Gelato &amp; aMore

My girlfriend and I went to Social for happy hour and appetizers about a week ago and had an…read moreabsolutely wonderful time. We originally planned to stay for happy hour, but ended up spending nearly three hours there because we were enjoying ourselves so much. Social is one of those rare places that completely lives up to the hype. From the moment you walk downstairs, the atmosphere transports you to another era. The speakeasy vibe is authentic without feeling gimmicky, and every detail has clearly been thoughtfully designed. It's a super cool speakeasy with a warm, inviting interior that makes you want to settle in and stay awhile. We shared the charcuterie board, which was excellent, and enjoyed both the champagne and the bourbon. Everything was high quality and thoughtfully prepared. Ryan, our bartender, really made the experience special. He treated us exceptionally well, made us feel genuinely welcome, and provided outstanding service throughout the evening. What started as a plan to enjoy happy hour turned into one of the most enjoyable evenings we've had in a long time. It's the perfect place for a date night or simply a relaxing evening with exceptional food, outstanding cocktails, and an atmosphere that's second to none. We'll definitely be back now that we live here in Fort Collins. If you're looking for an unforgettable experience in Fort Collins, Social is an absolute must-visit. Highly recommended!

This is the place where homeowners with golden retrievers go to feel edgy. Sexy, classy night life…read morevibes amidst trashy college bars. I don't love cocktails and their food menu is sparse, but if you want to impress a date or treat yourself to tasteful drinking, it's a nice place. Sometimes if you sit at the bar, there are annoying strangers who ask you to explain your thoughts on America's involvement in Iran. My server made sure to back me and my friend up when he started to get defensive. Thank you brother, you are an ally to the lesbian community.

Beautiful bar

Salsa bruschetta goat cheese spread

See all

Berry White ($12.50) - strawberry-infused white port, silver rum, ginger cognac, fresh lime, grapefruit, tonic syrup, soda water

RARE Italian

3.9(445 reviews)

1.6 mi

•$$$

Order the pizza or the ravioli- you will thank me later! Lots of excellent wine choices as well!…read moreLovely ambiance at the outdoor tables.

We had a really nice dinner at RARE Italian! The restaurant has a great atmosphere, and I loved the…read morefun location in downtown Fort Collins. The hostess and our waitstaff were wonderful--friendly, welcoming, and attentive throughout the evening. The house-made bread brought to the table was a great touch, and the food was good overall. I just didn't love it quite as much as I expected to, especially given the restaurant's reputation. Still, it was an enjoyable experience with great service and ambiance, and I'm glad we tried it!

Good drinks. Better company. Even better nights. Here's to more of what we love in 2026 -- together at Rare Italian.

Meet the newest reason to order pasta: Black Truffle & Mushroom Ravioli. Local mushroom-stuffed pasta layered with lemon ri...

See all

A timeless Italian ritual, reimagined at RARE. Did you know our Limoncello is made in-house each week?...

The Welsh Rabbit

4.7(136 reviews)

Adorable wine and cheese shop! Visited over the weekend and did a wine flight and made our own…read morecharcuterie board. The options were very appealing and lots to try! Everything tasted delicious. The shop was also very cute if you want to buy and bring home for friends, etc. A little small inside but we were seated right away. Definitely a fun spot to try for a wine and cheese dine.

The decor inside here is really cute (there's even rabbit wallpaper) and the servers were all…read morefantastic and super nice. The smoked duck breast was amazing, delice de bourgogne cheese, and prima Donna cheese were delicious as well. The wine flight complemented the charcuterie board nicely. 10/10 would recommend

See all

Wine flight!

