Like many reviewers, Godfather's comes with a lot of nostalgia for me. My son and I were in town for a youth hockey tournament last weekend, and I told him that on our final day we HAD to go hit the lunch buffet. It did NOT disappoint! There were at least 5-8 fresh pizzas out at all times, along with cinnamon rolls, dessert pizzas, jojos, and of course, the stocked salad bar. The service was great; never had to wait for anything, and just had a great meal! As others have said, the building could definitely use a facelift, but I didn't mind the 80's throwback ambiance and decor - took me right back to my childhood! My son fully bought in, and made me promise that next time we're in Wenatchee, we have to come back - and we will! (Seeing all the nostalgic reviews on here has me wondering: why aren't there more Godfather's locations in the Northwest? Clearly we all miss it!) read more

Always the freshest salad bar and pizza buffet - my favorite pizza of all times is the Godfsthers Ultimate combination classic is my go to

Thank you for a chance to review. Tried again while in town. Service and pizza were below expectations - and the pizza was over cooked. 5/5 next time. Some Godfather's Pizza places are closing - this one may be next if they don't improve. Time to uphold the heritage of Godfather's. Other reviews cite super poor customer service and disgust with management - and even getting sick after being served. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

See all

Agree with a recent reviewer. 5 Stars for an absolute blast from my past! I grew up with Godfather's in the Iowa City IA area, where I first tried my fave pizza, which is Taco. This one was not quite like the ones we had decades ago, but that didn't mean it wasn't deeeelicious! We were ordering up front, and I was looking at the menu for something to go with it; my Hubby said there's no way we were going to finish it, and the sweet girl at the counter smiled and said, "He's right." Well, he was, and three adults could only get down half of it. That's cool though, because we got to enjoy my nostalgia later that night. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Huge taco pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

This restaurant is just a shell of what Godfather's used to be. No buffet and not even a salad bar. The pizza was good. Our service was good. Totally uncrowded. At noon on a Thursday we were the only ones there. We went for a bit of nostalgia. And while we were not disappointed with the pizza, the rest of it was only ample. Again, the staff was very nice. I don't see this place long for this world. read more

Five stars for nostalgia. Definitely order your pizza fresh or go for that buffet on a busy lunch run. We ordered the classic combo and it did not disappoint with piles of cheese, onions and meats. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Classic combo - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

Amazing! Takes me back to childhood...the taco pizza....the bestest!!! We always visit when we are in the area

Old school perfection. I love the taco pizza here so bad. Quick service and I love the vibe.

Pizza was pretty good. Good parking which seems hard to come by in Wenatchee. Had to wait for someone to come up to counter to order and then again to ask for a box. read more

Great food, good service on a busy night. All the food was cooked correctly, hot and tasty. We did not get the buffet, but it was well stocked and looked like a great option. Salad bar was good as well. read more

Went on a Tuesday at 1:30pm, 4 people most of the time we were there we were only people in the restaurant, had the buffet, the salad bar was great, fresh lettuce, a large variety such as beets, baby corn, mushrooms, hard boiled eggs, and so on, the pizza selection was warm but had been there a while, there was a good mix from veggie to pepperoni, a fresh pizza came out just as we were leaving so timing helps, one guy working there was friendly and helpful, the price was very reasonable for the 4 of us, I fear this location will not be around someday soon, the owners clearly don't put investment into this location, it was old and worn, but wile it is here is worth a visit. read more

A nostalgic place for those who grew up going to your local Godfather's. Many memories at mine from birthday parties to just a family pizza night. It still tastes like I remember it! Love it! read more

See all

This has to rank one of the worse restaurants in the valley. Over priced and under quality. The staff are only there for a paycheck. The place was remodeled, in 1970. It's old, dirty and it surprises me that they can maintain their health food permit. The lettuce in the salad bar had been frozen, which makes it transparent, and when we asked for fresh lettuce, 20 minutes later they dumped a load right on top of the bad lettuce. The tomato's were also spoiled and the baby carrots were brown. The egg was more like mashed potatoes. It's no wonder the place was empty when we walked in for a buffet dinner. read more

See all

Reminds me of when godfathers was everywhere back in the 90's. Wish they would clean the place up though.

