Review Visit: April 18th, 2016 This place definitely garners the attention it deserves. On one of my many trips (with a friend that didn't like being in photos), we stopped for pizza at the recommendation of many people we knew. We walked in on a sunny afternoon with empty bellies and high expectations. We were greeted by a friendly staff and a post-lunch winding down of the restaurant. There were a handful of employees who stopped in for a bite to eat but they all were wrapping up to go back to work. We were seated at a table and given menus and some waters. My friend and I have similar taste buds, so we quickly settled on the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. If memory serves me right, I got my half of the pizza with jalapenos. I do love me a bit of a kick to my food. With the lunch rush past us, we got great service as we were really the only ones in there after about 10 minutes. Our waitress was prompt with everything and just great. It wasn't long before our pizza was brought out to us and boy did it look good. It's not stranger on this blog that I love pizza and Garner's was great. Each bite was full of flavor and each slice being exactly what our bellies needed before we started exploring Bloomington. About the only complaint I would have is that Garner's is in a weird location. It seems to be a newly-built area and I am not entirely too familiar with Morton but it seems to be in a weird location. When my GPS was taking us here, I had doubts the address was correct... but I am glad that I was proven wrong. Garner's was worth the hesitation while driving there. read more

Garner's Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Morton, Illinois

See all

Their italian beef sandwich and bone-in wings were delicious tonight! The delivery was so fast that nothing got cold even though it's only 23 degrees and very windy tonight. They paid attention to all my requested changes and got everything right! I ordered online but forgot to ask for the aujus on the side. I called the restaurant and they were happy to accommodate my request. This Morton restaurant is a new favorite! read more

Absolutely delicious pizza, tasty wings, and friendly service. A new favorite. The Family special was perfect for four people. read more

Love the wings. Pizza is ok too but not my personal favorite. It is a locally owned business so prices are a little high but nothing crazy. My service has always been good. read more

Garner's Pizza & Wings - Mild wings - Pizza Near Me - Morton, Illinois

See all

Prices are not correct on the website. Be ready to pay a lot more. A $28 pizza is now $38 And they will not honor the wrong advertised price. read more

it's 8/10/25 aside from having to sit and wait 30 mins past my order pick up time, the two sandwiches I ordered had bottom buns that were harder than the hubs of hell and cheese on them that didn't melt, just burnt around the 4 corners, and they were practically inedible, it's inexcusable to serve a sandwich which would force someone to take the meat off and take away the concept of a 12 dollar sandwich, a supreme pizza which had little to no sausage and a mound of onions, 100 dollar order and the only good thing would be the fries. I'm struggling to understand how this could've happened when they had a extra 30 mins to perfect the order, there was also only one couple in their eatting so it's not like it was a full house where mistakes could have a higher probability of happening. read more

Solid pie good flavor the wings were pretty good ! All thou it looks like the pie went up in too wheels a few times when it got to hotel but other than that it was all good read more

Garner's Pizza & Wings - Bbq Wings - Pizza Near Me - Morton, Illinois

See all

Good neighborhood pizza restaurant! This location is tucked in a corner of a strip mall. We ordered dinner for carry out. We ordered a medium thin crust pepperoni pizza, chef salad with chicken and French dressing, 2 orders of fresh cut fries, and an order of toasted ravioli with 2 marinara sauces. They unfortunately forgot our extra marinara. The pizza was crispy with a good amount of tasty pepperonis. This is good pizza. The toasted ravioli were good with marinara. The chef salad was ice berg lettuce with tomato pieces, purple cabbage, shredded cheese and a good amount of chicken pieces. The French dressing is served in marzetti brand honey French packets. The game changer here is the fresh cut fries. The fries are fantastic! We will be back ! read more

See all

Staff is friendly an be helpful. We ordered wings and a couple of appetizers. Everything came out golden brown and delicious. Casual, laid back counter service with no rush. We'll come back when we're in town again. read more

Nice place and settings a bit noisy but other then that place is friendly staff and good food

Just tried this place for the first time it was good staff was friendly the only thing that was kinda off set is a little to noisy for some people especially if they have issues with loud noises I know it can't be avoided but all other than that the food was decent and wouldn't mind ordering again read more

Very consistent wings and pizza. Best wings in Morton, hands down. I like the thin crust pizza. My wife loves the Chicago style. I will say the tomato sauce is one of the best I have ever had on the deep dish. We usually do take out and the food is always hot when we pick it up. Nice crew at the register, always friendly. read more

I have ordered from Garners on more than just a few occasions mainly because my husband like the wings. I have tried to be objective however, the boneless wings are disgusting. Hard chewy pieces and gross. The hand cut fries are so incredibly greasy. I would not recommend Garners at all. read more

Pizza and wings are always amazing! Service is good as well! This place has the best wings in town and pizza!