Nick's Restaurant and Bar

3.9(345 reviews)

Good cheese pizza and good meatballs. No overly large slices but adequate. Plenty of cheese on both…read moreitems and not real saucy which is how I normally order my pizza but I didn't have to here. Something to note-gnocchi isn't a year round menu item and sandwiches are not an all day menu item. I saw a lot of pictures of gnocchi on various review sites and was looking forward to it but was told that's an item they usually only carry toward winter time. I was bummed and the sandwiches are only a lunch time thing. The restaurant plays a variety of music and it's at a level that is good so you can hear the person talking across the table. Some restaurants crank it up too loud. Theirs was perfect. The restaurant was clean. We paid $22.67 for 3 slices of cheese pizza and a side of meatballs. We drank water. The service was friendly and the restaurant had an upscale yet casual vibe which I appreciated.

This was our first time at Nicks and we came for our anniversary. On the positive side, the service…read morewas good and very fast. We had our drinks and appetizers in no time and our dinner was served very quickly after that. We ordered the "crispy" calamari, which was not crispy AT ALL. Very limp and oily. The mozzarella garlic bread was not bad but could have been cooked a bit more. Again, it seemed underdone, like the calamari. I ordered the fettuccine alfredo which wasn't bad but a bit lacking in flavor. My husband had the eggplant Parmesan, which he said was crispy on the outside but more or less uncooked on the inside. His side of pasta had a watery sauce. My glass of Prosecco was very good. The bar area seemed very busy - we sat in a booth in the dining area and there weren't many people there when we were there at 5pm. Just a bit disappointed in our meal here - oh well.

Frozen beverage

Nick's Restaurant and Bar - Local Sausage Pizza ($19.50) - Italian sausage, peperonata, spicy Calabrese chiles, fontina cheese, herbed goat cheese, spinach

Local Sausage Pizza ($19.50) - Italian sausage, peperonata, spicy Calabrese chiles, fontina cheese, herbed goat cheese, spinach

See all

Chicken Parmesan ($21.50) - basil, mozzarella, spaghetti marinara

La Piadina Italian Flatbread Sandwiches

4.1(19 reviews)

6.5 mi

Way overpriced for flatbread and some arugula. No prosciutto to be found in my sandwich. I visited…read morethe mobile truck while at a brewery and it took 45 mins to even get my food. This was probably because the 2 guys working in the truck were going toe-to-toe yelling "f*ck you" in each other's faces. This happened in full view of customers, including kids. 100% do NOT recommend patronizing this eatery.

Delish! I got the Daniele, with prosciutto, mozzarella, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic…read morevinegar, and it's all organic! It's so hard to find a restaurant that serves quality food with history and passion!!! A wide drink menu, and cute patio dining.

Eat in nook

El' Originale

See all

Daniele Piadina

Panino's Italian Restaurant

4.0(245 reviews)

We went as a family for a Sunday lunch and to celebrate a birthday. Parking out front is limited,…read morebut there is more in back. I had called ahead and made a reservation, just in case. This is a small, family owned restaurant right on the edge of the CSU campus. You get the homey, welcome feel when you enter. There were four of us and we all enjoy Italian food. Two of us shared a pizza and the other two got Chicken Parmigiana with spaghetti. The service and preparation of food was swift. Our glasses were kept topped off. And we all enjoyed our food. Our birthday girl had a cannoli at the end to celebrate her day as well as leftovers to take back to her dorm.

My wife and I ate at the "new" Paninos today, at 1002 College Avenue. We really hadn't eaten a lot…read moreat the first Paninos, since it was on Prospect and we lived far south. We made an effort today though, to get to it for lunch. I got the Chicken Parmigiana Marinara ($20) (and my wife got the Eggplant Parmigiana ($20). I truly enjoyed my meal and my wife truly hated the Eggplant Parm. When our waiter, "Jackson" asked (for the second time) how everything was, I told him the truth. The first time my wife didn't say anything. We did not expect him to comp our meal, of course, but he did bring us a dessert I'd never had before, "Local Tiramisu Gelato from Sub Zero", and boy, Howdy, was THAT ever good! I thought I had died and gone to heaven! The total, with tax, came to $44, not unusual in today's market, I suppose. My wife says she'll never go back, and mentioned something about wild horses. Given the circumstances, I probably won't either, but it won't be because of the food. Looking at their drink menu though, I'm glad I don't drink much anymore. The drinks averaged around $12. I suppose that, too, is not unusual, but I don't know. Beer was $8, with a dozen taps to choose from. I didn't. Water worked just fine with my chicken parm. If this sounds good to you, give a new restaurant a try!

