Neighborhood pizza parlors are supposed to be welcoming and accepting, with the nostalgic feelings of a fun place to grab a slice. However, that was not our experience today. My sister was accidentally given the wrong pizza at pick up. She called to inform them and offered to come get the correct one because we don't live far. The young lady on the phone was disrespectful and raised her voice repeatedly. On the top of that, the owner was notified and he did not adequately address the issue and allowed the employee to resume disrespectful comments in his presence. Other customers were in the restaurant and when the situation unnecessarily escalated, there was no move to make my sister, the customer, feel safe and heard. When my sister left the establishment she said she wouldn't be back. The parting comments were "I hope you don't." This interaction seemed to have heavy undertones of racism and classism. My sister was accused of wanting to get free food and was blatantly disrespected in the presence of others, by the child answering phones. People of color, this establishment is not safe for us. Please do your best to take care of yourself and your family in regard to this restaurant. Buying dinner for your family should not turn into an emotionally abusive situation, that resulted in a lost customer. read more

Very polite delivery driver. Sausage rolls are my highlight go to at gallery. I placed the order online and they call to tell me they were out of something but then made an extra batch. I was pleased with it. Cash is King (discounts for cash) read more

See all

Gallery has food that people need. They've been nothing short of a godsend this summer with TV room and Kitchen torn out and completely remodeled. We've come here and always left with full stomachs and better kinship with each other. Great, consistent food and service always. read more

See all

After a long day, I ordered the grandma's pie, which is so delicious. The young man, Carmen, came without the right change. He was willing to take a hit with no tip. I told him I'd drop it off tomorrow, but didn't feel right doing that. He was so polite. He ran back to the store, then my house to deliver the right change. I love it when you come across kind and efficient people. Thank you Carmen read more

We were at a local brewery and decided to place a delivery order at Gallery. I've also heard from multiple people that Gallery is a very place to order pizza from. We placed an order for a chicken parm sandwich, fries, and a margherita pizza. We were told it would be 50 minute wait for delivery (which is expected for a Friday night around 7 with not so great weather). We called back 5 minutes later and asked if we'd be able to pick up and if it would knock any time off of our wait. Gallery was very accommodating as they had no issues changing our order to pick up and advised it would be ready in 10 minutes. We had a very pleasant experience customer service wise which is always very important. However, next time we order we'll stick to plan pies or Sicilian. The chicken parm sandwich wasn't great. It reminded me of something you'd get out of a school cafeteria. It's hard to judge the fries fairly because they were in a plastic container which could've led to them getting soggy. The pizza was very floppy and the crust wasn't crispy. Lots of tasty sauce on the margherita pie. The regular pies I've gotten from here in the past though were better than the margherita pie this visit. read more

See all

I'm a big fan of great cheesteaks and I've had a few of SJ greatest..Chick's deli,Carmen,Franachellos,King of Pizza, Yellow Submarine,and People's pizza to name a few( Donkeys is a steak sandwich in it's own category but still a top sandwich). But when it comes to me ordering a cheesesteak with extra fried onions ,cheese and ketchup it's kinda hard to mess up,but it happens. GALLERY adds extra onions small chopped not big and chunky like most places and for the price and size it hits the mark. Only had twice, but consistency is everything. Keep up the good work and I'll definitely be ordering again and I'm looking to trying a large pizza with sausage,pepperoni and jalapenos well done soon. read more

Veal might be pork. Service can improve, especially their manners. They have a Hispanic chick behind the counter that apparently doesn't know the meaning of the word "only" and will argue with you about it. Too many pizzerias in this area to deal with this nonsense. read more

What happened to this place, it use to have best Pizza around. We spent so much money eating here. I'm not sure if they got new ownership. Or they are hiring DEI overseas cooks? I stopped buying first panzerotti' because basically it was a giant piece of dough with all cheese in middle nothing on ends. It was dry with no gravy at all in it. Now I just got a pizza which reminds me of something that a group of grade schoolers made in cooking class...i do not like writing negative reviews. But my latest dry pizza with absolutely no flavor no spices no gravy I threw out the door for wild animals. I thought maybe i was being punked. The quality of the food tells me that they are hiring new cooks with no cooking experience or sold to New owner??? 1 Star is being generous. I doubt wild animals will eat it. read more

