Service was good, spaghetti with meat sauce did not disappoint, and dining out with friends went well for a party of nine.

Terrible service. We had party of 10 and we had told them 2 days ahead of time we'd be there at 6:30. They only had 1 waitress. We waited 60 minutes for our food and one order they totally forgot to put in. Not going back. read more

Great service ! Good pizza! Great sports bar vibes! My wife and I dined in for an early dinner on a Friday night! We saw this restaurant featured on "you gotta eat" on week nbc! Our waitress was wonderful! This was our first time here! We ordered a garlic cheese bread to start off our dining experience which was recommended by the waitress. We ordered a medium pizza with pineapple, pepperoni, sausage, onion, and green peppers with light cheese! Our waitress offered us a coupon with a purchase of a large you get a free cheese bread! We then upgraded from a medium to a large pizza! Great deal! The cheese bread was pretty good! The bread is thick and was a little dry! The cheese and garlic are delicious! The marinara is tasty for dipping. The pizza is really good! Thin crust with a crunch! The sausage is the way to go with small crumbles all over the pizza! We liked the toppings and wished we had more pineapple! My wife dipped her pizza in another side of marinara! We really liked the pizza and we will be back! This pizza is very similar to the old 3 fat guys pizza which was around in the early 2000s! The original owner of Mickie's was also a co owner of 3 fat guys! This pizza is pricey! Come with a coupon!!!! read more

Best bar and pizza in town! The bar setting is super cool, perfect lighting. Feels like a sports bar should feel. read more

Local pizza place. I had the pasta and my guest had a burger. Both were good, I will definitely try the pizza next time. read more

Mickie's Pizzeria - Ci - Pizza Near Me - East Peoria, Illinois

See all

great pizza..... been going here for years, my mom loved it and we had her 80th BP there. RIP mom, we still go!

East Peoria location (Yelp not allowing business address update): -Food 4 stars -Service 3.5 stars Trying to give them the benefit of the doubt since it was a Saturday evening. We were seated at a high top in the bar area which was less than half full when we arrived. It was full by the time we left. There were two bartenders (skinny guy with curly brown hair and blonde girl) and the hostess who floated in/out to clear tables. Ordered the hand cut fries as an appetizer which were OK. Our server, the blonde girl, warned they do not season fries. Yey for being fresh n hot, but they needed a few more minutes to drain as they were soggy from the extra oil. Entrees took at least 35-45 mins which is understandable for pizza. Bf got the Hawaiian pizza, and I had bone-in garlic Parmesan wings. Both were good and served at the correct temperature. Server didn't check on us after food arrived. We tried to catch her at least two times for a pop refill when she was taking orders at tables near us, but she would take off immediately. I had to ask for a refill at the bar = automatic 1 star deduction. Since food was good, I would try them again but get carry out or sit in the main dining room. read more

Mickie's Pizzeria - garlic parmesan wings - East Peoria location - Pizza Near Me - East Peoria, Illinois

See all

Rude and servers yelling at customer, Slow taking drink order(20min)to get your table, not any quicker ordering food , in the las week it took 2+ hr to get 1 order chicken wing. CAN'T FORGET OVER HEARING SERVER THREATEN A CUSTOMER, service very poor and slow WONT BE recommending this place read more

Usually great but last time the pizza was badly burned and today both orders of cheese bread the bottoms were burned. Check everything before you leave the restaurant! read more

During the covid19, Mickie's Pizzeria has made it clear that they are serious about keeping everyone safe. When you go in to pick up, they sanitize the pens to sign for your purchase. While my husband waited for our order, they wiped down the door w/ every customer. Now about the food, we have never had a bad meal! Love the pizza! read more

We stopped in for dinner last night, and got the Mediterranean chicken pizza, fried mushrooms and Buffalo chicken sandwich. It was all delicious. We sat at the bar and the bartender was great. I also had Desthils peanut butter porter. It was so good, and they had a large selection of different beers- not just the usual Miller lite etc. We left very full and can't wait to come back in the summer to hang out on the patio and see what beers rotate in. read more

One of the best pizzas in the Peoria area. We've tried most of them and Mickies does it right!

Really enjoyed our visit to Mickie's. Pizza was very good. Gluten-free crust option worked out well. Good beer selection and tv situation. Definitely headed back next time we are in town. read more

Clean restaurant and bar. Prices.... little above board. Service very good. Value for food and getting my order correct...... Not sure whos fault. I asked the waitress if the tenderloin was really a tenderloin or a little fritter. She claimed it was a tenderloin just not the super large kind. They pound out themselves. Well..... FRITTER!!!! Cause if this was pounded out.... it would have disappeared. Asked for LTPO on sandwich.... 3 out of 4 ain't bad.... No tomato. Asked for a bowl of chilli with my order. It was all to go. Asked me if I want cheese and onion. I said no. I also read the chips were supposed to have a cheese sauce. Did not get that. Lesson..... No matter how nice your server is. No matter how slow the place is at the time..... If you place an order to go and are there. OPEN IT UP and check it out. I would have requested a refund and left them with the order. Oh.... The chilli.... A glop of chilli. It was so thick, it looks like a complete solid. A thick patty of chilli. So, I spent 32.00 in there with 2 beer while waiting. I will not be returning. read more