Kids make art at dinner

The grinder is the best!

See all

Elliot's Martini Bar

4.3(142 reviews)

1.8 mi

Well worth dropping in for exquisite martinis handcrafted in this darkly moody but welcoming bar…read more Right in the heart of Old Town it has the perfect location for dinner or after dinner drinks. Extensive martini and craft cocktail list. We happened to drop in on "Dirty Wednesday" when the majority of drinks on the special menu were only $9! We sampled some pretty smooth dirty martinis with variations of added hot sauce or blue cheese but the standout was the Green Bean Dirty Martini a house original and a briny surprise! Friendly and attentive bartenders and even friendlier patrons to chat to at the bar. Highly recommended.

The drinks were amazing, but what really made the experience great was our lovely server Katie. She…read morewas so accommodating and wonderful, SHE is the reason we will be coming back. The menu was creative and fresh. They have an outside patio which was a huge plus. Thank you Katie!! See you soon!

Peach better have my honey

Elliot's Martini Bar - I absolutely loved the bar menu, the creativity behind the martini drinks was hilarious, they had so many options, so many great martinis.

See all

I absolutely loved the bar menu, the creativity behind the martini drinks was hilarious, they had so many options, so many great martinis.

Restaurant 415

4.1(599 reviews)

1.5 mi

Solid Wednesday night dinner, would go back. Walked in around dinnertime with no reservation and…read moregot seated right away, so midweek seems to be the move if you want to skip the wait. Got the Mediterranean bowl with a steak skewer add-on and an Odell IPA. The bowl looked the part (cauliflower, chickpeas, feta, spinach, peppers) but the flavor didn't land the way I hoped. Felt like it needed more punch. The steak skewer was cooked perfectly, but for what they charge as an add-on, you should be getting three skewers instead of one. The key lime cheesecake stole the show. Bright, tart, creamy, and worth saving room for. If you go, order it. Service was attentive without hovering. The space is open and well-lit with cool abstract art on the walls, and the noise level stays low enough to hold a real conversation, which is rare for a place this size. Two patios out front for when the weather cooperates. Come for the dessert and the easy vibe. Skip the Mediterranean bowl, try one of the pizzas or the ribeye next time.

So yum every time. I get their bbq chicken bowl which is consistently filling and delicious. Not…read moretoo bad price wise, the bowl is around 20$ for a quality meal

Gimme and a bowl of soup

See all

Exterior: Two patios, easy parking out front

Cafe Vino

3.9(345 reviews)

1.8 mi

Great spot! The service was great, we were checked on regularly! The food was very tasty and…read moreenjoyed some sangria for happy hour. Extensive wine list for bottle or glasses. Will definitely come back to try some more dishes.

Happy hour specials are really good here!Honestly would come back only for that…read more The food is pretty decent, but would only come back for their happy hour deals since it's not the best food for the pricing.

Almost a club vibe

Clam chowder

See all

Beau Jo's - Fort Collins

3.3(347 reviews)

1.6 mi

The food is delicious, great atmosphere and services. We love the pizza. This is our favorite…read morepizza place.

The mountain pie was very good and our server was a friendly young woman. There is indoor and…read moreoutdoor seating but was too hot the day we went.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tracey I.

8 years ago

It's the best Italian food I've had in a long time. Everything is homemade even the cheese. Tonight I got fettuccine with meatballs & diavolo sauce! It was BOMB! The meatballs are to die for and the sauce is delicious. The meatball sub is phenomenal! The gelato is really good and the customer service is off the chart! read more

Butter F.

1 year ago

Good for a hot day. Yummy . Good service. Nice place to hang out,..,.......,.....,....,.

Rachel D.