Workers talk at you instead of to you! Not a welcoming atmosphere for a place that's so overpriced

I'm so disappointed. I loved this place but the past couple times we've ordered have been upsetting. I found a rock in my chicken sandwich yesterday and really that's the last straw. I'm not sure how the rock got in my food. Wondering if the sandwich fell on the floor and they still served it. I'll be ordering from other restaurants from now on. read more

Gallery Pizza - A rock in my chicken sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

The worst pizza I've ever eaten aside from skating rink garbage. We ordered a Margherita pizza. The dough was severely undercooked. There was so much water?? Build up on top of the pizza.. I'm not sure if it was from the ton of fresh tomatoes they have on top or the crappy "fresh" mozzarella they used but it was absolutely inedible. My 16 year old bit into it and the dough PULLED. Being underdone was the icing on the cake. Mind you, it was all raw dough taste... Restaurant refused a refund. Surprise surprise. Ice heard horror stories about their customer service. I was appalled. We have been in Atco almost 2 years and this was the first time we ordered. Other families did far warn us to stay away, but, we decided to give them a try. Nope. Do your self a favor and take yourself to joes in Berlin.. you'll never be disappointed with any of their pies. read more

Great pizza, delicious eggplant parm, wings to munch on all day & night, was happy to learn about this place. Friendly & safe service, very organized, worth the drive from Hammonton. We look forward to getting a Sicilian tomato pie for the vegan husband. read more

They have reopened and not sure why. I will say the food is good. But, you will be treated like slime during pickup/purchase. The girl in the spacesuit for the ridiculous one wobbly table curbside pickup is scared to death to be there. I could go on but won't. Just don't go, unless you enjoy true disorganization and being eyed as a hazard. read more

We moved to Atco from the outside of Philadelphia area, this is the only good pizzeria. The margarita pie is amazing!! The chicken fingers and fries are great! The always have dessert which is awesome! The only issue is there is no delivery so I always have to get my lazy butt up and drive there read more

Great food best pizza in the area and great service . There Sicilian pizza is the best!! And the place looks great

I went here once and have never been back. Why? Because: (I) the service was awful. I called to order carryout and the lady who answered had the nastiest attitude ever. Her attitude was not any better in person. (II) we ordered 2 different types of pizza and both were just meh. Not worth it. read more

Best chicken parm sandwiches. The reason for the four star is because the bathroom is God awful. They really need to remodel and fix up the bathroom. Food is good though. I suggest take out and not dining. read more

Gallery Pizza - Best chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

What happened? Was looking forward to a good pizza from Gallery on Thanksgiving Eve upon returning to Atco where I grew up. What a disappointment! Shared a large mushroom/onion pizza. The sauce was flavorless and sparse. The mushrooms were canned (tasted like that at least). Also, the crust was dry and tough. I'm hoping this pizza was a fluke because Gallery has always made a quality pizza. read more

The place must have changed owners. My family and I have not eaten there in a bit and it was all new faces. The food was mediocre at best. We ordered a buffalo chicken pizza that had like one piece of chicken per slice. The pepperoni pizza wasn't cooked all the way even though the bottom was black. Their ovens must be too high. Won't be going back. read more

they just said they close in 10 minutes and I can't order... why be open if you can't order I don't understand.

Absolutely hands down the BEST pizza I've ever had in my entire life. Their ranchero pizza with fried chicken is to die for. Everything here is so good you cannot go wrong. I would choose this place for pizza over anywhere else in the country. I am from the west coast and when I move back I am going to miss this place so bad. read more

This has been an Atco favorite for many years! They have some of the best pizzas around. You have to try the Sicilian pizza. The crust is thick and has the perfect crunchiness. The pizza sauce is authentic and the cheese is of a high standard. You seat yourself and there is no formal arrangement, which you wouldn't expect at a pizzeria. Service is friendly and satisfactory. The inside is decorated in a rustic, terracotta fashion with the old school/classic booths and tables. Be sure to save room for dessert. They have fried pastries filled with nutella. This is a delicious way to conclude your meal and trust me...you will want more than one! read more