Possible Security breach yall got going on there.... someone tried to charge my card 4 days in a row for a charge i did not authorize and haven't even ordered a pizza from this business in a couple months now.. so where did the sudden charges come from? I'd say someone has hacked into you server and pulled CC information from it. Why else would yall be trying to charge my card when no one else has it besides merchants. read more

My friend family took us here for dinner before the hockey game. The name of this place really caught my attention. They have a pretty good selection of pizza to order from. They also have a buffet that includes salad bar as well for a reasonable price. Dinner was $11.15 I believe. On the buffet. They have a pretty large varieties of pizza, which includes pepperoni, Hawaiian, cheese, bbq chicken, and etc. They even have Jojo weird but I do love some Jojo. Not to mention, that there salad bar is fresh. A lot of toppings to pick and choose from. The price are cheap, the food are decent, service is good. Will be back here next time when I'm around town. :) read more

See all

We are on a business trip to Wenatchee and saw Godfathers on the drive in, I told my husband we HAVE to go! We haven't had a Godfathers back home in years! It's just as good as I remember it! We got half taco half bacon cheeseburger pizza it was out of this world! The girl behind the counter was very friendly. It was very quite but a nice place read more

See all

Wanted retro pizza and that's just what I got. No godfather pizza joint close to home

Since they have closed all the Godfather's pizza in the a Seattle area we have found one in Wenatchee and we stopped in on our way to Chelan! We ordered their taco pizza. We were able to sit inside and eat during COVID19 but you can take it to go. Pizza came out pretty quickly, about 15-20 min which is a normal cook time when you order a pizza. The pizza was hot and the toppings were fresh. It was as good as we remembered when we were able to get it in our area! read more

Godfather's Pizza - Taco pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

Been a longtime but they still delivered with their pizza buffet. Will look them up bext time in town.

First time going to the buffet and I will never go back. If I could review 0stars I truly would. Pizza was greasy. We had to ASK to have potato wedges made, and to top it off they tasted like freezer. The lettuce for their salad tasted like it had to be thrown away two days ago, absolutely disgusting and completely unsatisfying. $60+ spent for a family and I will truthfully never go back. The guys working obviously didn't seem to care about anything at all. Had to WAIT 5+ mins to get some help at the front counter. Guys were just worried about what song to play and who broke whose heart. This place needs to get it together seriously! read more

Dan Garcia, the owner refused to replace 2 burned, small, gluten-free pizzas that I paid over $40.00 for. I will never go back. It was awful. The order total was over $90.00 for 4 pizzas. This used to be my favorite.place in town. read more

See all

The nostalgia is real! Haven't been to a Godfather's for years, and it's as good as I remember. Fresh ingredients, loaded pizzas! The crust was crunchy and not too oily. Would definitely recommend to anyone wanting some classic pizza. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

See all

There's no stoppin' me once I hit play to every Selena Gomez song track on my iTunes library. I call it, review time! People call it, you've got issues. But who are you to judge, when you're a diamond in the rough. Well, who says? Ok, I admit, this place lacks a little life. Based on this, Godfather's Pizza has taken into consideration some remodeling towards both inside and out appearances. All for the simple pleasure of feeding our faces. Who says you're not worth it? It was a few days ago that I had the local buffet favorite. Unlimited pizza, salad and drinks for a measly $7.99! But more than all that, they have arcades for the kids, Gold Peak Tea and my personal favorite...an online jukebox! It's so cool that one can play, "I Just Had Sex (feat. Akon)" by The Lonely Island. If that wasn't the most over-the-top hint that I love Godfather's Pizza, then I don't know what else to tell ya? Stop reading and check it out! Listen to me, listen to me. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

My pizza was burnt and wrong and they refused to help me. They said their policy is you have to call the day of to get a refund. I couldn't call last night because I had to go into work and then they were closed by the time I got off. I called today and he refused to help me. Don't order from here unless you want to spend $45 on burnt pizza that is wrong and employees who won't do anything about it read more

Just got back to town for the first time in 22 years and man it was the first spot I ordered from! I remember this place so well from my younger years and it was absolutely delicious! No clue how this isn't higher rated!? I'll be going here on the regular that's for sure! Glad to be back in my hometown. read more

I thought the salad bar was great, the pizza was just ok. Some of the pizzas were a bit dry, almost as if they had been sitting for awhile. There was also about a 5 minute wait for an employee to take our order when we arrived. There used to be many Godfathers restaurants in the great NW, this is one of the few left. I love to visit for the nostalgia factor but the pizza is just not as good as I remember it being. read more

Godfather's Pizza - The All You Can Eat buffet at Godfathers - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

Got extremely bad food poisoning. Recommend never going here. I was sick for 4 days after eating at this location.