9 years ago

So delicious and staff is always very kind. Let's you try as many flavors as you want

Gelato & aMore - gelato - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Gelato & aMore also viewed

La Crêperie & French Bakery of Fort Collins

4.0

(305 reviews)

With trepidation due to mixed reviews, we set out to La Creperie to satisfy my croissant craving…read more However, no worries--it was all good. Some of the parking is for the liquor store and is signed as such, leaving not a lot of room for eaters to park. We parallel parked on the side street. The woman who greeted us wasn't overly friendly, just business-like, and took us directly to our table. No waiting for us, but it was a July weekday, 10 am. It was busy, but not packed. There were two outdoor seating areas, as well. Our server, Monica, was kind and helpful when answering questions from us old folks. Prompt and attentive was her style, though not overly so. Husband ordered an omelet with meat, which was good, not exceptional. I had a croissant with real butter and great raspberry jam. And fresh slices of avocado as a side order. Croissant was flaky on outside and soft and somewhat airy on the inside, so I fell in love. I drank an unremarkable bagged Earl Grey tea with milk, and my dear enjoyed two Americanos. They serve Lavazza coffee, which I regret not ordering. Afterwards I decided there was too much water in my mug for the little tea bag hence my poor tea experience. Perhaps an additional bag or a smaller cup would've helped. Anyway, it all arrived beautifully and promptly. The decor is slightly cute, though a bit overly decorated (busy) for my taste, but I liked the butter-yellow paint color, and I appreciated the wood furniture instead of metal or plastic. Enjoyed the red and white checked curtains. So overall, it's almost cozy. I despise sitting shoulder to shoulder in restaurants and will walk out if that's how tables are arranged. But that wasn't an issue here. Yay. Also, the woman in the bakery section was nice. Leave your house now and enjoy your trip to La Creperie. Eat a croissant for me, okay?

This is my new favorite breakfast place. I had breakfast this morning the smoked salmon Benedict on…read morea croissant. My son had a smoked salmon sandwich. My wife had a rotisserie chicken and mushroom on a croissant. It was just fabulous. we started with a French baguette , this is the best French baguette I have in United States !!!! really bring me back to Europe. We stopped next-door on their bakery and bought some desserts Mongo mousse cake, vanilla, feels beignet , lemon tarts, chocolate croissants and baguettes absolutely delicious so if you go in Fort Collins, do not miss this restaurant Bon appétit!

La Boutique French Deli & Market

4.7

(31 reviews)

We were given a gift card from our son and daughter in law months ago. I am not a huge fan of…read moreFrench food, too bland for me. Btw, I have been to France many times on business, have eaton at some of the best restaurants in Paris, really good, just not to my taste. Ok, we went here last Sunday, I wasn't hungry, but my wife was, so we thought we would use the card. Wife ordered a beef dip, one of her favorite sandwiches, not on my top 10 list. I ordered a charcuterie plater, figured we could take it home, which we did. Anyway, I took a bit of her sandwich, and even though I wasn't hungry, I ate about half of it. One of the best sandwiches I have ever had of any kind. Very simple but delicious. Baguette was amazing, beef appeared to be cured somehow, huge flavor, au jus was great. Today I am going to Timnath to meet a friend for lunch and I am going to make a 30 minute detour to get a sandwich for us for dinner. Not inexpensive, but worth it. Life is too short to eat mediocre food, plus I am a stingy with my calories, like to spend them on delicious food. Thank you La Boutique. Sincerely, Bret and Michelle

4.5 stars. Fresh delicious sandwiches at this French deli and market in Fort Collins. My partner…read moreand I made a stop en route to Wyoming. I just love the FoCo food scene and wanted to try something new. The barista made a few suggestions. It was before 11am, so that eliminated all the pretzel roll options on the menu. I decided to go with the Roma. She was right! It was refreshing. I loved every bite. Very bread-forward but clearly a high quality bake. My partner got the French Dip and enjoyed it. There's a few small tables as well as barstools along the wall, but most people ordered to-go. Check out the marketplace items, too. So cute!