We just had Gallery Pizza for the first time tonight, and we weren't disappointed. We ordered the Ranchero Pizza in a Sicilian pie with fried chicken instead of grilled and it was amazing! The crust was perfect and plenty of bacon, ranch, and chicken. We'll be ordering from Gallery more often! read more

Gallery Pizza - Sicilian Ranchero Pizza. Amazing and huge - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

One of my favorite places to order authentic Italian food, LIZ took our order great customer service , my favorite was the sweet potato fries , I highly recommend going there for local flavor read more

Love me some Gallery Pizza. Great cheese steaks, good pizza and the sicilian pizza on Sundays is amazing. The only reason I didn't give five stars is that they don't deliver. read more

Best pizza in Atco. I'd give them five if the crust were a little thinner. Their cheese doesn't taste fake.

Best pizza in Atco. Don't bother going anywhere else, unless you want it delivered. Then you have to go somewhere else because they don't do it. read more

Great cheesesteaks,great pizza,and the best hot peppers in town! And best of all they always get your order right!

Been going here for 25 years and they are still consistently the best. Best Sicilian pizza in town! Keep doin what you're doin!

The pizza is good. Very good. Service is friendly and nice. As for the "meatball parmigiana" sandwich- well, it was desperately missing a meatball! Tasted ok but it really was in need of another meatball. It was more like toasted bread with tomato sauce and cheese than anything......good if you're in a hurry and aren't in a picky mood! read more

The pizza is amazing! As well as the cheesesteaks, the wings and fries! Food is good! The only thing bad is the service. The girls (which always seem to be the same ones) always seem to have an attitude. They don't make you feel welcomed. I had ate in and I had to get up and grab my food instead of her having to bring it to me. They could provide better service and make you feel welcomed read more

We used to go here all the time. In fact, at one point, we would "ONLY" go here, and we'd tell our friends to do the same. Although the service was always substandard, we would choose this place for great take out pizza. Unfortunately, the food quality of late has dwindled over the years, and after a particular bad experience, we tried other places and discovered far better pizza places in this town. We all have a favorite pizza place, a favorite baker, or that favorite Asian take-out spot, but this place has a consistency issue, and it's never the same way twice. I wish they'd go back to making pizza the way they did before. We now go to two other local places that are much better. read more

I called to let them know that there was a cricket baked into in my pizza and I was not happy. I asked for another to be delivered, they told us they don't deliver. So I took it back and got a replacement, which was checked to make sure there wasn't any extra toppings on it. While there I asked to talk to the owner who never apologized and only after I asked, reluctanly refunded my money. Needless to say, I will NEVER go there again and highly recommend that no one else does. TERRIBLE!!! read more

Literally addicted to their sicilian pizza, obsessed with their garlic knots . It's in the top 3 reasons I moved back to the East Coast !!!

NEVER, EVER AGAIN!!! I called in an order for a pick up at this establishment this evening. The gentleman that answered the phone spoke English very well but clearly did not understand many things that I said to him. Upon my arrival to pick up our food I noticed the gentleman that was running the establishment whether a manager or an owner was trying to hurry his employees in the kitchen and at the counter. When I got home it turned out that my onion rings were missing from my order. So I turned right around and went back and asked where my onion rings were? They said you did not have onion rings on your order ticket. That's okay well I did tell the guy on the phone that I wanted them. The gentleman running the establishment asked if I wanted to wait so they could make them for me. I said no thank you that's okay. Upon my arrival home again I realized that my calzone was not made the way I asked them to make it and it was also missing a very key ingredient in a calzone: ricotta cheese. I told the gentleman on the phone that I didn't want ham I wanted pepperoni instead and I didn't want sauce on my calzone. They gave me pepperoni yes but, they also gave me sauce and left out my ricotta cheese. So I went back to Gallery Pizza and told them it wasn't made the way I asked and that's not what I paid for and I wanted my money back. So I got my money back when out to my car and I called Sally Starr's pizza and placed my order for my properly made calzone and my onion rings. read more