This place is nostalgia central, appearing to have not experienced any infrastructure changes since the late 80's/early 90's. There is an arcade (a rarity anywhere these days!) and a well stocked buffet including desert pizza. I checked it out in passing but decided to order delivery later. I ordered the medium Hawaiian with onions added and a side salad and it cost me about $24 including the delivery fee. That is a *bit* more expensive than Dominoes and other franchises, which I hadn't realized because their website is completely outdated and doesn't display the prices of anything. When I called to order a particular specialty pizza off the site menu, the woman sighed and apologized because she didn't know which one I was talking about. Clearly the website necessitates daily explanation from the employees which is probably very repetitive and frustrating for them so I won't hold it against the restaurant itself. The pizza was so darn good it outweighed the strangeness of this place. The crust was crispy but not greasy, and the flavor of the ham and pineapple was fresh and distinctive. It reheated very well too, not turning into a soggy mess after microwaving it. read more

Good pizza good price I always get the combo loved it ever since I was a kid. Delivery was quick

Just like I remember! Best Taco pizza ever, thanks for still being here and walking us down memory lane. The crust was perfect and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. We wish there was still a Godfathers in Spokane! read more

Came in with 10 till the buffet was over. They did a good job of putting out a fresh variety of new pizzas, as the 3 sitting on the hot area were pretty well dead. I use to frequent a Godfather's in Lewis Co 20+ years ago..... sadly the salad bar was the same. It just really grossed me out. Really, Godfathers can't think of anything new for your salad bar? read more

Just moved to Wenatchee and was surprised to see a Godfather's Pizza open and running. I grew up going to the one in Tri-Cities, and while I don't remember the food there, I remember my parents taking us there for family dinner, even though my dad didn't like pizza. So this is a bit of a reminiscent visit. We arrived here pretty much after work, and it was already busy. Since I didn't have a chance to look at the menu, we hung back and looked at everything. Right away we noticed they had a pizza and salad buffet for around $11.00 which came with a drink as well. I asked if I could take a look at the salad bar and did a walk by. I noted that the lettuce looked washed and fresh, the toppings all looked to be in clean containers and there was a pretty good variety of toppings including hard boiled eggs, fresh mushrooms, carrots, cucumbers, cheese, chickpeas and lots of other salad toppings. My husband went straight for the pizza, which came out pretty about every 5 minutes and there were some great options. They served pepperoni, Hawaiian, sausage and mushroom, Supreme, sausage and pinapple, veggie and just cheese. I personally liked the Hawaiian, and he preferred the Supreme. The crust is thick and doesn't get mushy, it holds up to the sauce and toppings. The cheese was the best, tasted fresh and had a really good mozzarella pull. Overall, the toppings on the pizza were fresh and the food was good in the buffet. I would consider ordering a pizza for carry out next time. I have to admit the atmosphere was a bit of a mind boggler. It looks and feels like you stepped right back into the 80's..... I have been watching Stranger Things, coincidence? hmmmmm read more

Only remaining GF's in Washington state--probably has overstayed it's tenure. Very little variety of pizza on the buffet and anything that resembled flavor was taken in bulk by the regulars. Salad bar was worth the two stars. read more

I've not been to a Godfather's in ages. Regardless of some of the negative reviews, I went for my past fave, Taco Pizza. It came with a side special. I went for the jo jo's. Get some salsa brava from the store for the pizza and best dinner ever. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Taco pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

See all

Love this place. We stop here every time we are in Wenatchee. To bad there wasn't one in Spokane. Their taco pizza is great. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wenatchee, Washington

We are from out of town and no longer have a God Father's pizza anywhere near where we live. So glad we stopped! Just like I remembered from the 80's. Great pizza and friendly staff. God father's pizza is the best! read more

Good salad bar. Fresh. Got the buffet. Bug mistake. Pizza is dry and tasteless. Most has onions. Nothing fresh for ov er 30 minutes

Yeah, yeah, yeah, another all you can eat buffet. I swear I'm not that fond of them. What I am fond of? Air hockey, vintage arcade games, and jukeboxes. Lucky for me, Godfather's has all of these AND an all you can eat buffet. They had a decent selection of pizzas (the usuals, like pepperoni, cheese, and Hawaiian, plus a sausage-jalapeno and the ubiquitous 'cowboy' (who ever decided that cowboys liked sausage, beef, pepperoni, black olives, and mushrooms...honestly, I grew up in Texas...I do not think my cowpunching relations would call that 'cowboy'). They had two dessert pizzas out, and cinnamon rolls. All were tasty enough. The real jewel was the salad bar. The server bragged it was the best and freshest in town, and you know what? I think he might have been right. All the food was hot, appetizing, and the saladbar wasn't full of old lettuce and shrivelled mushrooms. And besides, they have air hockey, vintage videogames, and a jukebox. read more

Please let me tell you it's my fault for choosing this establishment, never again! There needs to to be management training for this place! They can't get an order right and they don't take responsibility or accountability. I will be happy to go somewhere else with their lack of respect for customers. I would like to give them no stars!!!! read more