Turkish Cafe Co

4.8

(21 reviews)

This place was recommended by some friends, but I was not expecting it to be that good. Sandwichs…read morewere great. The desserts fantastic and the best baklava I've ever tried!!!!. 100% coming back.

The food was very good, and the baklava was especially delicious. We were excited to try this place…read morefor the first time and really enjoyed the meal itself. Unfortunately, the service at the register left a lot to be desired. We were polite and friendly, but the woman helping us seemed annoyed from the moment we walked in. Her responses were very short, and she came across as bothered by our questions, even though we were first-time customers ordering from a rotating menu on a screen that we ended up having to take a picture of. It's disappointing because the food was genuinely enjoyable, but the interaction at the front counter put a sour note on the experience and lingered after we left. We'd consider coming back for the food, but we'd hope for a more welcoming atmosphere next time.

Call Your Mother Deli - Fort Collins

4.1

(21 reviews)

Delightful bagel shop. Giddy happy employees & why not the decor is pink. Yummy sandwiches with…read morevery custom never-seen-before combos. A lot with smashed potato chips in between. (remember 4th grade?) We love the no salmon Royal Palm. Toasted everything bagel with two schmears of cream cheese and ICE cold tomatoes, cukes, & sliver of red onion. Like a Nova Plate from Chompies Phoenix. But No Salmon even has capers, now I don't have salmon breath rest of my day. The Very Cherry Black Iced Tea is lovely. Not made with syrup.

I've been passing by Call Your Mother Deli for months, but haven't stopped in for lack of close-in…read moreparking. Well, recently on my way home from working out at the Aztlan Center I was thinking about lunch and decided to turn the corner at Maple and whaddayaknow, there was a spot right there. I was hoping it would be more Jewish deli as in pastrami piled high on rye than bagel shop, but it is what it is. I decided to try one of their specials which must have been off of their spring menu since I don't see it online right now. I think it might have been called the Addison? Egg salad and potato chips on a bagel. I love egg salad but hadn't ever thought about putting potato chips on it - genius. I think my friends from NYC would probably say the bagels aren't chewy enough, but I think the not-so-chewy texture is just fine for a sandwich - who needs egg salad squirting out when you take a bite? I wasn't sure what I wanted to drink - the server went through a few options and hit upon an iced matcha latte - that sounded like it would hit the spot. Relative to other places one can get an iced matcha latte I think the one at CYM is a pretty good value - a large cup, not too much ice, and tasty. While it didn't take long for my order to come up, I will say that the interior of the shop is jarringly pink - I dunno, bright enough to put me on edge like someone was kvetching at me. Maybe that's the point?

Scalzotto Italian Restaurant

3.7

(173 reviews)

As we enter, we are greeted with a warm welcome! The decor and ambiance fit the bill of an Italian…read morerestaurant The service was delightful and quaint - they weren't busy for 7p, but we are 6mo new to NoCo and it seems normal. Which meant we were able to ask all the questions regarding the dishes and converse with your staff We had Brussels Sprouts as an appy, then selected the Norcina and Lasagna as our main dish. Both of which were fabulous! We ended the meal with Caramel Cheesecake With Crunchy Sugar & Vanilla Gelato. For my preference, the penne pasta seemed undercooked...and we ended up getting our bread when we got our main dishes. Different than what I'm used to ‍ - whatever, could have been an off day, and next time I can ask for bread with my drink We will come again! Thank you for your hospitality!!

We weee in Loveland for the night and found this Italian place. We were just in Italy and this…read morerestaurant compares to the real deal! Great food. Very friendly staff. Good service. Very quiet and pleasant atmosphere.

Walrus Ice Cream Company

4.0

(209 reviews)

•$

This spot was so busy! The staff worked fast to assist each customer and were patient as orders…read morewere made. They have a wide selection of flavors as well as other treats. Perfect shop to visit during the hot days.

Great local ice cream place!!! The staff are super friendly and the atmosphere is pretty cool, I…read morelove all the old buildings in this town.

Paris Banh Mi - Loveland

4.4

(72 reviews)