizza. read more

My family and friends were in on Saturday February 14, 26 and had an awful experience. I called 2 weekends in a row and to confirm our reservations due to a large party of 30 - upon arrival the staff and room was not ready. During the 2 hour wait for food, we were not offered refills or checked on. When I asked for refills, I was told to get my own refills, so I took care of the party's refills instead of enjoying visiting. At the 2 hour mark I went to the counter to check on the order and girl at the register did not know I had walked up and I heard talking to someone and said, I am sick of taking care of these people, we heard staff cussing, and to finish our visit I had to get my own to-go boxes (that are not accessible to customers) read more

Unbelievable lunch buffet. 15+ pizzas to choose from. Salads & drink included with buffet. $13. Friendly staff. Friendly Cute guy "Maddux" working front & taking care of drink station. 1 young lady constantly cleaning & friendly!!! Came around several times to make sure I was finished with the buffet. Definitely caring about there customers!! read more

Chicagos is our go-to place for pizza and breadsticks (with nacho cheese) We usually go to the Bargersville one or 31 location. Love the traditional crust AND the thin crust. read more

Well, Chicago's Pizza, is delicious. I love the service, the food, and just the whole feel. I service is always fast and always great. The salad bar is always fresh. I know dinner is going to be good when I am going to Chicago's pizza. I would recommend to all my family and friends. Pretty great!! ;) read more

Great food and service! The staff were very accommodating and pleasant! We will definitely return!!

Pizza good as well as salad bar at lunch buffet. Very clean dining room. Only disappointment is their change from Pepsi products to Coke products. read more

We ordered online our pizza, told us it would be ready by 5:55. Drove all the way there after getting text that it was ready as we were on a time crunch. Got there, they forgot to write it down. Nick the owner offhandedly apologizes but offers no sincere apology or even a discount for the travel there and inconvenience. Very rude. Update: spoke to a female manager this morning and found they will not refund me as I ordered online. She said I had to go through Doordash even though this was us pick up order by us. Can you believe this? read more

Just about every Friday order same thing it's always awesome pepperoni bread sticks to die for my family and friends we will always come back read more

Atmosphere is very good, place is clean. Pizza the only problem is, is the dough is never done enough. They don't make thin crust pizzas on their Pizza bar. Disappointing on that part. The salad bar is clean and stocked well. I would have gave five stars, if it wasn't for the dough of the pizza. read more

Great place, great service, great food, management, and the staff there are very friendly and welcoming have been there many times highly recommended read more

Best.Pizza.Buffet! I just wish they had it at dinner time or the weekend too. You can make a salad to go anytime for less than $5.00. Sooooooo good! read more

Decent pizza I get gift cards through my work. The servers/cashiers are all very kind ladies. Welcoming atmosphere,

THIS IS MY FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE IN INDIANAPOLIS. it's perfect. Not too greasy. Lots of cheese. Just enough sauce - not too much that I get heartburn but not dry either. I always get the pepperoni pizza and am very happy. Their breadsticks are simple but buttered and tasty, so go for it. They have a lunch buffet but make sure you get there with an hour to spare or else you get stuck with older pizzas. The service is always friendly. Plus it is right next to an ice cream place so there is dessert! Anyways, I like this place much better than Pizzaology in Mass Ave, Bazbeux, Napolese, Jockamos, etc. I even like it better than Brozinnis (although that is quite good as well); although their knuckles are better breadsticks. read more

Always hot and fresh pizza on the buffet! Nice salad options also! $11.00 is a great price nowadays.

We have been exploring other pizza joints of the last year or so... today we wanted an oldie but goodie and stopped in and had 1/2 pep/sausage and 1/2 pep/pineapple... and of course breadsticks! We realized how yummy it was! Definitely better than that other pizza place with "chicago" in their name. read more

I love Chicago's Pizza, no matter the location. If you like a deep dish pizza this is your place. The Pepperoni sticks are amazing here as well! It was very clean and our server did great! Come thru the week for buffet I want to say between 11:30-1:00( its there lunch special). We went on a weekend and they do not do the buffet during the weekend. read more

Prices are getting outrageous! Not worth 11.00 for the buffet. Increasing prices without customer enhancements has lost my business. Your shareholders aren't just your employees! Closed on a Sundays, close early, all while increasing prices. Since when do you accommodate your employees instead of your customers? read more

Still loving this location! We went in for some pizza and breadsticks on Saturday. Waitress was friendly and kind. She made an error on sauces for the breadsticks and just gave us an extra on the house - perfect customer service! My only complaint was the pizza was a little slow to come out considering there was barely anyone in the restuarant. read more

A very well priced pizza buffet with many options and plenty of seating. You can get the buffet and a drink for $8.50. The pizza was fresh and hot, and they will make specific pies if you ask. In addition to the pepperoni and sausage standards, they had a barbecue chicken pizza and a HEAVENLY buffalo chicken pizza. They have breadsticks with cheese and marinara dipping sauces. The salad bar has lots of options both for dressings and toppings. If I could change two things it would be to offer spring mix or romaine instead of iceberg and to offer Caesar dressing. Despite having a lot of customers, the restaurant was clean and the drink station was never dirty. My biggest complaint about this place? That they aren't closer to my house! Feel free to open another location on West 86th Street! read more