Great wings, pizza pretty good too. That's all I've had there but I hear they have great sandwiches

Thin crust pizza is amazing. People that work there are wonderful. I ordered for pickup during closing and they were nice enough to let me. Pizza was not rushed and had a perfect crispness to it. Thank you. The interior is nice enough to dine in as well. read more

We ordered the Basic Pizza & Wing Combo (14 in & a lb of wings) and Garden Salad to go. Supreme pizza was tasteless, bottom was barely toasted. Wings were puny and mostly bone; garlic parm dry rub didn't have a lot of flavor. Garden salad was basic iceberg. If you want meaty, flavorful wings, run to Rumberger's. read more

Garner's Pizza & Wings - supreme pizza (thin crust), garlic parmesan & teriyaki wings, garden salad - Pizza Near Me - Morton, Illinois

I used to like this place but it's not what it used to be. Pizza is just average. Wings are rubbery. Staff is okay. I can get better pizza across the street at Casey's. read more

We love this place! Hand tossed crust is so good! We love the wings and salad too. Great for carry out

I really do like their pizza and wings - have done since they were in Peoria back in the 90s. But the last few times we've ordered carryout, the food was barely warm. Eat there and everything is as it should be. But sometimes you just want pizza in front of a movie at home, ya know? They really need to get there timing or "keep warm" capabilities or something sorted out. read more

Just got lunch to go, how do you mess up a meatball sub? Don't put enough sauce on it! Possibly the driest meatball sub I've ever had and to top that off they don't dress the sandwich the way you want it they put all extras on the side. The fries are both over done but then soggy because of the Togo container condensation. They might be good for dine in but I'll go somewhere else for to go. read more

We stopped here today for a pit stop on a road trip, and the food was okay, decent wings and sandwiches. Very clean dining area in a small strip center. Might try a different spot in town if we were to pass through again. read more

Amazing service!!! The fries and BBQ sauce were to die for and the vibes were great!!!!

I've been here a couple of times, and the thin crust pizza (cheese and extra sausage) is absolutely excellent. The crust, in particular, is perfectly executed. Why would anyone opt for a national chain when local alternatives like Garner's are so much better? read more

Garner's Pizza & Wings - Thin crust pizza with cheese and extra sausage: excellent! - Pizza Near Me - Morton, Illinois

This is a very underrated restaurant in morton. Both the pizza and wings are mighty tasty. They really do quench my hunger after a days hard work. Other than the workers being slightly socially awkward, this is an amazing option in morton. read more

WOW is all i can say. This pizza restaurant is one of the best ive ever been to. My first time in America i stopped at Garners pizza and wings and i was greeted to a friendly smile and a warm welcome to a beautiful restaurant by Chloe I believe, we ordered a Basic Pizza and wing combo/ The wings were tender and delicious. When they were brought to me and my son ,in such speed i may add, they sparkled as bright as the day My lord Jesus was born. The wings were so tender and the crispiness on the wings was mouth watering(Much better than we get down in Enlgand) And dont even get me started on the pizza! The thin crust had such a delicious and heavenly taste to it. The crust was Crispy and the cheese was stringy and the tomato base sauce was to die for!! I think id travel all the way to America just to try it again YUMM! Would definitely recommend to all. Overall Garners pizza and Wings have a beautiful and loving environment perfect for families and the food wont disappoint! Even though they cut their thin crust pizzas in squares? Never seen that before but still delicious!!! read more

Killer wings, I got the hot buffalo sauce which isn't all that hot, but everything was very good none the less. Oddly though they don't have celery for their wings???? That isn't acceptable! It's like cutting an important step? Thankfully, I had celery at home. The chicken wings were good sized along were cooked properly. They had plenty of sauce on them and the ranch came in large packets and they gave me 3 of them. It was Marzeti's brand ranch that is quite good. I highly recommend the buffalo wings. read more

