Closed on Wilmington, but.... My wife is a beautiful Italian American, and her ancestors in this country were among the wave of Italians who adapted Italian cooking to Italian-American cooking. And the deep dish of Godfathers resembles the deep dish Italian pizza of her youth. Closed on Wilmington, but.... Godfathers is moving to a defunct Kentucky Fried Chicken location on Clyo and Wilmington. No evidence of work yet, and we expect Godfathers to be open February 2026. read more

I got a large thin crust pizza, with pepperoni, hamburger, and black olives from this Godfathers Pizza. I placed a carry out order, and it was ready when I arrived. The restaurant looks nice and there is limited seating. When I got home to try the pizza, it was visually appealing. However, when I tasted it I felt it was dry and I could barely taste the hamburger or pepperoni. It was there, I think, but it was hard to tell as it appears the pepperoni and hamburger was buried under the cheese. The crust was good but other than the black olives it was pretty flavorless. Also, at $3 a pop for each topping, I was expecting more. That's a bit expensive, to me, considering what I got and how it tasted. I would not recommend. The pizza came to around $30, with a tip, and there are better thin crust pizza options that are less expensive. I would not go again. read more

Godfathers Pizza - Large Thin Crust Pizza with Pepperoni, Hamburger, and Black Olives - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek Township, Ohio

See all

Order was ready on time and staff is friendly. We go a Pepperoni, mushrooms, banana peppers, extra cheese. I thought it was a little lite on sauce, I could not taste a note of the sauce. Crust is medium fluffy, and it was just ok for me. The pizza is just ok for me, and both Richelle and I got a little heart burn, I think it's from the crust, since those toppings at other place don't do that. Cheese bread is great, this sauce is sweet and nice. If this is the pizza sauce, our pizza definitely needed more of it. Cinnamon think was fantastic, put some in a cup with milk! read more

See all

Worth the trip to me. Trenton to Dayton mall. Pizza delivered in a timely manner and a constant flow of cars going through the drive through Got a thin crust and now I want to load up a deep dish when I go back read more

I ate in at a location near Dayton. I ordered the small classic. The pizza was delicious. The workers were very friendly and attentive. The ambiance was cool. I always prefer high top tables. I would eat there again. I don't like to reheat pizza in the microwave but I wanted it for lunch the next day at work so I tried it and the pizza held up and was still delicious. I'm in love read more

Godfather's has become where we celebrate birthdays. We have a birthday pie. Godfathers disappeared several years ago, but made a remarkable comeback! Best Pizza in town! read more

We love their Combo pizza, but these days you need to order it with EXTRA cheese to get the amount fo cheese you used to get automatically in the '80s. The worst part about this location is that they don't open until noon on Saturday and the earliest pickup is 12:30 which doesn't work in the fall when the Buckeyes football game starts at noon! so they lose a LOT of business by not being open for 11:30-noon pick-up during football season. read more

Great pizza! We ordered 3 pizzas for pickup. Staff was very helpful, we scheduled our pick up for a birthday party later in the day. Even better they have a drive thru window which was super convenient. Easy to order, easy to pick up, tasty pizza! read more

Ok when you spend over 30 dollars for a pizza and drive up to the pick up window and watch the employee cut and place your pizza in the box and than he gets on his phone for several minutes never looking over at the drive up window as we sit and watch all this. There are 4 employees standing behind the counter with no customers. We end up driving from the pick up window to the front and go inside to get our pizza. There are 4 employees not doing a thing, you really need to glance over to the window a few times!! read more

Mediocre pizza. Reminds me of Pizza Hut. If you're looking for high quality pizza look elsewhere.

I was here a few months ago for the first time and I would have to say I am a fan. I've heard great things from co-workers about Godfather's and since my husband loves pizza we thought we would try it out. We got a large double cheese pizza and I had a side salad. The manager heard it was our first time there and was nice enough to throw in free cheese bread. I will say that I much prefer the cheese bread over the pizza. Price was a little higher for a typically pizza place. We haven't been since that first time because it's further from our house then other places. I wish they would build a Godfather's closer to the Dayton Mall area. read more

Pretty good pizza if you like deep dish style. I prefer New York style better. I like the fact they put the cheese over the toppings. Far better pizza than what Vince G. described! read more

Godfathers Pizza - a man in a top hat - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek Township, Ohio

Great pizza ever no messing with The Godfather's it's a 10 thank you dominos ain't got nothing on this pizza I see why they call it Godfather it's The Godfather of pizza it's banging read more

Awesomeness in a box!! Perfect Friday night lockdown food. Too bad I can't share with friends. Tons of toppings...and best of all...THE CHEESE IS ON THE TOP!! Made just like Guido's...crust isn't quite as good but still tastey. Looking forward to leftovers!!! read more

Really like there pizza. Pick up is the way to go! Pizza is very good! Like the deep dish and there sauce.