Pro tip from a pro of pros here. Only dine here Monday through Friday on lunch hours. "Why?" You ask. Let me tell you why. Because you will experience one of the top pizza lunch buffets that you've ever had. All the pizza, salad, and breadsticks one can handle. The girlfriend gets so jealous when I come here without her. She gets so jealous that sometimes I keep it a secret, so I don't go home to all my clothes in the front yard. This is a testimate to how could this place is because she's not a throw your clothes in the yard kind of girlfriend. read more

So we decide to eat in......I guess that was the first mistake. The sign said seat yourself....So we tried. We walked around and round and round. There were tables, but all of them were dirty. So we go back to the front to let someone know, and everyone looks confused. So finally a young lady comes up and she said (very snarky) " I guess we gotta find a busser since servers cant seem to bus the tables". Which wouldn't have bothered me, but it seemed directed at me in some way. Finally.....We got a table which they cleaned the dishes off of but left dirty, so we started to clean it ourselves. Low and BEHOLD!!! Here comes our waiter to bus the table (after our wipe down.) Mind you.......he leaves the seats dirty. When he sees us attempt to clean that off, he leans in with a devilish grin and says, " I can help if you want". ........ No! The food was good. Cleanliness was 0, at least on that day. I say go there for good pizza, but bring a cloth and some spray cleaner with you.(Just in case) read more

Amazing pizza and crew running it. My favorite place to grab a pitcher of beer and a deep dish.

If you love pizza you have to eat here. They have any pizza you could imagine deep dish, bbq chicken and even buffalo chicken. But the best thing is the buffet its simply great. I could eat this every single day, i highly recommend it. read more

Chicago’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

See all

Above average pizza. They offer an acceptable variety of pizza choices. It's always nice that they put out a few dessert pizzas. The salad bar is ample enough as far as salad/lettuce varieties, pasta and potato salad, and a number of topping choices. The salad dressings are decent as well. They have a no frills very informal dining room area. That's quite alright with me, and I can always overlook that as long as it's clean and the food is good. The staff seem efficient and friendly; and are continuously working toward keeping the pizza stocked/presented and available. If I am in the mood for pizza at lunchtime - buffet, I usually frequent this pizza place. You get in and out of there with no problem. It's an overall good value price wise too. read more

We have eaten here quite a few times over my summer break. We usually eat the lunch buffet. There is pizza, breadsticks and a great salad bar. It's a great deal for a quick lunch. We have also eaten dinner recently. The service was great so was the food. Great value for the money. read more

Highly recommend the lunch buffet- it's my favorite way to eat their pizza. There are so many choices, and the salad bar is really fresh too. read more

Garlic bread was horribly salty, a total waste...deep dish pizzaa was just okay. Overall not a very great experience...

Pizza is so good. We've had the same server the past few times we have visited and she is great!

My sister was in town and I took her to Chicago Pizza. She loved it! Even though it was their only veggie option. The pizza was pretty darn good. It's right by 31 and very conveniently located. The service was pretty good. The restaurant has good ambience. Definitely going back!! read more

Twice I've ordered delivery through DoorDash for this Chicago Pizza location and both times I only got part of my order. The first time I called the store they told me I had to go through DoorDash for a refund, not their fault and my order was probably taken by my driver. Well, you do not actually get a refund for food you do not receive, only a DoorDash credit. Let it go, order again from Chicagos and again I'm missing part of my order I paid for. Called the store again but spoke to the manager this time. She was quite rude and again began to state that it's not their fault, they are not responsible for not filling their orders and again told me the DoorDash driver probably stole my food which is just ridiculous. I told her I had an issue with not getting my food before from another restaurant and they brought me the correct meal. She said we don't deliver and I told her neither do they. In the end, I've paid them twice for food that Chicago Pizza did not deliver and no refund. Will never order there again, their management team is rude and only care about making a profit by stealing from their customers. Horrible restaurant. read more

Our server was great and the pizza was really good. We ordered Chicago style deep dish meat lovers pizza. We got a thick crust pizza with very little sauce. I asked the cashier about this "Chicago style" and she said that was the way they make them, so basically it was just a thick crust pizza that was very good. I'll look elsewhere for Chicago style. read more

This place is awesome. Fun background music, great pizza and breadsticks. Decent beer selection. It is our family's favorite place to go for pizza. Been around for a really long time. Fresh, simple, tasty pizza. They really do have the best breadsticks in the world. Friendly staff. Clean restaurant too. read more

This place is great for a quick trip through the lunch buffet. The only drawback being during peak lunchtime there is often a wait on fresh pizzas as the demand is higher than what can be put out. The wait is generally minimal and if you request a certaIn pizza they will make it and put it on the buffet for you to share with the other customer. This would be a 5 star review if i didn't experience a wait more times than not. read more