Easily one of the best restaurants in East Peoria. Pizza always comes out perfectly no matter which one, the crust is always perfectly crispy. From taco to pepperoni or even just plain cheese I've yet to have a bad pizza here. Staff is kind and attentive. Mickies has some of the best bone-in wings I have ever had in my life. Fries are always cooked to perfection and never soggy. Wide selection of soft drinks from the fountain or bottles in the fridge. Atmosphere is inviting and spacious. Definitely one of my favorite restaurants. read more

All the food was good, and I'm very picky about pizza. We started with breaded mushrooms and cheesy garlic bread. Both were ample portions, piping hot, and delicious. Next we ordered a few wings, bone in. I probably would not get them again but hubby liked them. Also tried a bowl of chili - excellent. It was thick and rich, and well seasoned yet on the mild side. Finally, pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom pizza. Not a darn thing wrong with it. Crisp crust, slightly spicy sauce, plenty of toppings. Service was a little slow. We weren't in a hurry, so it wasn't a problem. It's a leisurely meal. read more

Mickie's Pizzeria - Nice decor - Pizza Near Me - East Peoria, Illinois

I went there with high expectations but the Pizza was average. Service though was absolutely horrible. A family sitting next to us literally walked out because nobody took their order. I could give of how bad it was, but I'll never go back. read more

Solid plain old average restaurant. Not bad, but nothing stands out. We tried pizza and boneless wings with salads. All were fine. Nothing to complain about, but disappointed that a non-chain pizza joint didn't shine out as something special. Service was just ok. A little slow, but not bad. I would go back, but just keep your expectations in check. read more

Mickie's Pizzeria is a great place for pizza in the Pekin area. We went here on a busy Friday night recently. I got the taco pizza, which was pretty good. My husband's veggie pizza was good as well. They are a couple dollars more than I would like, but not terrible. The service is good. Our waitress Nikki was super sweet and when the kitchen made our pizzas wrong, she had them remade for us at no charge. We ended up with lots of leftovers! read more

This place has really gone downhill in terms of service. The food is excellent, but when you wait 15 minutes to be seated in a near empty restaurant, and then still haven't had your drink order taken after sitting at the table another 5 minutes, no food is worth that. Such a shame my family really enjoys their pizza, but its only worth the price if your getting carry out. We won't be back. read more

Great pizza. Terrible service 6/12/19. Couldn't get my drink refilled . Waitress nowhere in site.

We ate at Mickies recently on a busy Saturday afternoon. The dining room was full, and service was a little slow but appropriately so for a packed dining room. The salads were not fresh, and appeared to have been in a cooler for a while. The pizza was good, but not awe inspiring. We will return because of the convenient location, but we don't crave the food. read more

Great pizza and always fast delivery service. This was one of our go to delivery spots during pandemic and we will continue supporting them. Price may seem a little high until you take the first bite. read more

We tried Mickies blindly, not knowing the area. We were not disappointed! Our waitress Cheryl, was very attentive. My had an order of mozzarella sticks, and then split a pizza. My daughter had pepperoni. I was intrigued by the sriracha sausage and got that with red onion and peppadew peppers, which I must say is a different yet excellent choice! I also liked the crisp crust. They had a nice selection of craft beers as well. We will be back next time we're in town. read more

Had heard good things about Mickie's Pizzeria, but had never made an effort to stop in. We were actually going to another pizza joint nearby that happened to be closed, so we decided to stop in for some pizza. We are glad we did! The pizza was outstanding and our waitress Jaclyn was awesome. I think I surprised her out of the gate with my smart ass comments, but she jumped right in and made it a entertaining evening. Back to the pizza, the crust was awesome with airy multi levels of crisp crust with generous toppings. We truly enjoyed the whole experience out on the patio on a beautiful evening. We will definitely be back and hope Jaclyn is there to wait on us -just don't tell her we said that! read more

This is one of our favorite pizza places in the area. Excellent cheese, our favorite is half "M" and half sausage. Worth checking out!

This is by far the best thin crust Pizza around. Not wasting inches of edgey dough, you can eat every inch. Waitress stated that they make their dough, meat, seasoning and their own sauce. This is a mom and POP locally owned restaurant and we will eat their every time we are in town. You have to try it out!!! read more

Owner extremely rude. I had my wedding rehearsal dinner here and purchased food practically all thru COVID. I refuse to spend a dime here ever again. hope she goes out of Business. you should be respectful to everyone you don't know who it is you are being rude to. read more

This was definitely my favorite restaurant in North Pekin. However, they CLOSED last year. They are in East Peoria. Bummer, but it's not that far to East Peoria. read more

Good pizza but a little pricey for what you get. We were the only people in the restaurant and it took us a while to be served. They had a decent selection of beers too read more