I'll NEVER eat here again! Ordered 3 chicken strip meals and got 6 strips total. I then contacted the manager and was told it's all done by weight. I have been going to Garner's since they were in Peoria and order the same thing. I have NEVER had 2 strips that's a kids meal!!! I paid almost $29.00 for 3 kids meals!!!!! read more

Was at Garner's last night (2/28/2020) with a buddy of mine to try their pizza, my first. We had a thin crust meat-lovers and it was absolutely fantastic! One of the very best pizzas I've had in a while. The staff is always friendly and attentive and I appreciate that; the pizza - outstanding! Great job. read more

The pizza is amazing and then the flavors of the wings mummmmm good. The lunch specials are amazing !

We went for the first time Wednesday night and the traditional wings were awesome ! My husband really enjoyed his pizza too ! The young girl working the phone , tables & register was so friendly and really working hard ! Great dinner ! read more

This use to be my favorite pizza and wing place. There traditional wings are still very good. There pizza however after opening the new store isn't the same. I've had it several times and it always seems slightly undercooked and ingredients are not as good as they use to be. Idk if they changed the recipe or the new employees dont try as hard. read more

Ate here with a large group and they were very accommodating and friendly. Their Chicago pizza was great and their wings were good too. They sell beer by the pitcher. Plan on going back. read more

Best wings anywhere. I love the traditional wings with mild sauce. I told my family that for my last meal I want Garners:). The place is nothing special but it is clean and they always do their best to make you feel at home. So you if you are hungry and want an amazing lunch, order a number 1 with supreme pizza and mild wings. You will thank me for sending you:):) read more

Went there last night for the first time and was very happy that we did. Got 2 orders of the traditional wings with fries and a garden salad. Everything was great! The wings are tasty, the fries are the awesome, fresh cut ones, and the salad was fresh. Most importantly, is that all of the staff was compliant with Covid protection. Everyone was wearing a mask! (Wish I could say the same for the other customers, but ...). I'll definitely be back as I appreciate the efforts to keep everyone safe. read more

On our carry out order, we had a 16 inch pizza, 6 boneless wings, and 6 bone-in wings. The bone-in wings were cold and not crispy. My husband went up to get them replaced. Manager said "no." He said nothing was wrong with them. He refused to replace them. This manager doesn't represent "good customer service." We won't be getting food from here, anymore. Put a bad taste in our mouths. read more

I went for the lunch buffet, the food was great but it was obvious that they were having problems handling a busy crowd. They could not keep up with the food demand. I really like their food but I have been disappointed every time I go for the buffet. They are the highest priced buffet in town and can't or won't keep up with the demand of food on the buffet. Today there were several people already seated when I arrived at 12:10, I was behind 6 people waiting to pay and there were people coming in behind me. I would think that someone would notify the kitchen to put more pizzas in but they don't. There was plenty of pizza the first time I went up and not much to choose from the second time. Knowing there was nothing but two pieces of pizza that nobody wanted that was still sitting up there just drying out I decided to wait to see if they were going to bring more out. 10 minutes later nothing. I left. There are other choices in town that will keep up and charge less. read more

Some of the best wings you will ever eat in the entire state of Illinois! The fries are amazing too. Nothing super special about the pizza IMO, but it's good. My only complaint is that I wish I could eat there more often, but it's a little pricey, especially for a family of 5 who can eat a TON of chicken wings. read more

I've ordered from here several times, each time getting something new to try out. I imagine that takeout is much different than dine in, but the wings weren't all that great. They tasted like Tyson wings you could buy and cook at home. The pasta tasted old, and again, like I could have made it from a package at home. The Chicago style pizza was the best thing that I had, and it was absolutely delicious. The sauce isn't to spicy and isn't too sweet. read more

We ordered the Basic Pizza and Wing combo (14 in thick or thin crust and a lb of wings(8 wings)). We got a cheese pizza hand tossed with half hot wings and half honey BBQ. We also got two fountain drinks with our order. The order came to about $26 which seems to be about average for most restaurants around here for two people. The food was really good! Wings were very flavorful, meaty, and the pizza was really good too! If I had to nitpick, it would be that I would have rather had a homemade ranch for the pizza and wings, instead, they give you packets of room temperature ranch. That was the only "problem" there was, and that's not even an issue, just personal preference. Over all, we will definity be back! read more