Carryout was a thorough disappointment..soggy, uncooked crust...doughy without crunch $22 for a large pie would be ok but for inedible, hurried product no thanks.. read more

The staff was absolutely rude we called to ask the specials and they answered in the most rude and aggravated way possible the costumer service was honestly horrific read more

I wrote a review on this place two months ago and it has been removed. It seems that Yelp is allowing restaurants to filter / censor or select the reviews. This place is not a pizza store or a restaurant. Its a gas station. The pizza is taken out of a freezer and cooked in a $40 counter top oven by the same kid that sells the cigarettes and candy and gas. They charge $14.00 for a plain cheese pizza. Avoid this dump. The food sucks. read more

I wanted to try godfathers, I haven't had God father's since 1990s. I went to the Wilmington pyke location on Monday. I have never seen a pizza restaurants closed on a Monday. I was extremely disappointed. I will NEVER GO back to ANY God fathers read more

Usually very good pizza but there was something terribly wrong with our last one. I wish now I had returned it. Had to deposit over half into the trash because of a very bad taste. read more

I got some carryout pizza here with some friends recently. Pizza was extremely overpriced and tasted like it had no seasoning whatsoever. I could make better pizza myself. read more

Godfather's. What can I say? "A Pizza You Can't Refuse" - and I wouldn't dare! If you love oooey gooey cheesy thick pizza, this is your place. You don't get more cheese than this unless you ask for triple cheese from somewhere else. I was recommended the Taco Pizza. Eh, it's okay if you like that kind of thing, but I'm a purist when it comes to pizza, so I'm happiest with the plain cheese. I think pizza is about the sauce, crust and cheese. Let's not cloud the deliciousness with funky toppings. The only thing that keeps me from coming back all the time is the price. It can get expensive - especially if you're getting bread sticks or the Cinnamon Monkey Bread (mmmmmm!). It's a nice treat for pizza, but you'd go broke making a habit of it. This is where I go when I need spoiled for a minute. read more

No prices on their menu online should have been the first red flag. We ordered two pizzas, 1 thin crust, 1 thick crust with different ingredients. My husband picked them up to bring home for a birthday party. They messed up the crusts. After everyone left I looked at the recipe and the 2 pizzas cost almost $50.00! Never ever again! read more

Super taco is great. Box must have weighed 7lbs or more. Copious amounts of cheeses and veggies. Great pizza. Price is steep but worth it.

I love the convenience of the pick-up window, and the pizza and everything else there is delicious!!! I highly recommend Godfather's to all my family and friends. read more

Just had a double Italian sausage pizza with jalapeños and it was great. The wait wasn't too long when I went there but I was starving so the smell of the pizza the other patrons were eating drove me nuts. Anyways, great pizza. Would go back for the pizza. The salad I got left a lot to be desired though. Too much cheese and not enough for the price. read more

I really like there pizza sometimes you just have to get a Godfathers Pizza. I just wish they made a version like they made pizzas back in the early 80's before they sold the the young lady serving us last night was very helpful and attentive to our needs. read more

The original Godfathers pizza is back and just as tasty. Steaming hot delicious pizza pie.

Good pizza ! I like bacon on mine and all the meat and veggies not healthy I know but so pleasing to the taste buds ! Just a bit pricy :/

Haven't had Godfathers pizza in years. Last time I had it was Tennessee. Was very good. Can't wait to get some here soon.

Pizza is really good. They do not deliver and they do not take any of the coupons available on their own website. :-(

Yeah this is a national chain, I wouldn't normally write a review for a national chain unless they are either really good or really bad, but this particular Godfather's Pizza is really good! We love the pizza here, the classic combo is the way to go (unless you're counting calories and then maybe not!), it's really thick and substantial, awesome flavor! Really brings backs memories of Godfathers back in the 80s when they were a lot more prevalent in this area. What this store does really well though is customer service! Very friendly and on the spot with everything. Even though you order at the counter they bring out silverware, napkins, and plates and then deliver your pie when it's ready. We couldn't quite finish everything and were just getting ready to go ask for a box, no need, they brought a box to the table without even having to ask, that was pretty cool. So for some very filling pizza that's always consistently good, check them out! read more

Beware! Location does not accept any Godfathers coupons. They offer you a free piece of monkey bread. Even a monkey would not order Godfather's pizza at this location. Orders are not as promised at specific times. Poor management. read more

Don't waste your time unless you call first, very strange hours, I drove 20 miles to try it only to find them closed in the middle of the day, Ill never go back read more

My wife and I stopped in here last night. First time for us to visit this location. We had heard it wasn't that great. So, we decided to try it out for ourselves. It was great! Friendly staff, clean, quick, hot, fresh! We even got a dessert pizza (Monkey bread) to go, awesome! We will definitely be back to this location; a lot closer than HH. read more

Awesome service from every employee we encountered. Yes, the price is a little more than some other pizza places but the product is also much better as you can tastel it in the food. It is worth trying at least once and I have to say KUDOS again for the service and the pride that the employees have about customer service was simply amazed how attentive they all were. Will be comiing back for sure.. read more

First off, I'm a fan of pizzas of all kinds so I give everybody a fair chance. Over the years I have even had the privilege of working at some pizza places. I've seen it all, from the local small town pizza house to a corporate chain store. So I'd like to think I can be a decent judge when it comes to pizza. I plan on doing reviews on every place I have dined at eventually so I hope you enjoy my food life in review. Enter Godfather's pizza, my most recent pizza experience... it's an old name in the pizza biz although I don't recall there being one around the south Dayton suburbs when I was growing up. This was my first time to try a legendary pizza. They have been running a commercial advertising the "Classic Combo" so I ordered a Large one for $20.99 Wowch! The price is a little bit of a shocker for everyone used to the 5 and 10 dollar pizzas out there today. Looking at the setup there, it's a mix of fast food and casual dine in and the pizzas are baked in a conveyor oven. The first good sign was how heavy the box was when they handed it to me! It's definitely a THICK pizza with a lot of toppings and generous amounts of cheese covering it all. The taste is unique and overall good. Didn't seem to be much sauce but maybe it just gets overpowered by all the toppings. Glad I tried it, it's now in the Winning column and it's nice to have another good pizza in town. Give Godfather's Pizza a try, see what you think. They even have a drive-thru window for fast pick up...nice. read more