Mickie's treats you like family. They also happen to have the best pizza and food. Trust me, I've tried the whole menu. Honestly, can't go wrong. It's locally owned by people who truly care. If could give more than 5 stars I would. read more

Get the orders right. We ordered wings, a house salad, and a meatball sandwich. When the food came, they sent out a Italian beef sandwich, then actually asked weather I wanted that. I said no and didn't reorder as I didn't want everyone else done while I just got my food. There was nothing special about the food. Would not recommend. read more

Terrible. My boyfriend and I were the only two people in the place the entire time we were there and it took an hour and 15 min to get one pizza. We ended up having to ask them to just put it in a box before it ever got to our table. read more

The pizza was outstanding! I would recommend the Mediterranean chicken pizza. The house made buffalo sauce was just an added bonus. The only thing holding it back was the less than exceptional service. Mickeys is a must eat! read more

If I could give this a zero, I would. I could bore you with details from our poor experience, but instead I will share my take aways from tonight... 1- The owner is completely unprofessional and rude. She is willing to throw anyone under the bus in defense of "company protocol". 2- The owner doesn't value her employees. She blamed one of our usual waitresses (who we loved) for all of the mistakes made. I believe as an owner, you "own up" and take responsibility. 3- Losing customers is okay if it means not losing a couple bucks. We have driven from Bloomington to attend trivia night for 6 months with at least 4-6 people. The owner was willing to throw our business away over $4 and her pride. 4- All business owners should be required to take an etiquette course. The most appalling part of the situation was her walking away from our table in the middle of our conversation....to another customers table to talk about what had just happened. TALK ABOUT COMPLETE TRASH. 5- We LOVE our Mickie's trivia family (Keith and Stephanie), but no where near enough to patron this establishment again. read more

The pizza is awesome. The beer is inexpensive. The atmosphere is pretty good, too. Yep, I think that sums it up quite nicely. read more

They have such good pizza and I am from Chicago where pizza is king delicious and reasonable

Typically I love this place. And all the way up until 830pm today, I would tell you I was planning on coming back every Wednesday, like I have for the past 6 months. But after dealing with the owner, tonight, instead of our usual waitress (Stephanie who is awesome) I will truly have to reconsider ever going back. You see, typically my gf orders a gluten-free pizza, not by choice but due to allergies, and it usually runs at about $13.59 for it. But tonight, after receiving the bill it magically was $4 more, which left me wondering why. So we ask, and we were told our server, before, charged us not enough, due to pickles being a specialty item, and that this is the right price. And instead of fixing it for us, the customer, and saying that she would fix it this time and it would be charged accordingly for future visits, she decided to tell us that Stephanie is not a good server. You see, i had no problem paying the difference of our food, as I ate it and I will gladly own that responsibility. But when she tells us that Stephanie is not a good server and that she will be reprimanded, that didn't sit right. I'm not mad I didn't get my food for what I normally pay for it. I'm mad that I was treated like an idiot. After listening to her justification, she walked away as my girlfriend was responding to immediately go to another table where she proceeded to talk about us before our backs, as if we couldn't see her. We drive from Bloomington, practically every Wednesday for the trivia night, and what we thought was a good deal on pizza. This owner has effectively lost nearly $100 every Wednesday from me and my trivia team. I will be sharing this story and letting everyone know of this crappy experience. Keith (the trivia moderator), Stephanie (good waitress/bartender), the three guys with funny team names, we will see you later, maybe. They are willing and able to get over losing nearly $100 A Wednesday for the owner's pride. Long story short, at Mickie's- customers are rarely right. read more

This is a great place for pizza and for meeting family and friends. We "head for Mickie's" at least twice a month. We think it's the best pizza in the area. read more

I would never recommend this place after the experience I had.  I was excited about having the party I had booked there.  I had been spreading the word about her business.  Coming in with family and friends ahead of the party.  We always ordered something, food or drinks and played machines.  But apparently the owner can't handle talking to customers. Her and the staff.  I called and had questions yes, but so what. I am sorry if you cant handle talking to customers, and doing your jobs.  She was EXTREMELY rude to me the for the last time a week out from the party date.  I thought I am NOT about to give her the amount of business we were about to give her after that awful treatment.  She made me feel like we were a major inconvenience.  She was also rude to my family and friends.  Mind you one of my friends walking with a cane and can't walk well. They told her we needed to go around to the back bar side and sit at a high table.  They acted like we couldn't sit at the first table in, they told us those are for people apparently ordering more food.  Oh we ordered two sodas and an appetizer.  We both told them we are sorry but she can't walk that far.  So after those experiences, I decided to cancel my party there.  I drove back in person to politely tell them.  I said Im giving you the respect you did not give me.  So cancelling I am sorry.  Not because of me but the rude treatment I got here.  Then asked for my money back.  The mgr. told me the owner said no will not be giving me any of my 100.00 back.  I said wow, she could have made this right, but she chose not too.  So we will never be patronizing this business again. You just don't treat people like that.  I had witnesses too.  So it was not just me. read more